SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you’re thinking that I might be drawn into wanting to join the Catholic Church, **NO. That won’t happen. ** I’m probably here because I feel concern for Catholics but I don’t want to get into a big debate on that, ok?
It’s not healthy to have your heart so strongly set against the will of God. We feel concern for you, so I hope you do stick around.
 
This may help give you at least some idea:

gotquestions.org/interpretations-Christian.html
FWIW, I actually printed out the article you provided so that I can study it more carefully…something I rarely do when people point me to anti-Catholic websites. However, my curiosity as to how anyone could possibly justify the dizzying contradictions among Protestants got the best of me. I can’t wait to read this article latter tonight.

However, the author of your linked article lost major credibility points by citing a “Recommended Resource” by noted anti-Catholic John MacArthur.

John MacArthur??? Maybe you didn’t know, but honestly…

:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:
 
Where does it say gates of hell not prevailing equals an infallilbe church?
If the Church were to teach an error that led people away from the Truth, would that not mean that Satan had prevailed against the Church - even if only in a very small way? How is this not clear?
Where does it say that church means some separate entity apart from Christians for that is what it seems you insinuate?
The Church is not a separate entity from Christians. However, not all Christians are in formal communion with the Church. Some are separated. (That’s you, btw.)
I can’t help but see you setting up what you deem to be the church as some kind of deity. No offense. Do you know that the church is people?
Right. I worship the Church.

:bowdown: :highprayer:

(I always wanted to use those emoticons.)
 
We understand that you cannot come to terms with a proper definition of “Church” because to do so would require you to recognize that you are on the outside looking in…at least, you are out of formal communion. I understand that would be a bitter pill to swallow at this point. It’s hard to hear, but this is your current situation. It’s probably not your fault…you were most likely born into Protestantism; therefore, your heresy is informal and not formal.
I, of course, disagree with you and find this to be rather arrogantly condescending but that’s okay. It’s what you truly believe. There’s no doubt in my own mind what the church is and there’s no doubt in my mind that I’m a part of it. I’m not on the “outside looking in.” But, you may have been raised up being taught this and this is what you believe. I can’t change it. I’m just happy I have the freedom to believe as the Lord and His word lead me to believe.
 
FWIW, I actually printed out the article you provided so that I can study it more carefully…something I rarely do when people point me to anti-Catholic websites. However, my curiosity as to how anyone could possibly justify the dizzying contradictions among Protestants got the best of me. I can’t wait to read this article latter tonight.

However, the author of your linked article lost major credibility points by citing a “Recommended Resource” by noted anti-Catholic John MacArthur.

John MacArthur??? Maybe you didn’t know, but honestly…

:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:
Is everyone who disagrees with Catholicism automatically anti-Catholic?
 
Catholics do believe that we should confess our venial sins and can do so directly to God and God will forgive us.

We are all members of Christ’s body the church.

When we mortally sin we do harm to Christ’s body the church. By confessing through the priest to God we are seeking to undo the harm to the church.

Jesus not only gave the disciples the power to forgive sin but to RETAIN sin.

Jesus did not give that authority to other christians.

I can’t RETAIN anyone else’s sin.

A Catholic priest can RETAIN a person’s sin if they are not truely repentent or do not have a firm purpose of amendment to sin no more.

We cannot do that.

It does not diminish Christ in anyway for Him to work grace through the sacraments just as it did not diminish God in anyway in Old Testament times to work grace through the Levitical priests.

Directly confessing our venial sins directly to God each day and confessing our mortal sins to Him through priests makes perfect sense.

And yes it is only God who knows the human heart–that is not diminshed if He works His grace through a priest or gives a priest the authority to RETAIN another’s sin–being able to RETAIN someone’s sin is good for an individual who does not see the error of his ways and it is good for the church whom he has harmed.

The exact moment that a person is truely repentent is when grace starts.

But grace is not an instanteous one time only event.

Grace continues through confession to a priest and when the priest gives absolution for sin it is God’s absolution given through that priest just as it would be Christ’s absolution given through the disciples who He had given the power to forgive or retain the confession of sins.

And even Catholics believe that if a person mortally sins and is PERFECTLY CONTRITE for such sins that they are forgiven right then and there–if they died at that moment they would die in a state of grace.

