SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In the first link it jumped out at me when it said priests reconcile people to God. I disagree. Christ reconciles people to God. You believe He does it through Catholic priests, obviously, and non Catholics do not.
Actually, there are some “non-Catholics” that believe that. Everyone believed that until about 500 years ago when there was a massive abandoment from the Apostolic Faith founded upon the Church of Jesus.

Anyway, Jesus has called some into the special ministry of reconciling other to Himself. For these persons, He grafts them into His own priesthood, so that they, like Him ,can given their lives for the sake of the world.
Paul the Apostle was such a one. Do you not believe that He believed it was His calling to minister reconciliation to God?
 
If it was so simple as to just read a book and the Holy Spirit would guide everybody to the truth, why didn’t Jesus just write the Bible Himself and tell His apostles to distribute them (ala JW with the Watchtower method) instead of telling them to go and “TEACH”?

And according to some beliefs, all that Jesus would have needed to write n His book was “Believe and you are saved.”

If just reading a book is so simple, why cant I buy a medical dictionary and go perform brain surgery. Will I be able to recognize a cancer sore from an infected pimple?

Our souls are more important wouldn’t you think?
Verily I do think so. Great post, thanks! 👍
 
You already believe these doctrines, so they are easy for you to see. But to those who reject them, they are not easy to see. Try to convince a JW that Jesus is God!
Tell me what is hard to understand about: Gen 1:1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.
I would love to, but I am not going to encourage you to derail your own thread. You seem to have a lot of trouble focusing, …

Let’s try to stay on topic, shall we?
:rotfl:

Do you know how funny that is?

You joined into a conversation between RandyC and I. The 2 of you have asked about, infant baptism, which books belong in the Bible, and how these books qualify to be in the bible, which Scripture outlines the essential doctrines of Christianity, if the Apostles Creed is binding, stated the Bible cannot be understood without the pope to explain it etc.,

When I answer you accuse me of being off topic!!! When I don’t respond, You accuse me being unable to defend my beliefs.

The funniest part is you seem to believe your off topic posts are on topic and my posts answering your questions are off topic. 😃

I don’t think I will respond to you any longer. You seem to just want to argue with me…which appears to have something to do with the false accusation you made when you pm’ed me. Please don’t do that again. I think it is against forum rules and I know it breaks the 9th commandment.
 
Ginger, you start off by telling us what the word epilysis can refer to and then you define 2 other words. Can you please tell me what these 3 words are in english? Are they all in the passage?

Thanks
The explanation is in posts #205 & 239.

We were discussing the meaning of 2 Peter 1:20-21.
you must understand that no prophecy of Scripture came about by the prophet’s own interpretation.
For prophecy never had its origin in the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.

To which I pointed out the word is “epilysis”. Epilysis can mean “an imaginary or fanciful interpretation” Therefore, verse 20 doesn’t prove what the RC claims.

Other places in the NT that use words translated “interpretation” use the word “diermēneuō” which means
  1. to unfold the meaning of what is said, explain, expound
  2. to translate into one’s native language
“diermēneuō” is used in reference to those who can interpret tongues.

OR
“hermēneuō” which means
  1. to explain in words, expound
  2. to interpret
    a) to translate what has been spoken or written in a foreign tongue into the vernacular
My point is that if that passage meant what the RC says it means, Peter would have used the word “hermēneuō” so his meaning would be clear. Or less likely, Peter might have used “diermēneuō”. But Peter would certainly not use a word that could mean “epilysis”.

Look at how “epilysis” reads when translated directly in 2 Peter:

you must understand that no prophecy of Scripture came about by the prophet’s own imagination. For prophecy never had its origin in the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.

Whereas, “hermēneuō”, which means to explain in words, expound, to interpret. “Hermēneuō” provides a concise meaning to the verse; a meaning that is so clear, it leaves no room for misinterpretation.

Even “diermēneuō” would provide a clear meaning to the verse.
 
The explanation is in posts #205 & 239.

We were discussing the meaning of 2 Peter 1:20-21.
you must understand that no prophecy of Scripture came about by the prophet’s own interpretation.
For prophecy never had its origin in the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.

To which I pointed out the word is “epilysis”. Epilysis can mean “an imaginary or fanciful interpretation” Therefore, verse 20 doesn’t prove what the RC claims.

Other places in the NT that use words translated “interpretation” use the word “diermēneuō” which means
  1. to unfold the meaning of what is said, explain, expound
  2. to translate into one’s native language
“diermēneuō” is used in reference to those who can interpret tongues.

OR
“hermēneuō” which means
  1. to explain in words, expound
  2. to interpret
    a) to translate what has been spoken or written in a foreign tongue into the vernacular
My point is that if that passage meant what the RC says it means, Peter would have used the word “hermēneuō” so his meaning would be clear. Or less likely, Peter might have used “diermēneuō”. But Peter would certainly not use a word that could mean “epilysis”.

