The Eucharist; superstition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Something to tak into consideration about hios book: Dr. Hahn does not say that Revelation is just about the Mass! It is also about historical events. It is also an apocolyptic vision. It is also about the good vs. evil struggle of Chriastian life. It is all of these things.
Thanks CWBetts. Right now I am trying to dig my way through Pope Benedict XVI aka Cardinal Ratzinger’s “Conscience”, but will keep Scott Hahn on the front burner.
 
I don’t know about anyone else on this thread who is Catholic, but I as being one, greatly resent your minimalization and your insulting attitude of my beliefs.
I agree whole-heartedly. It pains me to read such disrespect from Zundrah, but then I tell myself that she or he (I haven’t checked the profile) is acting like a petulant child & I must exercise patience. Perhaps his/her eyes might be opened to the truth by attending the Catholic Church (& yes, Zundrah, I am a convert from a Methodist background). Might I suggest you read, “Rome Sweet Home”?
 
I believe it was St. Augustine that said (and do correct me if I am wrong): “Not only de we not sin by adoring the Eucharist be fore we recieve, we would sin if we failed to adore the Eucahrist before we recieve” I heard this in a talk by Scott Hahn, and I do not know if this was what St. Augustine said, or if this was comment added onto what he said by Hahn.
 
…back to the main point, the eucharist is superstition and the scripture “this is my body and blood” was just a metaphore.
Dearest Jennifer

What are your proofs its a metaphor? Provide them all and debate this may help.

God bless you:thumbsup:🙂
John
 
I agree whole-heartedly. It pains me to read such disrespect from Zundrah, but then I tell myself that she or he (I haven’t checked the profile) is acting like a petulant child & I must exercise patience. Perhaps his/her eyes might be opened to the truth by attending the Catholic Church (& yes, Zundrah, I am a convert from a Methodist background). Might I suggest you read, “Rome Sweet Home”?
I have read a lot of Zundrah’s post and I believe she may be a troll. She appears to be one way and then does a complete 180. In 2 months she has over 1300 post. I find that a little strange in itself. Hard to figure out what she is doing or wanting. Needs many prayers IMHO.
 
A baby could ask the same thing at the time of weaning. 🙂

Jennifer, you started an earlier thread on the same topic and seemed to be making progress:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5501912&postcount=47

What happened between then and now to bring about this regression?
This is the thing that bugs me the most; I thought I had actually grasp the belief in the Eucharist but for some reason the belief has gone as if it was never there. Now I am certain that it is just a faulse belief, it has nothing to do with christiany. A person could go a whole life time without ever taking the Eucharist (as I haven’t) and it makes no change in their christianity, so obviously it is an unnecessary act in a church.
 
Zundrah,
I see now you have not come here to try to believe in the truth of the Eucharist. You have come here to try to convince us of what you believe, that the Eucharist is just a metaphor. Possibly a remembrance of what Jesus did.
It’s not. You are sadly misled. That the Eucharist is a quite literal teaching of Jesus Christ was accpeted from the first century. Even as I showed you, John Wesley, the great Anglican priest who began Methodiam knew it was really His body and blood.
I showed you where great Christians from the 1st century, 2nd and 3rd century proclaimed the teaching of what Our Lord stated. It is Jesus Christ’s body and blood truly in the Eucharist.
You refuse to accept the historical basis. That is too bad. But worse you refuse to believe the Lord who is God and He declared it to be so.
Zundrah,
our Church welcomes those who ask questions. But for those who ask with the agenda of proving the Catholic Church errant in this most basic belief speaks to me that you are not looking to become Catholic. So why not simply find a Methodist (Anglican, Presbyterian, Lutheran etc) church which makes no requirement of you regarding this teaching?
For those of faith no provinence is needed. For those of no faith, no provenence is sufficient.
I am not trying to convince anyone, I am instead just telling you that it is imaginary.
 
I agree whole-heartedly. It pains me to read such disrespect from Zundrah, but then I tell myself that she or he (I haven’t checked the profile) is acting like a petulant child & I must exercise patience. Perhaps his/her eyes might be opened to the truth by attending the Catholic Church (& yes, Zundrah, I am a convert from a Methodist background). Might I suggest you read, “Rome Sweet Home”?
If a muslim siad to me that my faith in christ was a fake because christ was just a man, then I would not be offended, I would instead realise that he has not recieved christ himself.
And since I have not recieved the eucharist then how can you expect me to believe it? You are being a hypocritical christian, if we all just took offence to peoples lack of belief then the whole world would be at war.
 
an irrational belief arising from ignorance or fear
wordnetweb.princeton.edu/perl/webwn-Since neither fear or nor ignorance have anything to do with our belief in the Eucharist-the pemise itself is wrong.It has everything to do with Love, which is always the most difficult thing about God to understand.
 
an irrational belief arising from ignorance or fear
wordnetweb.princeton.edu/perl/webwn-Since neither fear or nor ignorance have anything to do with our belief in the Eucharist-the pemise itself is wrong.It has everything to do with Love, which is always the most difficult thing about God to understand.
The eucharist is just a way of getting people to come to church. It has no christian purpose in either converting people or strengthening their faith in Christ.
 
