C
Contarini
Guest
The problem is that if person B is truly a repentant believer whose good works stem from love of God and neighbor, then obviously that person has received grace according to Calvinist theology. Irresistible grace is something that moves you to act in a certain way. You are reading a modern, antinomian version of evangelicalism back into Calvinism, and this is completely unfair. Your critique is at the level of “Catholics think they can buy salvation.” You need to understand what you are criticizing before you charge off on your holy crusade.Please tell me where this story is wrong, according to Calvinistic thought.
Two babies are born at the same time in the same hospital. One was born predestined to heaven, the other born predestined to hell. The first, called A, lives a horrible, sinful life. At some point, just before death, irresistable grace overtakes him, and he ends up in heaven. The second, called B, studies the Bible daily. He lives a life of service to others. When he sins, he weeps bitterly and begs for God’s forgiveness. He struggles to live the Beatitudes and the Commandments. In his heart of hearts, he is sure that there is a God and that he is doing what is asked of him to be saved. He has more than accepted Jesus as his savior: he is actively working to bring others to Christ. However, he never gets the irresistable grace and dies and ends up in hell.
Now, where is the problem per Calvin?
Edwin