Look at how “epilysis” reads when translated directly in 2 Peter:

you must understand that no prophecy of Scripture came about by the prophet’s own imagination. For prophecy never had its origin in the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.

Whereas, “hermēneuō”, which means to explain in words, expound, to interpret. “Hermēneuō” provides a concise meaning to the verse; a meaning that is so clear, it leaves no room for misinterpretation.

Even “diermēneuō” would provide a clear meaning to the verse.
Thanks for explaining that with more clarity (I had asked which words those were a translation of).

You don’t seem to see that the text can be seen in two ways. I can see your interpretation well: that prophecy comes from God and not from man’s own mind/imagination. What we are trying to show you here is that the reason he is telling us this (that prophecy comes from God) is that we do not have the MIND of GOD, therefore, it is not up to US to determine what prophecy means. Neither do we have the mind of God in even recognizing prophecy. It takes something extra-biblical, inerrant, and authoritative to recognize the inerrancy/inspiration (prophecy of God) of the books which became our canon.

I hope that is clearer to you.
 
And, of course, the 2nd point to this is that it takes that same, infallible, extra-biblical, earthly authority to help us interpret Scripture. The 2-sided nature of that one passage is evidence that Scripture is not always so easily interpreted. We need an outside authority.
 
And, of course, the 2nd point to this is that it takes that same, infallible, extra-biblical, earthly authority to help us interpret Scripture. The 2-sided nature of that one passage is evidence that Scripture is not always so easily interpreted. We need an outside authority.
I see that your posts are different now, and then I read your signature!😉
 
:rotfl:

Do you know how funny that is?

You joined into a conversation between RandyC and I. The 2 of you have asked about, infant baptism, which books belong in the Bible, and how these books qualify to be in the bible, which Scripture outlines the essential doctrines of Christianity, if the Apostles Creed is binding, stated the Bible cannot be understood without the pope to explain it etc.,
I am sorry, Ginger2, but you must be mixing up our posts. The topic here is about confession to a priest. I do believe that some scripture was brought forth to support the Catholic teaching on this point.

I can assure you that I never stated that the Bible cannot be understood without the Pope to explain it, because I personally do not believe that, neither is it Catholic Teaching. It is a strawman that you like to throw at us when you are in a corner.

What I did ask you was, which Apostle is recorded in the NT as having retained sins?
When I answer you accuse me of being off topic!!! When I don’t respond, You accuse me being unable to defend my beliefs.
Try this: When the question is off topic, note that, and address the topic. Now, you are unable to “defend” your beliefs for all the reasons you have noted, that Sola Scriptura is an extrabiblical doctrine. you and also failed to adequately explain away the scriputres that relate to confession. I gave you two examples from the NT about the public confession of sins. I am still waiting for you to explain them away!
The funniest part is you seem to believe your off topic posts are on topic and my posts answering your questions are off topic. 😃
No, they are both off topic. However, I think getting off topic is one of your favorite ways to avoid issues. The last thread this happened, I asked you three times to please explain to me what your posts had to do with the topic, and I got no answer.
I don’t think I will respond to you any longer. You seem to just want to argue with me…which appears to have something to do with the false accusation you made when you pm’ed me. Please don’t do that again. I think it is against forum rules and I know it breaks the 9th commandment.
Well, ok. I don’t think you have an adequate response, so it does not surprise me that you don’t think you will post one. I frankly can’t remember what I pm’ed you about, so I cannot promise that it will not happen again. Perhaps you will refresh my memory? If it has to do with confession to a priest, you can post it here!
 
We were discussing the meaning of 2 Peter 1:20-21.
you must understand that no prophecy of Scripture came about by the prophet’s own interpretation.
For prophecy never had its origin in the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.
I think we got on to this topic because you were asserting that confession to a priest was not necessary, and we were trying to show you scriptures that support this doctrine.
To which I pointed out the word is “epilysis”. Epilysis can mean “an imaginary or fanciful interpretation” Therefore, verse 20 doesn’t prove what the RC claims.
On the contrary, that is EXACTLY what the Church claims. Your fanciful and imaginary interpretations of the scripture to suit your opinions are not how scripture is to be interpreted.
My point is that if that passage meant what the RC says it means, Peter would have used the word “hermēneuō” so his meaning would be clear.
Well, Ginger2, you give a good example of why this verse says what the Church says it means. Your fanciful imagination about what words Peter “ought” to have used make it clear that you are not able to accept what the verse says. Peter, as well as all the other Apostles an writers of the NT was quite clear that the Scripture should never be separated from the authority of the One who authored it.
Or less likely, Peter might have used “diermēneuō”. But Peter would certainly not use a word that could mean “epilysis”.
Peter knew what he wanted to say, and stated it clearly. When one interprets the scripture apart from the Sacred Tradition that produced it, fanciful imagination results. All kinds of strange new doctrines occur, such as God did not give priests to the Church, priests can’t forgive sins, and that confession to a priest is not necessary. 🤷

