Speaking in Tongues

  • Thread starter Thread starter Holly3278
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Isn’t the biggest arguement about speaking in tongues- about HOW it is used? The gift exists. I think it is MISUSED frequently. Bringing attention to themselves is not the intention. I found it myself (speaking in tongues). I attended a Pentecostal Church with a school friend when I was 14 years old. (1979) I was overwhelmed with emotion. I wanted to say Thank you Lord!!! Words couldn’t come out right. I ended up mumbling some sentence and then covering my mouth, embaressed. Didn’t know what had happened. Years later, a sister (nun) prayer over me and my ulcer was healed. (She spoke in tongues. That was the first time I figured out what had happened).

I felt like I had “lost it.” Didn’t know what I had done to bring it on. I forgot about it for years. Recently(2006), I was hospitalized for a serious illness. I was unable to eat. Unable to communicate. However, I could read. I read and prayed. ended up fasting-by accident because I COULDN’T eat. Eventually, I was trying to speak to a nervous woman in the same hospital. I tried to comfort her and let her know God is good. Out comes the “babbling” again. She said I was speaking in tongues.

For some odd reason that I still don’t understand fully, THAT- speaking in tongues- brought her so much comfort. The same thing happened with a man coming to church for a healing service.

I met him outside. Went to hug him(after small talk and finding out his story), I was whispering, but speaking in tongues- he was touched. Started weeping. (was later able to read again after having it be impossible for two years!). I can’t explain what God wants of it.

I just know what I have seen. My mind is on God. My prayers are full and satisfying when I pray in tongues. I don’t shout it at church, or anywhere. (I have prayed out loud with SOME members of my family. Not many) .

Everyone has different reactions to it. It scares some. It’s mostly my private prayer. I will share but in the right ways.
rainy,
Speaking in tongues can be a divisive issue.
When a person receives this gift from ‘God’ it is the most surprising, exciting, emotional experience a person can have. You will cry or stop momentarily to see if it’s really happening.
Then go home and still wonder what has occured. All aglow with the wonder of it.
When my daughter received this gift she could not speak English for an hour or so. When she wanted to talk it would come out in her heavenly language. Some people call this gift gibberish. Lets keep in mind this is one of the gifts of the Holy Spirit. See
1Cor.12:10-11 and verse 30
Pray and ask the Lord to bless you with His gifts. 🙂

jean8
 
I find it hard to believe that a gift of the Spirit no longer exists. Where does Paul say this?
coco,
many folks will say this this because they really don’t know enough about this gift. You can read 1Cor.14 Even Paul spoke in tongues See verse 18,
The Jews were the first to receive this gift in the early Church, See Acts 2 1-13. Acts 10 44 This is when God gave the gift of tongues to the Gentiles to prove to the Jews they were to be included into the church
In 1901 Agnes Ozman spoke in tongues and started a new way to worship the Lord. look her up on the net. 🙂

God bless,
jean8
btw I have received this gift also. In 1982. Praise the Lord. I haven’t been the same since. 🙂 I say this with a humble heart. I want you to know it’s real and it’s from the Lord.

jean8
 
i read an article from a catholic apologist in which it explain that this gift no longer exists. for Paul himself said that this gift would cease. St Augustine has said that this gift no longer existed confirmed by Aguinas. the article also says that this type of language can also be used as a judgement upon those who desobeye God’s Statutes. tks God bless.
If this were the case, then I am sure the Church would not be supporting the use of it.

nsc-chariscenter.org/
 
I have been around charismatics who speak in tongues all the time. When they do this, they are in a state of religious ecstasy in which they are trance-like. So, they fall into a trance and speak in tongues at the same time.

I was around them so much as a young child that I began to wonder why I never spoke in tongues. I used to pray to God that I might speak in tongues, just so I could keep up.

A tradition exists wherein “speaking in tongues” means speaking so that everybody can understand you, not babbling on incoherently in ecstasy. I’ve never seen an example of that kind of “speaking in tongues”, only the incomprehensible kind.

In my experience, speaking in tongues either happens everywhere or not at all. It is a group participation dynamic; a manifestation of crowd psychology.

Those charismatics I knew who did speak in tongues come out of it acting like, and often being, your ordinary neighbor. I have been taught from the perspective that speaking in tongues is an everyday experience, like your morning coffee. That everybody does it (and everybody seems to).

Of course, in the larger world speaking in tongues is such a strange and remote happening that it is scandalous to mention.

I’ll be like Paul – I’ll hold out that speaking in tongues might be authentic, but it sure is strange. I’d wager, like Paul, that it would continue to be considered a strange thing and probably increasingly so.
 
