Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But the difference is that JESUS used those men and breathed on them and TOLD them to go establish his Church. The other men established THEIR OWN Churches, and did it on their own without Jesus’ direction or blessing. It is totally different, and I really can’t believe that you wrote that. The other men’s Churches were established on and reflect their own ideology, beliefs, changes of doctrine and personal interpretations of Truth. So, really, it isn’t a matter of them being “tarred” by the Catholic’s “commonly-held generalisation” - as that is not what it is. They are 'tarred" by the very fact that they separated from Christ’s Church by their own choice because of their own self-serving ideologies and beliefs. How could they ever think it was right to do such a thing?
It is not right to charge modern day Protestants with the sin of heresy committed by the Reformers. Most of them were raised in communities where they were never taught the truth of what the Apostles believed an practiced. They were not “separated by their own choice” as their spiritual ancestors were.
 
It is not right to charge modern day Protestants with the sin of heresy committed by the Reformers. Most of them were raised in communities where they were never taught the truth of what the Apostles believed an practiced. They were not “separated by their own choice” as their spiritual ancestors were.
I guess I should have made that more clear. I didn’t say modern day Protestants. When I was writing, I was thinking of the Reformers and the thoughts and teachings they had, and that they made the decisions to split and teach their beliefs. I thought I was pretty clear on who I was speaking about. I am sorry if it sounded like I was talking about people today. However, I will add here that people today are learning the Truth, and it is their choice to believe it or not. The ones who are hearing the truth, have now been taught.
 
Lisdogan,
Thank you for your very informative post. I am not a historian, so I am sure you eclipse me on that 10-fold.

When I say “I believe”, it is my belief, because I have never been able to disprove the Catholic Church’s 2,000 year old claim.

I understand that at the beginning of Christianity, when the Apostles went out to teach, they had limited means and as in every situation, misunderstandings arose. Those were routinely corrected, admonished, etc… Human’s always have the opportunity to misunderstand and have to make a determination on what it means that they are hearing. I guess it is wrong to assume that everyone listened and believed in the exact teaching as the way given by the Apostles and their successors. That would have been nice, huh?

I understand what you are saying about there being different interpretations, but that does not take away from the fact that there was no other Church that could ever claim to be founded by Jesus. The CC is the Church founded by Jesus and nothing or noone else’s interpretation negates that. Different interpretations are just what they are, separate beliefs and not a part of the Catholic Church. The fact that there were misinterpretations is really not a strong argument against the Catholic Church being THE Church that was created at that time by Christ.

It is unfurtunate that “heresies” evolved and still exist. That is just because those people all along never learned the Truth. So, they believed what they believed. If they taught any of it, it would have been heresy then and would be heresy now.

In everything that I have read, the protesters initially had some valid reasons for protest. I love your tree analogy. It is the perfect way to explain it. The eroneous behaviors were already under change before Trent. The Catholic Church was already addressing these issues and making strides towards eradicating said behaviors.

There are many wonderful Protestants that give good Witness and love and accept God. But, we can’t forget that they all have been taught and come from Churches that broke away from Christ’s Church 1500 years later and don’t teach the fullness of Jesus’ Word. It was definitely a good wake-up call for the Church.

There is a word that when translated means Catholic. It was used at that time. I have that somewhere, when I find it I will provide that information. I don’t know when the word Catholic was added to Church.

How are we expected to prove anything Jesus said? He founded the Church and did promised to guide her until the end of time. That is what Peter and the Apostles always believed and taught. It is what the Catholic Church was told and has always continued to believe. We really can’t “prove” anything Jesus said. We have to have faith. Otherwise, we would have to go with the people that say all of this Jesus, Church, “stuff” is just mad-up fiction. There is no proof, it is through faith that we believe anything at all.

We are the ONLY Church that Jesus established through Peter and the Apostles and gave His Deposit of Faith to. The Catholic Church is the ONLY Church that has safeguarded his Teachings and has never changed it’s doctrine in matters of faith and morals. Because she has always taught Jesus’ One Word, is why she is still here 2,000 years later. So, it is the Catholic Church that teaches the precious Word of Jesus, unchanged for 2,000 years now, not Christendom.

The fact that Protestantism and every other Church was founded on man is not to be diminished. Peter and the Apostles are the ONLY men that Jesus breathed on and gave his authority to to go forth and teach to all nations. I don’t understand your intention for writing that the CC is included as a Church that was founded by man. That is just splitting hairs of sorts. Jesus used man, of course. But the difference is that JESUS used those men and breathed on them and TOLD them to go establish his Church. The other men established THEIR OWN Churches, and did it on their own without Jesus’ direction or blessing. It is totally different, and I really can’t believe that you wrote that. The other men’s Churches were established on and reflect their own ideology, beliefs, changes of doctrine and personal interpretations of Truth. So, really, it isn’t a matter of them being “tarred” by the Catholic’s “commonly-held generalisation” - as that is not what it is. They are 'tarred" by the very fact that they separated from Christ’s Church by their own choice because of their own self-serving ideologies and beliefs. How could they ever think it was right to do such a thing?
AMEN!!👍 All they have to do is READ the Bible correctly and they will see that is true. St. Ignatius of Antioch first used the name Catholic in the year 107, Read the writings of the Early Church Fathers. Jesus Christ promised HE would be with HIS Church, (Catholic Church) till the end of time and that HIS Church would never teach error, He sent the Holy Spirit to guide it in the Truth. We can trust Jesus to keep HIS promise, (HE has , for over 2,000 years) and HE will continue to do so, NO MATTER WHAT. HIS Catholic Church is One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic, but that doesn’t mean everyone in it is one, holy, Catholic and Apostolic. Many Catholics do not know, love or live their Catholic Faith as we should, but that doesn’t change the fact that Christ’s Church is faithful to HIM and teaches the fullness of Truth. That will never change. The 7 Sacraments are there to help us return to the fullness of Truth. God Bless. Memaw
 
