Terribly hurt in a Christian church

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hislittlelady
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
…The girl answered, “Lord no. Thank God. They were saved.”
This girl is not our judge. Nor does she get to be her own judge, God help her. She needs our prayers. She is suffering from the sin of presumption.

Hislittlelady said:
“Don’t mention that word around here, you know it’s not appreciated.” A real bona fide Catholic bashing and they, not knowing that I was Catholic, sitting there with tears welling in my eyes from the deep pain they caused me.

You can take comfort from the scriptures that I’m sure they would say we know nothing about…
[18] For the word of the cross is folly to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God.
[19] For it is written, “I will destroy the wisdom of the wise,
and the cleverness of the clever I will thwart.”
[20] Where is the wise man? Where is the scribe? Where is the debater of this age? Has not God made foolish the wisdom of the world?
[21] For since, in the wisdom of God, the world did not know God through wisdom, it pleased God through the folly of what we preach to save those who believe.
[22] For Jews demand signs and Greeks seek wisdom,
[23] but we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles,
[24] but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God.
[25] For the foolishness of God is wiser than men, and the weakness of God is stronger than men.
[26] For consider your call, brethren; not many of you were wise according to worldly standards, not many were powerful, not many were of noble birth;
[27] but God chose what is foolish in the world to shame the wise, God chose what is weak in the world to shame the strong,
[28] God chose what is low and despised in the world, even things that are not, to bring to nothing things that are,
[29] so that no human being might boast in the presence of God.
[30] He is the source of your life in Christ Jesus, whom God made our wisdom, our righteousness and sanctification and redemption;
[31] therefore, as it is written, “Let him who boasts, boast of the Lord.” (1 Cor. 1:18-31)
Their boasting was not in the Lord, but in their own perceived rank in the world. They are in need of prayer.

Peace,
-Robert
 
Cinette virtually every thread started by JimmyB is offensive. I guess you have never noticed that even though others have complained.JimmyB is just the tip of the iceberg. I can have hard edge which I use to cut through what I see as intellectual dishonesty by Catholics,.
Cinette, another aspect I have noticed is that some posters cannot distinguish between questioning the doctrine of a faith and a personal attack. If I question the basis of a belief, I am not attacking the person who has that belief, I am questioning the belief itself. When a person cannot distinguish between the two, when they personalize everything, they bear the responsibility, the “attack” belongs to them.
Having said that, I submit that we could all be more charitable, and a great deal of good could come from just pondering and praying more before we speak, or type. Some may believe that a quick comeback makes them appear clever. But if they come here to CAF, or study their faith, with a view towards enabling themselves to take shots at others, and make the witty remark, they are failing in any effort to follow Jesus.
Hisalone has proven you right in her attack on Jimmy B. She makes attacks on our faith but she doesn’t see it as attacks because she thinks she is right. That is what I see about non-catholics. They think what they say is truthful and so they can say anything for instance we worship idols they don’t consider it an attack. They see what we say as untruthful and believe we are uncharitable and are quick to tell us so. They have no capability to see things in other people shoes.
 
Hisalone has proven you right in her attack on Jimmy B. She makes attacks on our faith but she doesn’t see it as attacks because she thinks she is right. That is what I see about non-catholics. They think what they say is truthful and so they can say anything for instance we worship idols they don’t consider it an attack. They see what we say as untruthful and believe we are uncharitable and are quick to tell us so. They have no capability to see things in other people shoes.
Adrift - I want to thank you for that comment - I am going to come back to this thread after the holidays. I will pray about it and give it a lot of thought because I believe that one does have to try to put oneself in another person’s shoes.

Just off the top of my head I have not had a lot of contact with JimmyB but what I recall is that he is bold and challenging and maybe has no patience for certain types. I don’t remember rudeness (although I have not been on many threads with him).

Hisalone struck me as a Fundamentalist and although it was explained time and again - painstakingly - that we do not worship idols - he would repeat the acusation! That gets people’s backs up. You cannot debate with someone who thinks he knows better than you what you believe!!!:eek:

My husband always says that intelligence goes together with a sense of humour. Maybe we should use humour more:extrahappy: :love: :extrahappy: :love: :love:

I will come back to Adrift’s posting and reflect on everything in it in case I missed something. It might make me understand the other person better. In any case if, as a result, I get to understand others better, it should make the communication more effective - and that is the purpose of these forums, to gain a better understanding of one another.

I have to rush because we have to leave for the airport in 4 hours and have still to attend Mass and…have not yet packed!!!

