Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am a researcher. If I am looking for facts, the first thing I do is to look at who is collecting the facts, and who is providing them to me.

I do not know from this website the author(s) and/or providers of the information.

Further I do not see any information on clergy and others in the CC.

Sorry. But this does not answer or prove anything about the question. What it does suggest is that no denomination, including the Catholic Church, can ensure that 100 per cent of its servants are and will remain pure as the driven snow for a lifetime. God gave us free will, and that includes members of all denominations.

Jabulani!
 
Lis…Is nit-picking possible given the vast array of nits to pick?
How do we define Holy Writings and Sacred Tradition in a way that can perhaps clarify the subtle variations of any belief system?
Yes, nit-picking is very possible and pick we must until every last erroneous nit has be discarded.

Why do we need to clarify the subtle variations of any belief system? I think we should show people who adhere to “any” belief system that Christ established one belief system by establishing His one Church and any system that deviates from that one, Christ ordained system is in error to some degree or another.
 
Sorry. But this does not answer or prove anything about the question. What it does suggest is that no denomination, including the Catholic Church, can ensure that 100 per cent of its servants are and will remain pure as the driven snow for a lifetime.
And we don’t need that data to know that, but the scripture alone. 🙂
 
Sandusky shamelessly writes: When Apostolic Successors hid pedophiles, instead of turning them over to the civil authorities, as true Apostolic successors would have done, I thought all of Catholicism would see the fallacy of Apostolic Succession and go flooding out of Catholicism.

Oh Sandusky, how undignified of of you. You fail to see that when you show your true colors it is not pretty. Where does the hostility come from? Were you molested by a priest? Is that what your problem is?

Can you not see the difference between a man who acts out on his own, committing a most vile sin and then other men acting on thier own, committing an even more vile sin by covering up the first, is very different then a committee of men (and women?), while representing an entire church membership, doing something sinful that will set a presidence in that church that, 1.) calls that which is evil good and 2.) will have a devestating effect on every member and 3.) will adversely effect Christendom? Do not see beyond you’re own desire to cast stones from your own glass house? Do you think that no non-C minister or pastor has ever committed a vile sin?

Where do you live that such perfection abounds ?

BTW, are you admitting here that Catholic Bishops are the successors of the Apostles? That would be a step in the right direction. How is it that "true successors of the Apostles would be without sin? Where the Apostles themselves without sin?
 
40.png
MIZER:
Where does the hostility come from? Were you molested by a priest? Is that what your problem is?
You’re not the first to ask this question of me, or, to ask this question of other ex-catholics on this forum.

I told you why I left the church—I was neither saved, nor regenerated while in the CC, but you are unable to accept that, because, if you do, your soteriology crumbles, and everything else with it. 🤷

I have yet to meet a Catholic who will accept my true reason for my leaving their precious church.

It’s unfathomable to the Catholic that what I say is true; the Catholic seems unable even to entertain the possibility that their Catholicism is not true; therefore, the Catholic reasons that I’m lying, and the real truth is either that I was poorly catechized, or he goes to the extreme of priestly molestation.

How pitiable is that? 😦
 
I’ve said all that I have say on the subject, Teflon—move on.

Do as MIZER did earlier on the thread, and claim complete and total victory for yourself.

I won’t say anything; I’ll let your Sour Grapes do the talking.
lol—is Sour Grapes a proper noun, now? You must have some sort of novel interpretation of grammar to go along with your unique theological and Scriptural interpretations.

I will continue to note the hypocrisy of calling Catholics to account for the teachings of their faith while retaining such reticence about describing your own.

For someone to whom consistency is such a mighty hobgoblin that you see inconsistencies everywhere but in the mirror, this is no doubt a useful service.

Now, if you were familiar with the Catholic view of pride and works, you’d understand that “claiming complete and total victory” simply isn’t what we do. There is no such thing until the Lord returns in glory and the faithful join him forever, and no guarantee of the eternal reward which must be worked out, as the apostle notes, with fear and trembling.