Oh please, please let us not go down that road again and again. You believe you are right in saying this. I accept that. As a Catholic however, I am content to allow for differences within the universal church of Christ.

Catholics know that there are differences among Catholic priests and other religious in interpretations of biblical texts, church traditions, preferences and priorities - some are Mariologists, some are not for example.

We know there are differences in texts in various Bible translations, and in the understanding of biblical teachings in various regions of the world - to the extent that regional meetings of Bishops have become more and more significant in interpreting the faith within the cultural context of each region, and taking into account extant indigenous belief systems which tend to persist alongside Catholicism.

There are numerous other examples. Most famously, we can look at the rehabilitation of the reputation of Martin Luther by the Catholic Church. It has been said he should have been a ‘Blessed’ much earlier. I have not yet read the criteria applied to the Luther about-face, but realise that whatever they are, they have profound implications for our understanding of the so-called Reformation and Counter-Reformation.

So, as I see it, there are variations within the Catholic Church itself. I think it is useful to consider that there are also legitimate variations within and among the various denominations of Christendom.

We simply cannot continue to cut off debate with the simplistic response you have given. I know that, and I think you know it too.

Jabulani!
Hello. I have some statements/questions for you. I hope you reply. Thanks.

Catholics know that there are differences among Catholic priests and other religious in interpretations of biblical texts, church traditions, preferences and priorities - some are Mariologists, some are not for example.
QUES:
How far off do the various interpretations among Catholic priests and other religious go? What unifies the church are the Traditional Doctrines and Dogmas that have been given as first given to us by Christ and as understood by the Apostles. These have never changed, nor will they.

There are numerous other examples. Most famously, we can look at the rehabilitation of the reputation of Martin Luther by the Catholic Church. It has been said he should have been a ‘Blessed’ much earlier. I have not yet read the criteria applied to the Luther about-face, but realise that whatever they are, they have profound implications for our understanding of the so-called Reformation and Counter-Reformation.
QUES:
Would you please find your reference to this and let me know? Thanks.

As an historian I disagree that there is proof of unchanged doctrine in faith and morals (viz 1300-1600 say), or of leadership (the dual (Avignon) papacy). We should also check our ‘proven history’, as our understanding of the actual and factual history of the CC changes regularly
STATEMENT:
One of the Popes was ousted. Can’t remember which one. One was proven legal, the other not. Where do we check this “proven” history? I think the Papl library has all the writings and documents needed to prove her point.

At the time Christ established his Church through Peter, there was no other Christian church, although very early on there were distinct differences in interpretations of Christ’s mission, as we see from the letters of St Paul to various communities. So I think we must adjust your statement here. There was no other church but Christ’s church, but there were a number of community variations.
STATEMENT:
The members of the Church who posited these variations either submitted to discipline by the Bishops, or they were ousted. Please explain variations.

Subsequently various so-called ‘heresies’ evolved within the CC, which were generally put down. Some still survive within the Catholic community. This was before the Reformation.

STATEMENT/QUES:
True. And??? Within???

Yes, the earliest church was the church founded by Christ, but I am not sure that it was called the ‘Catholic Church’, and am not sure when that name was applied, or to what it referred.

STATEMENT:
Agree with the first point, don’t know about the second either.

This statement is often made, but without proof. If you said that Christendom, in its own wobbly way, has sustained the profound and divine truth of Christ throughout the ages, I would agree that is true, because we are still here 2000 years later. But that is Christendom, not we - the only church.

QUES:
Why would the Catholic Church lie about its history?? At one time all Christendom was Catholic.
 
Lisdogan,
Thank you for your very informative post. I am not a historian, so I am sure you eclipse me on that 10-fold.

When I say “I believe”, it is my belief, because I have never been able to disprove the Catholic Church’s 2,000 year old claim.

I understand that at the beginning of Christianity, when the Apostles went out to teach, they had limited means and as in every situation, misunderstandings arose. Those were routinely corrected, admonished, etc… Human’s always have the opportunity to misunderstand and have to make a determination on what it means that they are hearing. I guess it is wrong to assume that everyone listened and believed in the exact teaching as the way given by the Apostles and their successors. That would have been nice, huh?