I have been around charismatics who speak in tongues all the time.
This does not really seem appropriate.
When they do this, they are in a state of religious ecstasy in which they are trance-like. So, they fall into a trance and speak in tongues at the same time.
While I think that both are possible, I think that they don’t have to go together. The fact that they do for these people “always” seems very odd to me.
I was around them so much as a young child that I began to wonder why I never spoke in tongues. I used to pray to God that I might speak in tongues, just so I could keep up.
I think this is all too common. I think in most Pentecostal communities it is an expectation, and people are made to feel left out or resisting the Spirit if they do not manifest this gift. I also think it is off the mark to seek the gift, rather than the Giver, as often happens. There is so much overemphasis on the gift that the Giver gets lost in the sauce! The purpose of the gift is to draw us closer to Him, not to show off, or prove something or to fit in with everybody, or as you say “keep up” with the Jones’s so to speak.
A tradition exists wherein “speaking in tongues” means speaking so that everybody can understand you,
This is one of the manifestations of the gift. There are many.
not babbling on incoherently in ecstasy. I’ve never seen an example of that kind of “speaking in tongues”, only the incomprehensible kind.
It may sound incoherent to people, but that does not mean it is just “babble”.
In my experience, speaking in tongues either happens everywhere or not at all. It is a group participation dynamic; a manifestation of crowd psychology.
This is tragic.
Those charismatics I knew who did speak in tongues come out of it acting like, and often being, your ordinary neighbor. I have been taught from the perspective that speaking in tongues is an everyday experience, like your morning coffee. That everybody does it (and everybody seems to).

Of course, in the larger world speaking in tongues is such a strange and remote happening that it is scandalous to mention.

I’ll be like Paul – I’ll hold out that speaking in tongues might be authentic, but it sure is strange. I’d wager, like Paul, that it would continue to be considered a strange thing and probably increasingly so.
yes. I do beleive that it is to be part of daily experience, but it is “strange” (other worldly) and is meant to be a sign to unbelievers.

There is a big difference between prayer and “speaking” though which is to be used in public meetings. The private prayer language is just that - private.
 
While I know very little about the Charismatic movement, one thing is very apparent here. The evil one is working full force in all of us. We are all Catholics and should all be united under our Lord Jesus Christ. From what I understand the Charismatic movement has been approved by the Holy See. Since it has if you are a true Roman Catholic you shouldn’t be debating it’s validity. You can all carry on trying to interperet passages in the Bible either supporting or dicsounting speaking in tongues but Jesus’ main teachings were love for one another. “What ever you do unto them you do unto me”. We just finished off the week for Christian Unity folks, maybe we should try accepting people in our own religion first.

Just a thought.

Robin
 
While I know very little about the Charismatic movement, one thing is very apparent here. The evil one is working full force in all of us. We are all Catholics and should all be united under our Lord Jesus Christ. From what I understand the Charismatic movement has been approved by the Holy See. Since it has if you are a true Roman Catholic you shouldn’t be debating it’s validity. You can all carry on trying to interperet passages in the Bible either supporting or dicsounting speaking in tongues but Jesus’ main teachings were love for one another. “What ever you do unto them you do unto me”. We just finished off the week for Christian Unity folks, maybe we should try accepting people in our own religion first.

Just a thought.

Robin
Thanks Robin. You said it better than I. 👍
 
While I know very little about the Charismatic movement, one thing is very apparent here. The evil one is working full force in all of us. We are all Catholics and should all be united under our Lord Jesus Christ. From what I understand the Charismatic movement has been approved by the Holy See. Since it has if you are a true Roman Catholic you shouldn’t be debating it’s validity. You can all carry on trying to interperet passages in the Bible either supporting or dicsounting speaking in tongues but Jesus’ main teachings were love for one another. “What ever you do unto them you do unto me”. We just finished off the week for Christian Unity folks, maybe we should try accepting people in our own religion first.

Just a thought.

Robin
Someplace I read that this “Speaking in Tongues” was demonic, or that it was un-Christian, etc.

And in another place, (Wish I could remember where-I WILL quote it when I find the source) It says that It makes sense that a great gift would be fought over. And wouldn’t satan try to forge/fake the gift? Satan cannot create anything only kill,steal and destroy so why wouldn’t he use this gift to cause the children to fight and destroy their unity?
 
i read an article from a catholic apologist in which it explain that this gift no longer exists. for Paul himself said that this gift would cease. St Augustine has said that this gift no longer existed confirmed by Aguinas. the article also says that this type of language can also be used as a judgement upon those who desobeye God’s Statutes. tks God bless.
I would like to look up this quote or text as well. Any ideas where to start?
 
