SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Also, the books of the NT were being circulated before the canonization so the church was never without Scripture.
Many, many, many books were being circulated and some of those books were the inspired ones. Of the many books that were being circulated, it was the Catholic Church that determined which ones were the inspired, inerrant Word of God. You wouldn’t have known which ones were inspired if it not for the Catholic Church guided by the Holy Spirit. The Church most definitely was without the Bible as we have it today for the first 400 years of Christianity!
 
Many, many, many books were being circulated and some of those books were the inspired ones. Of the many books that were being circulated, it was the Catholic Church that determined which ones were the inspired, inerrant Word of God. You wouldn’t have known which ones were inspired if it not for the Catholic Church guided by the Holy Spirit. The Church most definitely was without the Bible as we have it today for the first 400 years of Christianity!
If many uninspired books were being circulated, then doesn’t it stand to reason that the church was using some uninspired books before the canon was decided? So, for over 300 years the church didn’t know which books were inspired? So was it teaching error from the uninspired books? Was everything oral? If everything was oral, then why were books being circulated? If the truth was oral and there were books in circulation why did it take 300+ years to know which books were inspired?

I hope you realize the unlikelihood that the canon wasn’t decided for over 300 years and what that implies. I think it is more likely that the inspired books were already recognized and simply not formally declared or challenged for several hundred years.
 
Protestants do confess directly to God. But we also go to the person(s) we have wronged, apologize and do whatever we can to repair the damage and be reconciled to our brothers and sisters in Christ.

In all the years I was Catholic, I was never asked to do anything more than say x number of Hail Mary’s and y number of the Lord’s Prayer for penance.
Have you ever heard of using common sense and decency? How about God’s 2 great commandments?

To give a view from the other side of the bush, I had a friend who would not apologize to a person he wronged because he “knew that God had forgiven” him and he did not need to be reconciled to whoever might be offended.

But common sense tells me that’s not the way most Protestants perceive forgiveness.
 
If many uninspired books were being circulated, then doesn’t it stand to reason that the church was using some uninspired books before the canon was decided? So, for over 300 years the church didn’t know which books were inspired? So was it teaching error from the uninspired books? Was everything oral? If everything was oral, then why were books being circulated? If the truth was oral and there were books in circulation why did it take 300+ years to know which books were inspired?

I hope you realize the unlikelihood that the canon wasn’t decided for over 300 years and what that implies. I think it is more likely that the inspired books were already recognized and simply not formally declared or challenged for several hundred years.
Nope, precisely because of the confusion, of some Churches, i mean individual churches, having in circulation some books they thought were scripture,(list 'em…e.t.c.) That the Church decided to declare what was canon. So that there should be no confusion among individual churches.

So basically since you are not Catholic, you can decide that the Church’s determination of the Canon was a wrong one, and go ahead and create your own Canon. i.e. Add the Gospel of Peter, Infancy Gospel of Thomas, Acts of Peter…e.t.c. (or some other combination of texts that where floating around at the time) In addition, since what will entail the Canon is totally up to you, you can choose which ‘scriptures’ from the current Canon, is out of place, and you are free do delete those -(hey its been done before) - If not you will be acknoledging something that you are averse to do a this point.
 
If many uninspired books were being circulated, then doesn’t it stand to reason that the church was using some uninspired books before the canon was decided?
No, it stands to reason that when the Holy Spirit promised that the Church would be guided into all truth that the Church would not use non-inspired books as inspired.
So, for over 300 years the church didn’t know which books were inspired?
Again, no. The Church has the promise of the Holy Spirit to be guided into all truth. This is precisely why the Church **did **know which books were inspired.
So was it teaching error from the uninspired books?
Again, no. The Church has the promise of the Holy Spirit to be guided into all truth.
Was everything oral?
Do you know of a Bible as we have it today being used before 382AD?
If everything was oral, then why were books being circulated?
Because there were writings by the early Christians some of which were inspired by God.
If the truth was oral and there were books in circulation why did it take 300+ years to know which books were inspired?
Just because the Canon of Scripture wasn’t officially decided until some 300+ years after Christ doesn’t mean the Church didn’t know which books were inspired prior to that. Because of the confusion among Christians as to which books were inspired, the Church officially declared the Canon of Scripture in the year 382AD at the Council of Rome. Then the Council of Hippo in 387AD ratified the Council of Rome. Then the Council of Carthage ratified Hippo in the year 397AD.
I hope you realize the unlikelihood that the canon wasn’t decided for over 300 years and what that implies.
Facts is facts sir.
I think it is more likely that the inspired books were already recognized and simply not formally declared or challenged for several hundred years.
This is exactly what I’m saying. Where do we disagree?
 
