Syrian rebels behead Christian

  • Thread starter Thread starter latin_rite
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
For what it’s worth…I have known a number of Christians who live in Lebanon, Syria, and the Palestinian areas who do not consider Hezbollah to be terrorists…but they sure do view Israel as terrorists. 🤷
Great to hear that. I’m sure you would get the same result asking the average Saudi or Egyptian if al Qaeda is a terrorist organization. Some would say yes, some would say no. I know a considerable amount of Lebonese Maronite Christians, and a majority of those consider Hezbollah to be terrorists.

Coincidentally, that’s also the position of the US government. Killing 241 servicemen with a truck bomb kinda does that. Or bombing the US embassy in Lebanon. Or hijacking TWA Flight 847 (and killing another American, Robert Dean Stethem).

Many countries don’t consider al Qaeda to be a terrorist organization, but that doesn’t mean that they aren’t.

I hope you see the duplicity in your argument: Syrian “rebels” are terrorists because they kill Christians, and are acting against the legitimate government of Syria. Hezbollah are “freedom fighters” because they kill other people (often using the same tactics as al Qaeda), and are acting against eeevil occupiers, Israel.

Yeah, okay.
 
Great to hear that. I’m sure you would get the same result asking the average Saudi or Egyptian if al Qaeda is a terrorist organization.
I am talkinjg about Christians here. Hezbollah conducts humanitarian efforts to help the people (Christians included). They are not viewed as terrorists by most countries.
Many countries don’t consider al Qaeda to be a terrorist organization
Most do.
I hope you see the duplicity in your argument:
Try not to digest everything your government feeds you. 😉
 
I am talkinjg about Christians here. Hezbollah conducts humanitarian efforts to help the people (Christians included).They are not viewed as terrorists by most countries.
They also commit acts of terror. Some countries have just designated their military wing as a terrorist organizations.
40.png
Mickey:
Hardly. The EU, US, Canada, Israel, India, Japan, Netherlands, UK, Russia, Netherlands, do. About 20 countries, if you count organizations like NATO or UNSC as a country. How many countries are there in the world? 20 out of how many??

Turkey is the only Muslim majority country that has done so. No Saudi Arabia. No Egypt. No Lebanon. No Syria. No Jordan. No Iraq. No Iran. No Pakistan.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Qaeda#Designation_as_terrorist_organization

So, since a majority of Muslim majority countries don’t consider al Qaeda to be a terrorist organization, it must not be, right?

🤷
40.png
Mickey:
Try not to digest everything your government feeds you. 😉
Great comeback for the facts I’ve provided. Sad that your yardstick of what makes a ‘terrorist’ is only if they target Christians. If they kill a few hundred Americans, no big deal.

At least I’m consistent in my views. Al Qaeda, much of the Syrian opposition, and Hezbollah are terrorists.

👍
 
Great comeback for the facts I’ve provided.
You have provided no facts. I have a better understanding from the Christians who live in the countries of discussion. I will take their word over yours. You get your understandings from propaganda machines. You say Hezbollah is a terrorist organization…about eight countries believe this to be the case. By your statistics at least 20 countries designate Al-Queda to be terrorists. But putting the Al-Queda/Hezbollah discussion aside for a moment…let us look at Syria again:

Al-Assad protects minority groups (including Christians). You and others have attempted to ape the Western media by making him out be a brutal monster who is no better than the terrorist groups trying to topple him.

If he is toppled, you will have a hard-core Islamic Sharia law terrorist “government”…who will not only kill any citizen who gets in their way…not only fund Al-Queda around the world…but will make it a priority to wipe out Christianity in that country. The monasteries are are already being targeted. The Christians are already being beheaded and driven from their homes. And America will not protect them.

That is only the beginning. You will see an “administration” that makes Al-Assad look like Mickey Mouse.

So you go ahead and root for a regime change…and then get back to me after the foot is removed from the mouth. 👍
 
You have provided no facts. I have a better understanding from the Christians who live in the countries of discussion. I will take their word over yours. You get your understandings from propaganda machines. You say Hezbollah is a terrorist organization…about eight countries believe this to be the case. By your statistics at least 20 countries designate Al-Queda to be terrorists. But putting the Al-Queda/Hezbollah discussion aside for a moment…let us look at Syria again:
See my post #157 of this thread.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=10217999&postcount=157

I don’t support regime change. Period. Assad currently is the better option than the devil we don’t know. I said the same of Mubarak. A better choice, but marginally so.

The facts I was referring to we terrorist attacks Hezbollah has made. They’re 2nd to al Qaeda in the number of Americans killed.

I just find the position to be a double standard. Hezbollah (who Assad supports) are “good” terrorists. al Qaeda (currently fighting against Assad) are “bad” terrorists.
 
