Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Guanophor, thank you for correcting my harsh way:
MIZER, I think you are being too hard on sandusky here.
Possibly.
I say that because my background if very similar to his. I was raised in Catholic school and so called Catholic family. I left as a teen and joined a Southern Baptist congregation because I too believed that I was unregenerate and unsaved. The Baptists taught me to read and love the Word of God,
I do not doubt the veracity of what you are saying. It pains me to know that catholics (expecially the children) are not better taught to love the word as it is expressed every week (day), so beautifully in the Mass. I know that for many, however, who are raised in the church, particularly the generation born in the late 50’s and later, there was a disconnect there that the Protestants picked up. I don’t deny that faithful protestants could teach a few catholic parents a thing or two about keeping kids faithful to the beliefs they are raised with.
something that I had not done before. They also taught me about fellowship, ditto
conversational prayer, ditto
and many other things about Christian life of which I had no experience. ditto
After that I sojourned in a variety of Protestant communities for about 20 years, after which I finally came home. While I admit that I did lack faith in the Bride of Christ, I dont’ think God’s will was thwarted in my life.
And I didn’t mean to imply that sanduskys entire life is a thwarting of God’s will, merely his seeming refusel to honestly consider the truth catholicism holds at the present time in his life.
I was not trying to “rebel” either, but to get closer to God. A very good thing, one I respect sandusky for inasmuch as he would say the same of himself.
I wanted and needed the emotional and personal experiences that I did not have with God during my early years. And each of us in entitled to that wherever we may find it. Good point.
I don’t think it is fair to say that a person “never availed himself of the teachings” under such circumstances. While this is true of me also, I did eventually come to a point of doing so.
Another good point.
I disagree that most Catholics are strong in their faith.
Then you are not disagreeing with what I said. I said most catholics who are strong in their faith… I agree with everthing you say here and in the short paragraph that follows.
However, I think you need to be fair, and accept that sandusky has embraced what seems reasonable to him, based on his own personal experience.
One also needs to keep in mind that any truth found in Protestant Communities came from the Catholic Church, and is what unites all of our separated brethren to the One Body of Christ.
Indeed.
I think by living the life that Christ intended, thereby bearing witness to Him. One must consider, why is sandusky here? He has been continuing the same old arguements for almost two years. Why has he not gotten bored, and left? Something here is pulling his energy and attention. Something inside him keeps bringing him back.
Again, an excellent point.
sandusky is under no obligation to reveal his affiliations, just as none of us are. If he chooses to protect himself from the inevitable onslaught that would occur if he revealed this personal information, it is incumbent upon us to respect his choice.
Right again. I have been duly corrected. Sorry sandusky. My harshness and zeal for my faith sometimes gets the better of me. I don’t mean to be unfair or uncaring or unthinking or intrusive into your privacy.

Forgive me.
 
sandusky is under no obligation to reveal his affiliations, just as none of us are. If he chooses to protect himself from the inevitable onslaught that would occur if he revealed this personal information, it is incumbent upon us to respect his choice.
What onslaught would that be?

I asked his affiliation simply because he made claims for his denomination which cannot possibly be evaluated without knowing it.

I am a Catholic. I have even elsewhere referenced the name of my parish, bishop, and priests.

No onslaught has occurred.

What onslaught do you anticipate?
 
What onslaught would that be?

I asked his affiliation simply because he made claims for his denomination which cannot possibly be evaluated without knowing it.

I am a Catholic. I have even elsewhere referenced the name of my parish, bishop, and priests.

No onslaught has occurred.

What onslaught do you anticipate?
The Spanish Inquisition? Of course nobody expects…
 
40.png
Teflon93:
I asked his affiliation simply because he made claims for his denomination which cannot possibly be evaluated without knowing it.
The issue can only be a denominational one if you consider the RCC to be a denomination, which you don’t, which makes your point moot, and which is why I called it apples to oranges.
40.png
guanophore:
I left as a teen and joined a Southern Baptist congregation because I too believed that I was unregenerate and unsaved.
When I left as a teenager, I joined the congregation of sex, drugs, and booze, and except for weddings and funerals, I didn’t set foot inside another church for almost 30 years—unsaved, unregenerate Christ rejecter. :o
 
What onslaught would that be?

I asked his affiliation simply because he made claims for his denomination which cannot possibly be evaluated without knowing it.

I am a Catholic. I have even elsewhere referenced the name of my parish, bishop, and priests.