God lets us share in Christ’s suffering on the cross and Christ let the disciples share in His authority to not only FORGIVE but to RETAIN sin.

Let me ask anyone out there opposed to confession to a priest this question:

Why did Jesus give the power to RETAIN sins to the disciples?

Did He give you that authority?

If not then why not?
:clapping:

Good to see you again, Jerry. Thanks for jumping in.

BTW, I’ve already asked these two about “binding” or “retaining” sins…don’t hold your breath waiting for a coherent response.
 
I, of course, disagree with you and find this to be rather arrogantly condescending but that’s okay. It’s what you truly believe. There’s no doubt in my own mind what the church is and there’s no doubt in my mind that I’m a part of it. I’m not on the “outside looking in.” But, you may have been raised up being taught this and this is what you believe. I can’t change it. I’m just happy I have the freedom to believe as the Lord and His word lead me to believe.
You call someone else “arrogantly condescending?” That is funny. 😃

A little humility on your part may be in order.
 
Is everyone who disagrees with Catholicism automatically anti-Catholic?
Nope.

Honest disagreements are understandable.

“Anti-Catholicism” requires real effort, and John MacArthur has paid his dues, so to speak.
 
Ginger Sorry for the assumption that the OP would read my post and respond. Thank you for taking the time to do so.

Ginger much love and respect to you from me. We are all on this Christian journey together. Have a very Merry Christmas.
I didn’t actually start this thread, the moderator split one I was on at my post. So I have been dialoging same as if I were on one started by someone else.

Merry Christmas to you, yoo.
 
I, of course, disagree with you and find this to be rather arrogantly condescending but that’s okay. It’s what you truly believe. There’s no doubt in my own mind what the church is and there’s no doubt in my mind that I’m a part of it. I’m not on the “outside looking in.” But, you may have been raised up being taught this and this is what you believe. I can’t change it. I’m just happy I have the freedom to believe as the Lord and His word lead me to believe.
Raised up being taught this?

Uh, no. I’m a convert…I used to be one of you.

See the little “Tiber Swim Team” thingie in my signature?

“Swimming the Tiber” is a euphemism for converting to the Catholic faith.

Hope this helps.:tiphat:
 
If the Church were to teach an error that led people away from the Truth, would that not mean that Satan had prevailed against the Church - even if only in a very small way? How is this not clear?
Sorry, I can’t see it that way. The gates of hell not prevailing against the church means Satan cannot totally destroy the church, not that the church has infallibilty. Any part of the church (the church being Christians) could fall into error. If that weren’t so, why all the warnings to Christians (the church) in Scripture about false christs and false teachings? Paul was even having to correct errors in some of his letters to the various churches.

Acts 20
29 For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock.
**30 Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them. **
31 Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears.
The Church is not a separate entity from Christians. However, not all Christians are in formal communion with the Church. Some are separated. (That’s you, btw.)
I agree to disagree. 🙂
Right. I worship the Church.

:bowdown: :highprayer:

(I always wanted to use those emoticons.)
I’m merely pointing out the impression that Catholics can give and the impression that I’ve gotten from listening to them over a period of several years since I’ve been online.

I’m happy you got to use your emoticons.
 
Raised up being taught this?

Uh, no. I’m a convert…I used to be one of you.

See the little “Tiber Swim Team” thingie in my signature?

“Swimming the Tiber” is a euphemism for converting to the Catholic faith.

Hope this helps.:tiphat:
Sure, I realize not all Catholics have been raised Catholic. I just don’t always pay close attention to folk’s sig lines. I learned about the “swim the Tiber” thing on another board so I know what it means.
 
I doubt this will satisfy you but there is only one infallible Being in the universe and that is God (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit). The Bible doesn’t tell me to let another human being infallibly interpret Scripture for me. It does tell me this:

John 1612 I have yet many things to say unto you, but ye cannot bear them now.
13 Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth, is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak: and he will shew you things to come.
14 He shall glorify me: for he shall receive of mine, and shall shew it unto you.