Zundrah,
It is not the point that you insult us because we strongly believe that Christ is the Eucharist. You insult Christ by saying His words to us through the gospel of John was all lies.
The Eucharist is one of the Seven Sacraments and means of grace. To say it is false demeans our deepest strongest faith. And the faith of all true Catholics. Can you not see why we might be emphatic about it. It is Christ yet with us. It is Christ nourishing our faith. It is His body and Blood because that’s what He said.
It is simple but perhaps not easy. We believe because He said it. For us there is no other meaning to John 6,
It is not as if you only waiver on this point I suspect. How do you feel about our other sacraments? How about the infallibility of the Pope? The assumption of Our Lady?
How about birth control?
We feel strongly that Catholic teaching on these things is true. To be a Catholic pretty much requires belief in these things.
I winder when you started this thread what was your real intention? To try to find a way to believe in the reality of the Eucharist as believed by Catholics? Or to criticize us and our belief which you think is superstition?:confused:
 
If a muslim siad to me that my faith in christ was a fake because christ was just a man, then I would not be offended, I would instead realise that he has not recieved christ himself.
And since I have not recieved the eucharist then how can you expect me to believe it? You are being a hypocritical christian, if we all just took offence to peoples lack of belief then the whole world would be at war.
No, I am not being hypocritical at all. You are by going to the Catholic Church & coming on here with the premise that you can’t understand it, but then when other posters provide you with study materials, you refuse to explore. Also, you don’t need to receive the Eucharist in order to believe in it. My being offended is not the type to lead to war, on the contrary, I am trying to exercise patience & love, I have no desire to fight. I would pray for a Muslim just as I will pray for you in a few minutes. It appears praying for you is all any of us can do for you as you refuse to open your heart to what it appears He is trying to show you. If you feel the Catholic Church feels like the right place to worship, perhaps it is because of the fullness of what it teaches & where is He is leading you.

I am off to pray & you will be included in my prayers.
 
slyboots;5547448]Zundrah,
It is not the point that you insult us because we strongly believe that Christ is the Eucharist. You insult Christ by saying His words to us through the gospel of John was all lies.
No, christ is not a liar, but the way you interpritate his words is heresy.
The Eucharist is one of the Seven Sacraments and means of grace. To say it is false demeans our deepest strongest faith. And the faith of all true Catholics. Can you not see why we might be emphatic about it. It is Christ yet with us. It is Christ nourishing our faith. It is His body and Blood because that’s what He said.
It is simple but perhaps not easy. We believe because He said it. For us there is no other meaning to John 6,
It is not as if you only waiver on this point I suspect.
The “other” meaning of john is this; chirst is the bread of life. Did you miss that?
How do you feel about our other sacraments?
I feel that they are fine.
How about the infallibility of the Pope?
I am at full adoration of the pope, my favorite is (Sanit) John Paul.
The assumption of Our Lady?
Assumption? What assumption? Her virginity? Get back to me on this one as I do not understand the question.
How about birth control?
Birth control is sin.
We feel strongly that Catholic teaching on these things is true. To be a Catholic pretty much requires belief in these things.
If I do not believe in the Eucharist then I will never be catholic? But that alone will not send me out of my catholic church, I am staying there.
I winder when you started this thread what was your real intention? To try to find a way to believe in the reality of the Eucharist as believed by Catholics? Or to criticize us and our belief which you think is superstition?:confused:
I am not criticizing you, that would be very nasty.

xxx zundrah xxx
 
No, I am not being hypocritical at all. You are by going to the Catholic Church & coming on here with the premise that you can’t understand it, but then when other posters provide you with study materials, you refuse to explore. Also, you don’t need to receive the Eucharist in order to believe in it. My being offended is not the type to lead to war, on the contrary, I am trying to exercise patience & love, I have no desire to fight. I would pray for a Muslim just as I will pray for you in a few minutes. It appears praying for you is all any of us can do for you as you refuse to open your heart to what it appears He is trying to show you. If you feel the Catholic Church feels like the right place to worship, perhaps it is because of the fullness of what it teaches & where is He is leading you.

I am off to pray & you will be included in my prayers.
I opened this thread after already having read so many parts about the eucharist including the whole of John chapter 6.
 