Assad currently is the better option
Then we agree
I just find the position to be a double standard.
That is your opinion. I think America designated them as a T.O. in 1995. I think the EU still does not designate them as such. I have heard countless stories from Christians in Lebanon who have related stories of assistance and kindness from Hezbollah groups…but acts of terror from Israel. These are people that live and work on the ground in these countries. I take seriously what they tell me.

It shocked me when I first heard it because we are fed a constant diet from America that is biased one way…and one way only. After seeing American support for the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt…the cover-up in Libya…and now the Islamic extremists in Syria…there is not much I believe that comes from the talking government heads any longer.
 
That is your opinion. I think America designated them as a T.O. in 1995. I think the EU still does not designate them as such. I have heard countless stories from Christians in Lebanon who have related stories of assistance and kindness from Hezbollah groups…but acts of terror from Israel. These are people that live and work on the ground in these countries. I take seriously what they tell me.
Hitler was very kind to his dogs. That doesn’t change the acts he committed. Between 1982 and 1986, there were 36 suicide attacks in Lebanon directed against American, French and Israelis forces by 41 individuals, killing 659. They bombed embassies, synagogues and community centers, targeting civillians. Hezbollah has been implicated in every one. Hezbollah social services doing some good doesn’t take away the bad, friend, or make the people they’ve murdered any less dead.
40.png
Mickey:
It shocked me when I first heard it because we are fed a constant diet from America that is biased one way…and one way only. After seeing American support for the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt…the cover-up in Libya…and now the Islamic extremists in Syria…there is not much I believe that comes from the talking government heads any longer.
Again with the double standard? Al Qaeda, Hezbollah, the Muslim Brotherhood and the Syrian “rebels” use the same tactics, follow the same “Islam must rule supreme” ideology. The fact that you have first hand knowldedge of a few people saying good things about them suddenly wipes away every misdeed? The fact that 8, instead of 20 countries consider it a terrorist organization suddenly make it no so?

What’s our target number for official terrorist designation, then? 10? 15? 1 Muslim country, Turkey, has al Qaeda listed as a terrorist orgainization. 2 Muslim contries, Egypt and Bahrain have designated Hezbollah as such.

What is “biased” about Hezbollah killing Americans? Did it not happen, or is it justified in your eyes?

You can’t have it both ways.
 
Hitler was very kind to his dogs.
This is not about Hitler…or his dogs.
Between 1982 and 1986, there were 36 suicide attacks in Lebanon directed against American, French and Israelis forces by 41 individuals, killing 659. They bombed embassies, synagogues and community centers, targeting civillians.
They are still not considered to be terrorists by the French…or the EU…correct?
Hezbollah has been implicated in every one.
Implied?
Al Qaeda, Hezbollah, the Muslim Brotherhood and the Syrian “rebels” use the same tactics
All I can tell you is that the people (including Christians) have a good relationship with Hezbollah in those countries and do not see them as terrorists. I will take into account their experiences.
The fact that you have first hand knowldedge of a few people saying good things about them suddenly wipes away every misdeed?
More than a few people. I tend to listen to first hand experiences.
The fact that 8, instead of 20 countries consider it a terrorist organization suddenly make it no so?
I think it is significant…especially considering that the EU doesn’t think they are.
is it justified in your eyes?
Of course killing is never justified. It is a violation of the commandments of God. And it will not stop in Syria any time soon. I especially hate to see all the Christians murdered and driven out of the land where they were first called Christians. The monasteries there are beautiful…they will become rubble.
You can’t have it both ways
It has nothing to do with me. All I can do is pray.
 
Again with the double standard?.. What is “biased” about Hezbollah killing Americans?..Did it not happen, or is it justified in your eyes?..You can’t have it both ways.
Speaking about double standards and having it both ways, I find it strange that Israel condemns Hezbollah as a terrorist organization and Americans (rightly so) condemn Hezbollah for killing Americans, but neither Israel nor America nor the West ever condemned or prosecuted Menachem Begin for his role in the murder of 91 Brits, Arabs, and Jews in 1946 at the King David Hotel and neither Israel nor America nor the West ever condemned or prosecuted Yitzhak Shamir for his role in the murder of Folke Bernadotte in 1948. In fact, both these terrorists became Prime Ministers of Israel with no protest from the United States Government or Western Governments.

So, while Hezbollah is no angel, we need to keep this discussion in the proper context. When Western countries designate Hezbollah as a terrorist organization (yet refused to designate the Zionist terrorist squads of the 1940s as terrorists) I sort of have to take it with a grain of salt.
 
