The problem of evil

  • Thread starter Thread starter sadiebelle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I will, however, take the time to point out the major flaw in that entire website you posted. First of all, it presumes that God does not outright stop evil. According to Judeo-Christianity, God does outright stop evil on occasion.
That is what the Seventh officer says. 🙂 An example, please? Where God visibly interfered and stopped some evil? And “on occasion” is just a cop-out. A loving being does not ever allow evil to happen - because it is also a Catholic stance that “no good can ever come out of evil”. See Romans 3:8 for details.
At other times he permits evil to happen.
Well, if you want to be precise you should remember the following dogmas (Dogmas)
  1. God keeps all created things in existence. (De fide.)
  2. God co-operates immediately in every act of His creatures. (Sent. communis.)
so God actively participates in every evil act.
But the responsibility of God is not to outright stop evil, but to ultimately do something about it.
Says who? It would be the responsibility of a benevolent God.
The person who formulated the website you linked is basically saying that if a benevolent God exists, he has a moral obligation to stop all evil from happening everywhere, at all times. After all, that is the ramification of his criticisms.
Obviously!
And, course, that means that God has to violate our free will
Nonsense. Our freedom of action is already limited. As long as God does not “brainwash” us into “worshipping” him, we have enough freedom to commit “evil”. After all violating the first commandment is already a mortal sin.
(which is also a violation of love) and prevent us from being champions of virtue. I dare say, by now you should have seen that one coming.
Not a violation of love - it is an expression of love. I simply don’t care about the “champions of virtue”, because it is not an argument. Just out of curiosity, where in the Bible (which is the only “revelation”) does God explictly say that his “ultimate” goal is to have humans turn into “champions of virtue”? Chapter and verse, please.
Secondly, I ask you to determine what freedoms are “logically necessary” for the loving relationship between a husband and wife. I imagine that once we narrow down the field as to what a husband and wife should do for one another in terms of what is “logically necessary” it won’t be a relationship really worth having. The same could be said of a relationship between God and people.
You confuse eros with agape.
Give me one specific example of an atrocity and explain how you think a benevolent God should have acted.
Genesis, Garden of Eden. A benevolent God would have made that tree inaccessible. An equivalent human example: A loving father would not place a loaded gun where a child can get access to it.
 
Of course all questions are valid and in time we will have all the answers the problem is we are finite trying to understand the infinate. Our intellect can and does help us in our Faith but it has its limits so when it hits the buffers we need to rely on our deeper more instinctive knowledge and learn to trust God, and maybe this is why we cant have all the answers because it is in trust that we learn to Love. No matter how many questions you can answer you will always hit one you can’t. You can get an understanding; lots of theories but never a complete answer. This is when we have got to be humble and trust in God; pray and live a Good life and EXPERIENCE God in our lives.
Focusing all out energies on questions and none on experience is dangerous. I would suggest more time Praying for God to open you to EXPERIENCE and all those questions you will continue to explore but you wont get phased by being unable to get the hardback answer. I hope this makes some sense. 😃
 
