The day after pill

  • Thread starter Thread starter ADiosgracias
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Essentially, if a drug simply prevents conception after a rape BUT DOES NOT destroy a zygote/whatever, it can theoretically be allowed by the Church, since such a thing is not an abortion.
 
What did the Vatican say about this? Isn’t contraception intrinsically evil?
 
What did the Vatican say about this? Isn’t contraception intrinsically evil?
No. What is evil is not the use of contraception in itself, but committing a sexual act which is not open to life. You are completely free to take the birth control pill or wear a condom whenever you like; you simply may not have sex if you do. But since the victim in a rape does not commit the sex act voluntarily, she is not morally culpable for its having been committed in a manner not open to life.
 
This is incorrect. Please bear in mind, only in the cases of rape. From the National Catholic Bioethics Center, Fr. Tad Pacholczyk.
It is permissible, then, for Catholic hospitals to provide their patients with morning-after pills if the following four conditions are met:


  1. *]The woman is not already pregnant from prior, freely-chosen sexual activity.
    *]The woman has been sexually assaulted.
    *]The woman has not yet ovulated (i.e. has not released an egg from her ovary into the fallopian tube where it could be fertilized by the attacker’s sperm).
    *]The morning-after pill can reasonably be expected to prevent her from ovulating.

  1. The Morning After
 
Those Bishops contradict the Church teaching on this.
The Church does NOT permit the morning after pill to be used.
No, the bishops are in seeming communion with the Church. A typical protcol for emergency contraception in a Catholic hospital is to first administer a pregancy test and, if time permits, an ovulation test. Only in the case of negative results is the contraception administered.

Plan B inhibits ovulation. That is, it prevents an egg from ever having an opporunity for conception. In the case of rape, this is not an offense against chastity, it is legitmate self defense against an unjust aggressor.

The reason that an ovulation test is done if time permits is that Plan B also causes a slight thinning of the uterine lining. Although there is no scientific evidence of this preventing implantation of a fertilized zygote, the bishops/Catholic hospitals error on the side of life.

Blessed John Paul wrote about this distinction and reinforced the understanding that Humanae Vitae refers to voluntary acts of love. Similarly, Pope Benedict XVI gave some clarifying comments on contraception, chastity, and morality last year.

The Pontifical Academy for Life wrote a pastoral document that condemns all use of abortificants, which is completely coherent with Church teaching, since direct abortions are always a “grave moral disorder” (Evangelium Vitae). But emergency contraception in the case of rape is not an abortion, since there is no zygote involved. Emergency contraception for contraceptive purposes would still be illicit as an offense against chastity, but, again, rape is an attack.

Think about it morally for a second. A rape victim could licitly deliver a mortal blow to her attacker and not be guilty of sin (CCC 2264). The attacker is a fully formed human person. But, using your reasoning, she could kill the attacker but could not prevent the attacker’s sperm from fertilizing one of her eggs!?

Zygotes are precious because they are human life. But sperm from a violent criminal is not more sacred than a fully formed human person.

Pax Christi
 
No, the bishops are in seeming communion with the Church. A typical protcol for emergency contraception in a Catholic hospital is to first administer a pregancy test and, if time permits, an ovulation test. Only in the case of negative results is the contraception administered.

Plan B inhibits ovulation. That is, it prevents an egg from ever having an opporunity for conception. In the case of rape, this is not an offense against chastity, it is legitmate self defense against an unjust aggressor.

The reason that an ovulation test is done if time permits is that Plan B also causes a slight thinning of the uterine lining. Although there is no scientific evidence of this preventing implantation of a fertilized zygote, the bishops/Catholic hospitals error on the side of life.

Blessed John Paul wrote about this distinction and reinforced the understanding that Humanae Vitae refers to voluntary acts of love. Similarly, Pope Benedict XVI gave some clarifying comments on contraception, chastity, and morality last year.