No onslaught has occurred.

What onslaught do you anticipate?
Just that one which has been implied (in my opinon correctly) in this thread, that his community is not sinless either, and does embrace heresies. It is probably that most members of it cannot be charged with heresy, since they never were taught the true faith as it has come to us from the apostles.

Up th thread (I think it was this one) he posted links to some of the confessions. All of them diverge from the Apostolic faith to some degree.
 
The issue can only be a denominational one if you consider the RCC to be a denomination, which you don’t, which makes your point moot, and which is why I called it apples to oranges.

When I left as a teenager, I joined the congregation of sex, drugs, and booze, and except for weddings and funerals, I didn’t set foot inside another church for almost 30 years—unsaved, unregenerate Christ rejecter. :o
I praise God that He drew you back into His fold. Many persons are permanently lost after this happens. For me, it came a little later, after I went away to college.
 
Just that one which has been implied (in my opinon correctly) in this thread, that his community is not sinless either, and does embrace heresies. It is probably that most members of it cannot be charged with heresy, since they never were taught the true faith as it has come to us from the apostles.

Up th thread (I think it was this one) he posted links to some of the confessions. All of them diverge from the Apostolic faith to some degree.
But that’s all fair game, don’t you think?

It is an apologetics forum, after all, and whatever claims one makes for one’s own faith ought to be transparent and verifiable.

There is no requirement to share one’s affiliation, of course, but it is interesting to note how many of those holding the majoritarian Protestant confession in America shy from doing so, while we in the Catholic minority do not.

You’ll also note that Sandusky does not shy from claiming I’ve distorted the teachings of whichever affiliation he does or does not belong to despite the various claims he sometimes makes for it, whatever it may be.

This is what makes arguing with Protestants ultimately a pointless task, beyond simply puncturing their distortions of the Catholic faith. Protestantism is simply a chimera. We spend most of a thread trying to debunk the same ol’ anti-Catholic mythology they produce, most of the rest trying to clarify what it is precisely they believe, and then they bail before terms have been defined and an argument joined.

Hmmm, sounds an awful lot like this thread. 🤷
 
But that’s all fair game, don’t you think?

It is an apologetics forum, after all, and whatever claims one makes for one’s own faith ought to be transparent and verifiable.

There is no requirement to share one’s affiliation, of course, but it is interesting to note how many of those holding the majoritarian Protestant confession in America shy from doing so, while we in the Catholic minority do not.
Indeed it is, and he knows that, which is why he may be reticent in sharing it. Sometimes we are like a pack of wolves around here. 😃

I agree that Catholics and Catholicism are out there (the light on the hill) to be disparaged more than others, especially here in America. I sometimes wonder what Protestants would do if they found themselves in a Coptic or Syrian parish, where there were no Protestants.
You’ll also note that Sandusky does not shy from claiming I’ve distorted the teachings of whichever affiliation he does or does not belong to despite the various claims he sometimes makes for it, whatever it may be.

This is what makes arguing with Protestants ultimately a pointless task, beyond simply puncturing their distortions of the Catholic faith. Protestantism is simply a chimera. We spend most of a thread trying to debunk the same ol’ anti-Catholic mythology they produce, most of the rest trying to clarify what it is precisely they believe, and then they bail before terms have been defined and an argument joined.

Hmmm, sounds an awful lot like this thread. 🤷
Yes, but consider the lurkers, who are often ten times the number of posters. It is likely that many of them have the same distortions and myths about Catholicism as moondweller and sandusky have, yet do not want to wade into the fray. Your excellent posts will help them, as well as lapsed Catholics. :clapping:
 
I agree that Catholics and Catholicism are out there (the light on the hill) to be disparaged more than others, especially here in America. I sometimes wonder what Protestants would do if they found themselves in a Coptic or Syrian parish, where there were no Protestants.
It’s an interesting situation some Protestants on missions trips to the East are finding themselves in. One of the Orthodox posters told the story in another thread (paraphrasing here) of some evangelical minister who showed up in an Orthodox village in Eastern Europe to preach one Sunday. He asked anybody who wanted to accept Jesus into their hearts to come down to the altar. Nobody came. He was flummoxed, until someone called out, “Those who had accepted Christ before you came accept him still.” 😉
Yes, but consider the lurkers, who are often ten times the number of posters. It is likely that many of them have the same distortions and myths about Catholicism as moondweller and sandusky have, yet do not want to wade into the fray. Your excellent posts will help them, as well as lapsed Catholics. :clapping:
Oh, I know it’s not pointless from the lurkers’ standpoint, just from the standpoint of having a real debate and getting to the truth of the matter. I always find it useful to clarify what the Church actually teaches, but it would be nicer still to actually get to finish an argument.