I understand what you are saying about there being different interpretations, but that does not take away from the fact that there was no other Church that could ever claim to be founded by Jesus. The CC is the Church founded by Jesus and nothing or noone else’s interpretation negates that. Different interpretations are just what they are, separate beliefs and not a part of the Catholic Church. The fact that there were misinterpretations is really not a strong argument against the Catholic Church being THE Church that was created at that time by Christ.

It is unfurtunate that “heresies” evolved and still exist. That is just because those people all along never learned the Truth. So, they believed what they believed. If they taught any of it, it would have been heresy then and would be heresy now.

In everything that I have read, the protesters initially had some valid reasons for protest. I love your tree analogy. It is the perfect way to explain it. The eroneous behaviors were already under change before Trent. The Catholic Church was already addressing these issues and making strides towards eradicating said behaviors.

There are many wonderful Protestants that give good Witness and love and accept God. But, we can’t forget that they all have been taught and come from Churches that broke away from Christ’s Church 1500 years later and don’t teach the fullness of Jesus’ Word. It was definitely a good wake-up call for the Church.

There is a word that when translated means Catholic. It was used at that time. I have that somewhere, when I find it I will provide that information. I don’t know when the word Catholic was added to Church.

How are we expected to prove anything Jesus said? He founded the Church and did promised to guide her until the end of time. That is what Peter and the Apostles always believed and taught. It is what the Catholic Church was told and has always continued to believe. We really can’t “prove” anything Jesus said. We have to have faith. Otherwise, we would have to go with the people that say all of this Jesus, Church, “stuff” is just mad-up fiction. There is no proof, it is through faith that we believe anything at all.

We are the ONLY Church that Jesus established through Peter and the Apostles and gave His Deposit of Faith to. The Catholic Church is the ONLY Church that has safeguarded his Teachings and has never changed it’s doctrine in matters of faith and morals. Because she has always taught Jesus’ One Word, is why she is still here 2,000 years later. So, it is the Catholic Church that teaches the precious Word of Jesus, unchanged for 2,000 years now, not Christendom.

The fact that Protestantism and every other Church was founded on man is not to be diminished. Peter and the Apostles are the ONLY men that Jesus breathed on and gave his authority to to go forth and teach to all nations. I don’t understand your intention for writing that the CC is included as a Church that was founded by man. That is just splitting hairs of sorts. Jesus used man, of course. But the difference is that JESUS used those men and breathed on them and TOLD them to go establish his Church. The other men established THEIR OWN Churches, and did it on their own without Jesus’ direction or blessing. It is totally different, and I really can’t believe that you wrote that. The other men’s Churches were established on and reflect their own ideology, beliefs, changes of doctrine and personal interpretations of Truth. So, really, it isn’t a matter of them being “tarred” by the Catholic’s “commonly-held generalisation” - as that is not what it is. They are 'tarred" by the very fact that they separated from Christ’s Church by their own choice because of their own self-serving ideologies and beliefs. How could they ever think it was right to do such a thing?
Great Post MeMaw:thumbsup:
 
Hello. I have some statements/questions for you. I hope you reply. Thanks.

Catholics know that there are differences among Catholic priests and other religious in interpretations of biblical texts, church traditions, preferences and priorities - some are Mariologists, some are not for example.
QUES:
How far off do the various interpretations among Catholic priests and other religious go? What unifies the church are the Traditional Doctrines and Dogmas that have been given as first given to us by Christ and as understood by the Apostles. These have never changed, nor will they.

There are numerous other examples. Most famously, we can look at the rehabilitation of the reputation of Martin Luther by the Catholic Church. It has been said he should have been a ‘Blessed’ much earlier. I have not yet read the criteria applied to the Luther about-face, but realise that whatever they are, they have profound implications for our understanding of the so-called Reformation and Counter-Reformation.
QUES:
Would you please find your reference to this and let me know? Thanks.

As an historian I disagree that there is proof of unchanged doctrine in faith and morals (viz 1300-1600 say), or of leadership (the dual (Avignon) papacy). We should also check our ‘proven history’, as our understanding of the actual and factual history of the CC changes regularly
STATEMENT:
One of the Popes was ousted. Can’t remember which one. One was proven legal, the other not. Where do we check this “proven” history? I think the Papl library has all the writings and documents needed to prove her point.

At the time Christ established his Church through Peter, there was no other Christian church, although very early on there were distinct differences in interpretations of Christ’s mission, as we see from the letters of St Paul to various communities. So I think we must adjust your statement here. There was no other church but Christ’s church, but there were a number of community variations.
STATEMENT:
The members of the Church who posited these variations either submitted to discipline by the Bishops, or they were ousted. Please explain variations.

Subsequently various so-called ‘heresies’ evolved within the CC, which were generally put down. Some still survive within the Catholic community. This was before the Reformation.

STATEMENT/QUES:
True. And??? Within???

Yes, the earliest church was the church founded by Christ, but I am not sure that it was called the ‘Catholic Church’, and am not sure when that name was applied, or to what it referred.

STATEMENT:
Agree with the first point, don’t know about the second either.

This statement is often made, but without proof. If you said that Christendom, in its own wobbly way, has sustained the profound and divine truth of Christ throughout the ages, I would agree that is true, because we are still here 2000 years later. But that is Christendom, not we - the only church.