I don’t know how many Maronites who hate Hezbollah there are Scipio, and I’m aware they do exist, but I do know that 21 of 35 Maronites and 26 of 42 Catholic members of Lebanon’s parliament are aligned with Hezbollah and Amal, who combined have only 25.
 
This is not about Hitler…or his dogs.
Then drop the fallacy that people who do some good can do no wrong.
40.png
Mickey:
They are still not considered to be terrorists by the French…or the EU…correct?
Implied?
Correct. Again, what’s your yardstick for legitimacy in being considered a terrorist orgainization. Al Qaeda has 20. Hez has 8. is 15 your magic number?
40.png
Mickey:
All I can tell you is that the people (including Christians) have a good relationship with Hezbollah in those countries and do not see them as terrorists. I will take into account their experiences.
More than a few people. I tend to listen to first hand experiences.
There are many who don’t feel the same. See March 14 alliance.
40.png
Mickey:
Of course killing is never justified. It is a violation of the commandments of God. And it will not stop in Syria any time soon. I especially hate to see all the Christians murdered and driven out of the land where they were first called Christians. The monasteries there are beautiful…they will become rubble.
It has nothing to do with me. All I can do is pray.
I agree. I will pray with you, and pray Hezbollah changes their terror ways.
 
Speaking about double standards and having it both ways, I find it strange that Israel condemns Hezbollah as a terrorist organization and Americans (rightly so) condemn Hezbollah for killing Americans, but neither Israel nor America nor the West ever condemned or prosecuted Menachem Begin for his role in the murder of 91 Brits, Arabs, and Jews in 1946 at the King David Hotel and neither Israel nor America nor the West ever condemned or prosecuted Yitzhak Shamir for his role in the murder of Folke Bernadotte in 1948. In fact, both these terrorists became Prime Ministers of Israel with no protest from the United States Government or Western Governments.

So, while Hezbollah is no angel, we need to keep this discussion in the proper context. When Western countries designate Hezbollah as a terrorist organization (yet refused to designate the Zionist terrorist squads of the 1940s as terrorists) I sort of have to take it with a grain of salt.
Really? You aren’t willing to accept the notion that Hezbollah is a terrorist organization because the U.S. didn’t officially declare Zionists as terrorists for acts of 66 years ago and that no longer occur at their hands? Shall we still, then, consider Germans as warmongers, Russians as communists (and terrorists) and Americans as genocidal (the Indians)? And can we not consider a present terrorist organization to be one until we do?

That really isn’t a proper foundation for the conclusion, is it?
 
Speaking about double standards and having it both ways, I find it strange that Israel condemns Hezbollah as a terrorist organization and Americans (rightly so) condemn Hezbollah for killing Americans, but neither Israel nor America nor the West ever condemned or prosecuted Menachem Begin for his role in the murder of 91 Brits, Arabs, and Jews in 1946 at the King David Hotel and neither Israel nor America nor the West ever condemned or prosecuted Yitzhak Shamir for his role in the murder of Folke Bernadotte in 1948. In fact, both these terrorists became Prime Ministers of Israel with no protest from the United States Government or Western Governments.

So, while Hezbollah is no angel, we need to keep this discussion in the proper context. When Western countries designate Hezbollah as a terrorist organization (yet refused to designate the Zionist terrorist squads of the 1940s as terrorists) I sort of have to take it with a grain of salt.
We’ve been through this at least half a dozen times, Hans. I’m not sure if you honestly don’t grasp the concept, or wish to ignore it.

The Jewish Agency (precursor to Israeli government) labeled them a terrorist organization, demanded it disarm (like the UN has done to Hezbollah), and arrested its leaders.

They were later granted amnesty. Condemened, but never prosecuted.

Once Hizbollah disarms, and swears off violence, maybe then we will have a valid comparison, and the healing can begin. Until then, we’ve got an apples/rutabaga comparisons.

Oddly enough. I can admit the Irgun, Lehi, Al Qaeda, Hamas, the Muslim Brotherhood AND Hezbollah as terrorist organizations.
 
Really? You aren’t willing to accept the notion that Hezbollah is a terrorist organization because the U.S. didn’t officially declare Zionists as terrorists for acts of 66 years ago and that no longer occur at their hands? Shall we still, then, consider Germans as warmongers, Russians as communists (and terrorists) and Americans as genocidal (the Indians)? And can we not consider a present terrorist organization to be one until we do?

That really isn’t a proper foundation for the conclusion, is it?
Apparently, you did not read everything I wrote. I said Americans are correct to condemn Hezbollah for acts of terrorism against Americans.

But I refuse to not put the situation into proper context. I am sure the Zionist terrorists of the 1940’s did not consider themselves to be terrorists. They, like Hezbollah, considered themselves resistance fighters.