Nope, precisely because of the confusion, of some Churches, i mean individual churches, having in circulation some books they thought were scripture,(list 'em…e.t.c.) That the Church decided to declare what was canon. So that there should be no confusion among individual churches.

So basically since you are not Catholic, you can decide that the Church’s determination of the Canon was a wrong one, and go ahead and create your own Canon. i.e. Add the Gospel of Peter, Infancy Gospel of Thomas, Acts of Peter…e.t.c. (or some other combination of texts that where floating around at the time) In addition, since what will entail the Canon is totally up to you, you can choose which ‘scriptures’ from the current Canon, is out of place, and you are free do delete those -(hey its been done before) - If not you will be acknoledging something that you are averse to do a this point.
Yes, using your understanding of canon compilation I can see where you’d derive that belief. Going back to your first paragraph, are you saying then that the magisterium had already known what scripture was inspired but it was some individual “parishes” that were confused?
 
This is exactly what I’m saying. Where do we disagree?
That was what I was trying to get at.

So,we agree that the inspired books were already recognized and simply not formally declared or challenged for several hundred years.

The problem is with the claim that the Catholic church “gave us the Bible” or “decided its canon”. Just because there was some disagreement amongst some of the “parishes” at that time does not mean that there were not also many “parishes” in which the correct canon was understood.

What I am saying is that just b/c the CC can claim it knew which books were inspired does not mean it was the only one that did or could. What the CC basically claims when it says it decided the canon *for the world *is that all of Christianity at that time was in error about the canon and only the Catholic magisterium had the correct understanding of what the canon should be. As if it was impossible for anyone else to have known which books were inspired.

If it was possible that the correct canon was recognized by others then a formal declaration on the part of the Catholic magisterium is merely a formal declaration that the CC agrees with a certain canon. This means that determining which books were inspired was not something only within the power of a Catholic magisterium. If you can see that, then it isn’t fair to say that the CC gave us the canon.
 
Let me use another example.

Lets say we all agree that the sky is blue. Some group comes along and claims it is yellow. The church steps in and makes a formal declaration that the sky is blue. Does this mean it took some infallible power only given to the CC to decide the sky was blue?

Now lets say some of us believe the earth is round and some believe it is flat. Lets say the church steps in and makes the formal declaration that the earth is flat. Many people will follow that belief now b/c it was “formally declared” by the CC. What happens to those who think it was round? They are declared heretics (those, at least, that the magisterium knows about and corrects) and excommunicated (or worse). Undoubtedly some people will quietly leave and believe the truth elsewhere. Some will remain in the CC out of fear. Those who are able to leave or who quietly remain are, in a sense, already establishing other churches, whether secretly on the outside or quietly on the inside they may have found communion with others who are like-minded. This is not so hard to believe. This can even be observed today in the CC - each parish has its own “flavor” if you will and yes there are dissenting priests out there celebrating under the Catholic “label”.

B/c the CC declares something does not mean it is necessarily true, nor does it mean that it is the only one capable of determining truth. I think those who seek with sincerity and humility can know the truth from Scripture without an infallible mediator (other than the HS Himself through the individual). Just like in my first example: there was no infallible mediator between Jesus and his disciples. Some “got” what He said and others did not. The problem lies within the individual.

