Stephen Hawking Has Died

  • Thread starter Thread starter LoyalViews
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That being said, I don’t actually encounter that many Christians, and certainly very few Catholics, who seem to have quite the lust for hellfire and damnation as this particular poster, so I in no way think he represents the majority of his coreligionists.
I’ve said nothing which the Church herself doesn’t teach.

Just because many Catholics don’t believe in hell doesn’t mean the Church doesn’t teach it.
 
Good to know. For my part, I know relatively few atheists of the plotting, imprecating, hissing-and-cursing-at-the-light “infidel” persuasion. 😉
 
Mercy triumphs over justice!
Mercy triumphs over justice for man in his relations.

But Mercy and Justice are both attributes of God’s Person.

So there’s nothing intrinsically wrong with focusing on one or the other, as circumstances permit.
 
Last edited:
So there’s nothing intrinsically wrong with focusing on one or the other, as circumstances permit.
Actually, they should both be kept in mind at all times. As you say, they’re both attributes of God.
 
Generally speaking? That seems alright.
That’s how I was using them and the point I was trying to make.

Read what I said carefully - I never wished evil or harm or judgment or anything negative on Hawking.

The only judgment I made against him was his status as a public opponent of faith.
 
Read what I said carefully - I never wished evil or harm or judgment or anything negative on Hawking.

The only judgment I made against him was his status as a public opponent of faith.
These two points are contradictory. I have a feeling you’re trying to have your cake and eat it, too.
 
Actually, they should both be kept in mind at all times. As you say, they’re both attributes of God.
Amen.

Mercy without justice is tepid and shallow…

Justice without mercy is cruel and cold.
 
Judging certain public positions of someone is NOT making a judgment on their person.

I can say “Joe is being a horrific influence on people by doing this” and say “Joe is a great guy” without being contradictory.
 
Hawking was a great man.

He was an atheist? Doesn’t change that. I suspect God is more merciful than you think.
God is infinitely merciful.

Yes Hawking was a devout atheist.

I don’t know if I’d say great man - good scientist, maybe. I can’t make a judgment on his character because I don’t know enough about him.

I do know he was no friend of religion, and clearly made known publicly his disdain for it.
 
Judging certain public positions of someone is NOT making a judgment on their person.
You’ve called him “an enemy of the faith”. That is most assuredly a judgement of his person.
I can say “Joe is being a horrific influence on people by doing this” and say “Joe is a great guy” without being contradictory.
But what you actually said was “Joe is the enemy of all the people who believe X thing.”
 
But what you actually said was “Joe is the enemy of all the people who believe X thing.”
Perhaps my hyperbole was inappropriately strong worded.

Instead of using a positive, I should have said a negative - something like “Hawking was not a supporter of faith.”
 
Most of what you and others were disagreeing with me on in the first place wasn’t so much the substance of what I was saying, as it was the language I was dressing it up in.

I’ve spent a lot of time thinking of Hawking and his influence in our culture, so I have strong feelings about him.

I could have used a more level headed approach to get my point across, but I let my biases and opinions get the best of me, and thus came off as unnecessarily hostile.

I’ll be sure to confess at my next confession “using hostile and unthoughtful words, and being uncharitable in my conversation.”

I’ll also scan over previous posts and delete any posts which are too harsh.

Sins of wrath are one of the two major groups of the seven capital sins I struggle with most - the other being lust.
 
Last edited:
Most of what you and others were disagreeing with me on in the first place wasn’t so much the substance of what I was saying, as it was the language I was dressing it up in.
I agree with that analysis.
I’ve spent a lot of time thinking of Hawking and his influence in our culture, so I have strong feelings about him.
So do I. I think his intense dislike of religion is a tragedy, considering what he could have brought to it, and it to him.
I could have used a more level headed approach to get my point across, but I let my biases and opinions get the best of me, and thus came off as unnecessarily hostile.

I’ll be sure to confess at my next confession “using hostile and unthoughtful words, and being uncharitable in my conversation.”

I’ll also scan over previous posts and delete any posts which are too harsh.
That’s all up to you. I only addressed it largely because it’s the kind of lingo that tends to turn others away, and I know you don’t want that, as obviously devout as you are and as much as you have to offer others. Peace, brother.
 
That’s all up to you. I only addressed it largely because it’s the kind of lingo that tends to turn others away, and I know you don’t want that, as obviously devout as you are and as much as you have to offer others. Peace, brother.
Peace be with you.

I went back to the beginning of the thread and reread all my comments… I flat out deleted some, edited some others, and a few I left alone.

Now I’m confident my words are both true and charitable.
 
@niceatheist In about 45 minutes I’m going to pray Vespers.

I decided in reparation for anything uncharitable I said before and out of Christian charity, I’ll use the Office for the Dead and pray it for the repose of Stephen Hawking.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top