That is what the Seventh officer says. :0
If you want me to respond to the Tale of 12 Officers material further, I will remind you of the criteria I set down in Post #99
An example, please? Where God visibly interfered and stopped some evil?
The Third Chapter of the Book of Daniel. The Babylonian ruler, King Nebuchadnezzar, had three Jewish men (Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego) cast into a fiery furnace for refusing to worship a pagan god. The king saw them visibly saved by an angel of God.
And “on occasion” is just a cop-out. A loving being does not ever allow evil to happen…
It’s not a cop-out because God is under no moral obligation to stop all evil. When he chooses to stop a particular evil act, it is out of other intentions. As I said before, his obligation (to be in accordance with his nature) is to do something about evil, and he ultimately does. But I’ll comment more on this in a moment, because this topic comes up again in your current post.
  • because it is also a Catholic stance that “no good can ever come out of evil”. See Romans 3:8 for details.
No, this is not the Catholic stance, and neither was that Paul’s stance in Romans 3:8. This verse from Romans states, “And why not do evil that good may come? – as some slanderously charge us with saying.” Catholics (and most other Christians) see this as a rhetorical question, with the answer being that it is not permissible to do evil in the hope that good may come from it. The ends do not justify the means. This, then is the Catholic stance, and as you can see, saying “It is not permissible to do evil in the hope that good may come from it” is not the same thing as saying, “No good can ever come out of evil.”
Well, if you want to be precise you should remember the following dogmas (Dogmas)
  1. God keeps all created things in existence. (De fide.)
  2. God co-operates immediately in every act of His creatures. (Sent. communis.)
so God actively participates in every evil act.
And if you likewise want to be precise when debating Catholics over Catholic teachings, I recommend that you get an actual copy of Ludwig Ott’s Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma rather than relying upon snippets from a web site. That way you will avoid the mistake you just made.

The statement “God co-operates immediately in every act of His creatures” is not a dogma of Catholicism, but rather an opinion shared by certain theologians. Ott is quite clear about this:

“There is no decision of the Church on this. However, theologians generally hold that God co-operates immediately in every action of His creatures.” -Ludwig Ott, Patrick Lynch, trans., Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma (Roman Catholic Books, Fort Collins, Co.), 88.

In other words, this statement is neither dogma nor doctrinal, and Catholics are free to accept this idea or discard it. Ott then goes on to explain how this teaching was formulated to show distinctions between Catholic thought, Occasionalism and Deism (regarding divine action and human action).

Moreover, in this same section Ott shows how this teaching is applied to the concept of sinful activity:
“God cooperates in the physical activity of sin also (actio peccati entitas percatti); since the activation of the sensual and spiritual powers of the creature, is a being, and therefore something good. The moral deficiency (i.e., the sin as such), which is associated with the physical act, derives from the free will of the creature who, therefore, alone is guilty. God, in consequence of His infinite perfection, cannot be the cause of a moral defect.” (Ott, 88-89).

(Continued in my next post)
 
(Continued…)
EricFilmer;7770912:
But the responsibility of God is not to outright stop evil, but to ultimately do something about it.
Says who? It would be the responsibility of a benevolent God.
As I have repeatedly stated in this thread, God created us to be in a loving relationship with him (and with one another). In a relationship of true love, the beloved must be free to accept or reject the lover, and it is by evil action that we reject God. Therefore, when you say “A loving being does not ever allow evil to happen,” that is the same thing as saying, “A lover must always prevent the beloved from rejecting him.” Therefore we are back to my love potion example from Post #11. So it seems that we keep going over old ground in this discussion.
Nonsense. Our freedom of action is already limited. As long as God does not “brainwash” us into “worshipping” him, we have enough freedom to commit “evil”. After all violating the first commandment is already a mortal sin.
And to this I will simply repeat what I stated in Post #98:
“God intended to create a world where we are not simply to love God, but to also love one another. God intended to create a world where it is possible to not simply love, but to love powerfully as champions of virtue. Apparently you envision a world where everyone lives in seclusion to one another, make a daily devotional prayer to God, but without the freedom to do much of anything else. Some life. “

So once again we are just going back over old ground in this thread.
Not a violation of love - it is an expression of love. I simply don’t care about the “champions of virtue”, because it is not an argument.
It most certainly is an argument because it is my argument, and is clearly stated in Post #4, the very post you decided to respond to when you began participating in this thread. If you intend to continue debating against me then that means debating against my argument, which includes the concept of being champions of virtue. This is now at least the nineteenth time that I have had to point this out to you in this thread.
Just out of curiosity, where in the Bible (which is the only “revelation”) does God explictly say that his “ultimate” goal is to have humans turn into “champions of virtue”? Chapter and verse, please.
First of all, no Christian believes that the Bible is the “only revelation”. After all, the ultimate revelation of God is in the person of Jesus Christ. There are certain Protestant denominations that believe the Bible is to be the only source for the formation of Christian doctrine (i.e., Sola Scriptura), but Catholics and Orthodox Christians have always held that God’s revelation includes both Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition.