The assumption of Our lady and also her Immaculate conception and perpetual virginity.
newadvent.org/cathen/02006b.htm
newadvent.org/cathen/07674d.htm
newadvent.org/fathers/3007.htm
Note: By promulgating the Bull Munificentissimus Deus, 1 November, 1950, Pope Pius XII declared infallibly that the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary was a dogma of the Catholic Faith. Likewise, the Second Vatican Council taught in the Dogmatic Constitution Lumen Gentium that “the Immaculate Virgin, preserved free from all stain of original sin, was taken up body and soul into heavenly glory, when her earthly life was over, and exalted by the Lord as Queen over all things (n. 59).”

Then there is infallibility.
newadvent.org/cathen/07790a.htm

The seven sacraments…in which our belief in the Eucharist is taught.
newadvent.org/library/almanac_13295a.htm

These are important for those who are Catholics. And frankly should be for all Christians but that’s another thread.
 
Assumption? What assumption? Her virginity? Get back to me on this one as I do not understand the question.
The “Assumption of the Virgin Mary” refers to the belief of the Catholic and Orthodox Churches that Mary was “assumed”, or taken, soul AND body, up to heaven. (She may or may not have actually died a physical death. Many believe that she did, but that’s still a point of debate.) This would be similar to Elijah being taken directly into heaven in the Old Testament. It was declared an infallible dogma of the church in 1950 (meaning it is something that MUST be believed as fact), although the belief has existed since the earliest days of Christianity.
 
The assumption of Our lady and also her Immaculate conception and perpetual virginity.
newadvent.org/cathen/02006b.htm
newadvent.org/cathen/07674d.htm
newadvent.org/fathers/3007.htm
Note: By promulgating the Bull Munificentissimus Deus, 1 November, 1950, Pope Pius XII declared infallibly that the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary was a dogma of the Catholic Faith. Likewise, the Second Vatican Council taught in the Dogmatic Constitution Lumen Gentium that “the Immaculate Virgin, preserved free from all stain of original sin, was taken up body and soul into heavenly glory, when her earthly life was over, and exalted by the Lord as Queen over all things (n. 59).”

Then there is infallibility.
newadvent.org/cathen/07790a.htm

The seven sacraments…in which our belief in the Eucharist is taught.
newadvent.org/library/almanac_13295a.htm

These are important for those who are Catholics. And frankly should be for all Christians but that’s another thread.
Thanks, I will run through these now. But why are you making so much effort for me? I thought that you gave up on me?
 
The “Assumption of the Virgin Mary” refers to the belief of the Catholic and Orthodox Churches that Mary was “assumed”, or taken, soul AND body, up to heaven. (She may or may not have actually died a physical death. Many believe that she did, but that’s still a point of debate.) This would be similar to Elijah being taken directly into heaven in the Old Testament. It was declared an infallible dogma of the church in 1950 (meaning it is something that MUST be believed as fact), although the belief has existed since the earliest days of Christianity.
This is all new to me because my methodist church never taught me about Mary because they just say that she was a human USED by God and that is all that she is… I don’t believe that. I know that she is so much more then that. She was chosen to be the mother of God.
 
The whole liturgical life of the Church revolves around the Eucharistic sacrifice and the sacraments (CCC1113).
The Holy Eucharist is central to what we believe. The readings of today’s Mass (the 19th Sunday in Ordinary Time) all point to this reality.
As an RCIA candidate, do you have a copy of the United States Catholic Catechism for Adults? If so, please read chapter 17 which is all about this Sacrament that completes Christian initiation.
To call the Eucharist a fallacy is to call my personal faith a fallacy. As St. Paul said if what we believe is untrue, then we are indeed the most pitiful of persons.

The following are excerpts from the Guidelines for the Reception of Communion

*As Catholics, we fully participate in the celebration of the Eucharist when we receive Holy Communion. We are encouraged to receive Communion devoutly and frequently…

For Our Fellow Christians
We welcome our fellow Christians to this celebration of the Eucharist as our brothers and sisters. We pray that our common baptism and the action of the Holy Spirit in this Eucharist will draw us closer to one another and begin to dispel the sad divisions which separate us. We pray that these will lessen and finally disappear, in keeping with Christ’s prayer for us “that they all may be one.”

Because Catholics believe that the celebration of the Eucharist is a sign of the reality of the oneness of faith, life and worship, members of those churches with whom we are not yet fully united are ordinarily not admitted to Holy Communion…*

“All my other senses, cannot now perceive,
But my hearing, taught by faith, always will believe:
I accept whatever God the Son has said:
Those who hear the Word of God, by the truth are fed”.–St. Auquinas

If belief in the Divine Presence of Jesus Christ in the Holy Eucharist continues to be an obstacle, I suggest that you talk to the parish priest of the Catholic Church where you have been attending Mass.
Faith is hope in that which is not yet seen.
Just as the cross appears as an absurdity for those who do not believe, I suppose we could say the same is true for the Eucharist, the source and summit of our Faith.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top