QUES:
Why would the Catholic Church lie about its history?? At one time all Christendom was Catholic.
The name Catholic was first put in writing by St. Ignatius of Antioch in the year 107. Read the Writings of the Early Church Fathers.
 
Referring to the statement “with all of it’s proven history, leadership and unchanged doctrine in faith and morals since it was given to us by Jesus, is what it says it is,” and Lisdogan’s response, “As an historian I disagree that there is proof of unchanged doctrine in faith and morals …”, it is my belief that the Catholic Church laws can be changed. However Catholic Church’s doctrine in faith and morals has never changed. The Church changed its man-made laws regarding abstaining from meat on Fridays, no longer having to fast before Communion, necessary Masses in Latin, etc., and can change such laws in the future. Does anyone see any changes in the CC’s doctrine on abortion, etc.? Can Lisdogan cite changes in doctrine in faith and morals within the Catholic Church from its beginning over 200 years ago? And what current heresies within the CC are Lisdogan referring to?
Just a couple of points here.

CC is not the Vatican+orders+community of saints etc. It is the living presence of Jesus Christ.

I have suggested earlier that there have been so-called ‘heresies’ (viz Martin Luther’s) and consider that these have influenced faith and morals and continue to do so today. Further, I am convinced absolutely that the changes in the CC paradigm of morality and faith initiated by Vatican II were profound. That is not to say that CC is not the mother church, or that it has been delinquent in keeping the flame of true faith burning over two millennia.

My understanding is that there was not a doctrine on abortion until quite recently. From the Catholic Encyclopedia we read:
Such moral questions, when they are submitted, are decided by the Tribunal of the Holy Office. Now this authority decreed,** 28 May, 1884**, and again, 18 August, 1889, that “it cannot be safely taught in Catholic schools that it is lawful to perform . . . any surgical operation which is directly destructive of the life of the fetus or the mother.” Abortion was condemned by name, 24 July, 1895, in answer to the question whether when the mother is in immediate danger of death and there is no other means of saving her life, a physician can with a safe conscience cause abortion not by destroying the child in the womb (which was explicitly condemned in the former decree), but by giving it a chance to be born alive, though not being yet viable, it would soon expire. The answer was that he cannot. After these and other similar decisions had been given, some moralists thought they saw reasons to doubt whether an exception might not be allowed in the case of ectopic gestations.
Debates with regard to abortion continue from the point at which CC began to address the issue. We see adjustments being considered - particularly when we confront the global HIV and AIDS pandemic (see Fr Michael J Kelly SJ The Catholic Church and HIV (go Google). Crises come and go, contexts change, and that means there are inevitably adjustments to our perceptions of faith and morality. (I know - you are red with rage at this point.)

There is a small community of ‘Albigensian heretics’ still extant in Europe.

Jabulani!
 
If Lisdogan is going to invoke claims of professional competence, she should provide her bona fides. Anyone may claim to be an historian. Historians never shy from providing evidence—indeed, you can’t get many to shut up about it once requested. So please provide yours, Lisdogan, and also provide your bona fides that we may treat your credentials appropriately.
I am very reluctant to answer this query. No one else on this thread, or anywhere on the Forum as far as I know, is asked to present their credentials. *Why me? That is a real question - why me? What is it that has provoked you to ask these questions, and make these statements? *Perhaps it is because you cannot tolerate facts that interfere or challenge your opinions, wishes, preferences and personal observations. Perhaps we all speak too often in generalisations.

But OK:

(1) go Google ‘Carol Coombe’
(2) I will send you my cv and publications if you wish
(3) I have spent the last four years studying Catholic theology, liturgy, doctrine, dogma, history - you name it - full time.
(4) I have had guidance from four senior mentors: a Bishop, a Msgr (Canon Law), a spiritual counsellor, and an internationally known Jesuit who has also been a professional colleague (do you want their bona fides? Someone suggested previously that they were probably all heretics and should be reported to the Vatican. Two are Irish, and two are Belgian.)
(5) I am to be confirmed tomorrow morning, received into the Catholic Church in Pretoria. Say a prayer for me.

PS Why did you assume I am a female?

Jabulani!
(which means rejoice and be exceeding glad, in Xhosa - Mandela’s language)
 
It is not right to charge modern day Protestants with the sin of heresy committed by the Reformers. Most of them were raised in communities where they were never taught the truth of what the Apostles believed an practiced. They were not “separated by their own choice” as their spiritual ancestors were.
I have a big question here, and perhaps it should be the subject of a different thread, although it is pertinent to this one. I’ll be as brief as I can, although I am pretty angry and sad.

(1) Every human being is a child of God, endowed with divine spark/soul.

(2) Many humans have faith in Jesus of Nazareth, the Christ, Son of God and Man, Redeemer.

(3) Those who hold such faith are generally called ‘Christians’.

HOWEVER

(4) If members of the Catholic Church insist that we are ‘the one and only true church of Christ’ where does this leave other Christians? If they are not members of the ‘one true church’, what are they?
  • God’s bastards?
  • moral non-Christians?
  • non-moral Christians?
  • stupid idiots?
  • unrepentant ‘Christian’ sinners headed straight for hell?
  • blind followers of Satan?
  • wayward Christians?
  • confused would-be’s/should-be’s?
  • arrogant protesters on an unnecessary and ill-advised detour?
What are we trying to say to Protestants when we persist in saying that our church is ‘true’ and thereby implying their’s is anything but?