Thank you for your kind words, and for invariably setting the example.
 
It’s an interesting situation some Protestants on missions trips to the East are finding themselves in. One of the Orthodox posters told the story in another thread (paraphrasing here) of some evangelical minister who showed up in an Orthodox village in Eastern Europe to preach one Sunday. He asked anybody who wanted to accept Jesus into their hearts to come down to the altar. Nobody came. He was flummoxed, until someone called out, “Those who had accepted Christ before you came accept him still.” 😉
That reminds me of a story our pastor told. An evangelical Baptist came up to him and asked him to give his witness of his conversion to Christ. He stated that “he was born dead in sin, a child of wrath under the just condemnation of a Holy God, that he had spent his time on earth self-absorbed, only interested in self. Had he died at that moment he would’ve spent an eternity in perdition, but through the preaching of the gospel, he was sanctified by the Spirit, he was regenerated and born anew from above, he had faith in Christ as his risen savior from sin and he was brought into the fold of the church as an adopted son of God”…then he said “but I dont remember any of it, because I was only two weeks old when I was baptised.” LOL
 
That reminds me of a story our pastor told. An evangelical Baptist came up to him and asked him to give his witness of his conversion to Christ. He stated that “he was born dead in sin, a child of wrath under the just condemnation of a Holy God, that he had spent his time on earth self-absorbed, only interested in self. Had he died at that moment he would’ve spent an eternity in perdition, but through the preaching of the gospel, he was sanctified by the Spirit, he was regenerated and born anew from above, he had faith in Christ as his risen savior from sin and he was brought into the fold of the church as an adopted son of God”…then he said “but I dont remember any of it, because I was only two weeks old when I was baptised.” LOL
So true, so true.

I’ve had peopel ask me how I know I was baptised, and I tell them, “I have a certificate and my parents took pictures.”

That’s better documentary evidence than the apostles had!
 
In reply to Ronald Cote’s statement, “I have read the whole bible and am left with the impression that salvation is the unmerited free gift and that becoming “born again” Christians demands of us to perform good works as part of the routine ministry endowed as a result but not as a prerequisite.” Good works are vital to our Catholic/Christian existence and represent our love for God. However, why did God present the Ten Commandments to Moses, if He didn’t “command” us to follow them? Catholics believe that following God’s Ten Commandments is the key to salvation, and good works are the icing on the cake, so to speak. Catholics believe that not following the Ten Commandments is disobedience to God, meriting penalties (purgatory), and, if sins are severe (termed mortal) in nature and unrepented (hell).

Mr. Cote further states, “distinction being must we perform good works in order to gain salvation or do we perform good works because of our zeal for the Lord to serve Him through good works.” Perfect contrition would be our zeal to love and serve God through good works. Imperfect contrition would be serving God out of fear of Him and His final judgment of us. But any contrition is better than no contrition, wouldn’t you say?

I have no direct line to God, but I sincerely believe that many of my friends/acquaintances show signs of living a life that might lead them directly to heaven, or, possibly, only a minimal time in purgatory. God is good.
 
Read Matthew 25. Read it in full context and here is what you have done for me:

You have faith, which God’s grace has given you. God’s grace has given you a life of good works because Christ works through you. I have known you for many years and I see so much good you have done which will not get you into heaven, but your good works have been a witness to me so I believe because of your witness that Christ is my Lord and savior too, and through your witness and good works, I believe too and I accept Christ as my Lord and savior and I am baptized in water and spirit, because you reflected Christ to me and then I could believe. God Bless you for your faith and understanding of Christ’s love and forgiveness.

Just like in the Bible Matthew 25:
 
Just that one which has been implied (in my opinon correctly) in this thread, that his community is not sinless either, and does embrace heresies. It is probably that most members of it cannot be charged with heresy, since they never were taught the true faith as it has come to us from the apostles.

