Syrian rebels behead Christian

  • Thread starter Thread starter latin_rite
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The fact that these Islamic “rebels” have beheaded a Christian is proof that they are terrorists and are not better than the current government. Therefore these Islamic terrorist “rebels” should not continue in provoking the conflict. They have started an unjust war against President Assad.
 
The fact that these Islamic “rebels” have beheaded a Christian is proof that they are terrorists and are not better than the current government. Therefore these Islamic terrorist “rebels” should not continue in provoking the conflict. They have started an unjust war against President Assad.
Just out of curiosity, what is President Assad’s religion?
 
Don’t bother - I just looked it up: it’s Shia Muslim. Interesting. So Muslims are fighting Muslims but we know who is right or wrong by whether or not they kill or spare Christians? Whew, that clears up a whole lot…:rolleyes:
 
Don’t bother - I just looked it up: it’s Shia Muslim. Interesting. So Muslims are fighting Muslims but we know who is right or wrong by whether or not they kill or spare Christians? Whew, that clears up a whole lot…:rolleyes:
The point is that it’s an unjust war since the ones trying to seize power are terrorists. Assad isn’t a Christian, but his government at least allows for Christians to co-exist there. If the “rebels” take over they will kill and drive out Christians in order for it to be an absolute Islamic government.
 
And Assad is not a terrorist? Ever heard of Hezbollah?
You aren’t getting it. No matter how bad Assad might be, the ones trying to seize power are not any better. Therefore it makes no sense to be in support of overthrowing him unless one just likes to see people getting killed in war.
 
You aren’t getting it. No matter how bad Assad might be, the ones trying to seize power are not any better. Therefore it makes no sense to be in support of overthrowing him unless one just likes to see people getting killed in war.
That’s your opinion. There’s nothing to ‘get’. People who are being slaughtered by their government have a right to defend themselves. I certainly don’t think it’s my place to suggest that they line up their kids and wave to the snipers to open fire. If it were my kids being starved or shelled I would fight, so would every parent I know.

I don’t know how you define ‘unjust war’, but any war that regards children as legitimate targets has to qualify as unjust.
 
I do not discount Al-Jazeera’s account, I simply presented both for people to compare. The SANA article ‘proves’ exactly zilch. Two different news agencies gives two different accounts of how a child was killed. Regardless of which account is true, a child was still killed for what, running around with a knife or a sharp stick maybe? If anyone finds that acceptable, then maybe we should be discussing why.
The fact of the matter is that you do not know what happened to Khateeb. Neither does Al-Jazeera. Yet, Al-Jazeera asserted that he was tortured and detained. But they provided no evidence to support that assertion.

The Syrian authorities reported that Khateeb was a casualty of a violent protest. The SANA report also notes that there were not simply teenagers “running around with a knife or sharp stick” as you continue to assert. The SANA account notes that the Syrian authorities were up against heavily armed “protesters” SOME of whom were teenagers with sharp objects. The Syrian authorities also assert (based on the medical examiners report) that Khateeb was killed in that protest by a gunshot wound. For all we know Khateeb was killed in friendly fire. His body showed up almost a month later. The Al-Jazeera account asserts (with no evidence) that he was in Syrian custody during this month being tortured. The Syrian authorities assert that he was found in a badly decayed, mutilated state indicating that Khateeb probably laid in the streets or rubble for a period of time before his body was discovered.

In any case, lets stop pretending that we know what happened. We don’t. But the Syrian authorities have provided more evidence to back up their assertions. I know, I know, you will probably try to discount the Syrian medical examiner’s report based simply on the fact that he is a Syrian authority. But that would be a fallacy. If you have evidence to discount the Syrian medical examiner’s report, then please present it here.
 
That’s your opinion. There’s nothing to ‘get’. People who are being slaughtered by their government have a right to defend themselves.
The Syrian government didn’t start this war. The Syrian government doesn’t want this war. It’s the Islamic terrorist “rebels” that wanted this and who keep the war going. Do you believe Obama would allow a violent takeover of the US government which would assuredly result in him and his family being sodomized and executed?
 
The fact of the matter is that you do not know what happened to Khateeb. Neither does Al-Jazeera. Yet, Al-Jazeera asserted that he was tortured and detained. But they provided no evidence to support that assertion.

The Syrian authorities reported that Khateeb was a casualty of a violent protest. The SANA report also notes that there were not simply teenagers “running around with a knife or sharp stick” as you continue to assert. The SANA account notes that the Syrian authorities were up against heavily armed “protesters” SOME of whom were teenagers with sharp objects. The Syrian authorities also assert (based on the medical examiners report) that Khateeb was killed in that protest by a gunshot wound. For all we know Khateeb was killed in friendly fire. His body showed up almost a month later. The Al-Jazeera account asserts (with no evidence) that he was in Syrian custody during this month being tortured. The Syrian authorities assert that he was found in a badly decayed, mutilated state indicating that Khateeb probably laid in the streets or rubble for a period of time before his body was discovered.