For me, having been raised in a Protestant family in Canada, Protestant Christians are like any Catholic Christian, but (usually, not always) with legitimately different interpretations of the Christian traditions and mysteries.

Jabulani!
 
Whoa! I did not anticipate such long, thoughtful and tough responses to my contribution.

Now I must go and get ready for my confirmation early tomorrow, so will return post haste thereafter.

In other words, I am not trying to escape. Say a prayer for me.

In Christ

Jabulani!
 
I have a big question here, and perhaps it should be the subject of a different thread, although it is pertinent to this one. I’ll be as brief as I can, although I am pretty angry and sad.

(1) Every human being is a child of God, endowed with divine spark/soul.

(2) Many humans have faith in Jesus of Nazareth, the Christ, Son of God and Man, Redeemer.

(3) Those who hold such faith are generally called ‘Christians’.

HOWEVER

(4) If members of the Catholic Church insist that we are ‘the one and only true church of Christ’ where does this leave other Christians? If they are not members of the ‘one true church’, what are they?
  • God’s bastards?
  • moral non-Christians?
  • non-moral Christians?
  • stupid idiots?
  • unrepentant ‘Christian’ sinners headed straight for hell?
  • blind followers of Satan?
  • wayward Christians?
  • confused would-be’s/should-be’s?
  • arrogant protesters on an unnecessary and ill-advised detour?
What are we trying to say to Protestants when we persist in saying that our church is ‘true’ and thereby implying their’s is anything but?

For me, having been raised in a Protestant family in Canada, Protestant Christians are like any Catholic Christian, but (usually, not always) with legitimately different interpretations of the Christian traditions and mysteries.

Jabulani!
Hello. I can empathize with your anger and frustration when hitting that brick wall which is The One True Church. You do realize the Church has never condemned one person to the flames of hell, don’t you? And neither do I. What it does do is stick to its principles, truth and teachings in the matters of Faith and Morals. The basic Doctrines and Dogmas of the Church have never changed. They can never be CONTRADICTED. Those who hold to these Doctrines and Dogmas are full members of the Catholic Church. Those members of other Protestant denominations who have been Baptized are also at least partial members of the true Faith. (See Pope John Paul II’s document on Ecumenism Et Unum Sint.) I, for one, cannot deny the Catholic Church holds as repository the whole true Faith. It has not changed since its inception by Christ. You say it has. I am not challenging you, but am asking for references, ie. which Dogmas, Doctrines do you think have changed? I think you will find none have.

I would love to see all faiths, all people united as one. That was Christ’s hope. And ALL are God’s children. That is why I think God has found a way for ALL of us, Catholic, or not, who want to follow Him in love to be with Him always, even if we don’t yet know of it. 🙂

And you are in my prayers today, here in the U.S.:gopray2:
 
I am very reluctant to answer this query. No one else on this thread, or anywhere on the Forum as far as I know, is asked to present their credentials. *Why me? That is a real question - why me? What is it that has provoked you to ask these questions, and make these statements? *Perhaps it is because you cannot tolerate facts that interfere or challenge your opinions, wishes, preferences and personal observations. Perhaps we all speak too often in generalisations.
You claimed to be a professional historian in this thread, and a researcher in another. You did so to lend authority to what you were saying. Since anyone can claim anything within the anonymity of an Internet forum, it is good form to back up any claims with reasonable evidence, while preserving anonymity if you prefer. to do so.

Your insinuations are silly, paranoid, and irrelevant. I asked because you asserted authority without presenting your bona fides.
(1) go Google ‘Carol Coombe’
(2) I will send you my cv and publications if you wish
I appreciate the offer, but unnecessary for this purpose.

You have claimed separately to be an historian, a researcher, and your profile says you’re an educator. Perhaps these three instersect if you are a history instructor or a history professor or even a graduate student. Of course, a history professor who has made it their life’s calling to study the Reformation or Christian theology would command a great deal of respect and consequently their opinions a great deal of weight in this subject. A college student working toward a degree in the humanities would carry much less respect in this regard, as their expertise level is far lower. If you’re going to assert authority, you should provide enough insight as to the authority you have that your interlocutors may weigh it appropriately.

As I’ve mentioned, I have a degree in military history from a service academy. Unfortunately, questions of military art rarely come up here, so even my limited expertise in that field hardly puts the oomph in my opinions of it. I work professionally in the quality engineering field; likewise, process engineering and statistics only rarely arise here.