Nevertheless, I will be happy to comply with your request:

“Be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect.” (Matthew 5:48)

For a biblical analysis on this idea of perfection, see ”God Says that We Must Become Perfect as God is Perfect”. Although this particular Scripture study does not use the exact term, “champion of virtue” it is describing the same basic concept.
You confuse eros with agape.
I’m not confusing anything and you are dodging the question. So I will present it for the second time:
I ask you to determine what freedoms are “logically necessary” for the loving relationship between a husband and wife. I imagine that once we narrow down the field as to what a husband and wife should do for one another in terms of what is “logically necessary” it won’t be a relationship really worth having. The same could be said of a relationship between God and people.
Genesis, Garden of Eden. A benevolent God would have made that tree inaccessible. An equivalent human example: A loving father would not place a loaded gun where a child can get access to it.
The account from Genesis is a description of human freedom. Human freedom is very broad (Adam and Eve were told that they could eat the fruit of any tree in the garden). Nevertheless, human freedom has limits (God made a sole exception concerning the tree of knowledge of good and evil). As I have repeatedly pointed out in this thread, God created us to be in a loving relationship with him (and with one another). In a relationship of true love, the beloved must be free to accept or reject the lover, and it is by evil action that we reject God.

Whether we interpret the forbidden fruit of Genesis as a literal fruit or as a metaphor (symbolizing the sin of pride and lack of trust in God), it represents the ability of Adam & Eve to reject God in the context of a loving relationship. So when you say, “A benevolent God would have made that tree inaccessible,” that’s the same thing as saying “God should have made the rejection of his love inaccessible.” In other words, he would have to deny Adam & Eve the free will to accept or reject his love, and force them to love him instead. Once again, we are back to my love potion example from Post #11.
 
The account from Genesis is a description of human freedom. Human freedom is very broad (Adam and Eve were told that they could eat the fruit of any tree in the garden). Nevertheless, human freedom has limits (God made a sole exception concerning the tree of knowledge of good and evil). As I have repeatedly pointed out in this thread, God created us to be in a loving relationship with him (and with one another). In a relationship of true love, the beloved must be free to accept or reject the lover, and it is by evil action that we reject God.
The story of the loaded gun is about human freedom. You say that a loving father should allow the child to have access to the loaded gun - in the name of LOVE? You say that LOVE is compatible with allowing FATAL decisions? Well, I guess that settles it. Your opinion just imcomprehensible for me. I am bound by the rules of the board (to be “charitable”) so let’s just leave it at that.

One more remark, however concerning your post about God interfering.
The Babylonian ruler, King Nebuchadnezzar, had three Jewish men (Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego) cast into a fiery furnace for refusing to worship a pagan god. The king saw them visibly saved by an angel of God.
I am wondering if you are simply pulling my leg, or are you actually serious? If you are just joking, then everything is fine, and your sense of humor is commendable. But I have this sneaky suspicion that you were serious, and you really think that your answer is meaningful. Let me enlighten you: never try to “argue” with an atheist based upon the story in the Bible. It does not work. But, just for the fun of it, let’s say that you scored a point and God actually interfered a few thousand years ago on behalf of 3 poor Jews. Obviously God took an extended vacation and when the Holocaust happened with about exterminating 6 million victims (a majority of which was Jews) he was busy elsewhere. Where was God?