Happy Christmas everybody - enjoy your families - don’t let anybody spend Christmas alone (invite them to join your celebration)

Cinette:)
 
I went to my grandson’s Christmas play last night. I am Catholic, and my daughter passed away six years ago, and her children stayed with their daddy. He has remarried and he and his new wife decided that the Catholic church was not for them so therefore, they left and joined a Christian church. It’s probably Baptist based. That’s fine, although I’m disappointed that my grandchildren are not of my own church, but I’m so grateful they are being raised in the faith and being taught Jesus is the center of their lives.

When I arrived at their church some ladies invited me to sit at a table in their vestibule as we waited for the play to start. We had about an hour wait. They didn’t include me much in the conversation, but I understood that since they didn’t know me. I quietly sat as they conversed and one asked the other how was a wedding she had recently gone to and was it a Catholic wedding? I guess this other girl must have had Catholic relatives. The girl answered, “Lord no. Thank God. They were saved.” That was insult number one.

Insult number two came when the woman made another comment saying “Don’t mention that word around here, you know it’s not appreciated.” A real bona fide Catholic bashing and they, not knowing that I was Catholic, sitting there with tears welling in my eyes from the deep pain they caused me. This brought such a deep insight about how minorities feel when they are persecuted and ostracized just because of their color, their race, or any other person who might not quite fit into the mold. I believe this was a true sign from God for me as a lesson to be learned. How the other person feels.

I can only say I was so wounded and so distraught from feeling their hatred, and believe me, it was hatred. Out and out disgust on their part from the faces they made and the smirks. I told them then that I was Catholic and they didn’t even flinch except that they only ignored me more. It was awful.

I only want to say to all my other Christian brothers and sisters, who might in the past have said things about Catholics, “please don’t.” We are Christian people, we love the Lord, we obey His commands, we follow two thousand years of apostolic teachings, nor have I ever heard a fellow Catholic bash a Protestant, or speak against them. This was a lesson to me from the Lord and I pray to let it be a lesson to you as well. The wound is deep within me, that’s how badly it hurt my heart. I never knew we were that hated. It’s a terrible thing to feel.

May God bless you all and I pray for all Christian people in spite of the church they attend or their personal walk with Jesus, as well as all my non-Christian brothers and sisters, please refrain from saying things that one day you may have to account for when you are standing before the Lord’s throne.

Catholics are not evil, we are not the whore of babylon, we have a loving holy Pope who sits in the chair of St. Peter from a long line of popes before him, and we are taught through the apostolic church which is two thousand years old. I hope you all understand this. Thank you all for reading my statement of faith and of pain inflicted on me.

😦 :blessyou: :highprayer:
I’ve had many similar experiences. That’s why I generally avoid sharing my faith or spiritual experiences with non-Catholics. If I ever left my faith, which I wouldn’t, of course, I’d go in the direction of Liberal Christianity. I’d fall in with the folks who welcome gays, ordain women, and do all the things conservative Christians dislike. At least that brand of Christianity is truly tolerant.
 
Adrift - I want to thank you for that comment - I am going to come back to this thread after the holidays. I will pray about it and give it a lot of thought because I believe that one does have to try to put oneself in another person’s shoes.

Just off the top of my head I have not had a lot of contact with JimmyB but what I recall is that** he is bold and challenging and maybe has no patience for certain types.** I don’t remember rudeness (although I have not been on many threads with him).

Hisalone struck me as a Fundamentalist and although it was explained time and again - painstakingly - that we do not worship idols - he would repeat the acusation! That gets people’s backs up. You cannot debate with someone who thinks he knows better than you what you believe!!!:eek:

My husband always says that intelligence goes together with a sense of humour. Maybe we should use humour more:extrahappy: :love: :extrahappy: :love: :love:

I will come back to Adrift’s posting and reflect on everything in it in case I missed something. It might make me understand the other person better. In any case if, as a result, I get to understand others better, it should make the communication more effective - and that is the purpose of these forums, to gain a better understanding of one another.

I have to rush because we have to leave for the airport in 4 hours and have still to attend Mass and…have not yet packed!!!

Happy Christmas everybody - enjoy your families - don’t let anybody spend Christmas alone (invite them to join your celebration)

Cinette:)
I think he is just passionate in his belief and wants to challange our non-catholic brothers and sisters to think really hard about their beliefs.
The questions he have here are are some of questions I answered truthfully in my hearth without bias to any particular denomination to get to the truth.
It took me three christian denominations and and 5 years to finally find out that I left the truth in the catholic church.😃
 
I pray for them and for you.

