That was what I was trying to get at.
So,we agree that the inspired books were already recognized and simply not formally declared or challenged for several hundred years.
No, many of them were challenged immediately, and some of them remained under fierce dispute thru the centuries. There were also 400+ works floating about, claiming to be inspired, some of them being read as inspired in the Churches that did not make the canon.
The problem is with the claim that the Catholic church “gave us the Bible” or “decided its canon”. Just because there was some disagreement amongst some of the “parishes” at that time does not mean that there were not also many “parishes” in which the correct canon was understood.
Sorry watchful, but this just is not consistent with history. The canon was not agreed upon or accepted formally until done so at the council This council effectively stopped the arguements. This is the case because the council was considered to protected by the Spirit from error under the promise of Christ. After that council, beneficial readings that were not included in the canon were no longer read at Mass (until the litugical abuses in America emanating from the "spririt of vatican 2 when all sorts of trivia were substituted).
What I am saying is that just b/c the CC can claim it knew which books were inspired does not mean it was the only one that did or could.
Darlin’, there WAS nobody else!
What the CC basically claims when it says it decided the canon *for the world *is that all of Christianity at that time was in error about the canon and only the Catholic magisterium had the correct understanding of what the canon should be.
No, this is not true. The canon developed over time, and many of the books were recognized by the Catholic Church (the ONLY Church) as inspired and were used as such. It was the Church that made the final definitive doctrinal pronouncement, just as she always does, so that the hapless will not fall into error.
As if it was impossible for anyone else to have known which books were inspired.
The charism of infallibility was given to the Church founded by Christ, not to the individuals, as saintly as some of them may be.
If it was possible that the correct canon was recognized by others then a formal declaration on the part of the Catholic magisterium is merely a formal declaration that the CC agrees with a certain canon. This means that determining which books were inspired was not something only within the power of a Catholic magisterium.
I think you have some important facts to learn about your family history there, Watchful.
Recognitiion is great, but none but the magesterium had the authority to formally recognize. That is the way Jesus set it up, and that is how it works to this day.
Individuals who are fond of appointing themselves as their own authority notwithstanding.
If you can see that, then it isn’t fair to say that the CC gave us the canon.
It is not only fair, but historically accurate. You will learn this for yourself if you are willing to study.
Those who are not united to the magesterium are factious.
Titus 3:10-11
10 As for a man who is factious, after admonishing him once or twice, have nothing more to do with him, 11 knowing that such a person is perverted and sinful; he is self-condemned.