So “here” we were discussing confession to a priest. A few have shown how Scripture seems to challenge the belief that confession to a priest is sacramental or at least more sacramental than confession to someone not a priest or confession directly to God (without a mediator/priest). The discussion has moved on to the authority of the church. Why? I think b/c many of you recognize that Scripture does not really support the teaching. You have picked out some Scriptures that vaguely and possibly suggest (with a lot of extra-biblical thought) that the Catholic position is correct, but you realize that what it really boils down to is authority (Catholic authority). I believe that Scripture, NT primarily, is overwhelming in agreement with the non-Catholic position. I think the Catholic arguments are good, but I don’t know how “orthodox” they are. I tend to believe the NT gives a clear picture of confession. I think it is clear to some Catholics too and that is why the conversation quickly gets turned into “well it may look that way in Scripture, but you can’t know you are right about your interpretation b/c you aren’t infallible and you wouldn’t even have known which Scriptures were inspired if not for the CC”.

Btw - I started a thread about infallibility that this would probably fit better into. Here is the link:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=296353
 
So, I don’t feel any need for a priest
Was it Bishop Sheen who said “you follow God in your way, and I will follow Him in His”?

Since when did we take our steps with God according to what we felt our own needs are? It is human, certainly, as obviously Adam and Eve “felt a need” to eat of the forbidden fruit.
 
The problem…
It’s probably more accurate to say *your *problem.
…is with the claim that the Catholic church “gave us the Bible” or “decided its canon”.
To say or claim otherwise is simply to ignore facts and history.
This means that determining which books were inspired was not something only within the power of a Catholic magisterium.
Who else had the power, authority and promise of the Holy Spirit to be guided into all truth other than the Church?
 
That was what I was trying to get at.

So,we agree that the inspired books were already recognized and simply not formally declared or challenged for several hundred years.
No, many of them were challenged immediately, and some of them remained under fierce dispute thru the centuries. There were also 400+ works floating about, claiming to be inspired, some of them being read as inspired in the Churches that did not make the canon.
The problem is with the claim that the Catholic church “gave us the Bible” or “decided its canon”. Just because there was some disagreement amongst some of the “parishes” at that time does not mean that there were not also many “parishes” in which the correct canon was understood.
Sorry watchful, but this just is not consistent with history. The canon was not agreed upon or accepted formally until done so at the council This council effectively stopped the arguements. This is the case because the council was considered to protected by the Spirit from error under the promise of Christ. After that council, beneficial readings that were not included in the canon were no longer read at Mass (until the litugical abuses in America emanating from the "spririt of vatican 2 when all sorts of trivia were substituted).
What I am saying is that just b/c the CC can claim it knew which books were inspired does not mean it was the only one that did or could.
Darlin’, there WAS nobody else!
What the CC basically claims when it says it decided the canon *for the world *is that all of Christianity at that time was in error about the canon and only the Catholic magisterium had the correct understanding of what the canon should be.
No, this is not true. The canon developed over time, and many of the books were recognized by the Catholic Church (the ONLY Church) as inspired and were used as such. It was the Church that made the final definitive doctrinal pronouncement, just as she always does, so that the hapless will not fall into error.
As if it was impossible for anyone else to have known which books were inspired.
The charism of infallibility was given to the Church founded by Christ, not to the individuals, as saintly as some of them may be.
If it was possible that the correct canon was recognized by others then a formal declaration on the part of the Catholic magisterium is merely a formal declaration that the CC agrees with a certain canon. This means that determining which books were inspired was not something only within the power of a Catholic magisterium.
I think you have some important facts to learn about your family history there, Watchful. 😃

Recognitiion is great, but none but the magesterium had the authority to formally recognize. That is the way Jesus set it up, and that is how it works to this day.

Individuals who are fond of appointing themselves as their own authority notwithstanding.
If you can see that, then it isn’t fair to say that the CC gave us the canon.
It is not only fair, but historically accurate. You will learn this for yourself if you are willing to study.

Those who are not united to the magesterium are factious.

Titus 3:10-11
10 As for a man who is factious, after admonishing him once or twice, have nothing more to do with him, 11 knowing that such a person is perverted and sinful; he is self-condemned.
 
Wow - Just discovered what a silly comparison that was (sky and earth). I was using known truths in my examples presuming that the Bible would fit into that category, not realizing that I really have no reason to believe any particular canon is true.:rolleyes:
 
Y’know - I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard this argument over and over again. That the CC gave us the Bible, declared which books were inspired, etc., etc., and it never truly truly occured to me that this was a valid argument until now. 😊 I kept working with the assumption that the Bible was inspired. I can’t give any good reason why I should accept the canon that the CC declared.