One minor problem in the modern world that stems from our education system is that we have lost the ability to debate. Most Americans, and I would bet other nationalities as well, no longer have the ability to discuss issues without, at some level making it personal. It may be a personal issue within them or they may make it a personal attack on the other person.

I have been told by many, many non-Catholics that I am damned no matter what because I am Catholic. Just going to a Catholic Church, according to them, is the unforgivable sin. Now, it is one thing to tell me why you FEEL or THINK that the Catholic Church is wrong. You have NO AUTHORITY OR RIGHT to tell me that I am damned for anything. As I have gotten older, this is the one area that my charity has gone down. After all, if I am going to hell, I might as well make them upset first 😛 .

Seriously, those people are ignorant, small minded, heartless, brainless, and uneducated. We should pity them and pray for them. We should also be very worried about the society that allows this type of person to develop and prosper. They should have long ago been taught manners, decorum, and facts. both theological and historical.
 
I am very optimistic that at least some people in this world can have intelligent and respectful debates. This whole issue really needs to be brought to the forefront. While I would never even dream of hating, persecuting, or condemning my other Christian brothers and sisters, there are many that still must learn this lesson. It’s too important not to. I"m a great fan of EWTN, and from there I learn tolerance. In particular, from Father Groeschel. This Godly man ministers to everyone, no matter denomination. While a firm Catholic, he has the utmost respect for all and is a wonderful example of how we should all be with each other.

There are books out there on the history of the Holy Apostolic Church which is two thousand years old. I’ve learned so much from the book I read and it explains why there are the divisions in the church, why they happened, and who knows, just maybe, God in His merciful heart, speaks to each of us in the way we can understand. This is why it’s not good to persecute anyone for the church they lean towards. This is probably God’s way and God’s business and who are we to even dare to question HIm.

When He revealed Himself to Sister Faustina in His Divine Mercy, He said to her that He wanted to save every single soul. Do you think every single soul is going to turn Catholic? This is why I believe the Lord speaks to one’s heart and leads them in the best way they can understand. I understand the Catholic way, and someone else may understand the Protestant way. One thing remains though. Truth will always be truth and we each must seek that truth.

We are born with the instinct that there is a higher power then us. Maybe some do not agree, but I feel this is true. Then it’s our job to go on a quest and search for the truth.

I thank all of you so much for making my heart feel better about my recent persecution incident. Of course I know not everyone is this way as that woman was. She committed a sin by what she did to me. She was plain hateful. That’s not right. You can’t be a Catholic filled with hate for non-Catholics, nor can you be a non-Catholic Christian and be filled with hate for Catholics.

I say let’s all hold hands together and march on the road that leads to the heavenly Kingdom, and you can be sure, no matter which way you are worshipping our Jesus, if you believe in Him, the sacrifice He made for you, and obey His teachings, you will be saved. Maybe I sound liberal but I’m really not. Just realistic. I am a firm Catholic and I believe in all things Catholic, but let’s reason here. God has his own ways of doing things and let us keep to our own affairs. We just don’t know what God’s plan is or how he goes about it. I only know He wants to save every single soul.

I praise you Lord for You are my salvation :highprayer: :bible1:
 
.

I believe in my one Holy Catholic Apostolic church, and to quote Father Groeschel from EWTN, he stated that to become a Catholic, one must first be given the grace to do so, and also that he made it understood that all Christians are precious to God, not just us Catholics. I think these ladies are in darkness to speak so of us and to judge in such a miserable way.
Imperfect though we are, God lives in us, and does His work through us. We are the living body-- the “church”–of Christ, so whatever happens to us, happens to Him. Consider the words of writer Frederick Buechner in, *“A Room Called Remember”: *God chooses “for his holy work in the world…lamebrains and misfits and nitpickers and holier-than-thous and stuffed shirts and odd ducks and egomaniacs and milquetoasts and closet sensualists.” We are no different today than those who denied, deserted and betrayed Christ in His own time. Yet now, as then, he entrusts His work to us! The book, *“Disappointment With God” * by Philip Yancey discusses this in greater detail. A great read!
 
Yes I agree with you Triciacat. We are the body of Christ. The church is the body of Christ. Even with all the divisions among the Christian religions, I still think that we are all the ‘body of Christ.’