You should know that the Jews actually put God on trial (in absentia, of course) and convicted him for beaking his covenant. It seems that the Jews have a spinal cord and integrity to spell out that God did not fulfill his obligation put down in the covenant with them. So much for God’s credibility. And yours…
 
Of course all questions are valid and in time we will have all the answers the problem is we are finite trying to understand the infinate. Our intellect can and does help us in our Faith but it has its limits so when it hits the buffers we need to rely on our deeper more instinctive knowledge and learn to trust God, and maybe this is why we cant have all the answers because it is in trust that we learn to Love. No matter how many questions you can answer you will always hit one you can’t. You can get an understanding; lots of theories but never a complete answer. This is when we have got to be humble and trust in God; pray and live a Good life and EXPERIENCE God in our lives.
Focusing all out energies on questions and none on experience is dangerous. I would suggest more time Praying for God to open you to EXPERIENCE and all those questions you will continue to explore but you wont get phased by being unable to get the hardback answer. I hope this makes some sense. 😃
Trust is a wonderful idea. I would agree that in a new relationship one should always start with trusting the other. But trust should be reinforced and not abused. Here is a “parable” for you:

A man comes home too early one day and finds his wife in bed with a stranger. He is devastated and asks his wife for an explanation. She says that she loves him very much, and he should trust him. She has a perfectly good explanation for her act, but she does not wish to tell the details. She wants unquestioning trust. And the man trusts her. Then the same thing happens next day, next week, and the week after, and next month… and so on. Day after day… week after week… month after month… year after year…

How long should the man keep on trusting her? What is your opinion?
 
Ok, so I get this at first thought, but then I think about real horrific stuff that happens. Like, say a 3 year old being molested by her father. That has to exist so that we can love God? We have to be free to molest our children so that we can love God? That just seems so cruel. So unfair. Why would God design a universe in which child rape exists?
As far as I know child rape didn’t exist when God finished creating the universe. It is an invention of man.
 
Trust is a wonderful idea. I would agree that in a new relationship one should always start with trusting the other. But trust should be reinforced and not abused. Here is a “parable” for you:

A man comes home too early one day and finds his wife in bed with a stranger. He is devastated and asks his wife for an explanation. She says that she loves him very much, and he should trust him. She has a perfectly good explanation for her act, but she does not wish to tell the details. She wants unquestioning trust. And the man trusts her. Then the same thing happens next day, next week, and the week after, and next month… and so on. Day after day… week after week… month after month… year after year…

How long should the man keep on trusting her? What is your opinion?
I would say you have a real example there of how to work with God, his marraige appears to have lasted longer than many I know so I’m assuming the Marraige appart from this must be good. The fact she has never got pregnant by this strange man shows the mans trust must have been well placed 😃

only kidding but if you spend your time questioning God and never actually experience him I would suggest you are using your Questions as a barrier. 🤷
 
only kidding but if you spend your time questioning God and never actually experience him I would suggest you are using your Questions as a barrier. 🤷
I am glad you were just joking. By the way, I am not questioning God. I would be most happy to have a friendly chat with God, but he does not seem to have time for me. Maybe he is busy not helping the needy, not feeding the hungry, not healing the sick… it sure seems like taking a lot of time and effort of not doing anything. 😉 So I am questioning the apologists. And the apologists are not very… (well I am looking for a charitable word here, and cannot seem to find it) hmmm, let’s say on top of their chosen task. It would be disappointing, if one had some expectations.
 
I am glad you were just joking. By the way, I am not questioning God. I would be most happy to have a friendly chat with God, but he does not seem to have time for me. Maybe he is busy not helping the needy, not feeding the hungry, not healing the sick… it sure seems like taking a lot of time and effort of not doing anything. 😉 So I am questioning the apologists. And the apologists are not very… (well I am looking for a charitable word here, and cannot seem to find it) hmmm, let’s say on top of their chosen task. It would be disappointing, if one had some expectations.
Well how have you tried to talk to God; on your terms or his? 😊
 