Up th thread (I think it was this one) he posted links to some of the confessions. All of them diverge from the Apostolic faith to some degree.
If there is an onslaught of any kind, its coming from the non-C’s. I don’t think anyone is charging any person with heresy, but if the denomination is in heresy, thats a different story. The Truth is the Truth no matter what. Nothing can change that. All this division among believers is tearing our world apart. For Pete sake, just look around. Christ prayed for UNITY, not disunity. We should all be pulling together to do God’s will. If the Catholic Church is the ONE, True Church, (not because I said so, but because Christ said so.) then all christians should look into seeking the truth. Stop all name-calling, false accusations, and seek the truth with an open mind and loving heart. Sacred Scripture was not ment to be pulled apart like it has been. All of God’s children are obliged to follow the 10 Commandments. Love one another, as well as their enemies. Center our lives around the True Presence of Our Lord in the Holy Eucharist, not just a symbol. Learn about the Miracles of the Eucharist. Pray and humble ourselves before God.

2 chronicles 7-14

If MY people, which are called by MY name, shall humble themselves and pray, and seek MY face, and turn from their wicked ways, then I will hear from Heaven, and will forgive their sins and will heal their land.

God Bless,
 
I am sorry to seem so ignorant. I know that there are all kinds of thoughts about salvation, works, predestination within and among every Christian denomination.

I simply cannot get my head around the idea that we are saved simply by faith, that we are not commanded to follow Christ’s example, not just of serving God, but serving our fellow human beings. The idea that we can be saved by sitting around looking good seems antithetical to being a Christian - I mean what’s the point? Finally, the idea of predestination is exceptionally unsavoury, but I am not sure what place it has formally in the doctrine of the Catholic Church.

And in all of this where does purgatory lie? We are either saved (by faith alone) or we are not. Or we have had faith AND works and are therefore saved for eternity.

This side of the Atlantic, I have been taught that most people - Chrstians, those who have never known Christ and even those who have known Christ but turned away from the Church (moral non-Christians for example) - will be with God for eternity, as our divine spark which comes from Him returns to Him. Those who are instinctively imbued with evil will be separated from Him forever.

I know - to many this will sound heretical. But it is informed by Jesus’ example in the New Testament, the Old and New Covenants, and texts such as

Matthew 25:40
King James Version (KJV)
And the King shall answer and say unto them, Verily I say unto you, Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me.

Micah 6:8
King James Version (KJV)
He hath shewed thee, O man, what is good; and what doth the LORD require of thee, but to do justly, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with thy God?

Saved by Grace
through our Faith
which is made living by our Works
which are not motivated by salvific benefit, but rather by
Christian Love and Charity.

And all those who suffer have been called once and for all to become sharers “in Christ’s sufferings”(98), just as all have been called to “complete” with their own suffering “what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions”(99). At one and the same time Christ has taught man to do good by his suffering and to do good to those who suffer. In this double aspect he has completely revealed the meaning of suffering.
Pope John Paul II, Apostolic Letter, Salvifici Doloris, 1984

All your work shall be done for the common good, with greater zeal and more dispatch than if each one of you were to work for yourself alone. For charity, as it is written, is not self-seeking (1 Cor 13:5) meaning that it places the common good before its own, not its own before the common good. So whenever you show greater concern for the common good than for your own, you may know that you are growing in charity. Thus, let the abiding virtue of charity prevail in all things that minister to the fleeting necessities of life.
Saint Augustine

And of course

1 Corinthians 13:2
King James Version (KJV)
And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing.

OK - in five bullet points, can someone spell out the truth here? I am a neophyte, quite clearly totally confused.

My own prayer is:

Jesus of Nazareth, the Christ, Son of Man and God, Redeemer,
Thy will be done.
Mantle me with thy grace, courage and compassion,
That I may learn to do Thy will.

Faith without works? Work and faith? Predestination?

Jabulani!
 
I am sorry to seem so ignorant. I know that there are all kinds of thoughts about salvation, works, predestination within and among every Christian denomination.

Lisdogon, there may be all kinds of thoughts about salvation but Jesus taught only one Truth. We must seek HIS truth. There are many Sacred Mysteries concerning God in our lives, and Jesus IS God, the Son. The Trinity, as an example, can anyone, any human being, no matter how intelligent or well learned about God, ever explain that, No because it is above our human level of understanding. It is supernatural. But we all take the Word of God on that, the Word of Our Lord.

you continue,
I simply cannot get my head around the idea that we are saved simply by faith, that we are not commanded to follow Christ’s example, not just of serving God, but serving our fellow human beings. The idea that we can be saved by sitting around looking good seems antithetical to being a Christian - I mean what’s the point? Finally, the idea of predestination is exceptionally unsavory, but I am not sure what place it has formally in the doctrine of the Catholic Church.