It’s such a terrible shame that all Christianity cannot become one big church, but sadly I do not foresee anything even coming close to that happening, not now, and probably not ever. There are way too many differences in beliefs and customs. No one will bend but for a few that convert either way. Some go from Catholic to Protestant and some go from Protestant to Catholic, so I guess there is no way that can ever happen. But it’s a very good thing even to agree to disagree. There’s no harm in that and arguing or insulting is not acceptable. That woman was a prime example of true hatred for another’s beliefs. I learned an awful lot from that incident about what bigotry and persecution really means and what it can do to a person.

A number of years ago when my faith had reached a low point, I went on a quest to search for truth, and I did read that Philip Yancy book and he’s quite a good writer, and in my seeking and searching, although I was born and raised Catholic, I came to sort of a crossroads at that time and could have swung either way, but in the end my heart led me back to the Catholic church. This does not mean that people that do not understand Catholic teaching are wrong in their personal walk with Jesus. It only means they hear the word in a different way. This is my take on it anyway.

God has always used broken vessels and cracked pots. We are just so darn useless and unless God molds us and changes us from the inside out, we aren’t worth much. We have to be willing vessels, every one of us, and then through the blood of the Lamb we are made worthy.

I’m so happy to see that there are still people from other divisions of Christianity that can discuss with respect and intelligence without biting one another’s heads off. It’s a great pleasure to me. It is also good to know about each others beliefs and ways of worship and even in the face of disagreeing with each other’s beliefs, it still opens a door to unity of sorts which is a good thing.

Thanks so much to all of you for sharing so beautifully.

God bless and keep every one of you here
 
I think you show a tremendous amount of insight! God’s ways are mysterious–how and why He leads us where He does is where we should be! “Thy will be done…” (Matthew 6:10) Why, when we pray this prayer in earnest, do we not believe it happens???

I’m glad you are feeling better after that nasty attack. You are fabulous!

Peace of Christ!
 
Hislittlelady:

Did you remember, depsite your hurt, to rejoice?

“Blessed are you when they insult you and persecute you and utter every kind of evil against you falsely because of me. Be glad and rejoice, for your reward is very great in heaven. For so they persecuted the prophets that were before you.” (Matthew 5:11-12)
 
Did you speak to your SIL and his wife about this? Your Catholic grandchildren are being taught these things, this is tragic.
 
i have been through these attacks many times. it is ok with me.

if we could just get them to think about this. what is the difference between those who were taught by Christ Himself and those who picked up the Bible many many years later? who are the True followers of Christ? those who were ordained by Christ Himself or those who picked up the Bible many many years after?

:highprayer: :byzsoc: :takeoff:
 
There was a show the other night called “Momma’s Boys”
It is a reality show about three young men who with the help of their mothers will choose a girl to marry.
Anyway, one of these mothers called herself " A DEVOUT CATHOLIC".
I was so ashamed to hear what came out of her mouth as she was describing the ideal girl for her son.
The following were her requirements:
She MUST be white.
She MUST NOT be Black, Asian or Biracial.
She MUST NOT come from a divorced family.
She MUST be Catholic.
She MUST do as I say.

Is this what the Catholic religion is all about? BIGOTRY!
Where is the love for others that Jusus taught us? Where is the feeling of unity in knowing that we were all created equal, that the color of the skin does NOT matter?

That woman had the audacity to go on TV and say all those awful things without thinking of how her remarks would hurt all those girls who were black, asians and biracial and keep on repeating how she wanted a nice cathoic girl just like her!

Sad, very sad if a so called catholic talks like that!
 
Sadly, I used to be one of those people who ridiculed the Catholic church. I came out of Mormonism straight into a Pentecostal church. I am married to a life long Catholic… I went through RCIA and straddled the two churches for a long time.

Long story short, when I went through an incredibly hurtful time with the Assembly of God, (from the local Pastor to the main headquarters in Springfield, IL ) I knew where to turn. I went straight to the Catholic church kicking and screaming and found peace and love there in the congregation and through my wonderful Priest, Fr. Denny.

God works in mysterious ways. Throughout my time trying to “get my husband saved”, he kept steady and Jesus guided our path. Each time I receive communion it is not just a motion. It is so dear to me that I am flooded with His love and Grace!

I will pray for your grandchildren that Jesus stays with them and that they will understand His Love.

in Christ
Steph

:hug1:
 
. . . he and his new wife decided that the Catholic church was not for them so therefore, they left and joined a Christian church. It’s probably Baptist based. That’s fine, although I’m disappointed that my grandchildren are not of my own church, but I’m so grateful they are being raised in the faith and being taught Jesus is the center of their lives. . .
Laudetur Iesus Christus.