Dawn shines on marblehead…
 
Y’know - I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard this argument over and over again. That the CC gave us the Bible, declared which books were inspired, etc., etc., and it never truly truly occured to me that this was a valid argument until now. 😊 I kept working with the assumption that **the Bible **was inspired. I can’t give any good reason why I should accept the canon that the CC declared.

Dawn shines on marblehead…
Which Bible? You might the painting a broad brush, you know, your definition of what constitutes The Bible is different from what, for example, Marcion might have.

Point being. Since you are not Catholic, you are not bound by what a Catholic Synod determined were the only inspired books.

In other words, (and for example) the Synod that Claimed that --St. Paul’s so called Letter to Titus, was inspired—, from your perspective, might have done it from just pure fiat. How dare they? I mean it could have been a forgery, and you shouldn’t be bound by that.

This same fiat might have been the same reason the Gospel of the Hebrews was excluded from the Canon wasn’t it?. From your perspective, How can this Synod of mere men, Claim that this particular Gospel is not Inspired? After all some churches were still using these, and saw nothing wrong with them.
 
Y’know - I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard this argument over and over again. That the CC gave us the Bible, declared which books were inspired, etc., etc., and it never truly truly occured to me that this was a valid argument until now. 😊 I kept working with the assumption that the Bible was inspired. I can’t give any good reason why I should accept the canon that the CC declared.

Dawn shines on marblehead…
Couldn’t edit my previous post so, just wanted to say, i don’t know if you are are being sarcastic or sincere here given your preceeding post.
 
Sorry about that Game… I can see that it does look sarcastic. No, seriously, the lightbulb just came on. It’s a terrible argument (mine). I truly can’t find any reason to accept the canon of the Bible without acknowledging an earthly authority.

IOW, if I’m going to accept the Bible as God’s Word, I have to acknowledge some earthly authority (the CC) to have determined it to be so.

I am trying to find a better way to explain why I just figured this out and I’m still not quite able to articulate it.
 
The DR Bible is wrong, but that should come as no surprise.
You missed the point. We can debate the merits of the translation if you like, but I was more interested in what the footnote said.

Regardless of the accuracy of the translation, the footnote concerning private interpretation of scripture is correct.

Let me put this to you another way: who (apart from God) would you recognize as having the authority to correct your interpretation of a passage of scripture and why?
 
Was it Bishop Sheen who said “you follow God in your way, and I will follow Him in His”?
So Mr. Sheen says He is following God in God’s way and those who disagree with his opinion of God’s way are not. As you would say to non-Catholics, his is this any more than Mr. Sheen’s opinion of what God’s way is?
 
So Mr. Sheen says He is following God in God’s way and those who disagree with his opinion of God’s way are not. As you would say to non-Catholics, his is this any more than Mr. Sheen’s opinion of what God’s way is?
First, it’s not “Mr.” Sheen. It is Archbishop Sheen. You don’t have to be Catholic to be respectful.

Second, Archbishop Sheen is pointing out that by staying faithful to the teachings of the Church that Jesus founded, the Catholic Church, he can be sure of worshipping God according to God’s own plan.

Non-Catholics have chosen another way of their own design.
 
You missed the point. We can debate the merits of the translation if you like, …

Regardless of the accuracy of the translation, the footnote concerning private interpretation of scripture is correct.
I didn’t miss the point: The footnote is wrong:

The word used in 2 Peter 1:20 is “epilysis”.

It can refer to “an imaginary or fanciful interpretation”

On the other hand, “diermēneuō” means:
  1. to unfold the meaning of what is said, explain, expound
“hermēneuō” means:
  1. to explain in words, expound
    a. to explain; interpret.
  2. to interpret
    a) to translate what has been spoken or written in a foreign tongue into the using plain, everyday, ordinary language.
Are you suggesting the Apostles, under the inspiration of God, wrote an obscure, vague and uncertain passage to ensure Christians received a clear and correct interpretation of the Scriptures?

Merry Christmas!!!

My morning will be filled with peeling potatoes for forty people! Yeah!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top