I found this… web site at bottom of quote…

…"By St. Augustine’s time the gifts of tongues were thought to only have occurred in the times of the apostles. The gift had served to help then evangelize the early church. Augustine also thought miracles only occurred during the time of the apostles until he witnessed the sight restored to a blind man near the bones of martyrs in Milan. It seems that Augustine held a similar opinion as Origen concerning the gift of tongues, it had been given to bridge foreign languages, but in his time Christianity was widely accepted and there was a common language throughout the Roman Empire.

However, in his City of God Augustine relates how his attitude changed when he witnessed two children cured of a physical disorder caused by trembling and convulsions. The cures took place on sequential days at the shrine of the martyr St. Stephen at Easter time. They were inspired by a dream to come to pray. On Easter the boy was instantly cure, and the next day the girl was cured. On both occasions the people in the entire church burst forth with prayers of thankfulness, praise, and rejoicing to God. All went forth to God. Augustine wrote “The people shouted God’s praises without words, but with such a noise that our ears could scarcely stand it. What was there in the hearts of all, this clamoring crowd but the faith of Christ, for which St. Stephen shed his blood?”’
www.themystica.com/mystica/articles/c/charismatics
 
From New Advent. The Catholic Encyclopedia Online:

In post-Biblical times St. Irenæus tells us that “many” of his contemporaries were heard “speaking through the Spirit in all kinds (pantodapais) of tongues” (“Contra haer.”, V, vii; Eusebius, Church History V.7). St. Francis Xavier is said to have preached in tongues unknown to him and St. Vincent Ferrer while using his native tongue was understood in others. From this last phenomenon Biblical glossolaly differs in being what St. Gregory Nazianzen points out as a marvel of speaking and not of hearing. Exegetes observe too that it was never used for preaching, although Sts. Augustine and Thomas seem to have overlooked this detail.
 
From New Advent. The Catholic Encyclopedia Online:

In post-Biblical times St. Irenæus tells us that “many” of his contemporaries were heard “speaking through the Spirit in all kinds (pantodapais) of tongues” (“Contra haer.”, V, vii; Eusebius, Church History V.7). St. Francis Xavier is said to have preached in tongues unknown to him and St. Vincent Ferrer while using his native tongue was understood in others. From this last phenomenon Biblical glossolaly differs in being what St. Gregory Nazianzen points out as a marvel of speaking and not of hearing. Exegetes observe too that it was never used for preaching, although Sts. Augustine and Thomas seem to have overlooked this detail.
I am not sure what you are trying to say. Do you mean that the phenomenon that occurred on Pentecost was not the gift of tongues?
 
I was just posting extra-biblical sources from the early church fathers on speaking in tongues from a Catholic source, the New Advent Encyclopedia.

I know that some people were looking for early church sources of speaking in tongues outside of the New Testament.
 
I was just posting extra-biblical sources from the early church fathers on speaking in tongues from a Catholic source, the New Advent Encyclopedia.

I know that some people were looking for early church sources of speaking in tongues outside of the New Testament.
Yes, thank you very much. 👍

Welcome to CAF also. :hug1:
 
The following short video may be helpful in understanding why tongues, prophecy and knowledge have ceased.

Speaking In Tongues Part A

God bless,
Mick
there are some accurate statements in this video, but the timeline is wrong. The gifts of the HS were given for the building up of the Body of Christ, therefore, will be needed until He calls His Bride home to Himself.

The other gross error is the assertion that the Gifts of the HS are “childish”. Tongues, knowledge, and prophesy are not “childish”. If they were, Paul would not so stronly urge the believers to earnestly desire prophesy especially.

Faith, Hope, and Love do remain, and indeed there will be no need for faith and hope when we are joined eternally to Him. However, as long as we sojourn here in the vale of tears, we need all of His gifts and grace to get there.

I understand why some people are afraid of the charismatic gifts. The exercise of them requires that one yield one’s will and feeling of being in control, which is difficult. It is an exercise of trust in God, to build up our faith in Him.
 
The verse that is used to support this is Paul, when he says “tongues shall cease”. The thinking is that they did so shortly after the Apostolic age because they were no longer needed.
So … was the thinking [by whom ?] right or wrong ? What does the Church say today ?
 
So … was the thinking [by whom ?] right or wrong ? What does the Church say today ?
There are so many errors in that presentation, it is hard to know where to begin!

The Church teaches that the gifts of the Spirit are for the building up of the Body of Christ, and therefore, will be needed so long as His Bride sojourns here on earth.

That entire presentation is based upon the fundamental heresy of Sola Scriptura.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top