The Pontifical Academy for Life wrote a pastoral document that condemns all use of abortificants, which is completely coherent with Church teaching, since direct abortions are always a “grave moral disorder” (Evangelium Vitae). But emergency contraception in the case of rape is not an abortion, since there is no zygote involved. Emergency contraception for contraceptive purposes would still be illicit as an offense against chastity, but, again, rape is an attack.

Think about it morally for a second. A rape victim could licitly deliver a mortal blow to her attacker and not be guilty of sin (CCC 2264). The attacker is a fully formed human person.** But, using your reasoning, she could kill the attacker but could not prevent the attacker’s sperm from fertilizing one of her eggs**!?

Zygotes are precious because they are human life. But sperm from a violent criminal is not more sacred than a fully formed human person.

Pax Christi
That is correct.
 
Those Bishops contradict the Church teaching on this.
The Church does NOT permit the morning after pill to be used.
The Church teaches life begins at the moment of conception. Even in the case as the OP describes…no one can be certain that life has not been created in the hours following. This could only be determined a few weeks out.

Therefore I fully accept that the morning after pill is not in line with Catholic Church moral theology.
 
Fact sheet from the USCCB website:
Treatment of Victims of Sexual Assault
Victims of sexual assault should be treated with compassion and understanding. Health care providers who treat sexual assault victims should provide medically accurate information and offer spiritual and psychological support.
A woman who has been raped should be able to defend herself from a potential conception and receive treatments to suppress ovulation and incapacitate sperm. If conception has occurred, however, a Catholic hospital will not dispense drugs to interfere with implantation of a newly conceived human embryo.
Hospitals should develop appropriate protocols to determine whether administering emergency contraception would have an abortifacient effect. Tests are available to determine whether ovulation has occurred.
Fact Sheet:Emergency Contraception and Treatment of Victims of Sexual Assault
 
The Church teaches life begins at the moment of conception. Even in the case as the OP describes…no one can be certain that life has not been created in the hours following. This could only be determined a few weeks out.

Therefore I fully accept that the morning after pill is not in line with Catholic Church moral theology.
There seems to be some real confusion over modern biology. The hospital can test for ovulation and conception using modern blood and hormonal markers almost immediately.

The emergency contraceptions used in Catholic hospitals are not abortificants. They are a massive hormone dose that prevents ovulation. that is, no egg with an opporunity for conception. It is, contraception, not abortion.

Abortion is always a grave moral disorder, contraception is not. For example, nuns can licitly use oral contraceptives for other health issues, because they have no reasonable expectation of sexual intercourse in the general model of chastity and proper marriage in the Church.

The bishops are holding, with some recorded support of two popes, that this is, carefully administered, licit self defense. Clearly, Catholics can dissent with the Magisterium on the matter, but I find the logic morally troubling.

For example, using Thistle’s reasoning above, it would not be licit for a woman to continue resisting a rape attack after penetration, because coitus interruptus is contraception in Catholic teaching. To me, that is a reprehensible concept and I am glad that I am in agreement with the Magisterium on the matter.

Pax Christi
 
There seems to be some real confusion over modern biology. The hospital can test for ovulation and conception using modern blood and hormonal markers almost immediately.

The emergency contraceptions used in Catholic hospitals are not abortificants. They are a massive hormone dose that prevents ovulation. that is, no egg with an opporunity for conception. It is, contraception, not abortion.

Abortion is always a grave moral disorder, contraception is not. For example, nuns can licitly use oral contraceptives for other health issues, because they have no reasonable expectation of sexual intercourse in the general model of chastity and proper marriage in the Church.

The bishops are holding, with some recorded support of two popes, that this is, carefully administered, licit self defense. Clearly, Catholics can dissent with the Magisterium on the matter, but I find the logic morally troubling.

For example, using Thistle’s reasoning above, it would not be licit for a woman to continue resisting a rape attack after penetration, because coitus interruptus is contraception in Catholic teaching. To me, that is a reprehensible concept and I am glad that I am in agreement with the Magisterium on the matter.