The complete and total victory will be the Lord’s.
 
I am a researcher. If I am looking for facts, the first thing I do is to look at who is collecting the facts, and who is providing them to me.

I do not know from this website the author(s) and/or providers of the information.

Further I do not see any information on clergy and others in the CC.

Sorry. But this does not answer or prove anything about the question. What it does suggest is that no denomination, including the Catholic Church, can ensure that 100 per cent of its servants are and will remain pure as the driven snow for a lifetime. God gave us free will, and that includes members of all denominations.

Jabulani!
You apparently haven’t looked at it very closely.

The accounts are newspaper and wire accounts. As a researcher, plug 'em into LEXIS/NEXIS and you should find the originals.

I am not surprised that when given evidence you asked for you ignore it, however.
 
You’re not the first to ask this question of me, or, to ask this question of other ex-catholics on this forum.

I told you why I left the church—I was neither saved, nor regenerated while in the CC, but you are unable to accept that, because, if you do, your soteriology crumbles, and everything else with it. 🤷

I have yet to meet a Catholic who will accept my true reason for my leaving their precious church.

It’s unfathomable to the Catholic that what I say is true; the Catholic seems unable even to entertain the possibility that their Catholicism is not true; therefore, the Catholic reasons that I’m lying, and the real truth is either that I was poorly catechized, or he goes to the extreme of priestly molestation.

How pitiable is that? 😦
I have no trouble whatsoever believing you were a poor Catholic, and a poorly-catechized one.

Your credibility is hampered by your continuing to ignore correction regarding your misstatements concerning Catholic teaching. You have been corrected many times, and provided evidence from the Catechism and other documents in the process.

And yet you require the crutch of anti-Catholic mythology to buttress your, ahem, soteriology.

And that is pitiable indeed!
 
Here’s a sample entry that Lis rejected out of hand:
TEMECULA, CA. Six years ago, Becky J.'s life revolved around Temecula Valley Baptist Church. She worshipped there, went to school there, and even worked after hours two days a week at the school to earn pocket money. That’s where she met 40-year-old Pastor Kerry Clyde Martin. But at 14, Becky didn’t understand the concept of street smarts, she said. She didn’t know when the man befriended her what the future held. “He listened to my problems and would tell me how right I was if I had a fight with my parents,” she said. “I always thought he meant it in a pastor way, or like a father.” Little did Becky know that as a cleric at two previous churches – one in Maryland and one in Orange County – Martin had already been accused of sexually molesting at least three other girls, all 14. Little did she know the friendly, charismatic minister was taking the first steps that would culminate in his repeatedly raping the girl over the next two years. (The Californian, Dec. 8, 2002)
You’ll note the source at the end. Shouldn’t be too hard to check if one is skeptical, should it?

What you can’t see in the quoted excerpt is it contains a hyperlink to the article in question.

This should matter, shouldn’t it?
 
I have no trouble whatsoever believing you were a poor Catholic, and a poorly-catechized one.

Your credibility is hampered by your continuing to ignore correction regarding your misstatements concerning Catholic teaching. You have been corrected many times, and provided evidence from the Catechism and other documents in the process.

And yet you require the crutch of anti-Catholic mythology to buttress your, ahem, soteriology.

And that is pitiable indeed!
Sour Grapes, Teflon.

I certainly would never question your reasons for leaving whatever church you left for Catholicism, rather, I would take you at your word.

As far as correction concerning Catholic teaching, you too have been corrected concerning your understanding of reformed teaching, and you continue to ignore them, preferring instead, the crutch of Catholic mythology to buttress your, ahem, soteriology. 😉
 
Sour Grapes, Teflon.

I certainly would never question your reasons for leaving whatever church you left for Catholicism, rather, I would take you at your word.

As far as correction concerning Catholic teaching, you too have been corrected concerning your understanding of reformed teaching, and you continue to ignore them, preferring instead, the crutch of Catholic mythology to buttress your, ahem, soteriology. 😉
Really? Which flavor of Reformed teaching have I been corrected upon, and continued to ignore?