See how that happens?
Code:
Look at how "epilysis" reads when translated directly in 2 Peter:
you must understand that no prophecy of Scripture came about by the prophet’s own imagination. For prophecy never had its origin in the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.
Doesn’t it stand to reason that the best way to understand what someone wrote is to understand and use the mindset they had when they wrote it? I learned this in high school when studying Shakespeare. Don’t they teach this anymore? Or did you just not go to literature class?
Whereas, “hermēneuō”, which means to explain in words, expound, to interpret. “Hermēneuō” provides a concise meaning to the verse; a meaning that is so clear, it leaves no room for misinterpretation.

Even “diermēneuō” would provide a clear meaning to the verse.
Misinterpretation happens when the Scripture is taken out of it’s context, which is the Catholic Church. Your desire to replace the language so that it is more clear to you is reminiscent of Martin Luther, who also made these kinds of edits. Have you considered creating “Ginger2’s NT”?
 
That’s just the thing Wind, we do believe we are, but not by our own authority. You believe you’re right, but who tells you you’re right? Just you? You can’t say the Bible does, b/c the Bible doesn’t TELL anyone anything, we READ the Bible. So is everyone who has their own interpretation right?
It’s kind of odd that Jesus would say to people “search the Scriptures” if they don’t tell us anything. :confused: You know I have just as much right to believe I’m right about something as you do to believe you’re right.
 
If you disagree as you say you do, then provide a scripturally sound and viable meaning for John 20:21-23, .
You’re going to find fault and say that any explanation that doesn’t agree with what you believe is unsound even though there are other explanations. There’s just no way Catholics will agree with any explanation that is not the Catholic one. That’s a given.

justforcatholics.org/a08.htm
 
40.png
WindGirl:
You’re going to find fault and say that any explanation that doesn’t agree with what you believe is unsound even though there are other explanations. There’s just no way Catholics will agree with any explanation that is not the Catholic one. That’s a given.
I would agree with you here. Catholics are bound to accept the teaching of those left in charge with the authority to teach. For a Catholic that is the Magisterium of the Church. Certain teachings remain somewhat flexible (creation in 6 days and predestination, for example) while others are dogma and there is no flexiblility. So on some issues a Catholic “cannot” agree with your opinion while on others they can.
Honestly - Joe Mizzi? He is truly a light weight in the world of apologetics. The article from the link you provided is a classic example. He spouts off as if he actually knows something and doesnt even begin to develop or defend his position. He doesnt even say what his position is - he simply implies that a study of the rest of the NT will reveal what the true meaning of John 20:21-23 is. How ridiculous is that? Seriously - read anything he has ever written in his entire life and compare it to any encyclical from the Magisterium. It would be like comparing a doctoral thesis to a sixth grader’s book report. He has foolishly attempted to cross swords with John Martignoni (Catholic convert and apologist) and he gets absolutely destroyed - repeatedly. There are much, much better Protestant apologists to listen to.
 
It’s kind of odd that Jesus would say to people “search the Scriptures” if they don’t tell us anything. :confused: You know I have just as much right to believe I’m right about something as you do to believe you’re right.
Scriptures tell us plenty, WindGirl. However, if you read that passage, you will see that Jesus is scolding them. “You search the scriptures” he states, in the accusative mode. “because in them you think you can find life, and they testify of me, yet you will not come to me that you can have life”.

He is criticizing them for looking for “life” in the pages, instead of His person. Now, His person is present in the Church, and people are still doing the same things!
 
You’re going to find fault and say that any explanation that doesn’t agree with what you believe is unsound even though there are other explanations. There’s just no way Catholics will agree with any explanation that is not the Catholic one. That’s a given.

justforcatholics.org/a08.htm
This is true. We can listen, and understand, and illuminate the differences, but to accept something non-apostolic would be accepting “a different gospel” and we would be accursed. :eek:

I don’t think this link is allowed here. It is against the forum rules for you to try to pull Catholics out of the Church.
 
It’s kind of odd that Jesus would say to people “search the Scriptures” if they don’t tell us anything. :confused: You know I have just as much right to believe I’m right about something as you do to believe you’re right.
My point is that the Bible contains information, it cannot “tell”, only people can “tell”. You have a right to whatever you want. You look a little silly acting like you didn’t understand what I meant so you could avoid answering the question, but whatever.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top