The only way my scribblings here have any weight at all, then, is when they are backed up from Scripture, Magisterium, and Tradition and argued logically. I cannot buttress theological arguments with authority and expertise I cannot claim. But I can get my facts straight, and argue from them—which is what I always try to do.
(3) I have spent the last four years studying Catholic theology, liturgy, doctrine, dogma, history - you name it - full time.
(4) I have had guidance from four senior mentors: a Bishop, a Msgr (Canon Law), a spiritual counsellor, and an internationally known Jesuit who has also been a professional colleague (do you want their bona fides? Someone suggested previously that they were probably all heretics and should be reported to the Vatican. Two are Irish, and two are Belgian.)
When you say in 3 above that you have been studying Catholic theology, liturgy, doctrine, dogma, history etc full time, in what capacity was this? Again, you don’t need to release specific details, but anyone can see that 4 years of such study doesn’t necessarily speak of significant experience in any of these fields, much less all of them. If asserting authority to lend credence to one’s arguments, one should clearly highlight the boundaries of one’s experience and knowledge. This is so that people are not led astray in presuming that your opinions somehow represent a specific community of expertise.

For example, Richard Dawkins, a biologist of some accomplishment, runs around beating the drum for atheism. Are we to believe that his doctorate in biology lends him special expertise as a theologian? Of course not! And still he asserts his credentials at every opportunity, as people in general respect a PhD.
(5) I am to be confirmed tomorrow morning, received into the Catholic Church in Pretoria. Say a prayer for me.
Congratulations! I will say a prayer for you.
PS Why did you assume I am a female?
Previous threads (if I recall correctly) responded to you in the female form; I presumed they were accurate as I don’t recall a correction. If you are a male, I apologize for my error.
Jabulani!
(which means rejoice and be exceeding glad, in Xhosa - Mandela’s language)
Jabulani right back at you.
 
Just a couple of points here.

CC is not the Vatican+orders+community of saints etc. It is the living presence of Jesus Christ.
It is both. To the extent that the fallible members are in unit with the divine elements of the Church, they are also infallible. We can see some examples of this in Scripture, where individuals and councils were in perfect unity with the Head, who is Jesus, an the Soul of the Church (the Holy Spirit). It is the divine elements of the Church that make her infallible.
I have suggested earlier that there have been so-called ‘heresies’ (viz Martin Luther’s) and consider that these have influenced faith and morals and continue to do so today. Further, I am convinced absolutely that the changes in the CC paradigm of morality and faith initiated by Vatican II were profound. That is not to say that CC is not the mother church, or that it has been delinquent in keeping the flame of true faith burning over two millennia.
You mention Luther, then Vat. II. Did you mean Trent? Heresy and schisms have always been the impetus for the Church to rally and defend the Apostolic Teaching. I agree that the “new” gospel promulgated by the Reformers created the need for the doctrines clarified at Trent. Immorality and scandal was rampant across Europe through the Middle Ages as well, and much reform was needed. Men are always in need of reform. The pure bride of Christ, however, has been perfected by Christ, and there can be no better reform. 👍
My understanding is that there was not a doctrine on abortion until quite recently. From the Catholic Encyclopedia we read:

Debates with regard to abortion continue from the point at which CC began to address the issue. We see adjustments being considered - particularly when we confront the global HIV and AIDS pandemic (see Fr Michael J Kelly SJ The Catholic Church and HIV (go Google). Crises come and go, contexts change, and that means there are inevitably adjustments to our perceptions of faith and morality. (I know - you are red with rage at this point.)
I can see how you might come to this understanding. It is true that debates about abortion did not become fueled until the 20th century, When artificial birth control became a way of life.

However, the doctrine on abortion was inherited by the Church from our Jewish heritage, from whence we are taught that a human being is formed at the moment of conception, and that killing a baby in the mother’s womb is murder. This doctrine has been taught and believed in the Church from the beginning. Some background can be found here.

The Didache is written around the year 100 AD, and is considered accurately reflective of Apostolic Teaching.
Chapter 2. The Second Commandment: Grave Sin Forbidden. And the second commandment of the Teaching; You shall not commit murder, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not commit pederasty, you shall not commit fornication, you shall not steal, you shall not practice magic, you shall not practice witchcraft, you shall not murder a child by abortion nor kill that which is born.
The Catholic Church and HIV (go Google). Crises come and go, contexts change, and that means there are inevitably adjustments to our perceptions of faith and morality. (I know - you are red with rage at this point.)
Not at all! 😉 I love your propensity to fan the flame of controversy. But in this case, I am in complete agreement with you. It is our perceptions of faith and morality that change, not the Teachings. The Apostles could not imagine the issues we deal with, like pandemic illnesses, the culture of death, internet and porn, etc. etc. However, the principles are the same, though they must be applied to each new generation. This is the job of the magesterium.
 
I am very reluctant to answer this query. No one else on this thread, or anywhere on the Forum as far as I know, is asked to present their credentials. *Why me? That is a real question - why me? What is it that has provoked you to ask these questions, and make these statements? *Perhaps it is because you cannot tolerate facts that interfere or challenge your opinions, wishes, preferences and personal observations. Perhaps we all speak too often in generalisations.
No, this is standard and in compliance with the forum rules. If a person claims to have a specialty or credentials, they must be able to back up their claims, or are not to make them here. This question was put to you because you made the claim to have expertise. 🙂
(5) I am to be confirmed tomorrow morning, received into the Catholic Church in Pretoria. Say a prayer for me.

PS Why did you assume I am a female?