I have heard it claimed that Israel eventually disavowed the Zionist terrorist sqauds of the 1940s. But I find that suspect. Maybe they disavowed them in word, but not in deed. Menachem Begin and Yitzhak Shamir were leaders in the terrorist squads of the 1940s and yet were never prosecuted by the international authorities - the same authorities that later proclaimed Hezbollah to be a terrorist organization. I find that strange and hypocritical. That was my point, which you did not deal with.
 
We’ve been through this at least half a dozen times, Hans. I’m not sure if you honestly don’t grasp the concept, or wish to ignore it.

The Jewish Agency (precursor to Israeli government) labeled them a terrorist organization, demanded it disarm (like the UN has done to Hezbollah), and arrested its leaders.

They were later granted amnesty. Condemened, but never prosecuted.
Ah, so, in other words, nothing meaningful happened.

Condemned, but later Menachem Begin and Yitzhak Shamir were turned into Prime Ministers. Puh-lease!
Once Hizbollah disarms, and swears off violence, maybe then we will have a valid comparison, and the healing can begin. Until then, we’ve got an apples/rutabaga comparisons.
There can never be a valid comparison because the ones setting the standard for the comparison (the Israelis) came to power using the same tactics that Hezbollah is now using.

For a proper comparison, the Stern Gang and the Irgun would have had to disarm and disband BEFORE helping in the creation of the modern state of Israel. Give me a break!
 
Apparently, you did not read everything I wrote. I said Americans are correct to condemn Hezbollah for acts of terrorism against Americans.

But I refuse to not put the situation into proper context. I am sure the Zionist terrorists of the 1940’s did not consider themselves to be terrorists. They, like Hezbollah, considered themselves resistance fighters.

I have heard it claimed that Israel eventually disavowed the Zionist terrorist sqauds of the 1940s. But I find that suspect. Maybe they disavowed them in word, but not in deed. Menachem Begin and Yitzhak Shamir were leaders in the terrorist squads of the 1940s and yet were never prosecuted by the international authorities - the same authorities that later proclaimed Hezbollah to be a terrorist organization. I find that strange and hypocritical. That was my point, which you did not deal with.
But the Zionists of the 1940s are probably all dead by now. Certainly Begin and Shamir are. If you admit Hezbollah is a terrorist organization, then there’s no context to put it in other than with other current terrorist organizations.

And if “international authorities” prosecuted the likes of Mladic but not Begin and Shamir, perhaps after looking at it all they decided they didn’t have a winning case despite the beliefs of some that they did?
 
But the Zionists of the 1940s are probably all dead by now. Certainly Begin and Shamir are. If you admit Hezbollah is a terrorist organization, then there’s no context to put it in other than with other current terrorist organizations.

And if “international authorities” prosecuted the likes of Mladic but not Begin and Shamir, perhaps after looking at it all they decided they didn’t have a winning case despite the beliefs of some that they did?
Here is a thought: let’s say that the Irgun and Stern Gang had been labeled “terrorists” by “the West” during the 1940’s. Do you think that would have stopped their activities? Heck no! These Zionist terrorists murdered a British foreign minister and British at the King David Hotel and they murdered the UN mediator that had been sent to resolve the 1947-48 war, yet nothing consequential happened to these Zionist terrorists. Just words. Begin and Shamir were made PM’s. What a slap in the face to Justice.

So, I hardly think the fact that Hezbollah is labeled “terrorists” is going to change anything. They consider themselves “freedom fighters” in the exact same sense that the Zionist terrorists of the 1940’s thought of themselves as “freedom fighters.”
 
This was interesting. Right from a rebel’s mouth.

“They don’t have a revolutionary mindset,” he said, putting support for Assad at 70 percent among an urban population that includes many ethnic Kurds, Christians and members of Assad’s Alawite minority. But he also acknowledged that looting and other abuses had cost the incoming rebels much initial goodwill.

news.yahoo.com/insight-aleppo-misery-eats-syrian-rebel-support-074943116.html
 
This was interesting. Right from a rebel’s mouth.

“They don’t have a revolutionary mindset,” he said, putting support for Assad at 70 percent among an urban population that includes many ethnic Kurds, Christians and members of Assad’s Alawite minority.
That’s not surprising. Urban populations in many countries have quite a different life experience from the rural majority. They generally get the best of what the country has to offer and in some cases the urban-rural disparity can be as stark as if it were two different countries. Urban centers often contain the leader’s power base and so urban people tend to get preferential treatment. I can totally see why they might still support Assad.
But he also acknowledged that looting and other abuses had cost the incoming rebels much initial goodwill.
Sounds like the “war is messy” explanation I’ve been hearing from Assad supporters.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top