Yep,
You are right Lisdogon, if we truly listen to Our Lord, he tells us that faith and works go hand in hand. Can’t have one, without the other and be a true Christian. As for predestination and the place it has in the Catholic Church, we believe that God predestined for EVERYONE to go to Heaven. That was HIS Will in creating mankind, but Adam and Eve messed that up royally. And so God sent His Only Son to show us the way around Adam’s sin. And Jesus gave us HIS Catholic Church to teach us, to govern us and to Sanctify us thru HIS 7 Sacraments. And it has done so for 2,000 years and will continue to do so for the rest of time.

you ask?,
And in all of this where does purgatory lie? We are either saved (by faith alone) or we are not. Or we have had faith AND works and are therefore saved for eternity.

This side of the Atlantic, I have been taught that most people - Chrstians, those who have never known Christ and even those who have known Christ but turned away from the Church (moral non-Christians for example) - will be with God for eternity, as our divine spark which comes from Him returns to Him. Those who are instinctively imbued with evil will be separated from Him forever.

OK,
What does instinctively evil mean? Jesus died for all, so that all might be saved by Him. Not forced to be saved by a moment of grace. But by choosing that Grace of our own Free Will, through out our lifetime. (given by God at conception.) And Not one single human being is outside of God’s Saving Grace. As for purgatory, it is another Great Mercy of God, he allows for us to atone for our forgiven sins. It is not a form of repentance, but a cleansing, Purgatory means purging, cleansing. atoning. Jesus said we must atone for every sin, either in this world or in the next. Do we believe Him or not! What IS Faith, but trusting in the complete Word of God, HIS Son. Study the early Church Fathers and the Acts of the Apostles. In the Catholic Church the Old Testament and the New Testament go hand in glove, Jesus taught from the Old Testament, Sacred Tradition was given by Jesus Himself. The New Testament was written to bring His teachings to us along with Sacred Tradition. Not separated from it. God Bless. Memaw

I know - to many this will sound heretical. But it is informed by Jesus’ example in the New Testament, the Old and New Covenants, and texts such as

Matthew 25:40
King James Version (KJV)
And the King shall answer and say unto them, Verily I say unto you, Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me.

Micah 6:8
King James Version (KJV)
He hath shewed thee, O man, what is good; and what doth the LORD require of thee, but to do justly, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with thy God?

Saved by Grace
through our Faith
which is made living by our Works
which are not motivated by salvific benefit, but rather by
Christian Love and Charity.

And all those who suffer have been called once and for all to become sharers “in Christ’s sufferings”(98), just as all have been called to “complete” with their own suffering “what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions”(99). At one and the same time Christ has taught man to do good by his suffering and to do good to those who suffer. In this double aspect he has completely revealed the meaning of suffering.
Pope John Paul II, Apostolic Letter, Salvifici Doloris, 1984

All your work shall be done for the common good, with greater zeal and more dispatch than if each one of you were to work for yourself alone. For charity, as it is written, is not self-seeking (1 Cor 13:5) meaning that it places the common good before its own, not its own before the common good. So whenever you show greater concern for the common good than for your own, you may know that you are growing in charity. Thus, let the abiding virtue of charity prevail in all things that minister to the fleeting necessities of life.
Saint Augustine

And of course

1 Corinthians 13:2
King James Version (KJV)
And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing.

OK - in five bullet points, can someone spell out the truth here? I am a neophyte, quite clearly totally confused.

My own prayer is:

Jesus of Nazareth, the Christ, Son of Man and God, Redeemer,
Thy will be done.
Mantle me with thy grace, courage and compassion,
That I may learn to do Thy will.

Faith without works? Work and faith? Predestination?

Jabulani!
 
I have several friends who are protestant ministers. Though I see them as holy, devout people who love Christ, I feel very bad that they do not have the fullness of the Truth as having been taught by the Catholic Church from it’s founding by Christ in 33 A.D.

During the protestant revolution in the 1500’s, sola fide, especially taught by Luther, Calvin and the rest of the reformers, was their attempt to reduce the Sacraments to two, Baptism and Eucharist, which are merely signs of one’s faith. If Christ were truly present in the Sacrament of the Eucharist, it would mean that it would be necessary for salvation. If it would be necessary for salvation, then it would need a formal church and a clergy that is duly ordained to confect these sacraments. These would also invoke the theology of the Mass being a Sacrifice and a valid priesthood to celebrate the Mass and the Sacraments.