In any case, lets stop pretending that we know what happened. We don’t. But the Syrian authorities have provided more evidence to back up their assertions. I know, I know, you will probably try to discount the Syrian medical examiner’s report based simply on the fact that he is a Syrian authority. But that would be a fallacy. If you have evidence to discount the Syrian medical examiner’s report, then please present it here.
We don’t know, you say, yet you accept SANA’s account. That’s your prerogative. Assad’s subsequent actions has told me which account is believable. No amount of defending him can belie his actions: innocent people are being killed and he’s making delusional speeches. Typical dictator who cannot see the end until it stares down the barrel of a gun at him. Hopefully Syrians of goodwill can reach through his smokescreens of compulsive denial to do something to save their country.
 
We don’t know, you say, yet you accept SANA’s account. That’s your prerogative. Assad’s subsequent actions has told me which account is believable. No amount of defending him can belie his actions: innocent people are being killed and he’s making delusional speeches. Typical dictator who cannot see the end until it stares down the barrel of a gun at him. Hopefully Syrians of goodwill can reach through his smokescreens of compulsive denial to do something to save their country.
Yes, I choose to accept the medical examiner’s report given that there is no real evidence to counter his claims.

Your argument amounts to “Assad is a bad guy because his opposition says so.” :rolleyes:
 
The Syrian government didn’t start this war. The Syrian government doesn’t want this war. It’s the Islamic terrorist “rebels” that wanted this and who keep the war going. Do you believe Obama would allow a violent takeover of the US government which would assuredly result in his own execution and the rape and murder of his wife and daughters?
Oh please. If ANY PRESIDENT shot down kids in the streets for demanding their rights, I would take their places in the streets and dare him do the same to me. The Syrian government is like the guy with a can of gas torching his neighbor’s house, who gets caught in his own inferno. He promoted terror and now he’s whining 'cause he woke up in bed with it? He can spare me the excuses: they who live by the sword die by the sword.
 
The Syrian government didn’t start this war. The Syrian government doesn’t want this war. It’s the Islamic terrorist “rebels” that wanted this and who keep the war going. Do you believe Obama would allow a violent takeover of the US government which would assuredly result in him and his family being sodomized and executed?
Oh please. If ANY PRESIDENT shot down kids in the streets for demanding their rights, I would take their places in the streets and dare him do the same to me. The Syrian government is like the guy with a can of gas torching his neighbor’s house, who gets caught in his own inferno. He promoted terror and now he’s whining 'cause he woke up in bed with it? He can spare me the excuses: they who live by the sword die by the sword.
A very emotional piece of propaganda. But you didn’t answer the question.
 
Yes, I choose to accept the medical examiner’s report given that there is no real evidence to counter his claims.

Your argument amounts to “Assad is a bad guy because his opposition says so.” :rolleyes:
I always knew he was a bad guy. What I find shocking is how it took his people so long to see that.
 
No? I said ANY PRESIDENT. I’m not that enamored of the current president that I’m under some compulsion to drag his name into my every post.
I don’t understand why you keep blaming the Syrian government for defending itself when you know Obama would do the same.
 
The Assad family are Alawites, who are a sect twho’s origins go back to the Shia. While not Christians, they still do have a type of celebration of Christmas, Palm Sunday and Easter. Christians have been treated very well in Assad’s Syria.
 
The Assad family are Alawites, who are a sect twho’s origins go back to the Shia. While not Christians, they still do have a type of celebration of Christmas, Palm Sunday and Easter. Christians have been treated very well in Assad’s Syria.
Good for them. Now maybe they can induce Assad to treat the rest of Syria, not to mention Lebanon, the same way?
 
The Assad family are Alawites, who are a sect twho’s origins go back to the Shia. While not Christians, they still do have a type of celebration of Christmas, Palm Sunday and Easter. Christians have been treated very well in Assad’s Syria.
And that relatively peaceful co-existence with Christians will immediately end if the Islamic terrorists “rebels” get their way and institute a Taliban-like government. But I guess Obama and his supporters would see that as a good thing.
 
I don’t understand why you keep blaming the Syrian government for defending itself when you know Obama would do the same.
There are lots of things I don’t understand either. Like why you seem to think any government has a right to exist at the expense of the lives of its people. As a man Assad, just like any Syrian, has a right to self defense. As an aggressor-leader, he has 0 rights to anything other than perhaps a one-way ticket to where-ever.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top