Jabulani!
(which means rejoice and be exceeding glad, in Xhosa - Mandela’s language)
You are always in my prayers. :highprayer:
 
Since anyone can claim anything within the anonymity of an Internet forum, it is good form to back up any claims with reasonable evidence, while preserving anonymity if you prefer. to do so. Your insinuations are silly, paranoid, and irrelevant. I asked because you asserted authority without presenting your bona fides.
Thank you for your observations. I wrote with respect and honesty about matters which I think important for consideration.
 
I have a big question here, and perhaps it should be the subject of a different thread, although it is pertinent to this one. I’ll be as brief as I can, although I am pretty angry and sad.

(1) Every human being is a child of God, endowed with divine spark/soul.

(2) Many humans have faith in Jesus of Nazareth, the Christ, Son of God and Man, Redeemer.

(3) Those who hold such faith are generally called ‘Christians’.
They may be called that, or call themselves that, but the Catholic Church does not consider anyone a member of the Body until they have been validly baptized.
HOWEVER

(4) If members of the Catholic Church insist that we are ‘the one and only true church of Christ’ where does this leave other Christians? If they are not members of the ‘one true church’, what are they?
  • God’s bastards?
  • moral non-Christians?
  • non-moral Christians?
  • stupid idiots?
  • unrepentant ‘Christian’ sinners headed straight for hell?
  • blind followers of Satan?
  • wayward Christians?
  • confused would-be’s/should-be’s?
  • arrogant protesters on an unnecessary and ill-advised detour?
Your answer can be found in the catechism, and I think you will find that none of these negative terms and perceptions are applied.

817 In fact, "in this one and only Church of God from its very beginnings there arose certain rifts, which the Apostle strongly censures as damnable. But in subsequent centuries much more serious dissensions appeared and large communities became separated from full communion with the Catholic Church - for which, often enough, men of both sides were to blame."269 The ruptures that wound the unity of Christ’s Body - here we must distinguish heresy, apostasy, and schism270 - do not occur without human sin:

Where there are sins, there are also divisions, schisms, heresies, and disputes. Where there is virtue, however, there also are harmony and unity, from which arise the one heart and one soul of all believers.271

818 "However, one cannot charge with the sin of the separation those who at present are born into these communities [that resulted from such separation] and in them are brought up in the faith of Christ, and the Catholic Church accepts them with respect and affection as brothers . . . . All who have been justified by faith in Baptism are incorporated into Christ; they therefore have a right to be called Christians, and with good reason are accepted as brothers in the Lord by the children of the Catholic Church."272

819 "Furthermore, many elements of sanctification and of truth"273 are found outside the visible confines of the Catholic Church: "the written Word of God; the life of grace; faith, hope, and charity, with the other interior gifts of the Holy Spirit, as well as visible elements."274 Christ’s Spirit uses these Churches and ecclesial communities as means of salvation, whose power derives from the fullness of grace and truth that Christ has entrusted to the Catholic Church. All these blessings come from Christ and lead to him,275 and are in themselves calls to "Catholic unity."276

Are your terms and characterizations a deliberate attempt to be inflammatory? Do they represent your perception of how Catholics see our separated brethren?
What are we trying to say to Protestants when we persist in saying that our church is ‘true’ and thereby implying their’s is anything but?

For me, having been raised in a Protestant family in Canada, Protestant Christians are like any Catholic Christian, but (usually, not always) with legitimately different interpretations of the Christian traditions and mysteries.

Jabulani!
As you can see from the above sections of the catechism, the Church recognizes the Truth of Christ and the work of the HS in these communities. It is far from your accusation “implying their’s is anything but” true.

I am not sure what you mean by “legitimate interpretations”. Certainly any number of people can come up the the same number of different perceptions of the Truth. This goes back to your earlier suggestion that Truth is relative, which it is not. There is only one Truth, and He has revealed HImself to mankind in a particular manner, through a particular people, with particular conditions. If we want to be united with that Truth, then we must do so in the manner in which He desires, and not we ourselves “interpret”.
 
Thank you for your observations. I wrote with respect and honesty about matters which I think important for consideration.
Perhaps if you referenced your quote above which I specifically referenced, you would see my point:
I am very reluctant to answer this query. No one else on this thread, or anywhere on the Forum as far as I know, is asked to present their credentials. ***Why me? That is a real question - why me? What is it that has provoked you to ask these questions, and make these statements? ***Perhaps it is because you cannot tolerate facts that interfere or challenge your opinions, wishes, preferences and personal observations. Perhaps we all speak too often in generalisations.
This is what I meant by silly, paranoid, and irrelevant.
 
Are your terms and characterizations a deliberate attempt to be inflammatory? Do they represent your perception of how Catholics see our separated brethren?

As you can see from the above sections of the catechism, the Church recognizes the Truth of Christ and the work of the HS in these communities. It is far from your accusation “implying their’s is anything but” true.