More claims without evidence, Sandusky, but perhaps you’re projecting your sour grapes 360 degrees out from the epicenter…

Meanwhile, I continue to slog through Calvin’s Institutes and a number of fine histories of the fundamentalist and Reformed movements.

When will you be cracking that Catechism?
 
Really? Which flavor of Reformed teaching have I been corrected upon, and continued to ignore?

More claims without evidence, Sandusky, but perhaps you’re projecting your sour grapes 360 degrees out from the epicenter…

Meanwhile, I continue to slog through Calvin’s Institutes and a number of fine histories of the fundamentalist and Reformed movements.

When will you be cracking that Catechism?
And now, the bitterness of gall. 🤷

(BTW, my copy of the catechism is dog-eared, and twice its normal size from the post-its.)
 
And now, the bitterness of gall. 🤷
lol—tell me, which galls you more: requesting you back up your claims with evidence or asking you to read the Catechism?

Take up your cross, Sandusky, take up your cross!
 
lol—tell me, which galls you more: requesting you back up your claims with evidence or asking you to read the Catechism?

Take up your cross, Sandusky, take up your cross!
I’m sorry, Teflon; I’ve been laughing so hard at your lack-of-pride antics that I’m not sure what evidences you’re talking about. 😉

Be that as it may, does it gall you that I’ve read the catechism?

Put down your sword Teflon; put down your sword! 🙂
 
I’m sorry, Teflon; I’ve been laughing so hard at your lack-of-pride antics that I’m not sure what evidences you’re talking about. 😉
Would it be too proud of me to point out that there’s a feature on Catholic Answers known as Scroll Up?
Be that as it may, does it gall you that I’ve read the catechism?
In English?
Put down your sword Teflon; put down your sword! 🙂
Who needs a sword when one has been blessed with a rapier wit?
 
Sour Grapes, Teflon.

I certainly would never question your reasons for leaving whatever church you left for Catholicism, rather, I would take you at your word.

As far as correction concerning Catholic teaching, you too have been corrected concerning your understanding of reformed teaching, and you continue to ignore them, preferring instead, the crutch of Catholic mythology to buttress your, ahem, soteriology. 😉
What is reformed teaching?

The only thing you guys seem to agree on is the catholic Church being wrong.
 
I told you why I left the church—I was neither saved, nor regenerated while in the CC, but you are unable to accept that, because, if you do, your soteriology crumbles, and everything else with it. 🤷
This is nothing more than Sandusky projecting what he wishes were true onto our most holy faith.

“Our soteriology” is as New Testament as it will ever get, as I point out in my blog article, Who REALLY Preaches “A Different Gospel”?. The same cannot correctly be asserted about the modern post reformation “gospel”. (Depending, of course, on all of them ever starting to preach that same exact gospel. I don’t see it happening.)
I have yet to meet a non-
Catholic who will accept my true reason for my leaving their precious church.I can say the very same thing about you and the majority of n-Cs/a-C that I encounter. Yet I have my testimony and personal witness.
It’s unfathomable to the Catholic that what I say is true; the Catholic seems unable even to entertain the possibility that their Catholicism is not true; therefore, the Catholic reasons that I’m lying, and the real truth is either that I was poorly catechized, or he goes to the extreme of priestly molestation.
How pitiable is that? 😦
Please get off that martyr bit. It just doesn’t wash. You have us all figured out. Too bad that it’s a completely fallacious reasoning.

The reason that I (in particular), reject your position is rational and many fold.

Essentially, it comes down to the fact that I went where you are and came back after having examined both the teachings of the n-C faith communities that I have been exposed to, the Word of God, and the actual teachings of the Catholic Church. This was brought about by an extremely anti-Catholic attack on Catholic belief. (see my testimony for details).

I did the “homework” and I am heart and soul convinced that the n-Cs have their gospel messed up, and that the Catholic Church really is the direct doctrinal descendant of the New Testament Christian Church.

I have never thought you are lying or any other weird stuff…just that you are dead wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top