The CC has only, to my understanding, “infallibly” interpreted a few verses for Catholics. What do you do with the rest of the Bible? Just believe your catechism and forget it?
Nothing personal towards you, either. Catholics appear to make a lot of strong arguments for their case but, like you (if the reverse position) I’ve not been swayed from what I believe.
What do you do with the rest of the Bible? Just believe your catechism and forget it?
You are the one self appointing scriptural interpretation with no guidance. What do you do with the rest of the Bible; interpret what you personally believe to be truth and forget the rest. How convenient to not have any authority over your interpretations of scripture and then try to claim that the catechism is wrong. Just because you self appointedly answer to no authority you think I am wrong for respecting authority of the church. Did you miss the scripture which Jesus tells us to listen to and pray for our authority figures. Or is that the scripture you interpret in your own way too.
The CC has only, to my understanding, “infallibly” interpreted a few verses for Catholics. What do you do with the rest of the Bible? Just believe your catechism and forget it?
Where do you derive your understanding from? How do you develop your understanding?

I am using a structure which has been refined through many years and many scholars. You are on your own but ridicule with sarcasm as if you are some kind of authority. I mean no disrespect to you, nor any ill will but think about this from my perspective. You assume you interpret scripture correctly without any scrutiny from any authoritative source whatsoever. And then you turn around and pummel the catecism as if you actually have a clue as to what it says. Hello, this is self appointed and frankly I really don’t think you have researched any of what you are saying. Perhaps you should educate yourself before making such claims. If you have done the research and have an educated understanding of the catecism you will be able to answer the next question. In what way is the Catechism ignoring any part of the Bible?

Besides all that, you clearly ignored a good majority of my post. How about the fact that you didn’t address any of the below statement.
I say that confession directly to God (rather than a priest) is out of convenience and ease instead of true repentance and sorrow for offending God. How much more difficult to get up, get dressed, drive to the church and put yourself in a position where an authority figure can see you and hear you confess. This is much more than a silent prayer in your comfy home. This takes determination, true humility and strong conviction about getting forgiven. You are actually told by the priest what to do and that you are forgiven and must follow his instructions. This in itself is more convincing than the alternative, okay; I have prayed all is forgiven; now I just have to make restitution. It seems too easy and convenient to me. This is just my 2 cents.
Also see post number 134 and please think before you reject our position. Don’t just be a rebel, give a clear perspective of how the scriptures and your position relate to what I am saying. I am willing to listen and even contemplate the validity of your position but it has to be intelligent bantor and not just a pummel.
 
It’s not healthy to have your heart so strongly set against the will of God. We feel concern for you, so I hope you do stick around.
I have concern for you, too. I think it’s unhealthy for you to think everything is all about the RCC and what it says. No offense intended. My heart isn’t set against the will of God but you’re entitled to your belief.
 
Where does it say gates of hell not prevailing equals an infallilbe church?
If the Church teaches a lie, then the gates of Hell prevailed against it. The Church needs to be infallible in order to prevent this. Remember who is the father of lies.
 
Do you know that the church is people?
More accurately it is the Body of Christ made up of the Church Militant, Church Suffering and Church Triumphant at the same time being a visible, concrete, hierarchical structure on Earth.
 
I have concern for you, too. I think it’s unhealthy for you to think everything is all about the RCC and what it says. No offense intended. My heart isn’t set against the will of God but you’re entitled to your belief.
Since I was open to the will of God, He led me to the Church His Son established on earth. There is nothing unhealthy about following the true teaching of His Church. Certainly, the Protestant movement has not led to any unified understanding of God. When people rely on their own personal feelings about Scripture, they are naturally going to lead themselves in a variety of directions.
 
Sorry, I can’t see it that way.
I understand. That’s why I’m explaining it to you.
The gates of hell not prevailing against the church means Satan cannot totally destroy the church, not that the church has infallibilty. Any part of the church (the church being Christians) could fall into error. If that weren’t so, why all the warnings to Christians (the church) in Scripture about false christs and false teachings? Paul was even having to correct errors in some of his letters to the various churches.

Acts 20
29 For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock.
**30 Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them. **
31 Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears.
You’ve actually refuted your own position, but you don’t realize it. You wrote, “Any part of the church (the church being Christians) could fall into error.” You went on to speak of false teachers, etc.

Don’t you see it? These are individual teachers or even parts of the Church, but not the totality of the Church.