I am not sure what you mean by “legitimate interpretations”. Certainly any number of people can come up the the same number of different perceptions of the Truth. This goes back to your earlier suggestion that Truth is relative, which it is not. There is only one Truth, and He has revealed HImself to mankind in a particular manner, through a particular people, with particular conditions. If we want to be united with that Truth, then we must do so in the manner in which He desires, and not we ourselves “interpret”.
I do not intend to be inflammatory: far from it. However, I think that the constant emphasis on the ‘one true church’ with its implications for other Christian denominations/churches/sects/ cults/communities/groups - whatever you want to call them - does tend to promote unnecessary divisiveness within Christendom. And I wonder if CC is following this line of ‘only true faith’ as firmly as some suggest, at least as far as mainstream denominations are concerned.

Try something. Close your eyes. Imagine a lake, any lake, anywhere in the world, any time of the day or night. I shall do the same.

Now tell me what your lake is like - its size, the colour of its water, whether it is calm or is rushing with ‘white horses’ on a windy day, what surrounds your lake (in my case, pines, cedars and rocks of the Cambrian Shield in northern Ontario), whether you see it at sunrise or sunset.

No one person’s image of ‘their’ lake is like that of any other’s. Doctrine and dogma may be fixed, but personal interpretation is not.

I am grateful for your many helpful lessons, which I shall absorb in time, but not before my confirmation tomorrow! This is a long journey into a new spiritual paradigm - give me a few decades.
 
Perhaps you do not share it yet? 😉 Those who do not accept the infallibility of the Church are not united to the Catholic doctrine. Even if such persons call themselves Catholic, they are lacking in catholicity.

God allows factions in order to bring to light those who are “true”

" Indeed, there have to be factions among you, for only so will it become clear who among you are genuine." 1 Cor 11:18-19

Where there have been attempts to change doctrine, and disingenuine “popes”, it has brought to light where the genuine may be found.

Such variations are termed “heresies” and Paul does not speak in a complementary manner about them.

Gal 5:11-12
" I wish those who unsettle you would castrate themselves!"

Subsequently various so-called ‘heresies’ evolved within the CC, which were generally put down. Some still survive within the Catholic community. This was before the Reformation.

Perhaps. The manner in which they did so, however, has been a great wound to the Body.

It seems like what you are saying is that all the branches that come from the root are valid, even if they are separated from Catholicism.

Such a formulation leads the reader to believe that there is not an accurate perception of the Church. The Church cannot err because her Head is Christ, and she is ensouled by the Holy Spirit. It is the immuntable elements of the Body that make her infallible. To say that the Holy and pure bride of Christ is part and parcel with “suckers and parasites” is insulting to the One who has joined HImself to her. Such language should be reserved only to the fallible persons who have acted in crookenness and corruption, and not equated with the Bride herself.

" …Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her, 26 in order to make her holy by cleansing her with the washing of water by the word, 27 so as to present the church to himself in splendor, without a spot or wrinkle or anything of the kind — yes, so that she may be holy and without blemish." Eph 5:25-27

Jesus has cleansed the Church, made her to be without spot or wrinke, or anything of the kind. She is holy and without blemish. A distinction about the Holy Bride must be made, because when corrupt men behave crookedly, they separate themselves by their actions from the grace that joins them to the Church. Although they may appear to outsiders to be members of her, spiritually they are cut off. We know them by their fruits.

Here is a good link to read some material on “the branch theory”.

I agree that denigration is not fruitful, however, it was not the Refromers that “set the CC back on track”. The CC never left the track. Further, it is not “men” who have any power to guide the Church, but only her Head, which is Christ. I agree that men are constantly in need of reform, and the HS worked through these events to make it clear how sinners are separated from the pure bride.

This is a good point. The word “catholic” comes from the Greek. It is translated "universal’. In the NT, we see this word translated “throughout the whole”

" I want you to know, beloved, that what has happened to me has actually helped to spread the gospel, 13 so that it has become known throughout the whole" Phil 1:12-13

kath holos = throughout the whole

Col 1:6
Just as it is bearing fruit and growing in the whole world,

kathos = whole

The church has been called this since the NT was penned.
Lisdogan;3859749:
This statement is often made, but without proof. If you said that Christendom, in its own wobbly way, has sustained the profound and divine truth of Christ throughout the ages, I would agree that is true, because we are still here 2000 years later. But that is Christendom
, not *we - the only church. *

I suppose you are right, it is an article of faith, and thus does not commend itself to “proof”.

“… making every effort to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. 4 There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope of your calling, 5 one Lord, one faith, one baptism, 6 one God and Father of all, who is above all and through all and in all.” Eph 4:3-6

Unity is found when all are in truth. I know that you have some different thoughts about truth. But for Catholics, Jesus is the Truth, and He is absolute. To the extent that any and all of us are not united to Him, we have fallen from unity and truth.

He only has One Body, which is the Church. Therefore, all who are connected the Head are members of that One Body.

I agree with you about God working through people to bring all of us to holiness, wherever we are. However, the Catholic Church is not a “denomination”. This word comes from the Latin “to designate”. All Protestant communities have designated themselves based upon how they differ from Catholicism. It is the one uniting factor in all non-Catholic communities.

WOW, THANKS…I JUST LEARNED ALOT ABOUT CATHOLIC HISTORY FROM YOUR DISCUSSION! IT HELPS MY CATHOLIC FAITH TO BE MORE SECURE…THANKS AGAIN
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top