Pax Christi
When the main purpose of a contraceptive is to prevent pregnancy it is a grave sin. That is the Church teaching.
 
When the main purpose of a contraceptive is to prevent pregnancy it is a grave sin. That is the Church teaching.
In which case, the morning after pill, assuming a contraceptive only effect, would be fine, as its intent is the same as with all other defesive actions - preventing or limiting the effect of attack on the victim. A gun of course would be preferable, as it can limit the attack with greater effect and sooner than a contraceptive, but if a gun isnt available, contraceptive would be fine. (And just like a gun might also harm innocent life and still may be used if that risk is small enough, contraceptives might be used if the risk is deemed small enough) .
 
In which case, the morning after pill, assuming a contraceptive only effect, would be fine, as its intent is the same as with all other defesive actions - preventing or limiting the effect of attack on the victim. A gun of course would be preferable, as it can limit the attack with greater effect and sooner than a contraceptive, but if a gun isnt available, contraceptive would be fine. (And just like a gun might also harm innocent life and still may be used if that risk is small enough, contraceptives might be used if the risk is deemed small enough) .
Wrong. The prime purpose of all contraceptives is to prevent pregnancy. Contraception does not prevent the act of rape. While rape is a vicious evil thing contraception by the rapist before the act or by the victim the day after does not justify contraception.
Contraception to prevent pregnancy is not permitted under any circumstances. That is the Church teaching, no matter if some Bishops disagree with the Church on this.
 
Wrong. The prime purpose of all contraceptives is to prevent pregnancy. Contraception does not prevent the act of rape. While rape is a vicious evil thing contraception by the rapist before the act or by the victim the day after does not justify contraception.
Contraception to prevent pregnancy is not permitted under any circumstances. That is the Church teaching, no matter if some Bishops disagree with the Church on this.
If you look up Contraception in the index of the Universal Catechism it will refer you to “Matrimony, purpose”.

Inside the Sacrament of marriage, some contraceptive actions are prohibited, others (NFP) are not. Sex inside the sacrament serves two purposes, unity and procreation.

Consensual sex outside the sacriment of marriage is a sin wether contraception is used or not. It is an offense against chastity.

But this is neither an offense against the nature of matrimony or chastity, it is a violent attack from an unjust aggressor.

Again, you can beleive whatever you want. I am bound by an Oath of Fealty, it would never be appropriate for me to declare, as you already have repeatedly, that part of the college, in communion with Rome, is defying Church teaching.

But in theological circles, there is a concept of ‘moral consistancy’. For Catholics, this concept extends to something called “Eucharistic Consitancy” (see Sacramentum Caritatis). If you contend that contraception cannot be licit even in forced sex, then you are arguing that post penatration physical resistance is also immoral, because the Church has specifically ruled that coitus interruptus is ‘contraception’ and ‘illicit’ in the circumstances above (ex thwarting procreation inside the Sacrament of Marriage).

If one form of contraception is moral self defense (say, shoving the attacker away and running), then so is the other. Conversely, if contraception cannot be used, then it cannot be used in any form.

Fortunately, my moral conscience is aligned with the Magisterium. I cannot profess to hold absolute truth, but the idea that dutiful Catholics must hold felon sperm in higher regard than fully formed human lives seems morally depraved to me.

Pax Christi

P.S. Two popes and the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith have also commented on this. It is you that appear to be at odds with them. Declaring yourself, with certainty, to be morally superior to the Vicar of Christ has a name in Catholic teaching too. See Lumen Getium #25.
 
Contraception to prevent pregnancy is not permitted under any circumstances.
This is so incorrect it is worth highlighting by itself.

If a Catholic is interested in what the Church actually teaches, Pope Paul VI’s Humanae Vitae is a good place to start. It acknowledges that Catholic couples have licit reasons to avoid pregnancy while still enjoying the unitive properties of martial sex. That is why NFP, which is historically viewed as contraception, can be used licitly.

