Taylor Marshall Asks Pope Francis whether he, Pope Francis, is a Heretic!

  • Thread starter Thread starter mjm076
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mjm076

Guest

I’m surprised this guy hasn’t been shut down by his diocese. He is making VERY serious accusations against our Holy Father!
 
Considering everything that has happened in the Vatican this past month (one of the Pope’s friends calling him an Arian, the Pope apologizing to pagans for faithful Catholics throwing out idols from God’s church, the Pope even calling said idols “Pachamamas”, etc) it is a pretty fair question to ask.

And he isn’t accusing The Pope, he is merely asking a question. Dont take him out of context. Have some charity.
 
Last edited:
Pope Francis has left himself open to this line of questioning with some of his recent statements and silences on issues.
I don’t think he is a heretic and i think he is due a bit more respect - on account of the office he holds, if not the man personally - but he’s doing himself no favours by not even acknowledging the valid questions and puzzlements of his brothers and sisters.
 
– unraveled more –

If you believe that the Church is unraveling, why would you want to wait for more? Or do I misunderstand your comment?
 
He loves Jesus’ church. I don’t blame him for losing sleep (if he is). The mere thought of Jesus’ Church going through it’s own time that mirrors that of the Church in the book of Ezekiel keeps me up sometimes too. God forbid people become scandalized by the Pope and they think idols in the Church is okay or that paganism is just a cultural thing and not a spiritual matter.

I dread the day that my bishop replaces my pastor with someone that would allow idols for the sake of “inculturing the church” and I have to talk to the pastor about it.
 
Lets see…

No one goes to hell, the condemned soul is annihilated. - no forceful denial

Jesus was not divine while on earth until after resurrection - no forceful denial

Yes it was an idol, but no problem with it in the Church…

Non-heretical but troubling statements/actions:

Insulting Priests who were saturnos/cossacks

People who make weapons cant be christian

Insulting large families: ie. “Breed Like Rabbits”

Per Vigano rehabilitating McCarrick; his refusal to comment.

Refusing to answer the Dubia

“I want the confusion.”

So yeah,

Fair Question.
 
And then you have someone in the Vatican trashing him (Taylor) on his wiki page.
 
Last edited:
Here’s the 2 cents of an adult convert from atheism who has been Catholic for 2 and a half decades and who has watched quite a few Marshall videos in the last year:

I gotta admit, I squirmed and couldn’t watch more than a minute or so.

Part of me squirmed because I remember when Gerry Mattitix (spelling?) went from Protestant to Catholic to SSPX.

But part of me really admires what Marshall has had the guts to do. He is only asking questions. He is asking the questions this V2-loving Catholic also has. He is opening the windows and giving us fresh air. Very V2.

Pope Francis is not JP2. I honestly don’t know what he is. Early in his pontificate, I started wearing a T-shirt with his picture because I LOVED all the things he said about the voiceless (I have felt voiceless in the Church for quite some time).

I remember being in a convenience store some 3-5 years ago, wearing the Francis T-shirt, and suddenly being yelled at by a Jewish woman who went on a tirade about Francis being anti-Jewish. She gave recent news examples.

I wasn’t following the news and didn’t know what she was talking about. I simply replied, “Believe me - I love Israel. I want the best for my Jewish brothers. I don’t know what you’re talking about, but I do know that it’s not the pope’s job to be political. It’s the pope’s job to save souls.”

Everyone in the store was tense during the exchange, and I think my words calmed things down. The woman became silent.

But I then started to pay attention to the news.

The first thing I heard was that Pope Francis was appointing a Chilean bishop whom, it seemed, everyone in Chile wanted prosecuted. Eventually, it turned out that there was good reason the Chileans felt that way. It became so clear that even Pope Francis recognized it and demanded the resignations of every Chilean bishop (every???).

Then the Summer of Shame, then Vigano, then the pontiff’s tirades about hating walls when he lives in a walled city - etc. The more words that come out of Pope Francis’ mouth, the more I want to vomit.

I mean that seriously: I have mental health issues (anxiety, depression, PTSD from being kidnapped and raped) which make me physically ill when in the presence of what I perceive as falsehoods and BS. Obviously, my emotions are in no way (not even in the least) infallible, but they’re not insane. I’m sorry, but anyone who thinks Pope Francis doesn’t have a lot of ‘xplainin’ to do is not paying attention. At best, he is a pope who so-far has no interest in making himself clear to thinking people who want to love both him and the Church.

I will never leave the Catholic Church (where else would I go?); I will never say Pope Francis isn’t the pope. But decades of apologetics have taught me that there have been many awful popes - and no pope is beyond criticism (Peter/Paul biblical kosher argument is the prime example - Medicis and Borgias also factor in).

So here I am: someone who has argued in person with SSPX members as much as she’s argued with JWs (i.e., A LOT).

And now, every time my Holy Father speaks, I feel ill. Please pray for me. Please pray for him. Please pray for Taylor. Please pray for the Church.
 
Now I know who Taylor Marshall is! I have watched some of his you tube videos, but I did not know that was Taylor Marshall. He was mentioned on another thread
and I had not heard of Taylor Marshall. Now it all makes sense.
 
I honestly think his video hit the rock bottom, Dr Marshall clearly doesn’t recognize anymore the Papal Authority. Now after his very recent tweet I am left wondering if he is heading soon toward SSPX.
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
Last edited:
Vatican internet went down shortly after Vatican IP address revealed as editing source
 
I think this is a valid concern about Taylor Marshall … to be honest I wouldn’t be surprised if quite a few like him (including Michael Voris) go down the SSPX path…
 
aroosi said:
I honestly think his video hit the rock bottom, Dr Marshall clearly doesn’t recognize anymore the Papal Authority. Now after his very recent tweet I am left wondering if he is heading soon toward SSPX.
Click to expand...
The SSPX recognize Francis as the pope. I am left wondering if Marshall is heading toward sedevacantism.
 
Last edited:
Trust me, im praying for the Pope as much as the next guy. Everytime he opens his mouth it gets harder and harder to pray for him. Pray for him, the clergy and pray for me so I dont abandon Jesus’ church over the scandals.
 
The other thread just got shut down by the mods . I am thinking this one will go the same way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top