The Catholic Church wrong? Part two

  • Thread starter Thread starter twb1621
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s amazing if you think about it–hundreds of thousands of pastors, scholars, missionaries and ministries with incredible results, looking often much more like the explosion in the book of Acts than the RCC has ever seen, and yet none of them are led by the Holy Spirit or guided in interpretation by rhe Holy Spirit! (Edited)
1 - Define “incredible results”.

2 - “much more…than the RCC has ever seen…” - Did you miss the first 1500 years of Roman Catholic evangelization before the Reformation? Did John Wesley convert the Roman Empire, North Africa, India, the Far East, the New World, etc. and I didn’t hear about it?
 
And the assumption is that if you don’t instill some fear in people, they just won’t perform! That is LAW, my friend. And the truly born again person is out from under that system.
Amazing! So, you reject the two “new” commandments of Christ? You know the ones:
  1. Love God with your whole heart, mind, and soul.
  2. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.
According to your belief, Jesus is just trying to scare everyone.
 
It is about unconditional acceptance from a Father who has the power, love, desire and promise to complete the work He has begun in me, and to be to me FOREVER the perfect Father. That’s a critical difference between the RCC and Evangelicals.
Because the Father unconditionally accepts you doesn’t prevent you from unconditionally rejecting Him through mortal sin.

What’s this forgiving/not forgiving of sins directive that Jesus laid on the Apostles if it’s rendered moot by being “born again” (as you understand the concept)?

You can cherry pick the epistles all day, but if your point of view is contradicted elsewhere, it’s clearly not the right exegesis.
 
It’s amazing if you think about it–hundreds of thousands of pastors, scholars, missionaries and ministries with incredible results, looking often much more like the explosion in the book of Acts than the RCC has ever seen, and yet none of them are led by the Holy Spirit or guided in interpretation by rhe Holy Spirit! You guys are seriously in a world of denial and the emperor truly has no clothes on.
What out Martin, you’re revealing your spots.

The difference in TWB’s and Hank’s post is that TWB never hinted the Holy Spirit wasn’t with your pastors. Hank’s seems to indicate that the Catholic is nothing but fallible men, no Holy Spirit whatsoever.

So which one of those two is in serious denial?!?!?

BTW, when you guys get to 1 billion strong, all teaching the very same thing, then you can compare yourself to the Church’s explosion in the book of Acts to the Catholic Church today.
 
twb1621;4550976:
It’s amazing if you think about it–hundreds of thousands of pastors, scholars, missionaries and ministries with incredible results, looking often much more like the explosion in the book of Acts than the RCC has ever seen, and yet none of them are led by the Holy Spirit or guided in interpretation by rhe Holy Spirit! You guys are seriously in a world of denial and the emperor truly has no clothes on.
ok who are you talking about, HankZ or my post, you’re confusing in this one…
 
It’s amazing if you think about it–hundreds of thousands of pastors, scholars, missionaries and ministries with incredible results, looking often much more like the explosion in the book of Acts than the RCC has ever seen, and yet none of them are led by the Holy Spirit or guided in interpretation by rhe Holy Spirit! You guys are seriously in a world of denial and the emperor truly has no clothes on.
ok who are you talking about, HankZ or my post, you’re confusing in this one…
 
twb1621;4551296:
I do believe in scripture. It tells me that all believers in Jesus will be given the Holy Spirit. I get the feeling from this, you think that only the church leaders are allowed the Holy Spirit. Is that what you’re saying?
thats not what I said but it shows how off the wall you can be with the responses you come up with. Read it again Hank, a little more carefully. And stop being so selective with which Gospel verses you choose to believe in.
 
HankZ;4551378:
The Holy Spirit is received in the method and matter of the Sacraments. If you believe that everyone is just “given” the Holy Spirit, I presume you view baptism as empty ceremony?
the quoted text is HankZ’s not mine, just to clear that up…:rolleyes:
 
TM30
The Holy Spirit is received in the method and matter of the Sacraments. If you believe that everyone is just “given” the Holy Spirit, I presume you view baptism as empty ceremony?
the quoted text is HankZ’s not mine, just to clear that up…:rolleyes:
 
I do believe in scripture. It tells me that all believers in Jesus will be given the Holy Spirit. I get the feeling from this, you think that only the church leaders are allowed the Holy Spirit. Is that what you’re saying?
All who are baptized into Christ become partakers of His Spirit. No, what we are saying is that the promise of the HS to be guided into all truth was given to the church. That is the body of believers in union with the Apostles. There was no promise given that any one individual would be prevented from straying away from that Truth.

Since the believers separated from the unity with the successor of Peter, more and more splinters and separations have occurred. We see a divergence from unity, which is not the fruit for which Jesus prayed.
 
HankZ;4551378:
thats not what I said but it shows how off the wall you can be with the responses you come up with. Read it again Hank, a little more carefully. And stop being so selective with which Gospel verses you choose to believe in.
Hmmmm… I haven’t seen any of these “quote issues” since JustAsking4 was banned.
 
whats going on with the references to who quotes what anyway. They seem goofed up…
When you see your quote begin with two “quote=”'s, you need to delete the 2nd one.