To understand why, say, “Dignitas Personae” is addressed to Catholic couples, you need to study deeper.
“Unfortunately, Catholic thought is often misunderstood … as if the Church supported an ideology of fertility at all costs, urging married couples to procreate indiscriminately and without thought for the future. But one need only study the pronouncements of the Magisterium to know that this is not so. Truly, in begetting life the spouses fulfill one of the highest dimensions of their calling: they are God’s co-workers. Precisely for this reason they must have an extremely responsible attitude. In deciding whether or not to have a child, they must not be motivated by selfishness or carelessness, but by a prudent, conscious generosity that weighs the possibilities and circumstances, and especially gives priority to the welfare of the unborn child. Therefore, when there is a reason not to procreate, this choice is permissible and may even be necessary.” - Blessed John Paul 17 July 1994
“She [the Catholic Church] of course does not regard it as a real or moral solution, but, in this or that case, there can be nonetheless, in the intention of reducing the risk of infection, a first step in a movement toward a different way, a more human way, of living sexuality.” - Pope Benedict XVI, Light of the World interview, 2010
Pope Benedict’s comments may seem radical, since they refer to condom use in the sex trade, but he covered the underlying theology very well in the Encyclical God is Love.

Peace
 
I repeat. When the** prime reason** for using it is prevention of pregnancy contraception is NOT PERMITTED under any circumstances (not even rape - despite what some bishops think).
That is the clear Church teaching.
 
Contraception does not prevent the act of rape.
If i would disgust us by precisely spelling out, what is all part of an act of rape, which results in pregnancy, you would notive that having the rapist sperm inside her at the time she ovulates is also part of the rape. And against that part medications that prevent ovulation obviously help.

As a theoretical example for purpose of highlighting the difference in intent between contraception and stopping the assault from affecting the women, assume that a medication exists that prevents contraception only from a specific person. If a married women had had sex with her husband and later that day got raped, she would with such hypothetical medication be able to ensure, that she doesnt get pregnant from her rapists. Would in taking such medication be her intent to prevent pregnancy?
Obviously not, as she could still get pregnant from her husband. Her only intent would be to stop the effect of the rape.

As another example, assume some medication/treatment existed that just kills the sperm. How could removing the unwanted sperm from ones body be immoral?

This all shows that the rapist sperm is part of the illegal attack, the rape is not over after he pulls out, and therefore action taken in defense against it are permissable assuming the risk of negative effects for thrid innocent parties are reasonably low. And denying access is also a form of defense.
 
If i would disgust us by precisely spelling out, what is all part of an act of rape, which results in pregnancy, you would notive that having the rapist sperm inside her at the time she ovulates is also part of the rape. And against that part medications that prevent ovulation obviously help.

As a theoretical example for purpose of highlighting the difference in intent between contraception and stopping the assault from affecting the women, assume that a medication exists that prevents contraception only from a specific person. If a married women had had sex with her husband and later that day got raped, she would with such hypothetical medication be able to ensure, that she doesnt get pregnant from her rapists. Would in taking such medication be her intent to prevent pregnancy?
Obviously not, as she could still get pregnant from her husband. Her only intent would be to stop the effect of the rape.

As another example, assume some medication/treatment existed that just kills the sperm. How could removing the unwanted sperm from ones body be immoral?

This all shows that the rapist sperm is part of the illegal attack, the rape is not over after he pulls out, and therefore action taken in defense against it are permissable assuming the risk of negative effects for thrid innocent parties are reasonably low. And denying access is also a form of defense.
Contraception to prevent pregnancy is FORBIDDEN by the Church - no exceptions. That is the Church teaching and a few bishops who disagree with that do not change that fact and nor do the opinions of any lay people.

As for another poster quoting the Pope he is on shaky ground. The comments to which the poster refers were about condoms and nothing else. Cardinal Lombardi spoke to the Pope for clarification and the Pope told him what he said was in no way meant as any support for the use of condoms, and that what he said in his book was simply an opinion regarding the immorality of male prostitutes and nothing he said was any in way Magesterial and he was not advocating any changes to the Church teaching.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top