False teachers may indeed infiltrate the Church (though the pope Himself is protected by the charism of infallibility in very specific circumstances), and portions of Christendom HAVE fallen into error (ie, the Orthodox, all of Protestantism, etc.), but the Catholic Church remains standing and infallible in its teachings after 20 centuries.

However, the Church has NEVER formally taught error nor has she EVER be prevailed upon.

One question: how do you know with certainty that you are not a member of the portion that has been prevailed upon? 🤷
I agree to disagree.
Fine. But the bottom line is that you’re either in full communion with the one Church that Jesus established and which has been in continuous existence from that moment forward, or you’re not.
I’m merely pointing out the impression that Catholics can give and the impression that I’ve gotten from listening to them over a period of several years since I’ve been online.
Oh. So, you came to this discussion with some presuppositions. Fair enough. I have the same problem…talking with Protestants online has give ME the impression that you worship the Bible instead of the God of the Bible. 😃
I’m happy you got to use your emoticons.
👍
 
You need to discuss the scripture you are quoting. You can’t just spout scripture and then let me surmise what you are trying to say. Unless of course you really don’t have a valid point to make. Yes I follow the catechism and you are a self appointed scholar. I have to question why you think this makes your beliefs truth and mine not truth.

I didn’t say the Pope was infallible I said he is less infallible than you ar me or any laymen. I not trying to change your beliefs I am just pointing out the lack of logic to some of what you are claiming.

I don’t appreciate your sarcasm. The reponse below is just a pummel which lacks intelligent discussion. You can do better than that. In what way did I ignore the rest of the Bible

What do you do with the rest of the Bible? Just believe your catechism and forget it?

You are the one self appointing scriptural interpretation with no guidance. What do you do with the rest of the Bible; interpret what you personally believe to be truth and forget the rest. How convenient to not have any authority over your interpretations of scripture and then try to claim that the catechism is wrong. Just because you self appointedly answer to no authority you think I am wrong for respecting authority of the church. Did you miss the scripture which Jesus tells us to listen to and pray for our authority figures. Or is that the scripture you interpret in your own way too.

Where do you derive your understanding from? How do you develop your understanding?

I am using a structure which has been refined through many years and many scholars. You are on your own but ridicule with sarcasm as if you are some kind of authority. I mean no disrespect to you, nor any ill will but think about this from my perspective. You assume you interpret scripture correctly without any scrutiny from any authoritative source whatsoever. And then you turn around and pummel the catecism as if you actually have a clue as to what it says. Hello, this is self appointed and frankly I really don’t think you have researched any of what you are saying. Perhaps you should educate yourself before making such claims. If you have done the research and have an educated understanding of the catecism you will be able to answer the next question. In what way is the Catechism ignoring any part of the Bible?

Besides all that, you clearly ignored a good majority of my post. How about the fact that you didn’t address any of the below statement.

Also see post number 134 and please think before you reject our position. Don’t just be a rebel, give a clear perspective of how the scriptures and your position relate to what I am saying. I am willing to listen and even contemplate the validity of your position but it has to be intelligent bantor and not just a pummel.
What’s with the knee jerk anger response? I wasn’t trying to be sarcastic. I thought I was asking a legitimate question. You need to remember I’m not a Catholic and I don’t believe what you do concerning Catholicism, it’s claims, it’s teachings, and it’s papacy. But I’m not trying to be purposefully sarcastic. Yet you come back, like other Catholics have, acting very superior, arrogant, and condescending. I don’t like that but I realize I’m on a Catholic board and that’s the way it goes. But I don’t like being accusesd of sarcasm when that was not my intent. I admit I have used that as sarcasm before on other boards but I assure you it was not intended that way here.

p.s. what you see as authority figures and what I see are two different things. Also the apostle Paul said to follow him AS HE FOLLOWED CHRIST. What if he ceased to follow Christ? Or began to teach heresy. We don’t follow authority blindly. They’re subject to the same Scriptures we are. They depart from them and the authority departs. That’s my belief, you don’t have to agree.
 
None at the time that Jesus healed the man.
Then I think you have your answer to Mark 2:12

The Apostle’s were not performing miracles. No one really understood yet that Jesus was more then just a mere man.

“…they were filled with fear; and they praised God, who had given such authority to men.”

is not referring to the disciples being able to do what Jesus did, because they hadn’t been given power to heal yet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top