Justasking4 used to cause this problem. He/she said that they would cut the quote and insert it into a word document, and then cut and paste it back. All I know is that it messed things up, just like its happening here.
 
the NT was written by Catholics, Martin. St. Paul is writing what the Catholic Church believes and teaches.
You have it backwards, but that was not my point. Paul was a Jew, trained under Gamliel, who was converted to Christ when He appeared to him, and he became a missionary and was chosen by God to teach the gatherings of born again people, in churches throughout the Mediteranean area, and he had him write letters which were the very Word of God. Beleivers quickly saw this was doctrine from God. So, first things first. But my simple question is, do you believe what he teaches–that all believers, myself included are saints? Not a trick question, guano.
 
1 - Define “incredible results”.

2 - “much more…than the RCC has ever seen…” - Did you miss the first 1500 years of Roman Catholic evangelization before the Reformation? Did John Wesley convert the Roman Empire, North Africa, India, the Far East, the New World, etc. and I didn’t hear about it?
Yeh, and tell me about the vitality of the spirituality of those Rome ‘converted’
 
Yeh, and tell me about the vitality of the spirituality of those Rome ‘converted’
“Vitality of the Spirituality”?!? We are judged by how much “vitality” we have, now? I must have missed that bible class!
 
Amazing! So, you reject the two “new” commandments of Christ? You know the ones:
  1. Love God with your whole heart, mind, and soul.
  2. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.
According to your belief, Jesus is just trying to scare everyone.
You, my dear friend, are a legalist who has yet to have that “Aha” moment where the incredible, eternal, PERFECT work of the cross becomes the shattering of all barriers between you and God. You think God has Christians on probation. You are still under the Law and are the target audience (minus the Jewish influence) of Paul when he fervently warned against those who teach another gospel. They weren’t teaching another religion or something pagan, they were teaching Jesus with conditions–“Another Jesus”, as Paul called it when he cursed them. He says in Colossians that Jesus destroyed the enmity between us and God–forever. Evangelicals believe that their all-poserful, all loving Father knew every sin we would EVER commit before He saved us, and did it anyway, placing those sins on His Son. They are separated from Him “as far as the east is from the west” and it is a disgrace that you want to dredge them up. That is why Paul said, “BEING CONFIDENT OF THIS VERY THING, THAT HE WHO BEGAN A GOOD WORK IN YOU WILL CONTINUE IT UNTIL THE DAY OF JESUS CHRIST” Believers are eternally seated with Christ in the heavenlies (Eph 2) and they are literall part of Christ’s body. Your theology would require Him to cut an arm or a foot off. One day, I pray, you will understand how AMAZING Grace REALLY is.
 
You, my dear friend, are a legalist who has yet to have that “Aha” moment where the incredible, eternal, PERFECT work of the cross becomes the shattering of all barriers between you and God. You think God has Christians on probation. You are still under the Law and are the target audience (minus the Jewish influence) of Paul when he fervently warned against those who teach another gospel. They weren’t teaching another religion or something pagan, they were teaching Jesus with conditions–“Another Jesus”, as Paul called it when he cursed them. He says in Colossians that Jesus destroyed the enmity between us and God–forever. Evangelicals believe that their all-poserful, all loving Father knew every sin we would EVER commit before He saved us, and did it anyway, placing those sins on His Son. They are separated from Him “as far as the east is from the west” and it is a disgrace that you want to dredge them up. That is why Paul said, “BEING CONFIDENT OF THIS VERY THING, THAT HE WHO BEGAN A GOOD WORK IN YOU WILL CONTINUE IT UNTIL THE DAY OF JESUS CHRIST” Believers are eternally seated with Christ in the heavenlies (Eph 2) and they are literall part of Christ’s body. Your theology would require Him to cut an arm or a foot off. One day, I pray, you will understand how AMAZING Grace REALLY is.
Sniff, sniff… Do I smell the heresy of Once Saved Always Saved?
 
Well, Hank, the fact is that we embrace a faith that has transcended many languages and cultures, and the best we can do to understand it is to educate ourselves in those cultures and languages in which our faith is rooted. For example, Jesus testified that “salvation is of the Jews”. We know that all that was written in the OT is there for our instruction, and is a shadow of what was to come. If we understand the shadows then we will have a better appreciation for the fulfillment. The NT was written originally in Aramaic and Greek. Knowing some things about these languages greately enriches our faith. If you are serious about having the HS show you more about your faith, then I encourage you to be open to these things. 👍
Guano–I wanted to continue some discussion you painstakenly detailed on the thread that just closed…and by the way, thanks for the advice on checking posts. I am gonig to try that.
 
You have it backwards, but that was not my point. Paul was a Jew, trained under Gamliel, who was converted to Christ when He appeared to him, and he became a missionary and was chosen by God to teach the gatherings of born again people, in churches throughout the Mediteranean area, and he had him write letters which were the very Word of God. Beleivers quickly saw this was doctrine from God. So, first things first. But my simple question is, do you believe what he teaches–that all believers, myself included are saints? Not a trick question, guano.
not in one little bit…why even demons believe in God:p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top