I believe that there are many ministers who are researching Catholic Theology. Some hinderances to their returning is the loss of position and salary and their admitting that Rome is right and they must be obedient to the ancient churches teaching.

I had a minister recently tell me that we put so much emphesis on Paul and not on Jesus. Paul was defending his work against the Judeizers, Jesus clearly states that our work is salvific. "When I was hungry you gave me to eat, etc. (Gospel of Matthew.) Again, they are searching but we have to be strong in our faith and show that we are saved by faith, but as St. Paul also says, this must be rooted in love, i.e., works. Sorry for being so long.
 
Oh, we get plenty of them around here. We deluge them with evidence and then they move on, disgruntled.

Still, it’s fun to try to get a coherent argument out of them for their beliefs. Since they’re based neither on evidence, nor on reasoning, but rather on their own very late manmade tradition, there isn’t much for a KJV-only fundamentalist apologist to do BUT recite propaganda.

Seeds planted may grow even in the rockiest ground, though, so one must spread the truth even if the odds aren’t good.

Asking them why Jesus turned water into wine and not the other way around’s always amusing, anyway.
Well, I think I have done pretty well so far and I haven’t jumped ship.

PS I will be finishing off the exposition of John 6 and will be ready to give a closing argument very soon.

Not your ‘typical’ Fundamentalist.
 
There have been several threads recently dealing with the Sola Fide issue, and a lot of Protestants misunderstanding, and sometimes misrepresenting the Catholic position, accusing Catholics of believing in a works based salvation, trying to earn their way into heaven. And explaining our belief that faith without works is dead doesn’t seem to be doing any good. So I have an analogy that I hope will help our Protestant friends to understand our position, even if they don’t agree with it. As my favorite radio host Dennis Prager says, clarity is preferable to agreement.

The reason our Heavenly Father calls Himself that is because it’s the closest human analogy to His relationship with us. And He deals with us much the same way that our terrestrial parents do. We are as children to God. Keep this in mind as you ponder this analogy.

Pretend that you are once again a small child. Your parents tell you that if you pick up your toys and eat all your vegetables, they will take you out for ice cream. This seems like a pretty good deal, so you pick up all your toys, and you eat all your broccoli, and they take you out for ice cream.

Your parents know that you love them, but they desire your obedience, not for their sake but for yours. You didn’t earn the ice cream. You have no money, or the means to make any. It doesn’t hurt your parents when you don’t eat your vegetables, and the two minutes it would have taken them to pick up your toys for you doesn’t even compare to the 20 minutes and $5 it took to get you ice cream. The ice cream was a gift and a reward, for loving and obeying your parents. The love and obedience go hand in hand. They are incomplete without one another.

Simply loving and believing in God is not faith. I believe it was James who said, “you do well to believe, but the devils also believe, and tremble”. And Jesus said that those who love Him will obey His commandments. When Protestants talk about being saved through faith but deny the importance of works, it seems like what they’re actually saying is that you are saved through belief. This may not be the way Protestants understand their belief in Sola Fide, but that’s how it sounds to Catholics. Because without obedience, belief is just belief, and clearly that is not enough.

Yes, salvation is a gift, pure and simple. No, there is absolutely no way we could ever possibly even begin to earn it. And yes, we are saved by our faith. But faith without obedience simply isn’t faith at all.

This analogy is obviously flawed, as is every analogy that tries to explain God. But I hope it helps. And if anyone has suggestions on how to improve it, or has a better analogy altogether, I welcome them to share it with us.

God bless.
One thought that just streamed through my brain is: Jesus could have just sat and “thought” about the Father, but didn’t He say at one time, “I must be about my Father’s work”?
 
Well, I think I have done pretty well so far and I haven’t jumped ship.

PS I will be finishing off the exposition of John 6 and will be ready to give a closing argument very soon.

Not your ‘typical’ Fundamentalist.
I wouldn’t say you’re a typical Fundamentalist in that regard, drbible.

I will continue the other thread this weekend—I have read your latest responses and do appreciate you sticking with that thread.

It is quite a difference from the “lob a hand grenade in the form of a question and then run off without waiting for an answer” stuff we tend to get around here.

Of course, it may be that Australians have just never been much for running away from anything. 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top