This paragraph seems deeply misguided. Based on this representation it is not true that these children are being “raised in the faith.”

“. . . There is no such thing as a religion called “Christianity” – there never has been such a religion.

There is and always has been the Church, and various heresies proceeding from a rejection of some of the Church’s doctrines by men who still desire to retain the rest of her teaching and morals. But there never has been and never can be or will be a general Christian religion professed by men who all accept some central, important doctrines, while agreeing to differ about others. There has always been, from the beginning, and will always be, the Church, and sundry heresies either doomed to decay, or, like Mohammedanism, to grow into a separate religion. Of a common Christianity there never has been and never can be a definition, for it has never existed.” – Hilaire Belloc, The Great Heresies, (1938).

One cannot love our separated brethren, without realizing this. Worse, one cannot resist the downward tendency of the “slippery slope” of the protestant mindset without realizing this.

Pax Christi nobiscum.

John Hiner
 
Hislittlelady, I too am so sorry that this happened to you. Reading your story made me feel sad inside. You know as strange as it might sound, I never really knew how much people don’t like Catholics up until a few months ago. To this day, I still don’t know why. I’ve heard things such as people thinking that Catholicism is a cult, and that we are not true Christians, etc, and it baffles me. A cult?? Not Christians?? I mean, I just can’t figure out why people say such things.
This reminds me of a time when I was at work, and I was wearing a Sacred Heart of Jesus medal. A guy that I was assisting asked me if I was Catholic, and I told him yes. Then he said, “Hmmm.” In my mind, I couldn’t help but wonder why he responded like that.
 
This reminds me of a time when I was at work, and I was wearing a Sacred Heart of Jesus medal. A guy that I was assisting asked me if I was Catholic, and I told him yes. Then he said, “Hmmm.” In my mind, I couldn’t help but wonder why he responded like that.
Maybe he was thinking good thoughts! He could have been trying to “figure you out” by categorizing you. One would have to read into the body language accompanying the “Hmmm.” Perhaps he even liked you? ❤️
 
Laudetur Iesus Christus.

This paragraph seems deeply misguided. Based on this representation it is not true that these children are being “raised in the faith.”

“. . . There is no such thing as a religion called “Christianity” – there never has been such a religion.

There is and always has been the Church, and various heresies proceeding from a rejection of some of the Church’s doctrines by men who still desire to retain the rest of her teaching and morals. But there never has been and never can be or will be a general Christian religion professed by men who all accept some central, important doctrines, while agreeing to differ about others. There has always been, from the beginning, and will always be, the Church, and sundry heresies either doomed to decay, or, like Mohammedanism, to grow into a separate religion. Of a common Christianity there never has been and never can be a definition, for it has never existed.” – Hilaire Belloc, The Great Heresies, (1938).

One cannot love our separated brethren, without realizing this. Worse, one cannot resist the downward tendency of the “slippery slope” of the protestant mindset without realizing this.

Pax Christi nobiscum.

John Hiner
Thank you so much for your response and you are absolutely one hundred percent correct. I should have clarified what I said. I’m not at all happy that they are not being raised in the “Church”, which you and I both agree upon which one is the “Church.”, however, I’m just grateful that they are getting to know Jesus at all. For this I am grateful. I have no say since my Daughter died, and these are her children and I cannot control what the father does concerning them, so what I really meant was I’m grateful that they are being taught Jesus at all. Praise God for this small comfort.

I’m praying all the time that some day, even maybe after I’m gone, they will themselves seek the fullness of truth in our own Catholic Church which I believe is the true Church. I let them come to mass with me always hoping and praying that they will be drawn to my own faith and the Church of Jesus started from the apostles. The little one has expressed a deep interest and he’s just under eight years old, but the older one likes the church she’s being brought up in. For this I’m not happy but still grateful that she is getting teachings of Jesus at all. I’m going to keep praying that my grandchildren will make that decision as they grow older, and if they don’t, then the father is to blame because he’s instilling this deeply in them and then I will entrust them to the Lord. Please, no offense to anyone, I’m not trying to start a debate here. Just expressing my own views since I’m on a Catholic forum here. But thank you for giving me this opportunity to clarify my statement and for reminding me to make my statement much more clear in the future. God bless you now and always.:blushing: :highprayer:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top