The story of the loaded gun is about human freedom. You say that a loving father should allow the child to have access to the loaded gun - in the name of LOVE? You say that LOVE is compatible with allowing FATAL decisions? Well, I guess that settles it. Your opinion just imcomprehensible for me. I am bound by the rules of the board (to be “charitable”) so let’s just leave it at that.
Well, let’s just take a look at how comprehensible your own position is. In an attempt to envision a world that God could have created in which the problem of evil was addressed to your satisfaction, you stated the following:
  • “The only “freedom” we need is to accept or reject God. No other freedom is logically needed. We could be total ‘robots’ or saints in every other respect. We could be compelled and forced to be loving and caring toward each other. As long as we have the freedom of ‘not loving God’, we have enough freedom.” (Post #96)
“From God’s omnipotence it follows that he could create a world, where the only freedom we enjoy is to love or not love God.” (also Post #96)*

Because the relationship being described is one of love, the choice to not love God also represents the rejection of God. Because God is Life Itself, the choice to reject God is likewise a choice to reject life. This is why it is considered a mortal sin (mortal sin is a deadly sin, just as a mortal wound is a deadly wound). You recognized this yourself when you said:

“As long as God does not ‘brainwash’ us into ‘worshipping’ him, we have enough freedom to commit ‘evil’. After all violating the first commandment is already a mortal sin.” (Post #100)

Therefore, even in this world you envision, the decision to not love God is a fatal decision, although it would presumably be the only fatal decision one could make. The choice to not love God would be the forbidden fruit in the Garden of Eden, and it would be the “loaded gun” in your other example (concerning whether or not loving parents would leave a loaded gun out in the open with children around).

And while we are mentioning your example concerning the gun, let us also consider the following statement you made:

“The story of the loaded gun is about human freedom. You say that a loving father should allow the child to have access to the loaded gun - in the name of LOVE? You say that LOVE is compatible with allowing FATAL decisions?” (Post #104)

Moving on…
When I asked you how you think a benevolent God should act in the face of human atrocity, you said:

*“Genesis, Garden of Eden. A benevolent God would have made that tree inaccessible. An equivalent human example: A loving father would not place a loaded gun where a child can get access to it.” (Post #100)
*
So based on all this, let us now let us outline your concept of the world God should have created in order to address the problem of evil to your satisfaction:

**1) A benevolent God cannot brainwash people into worshipping him. Therefore, he must give people at least the freedom to love him or not.
  1. The choice to not love God is basically the forbidden fruit of the Garden of Eden. It is the “loaded gun” that would lead to a fatal experience if children chose to play with it.
  2. Because you say that “A benevolent God would have made that tree inaccessible”, and that a loving father would not allow his child to have access to a loaded gun, God now has to actually prevent each and every person from choosing not to love him. If God allows the decision to not love him to be accessible then he does not meet your standards of what a loving parent is supposed to do for the sake of his children.
  3. Now that God has made the choice to not love him inaccessible (as per #3), he has now violated the condition you set down in #1. After all, you said people must have at least the freedom to love or not love God, but now they only have one choice to make, which is to love God.**
Conclusion: The world you envision cannot actually exist, because it is impossible for God to fulfill both condition #1 and #4 (i.e., they contradict one another).

(Continued in my next post)
 
(Continued…
One more remark, however concerning your post about God interfering.

I am wondering if you are simply pulling my leg, or are you actually serious? If you are just joking, then everything is fine, and your sense of humor is commendable. But I have this sneaky suspicion that you were serious, and you really think that your answer is meaningful.
Yeah, sure, how funny was that? Who would have suspected that a Catholic on a Catholic forum would actually answered your question with material derived from Catholicism???

In other words, of course I was sincere, and my response was, indeed, meaningful, even if you disagree.
Let me enlighten you: never try to “argue” with an atheist based upon the story in the Bible. It does not work.
And now let me enlighten you. This thread started off as a discussion between Catholics, based upon our understanding of the Catholic Faith. You, an atheist, decided to interject yourself in the correspondence between me and the OP. But instead of discussing this subject in terms of Catholicism, you routinely demanded that I suddenly limit my comments to a set of ”mutually agreed upon assumptions.” Now, where in this thread did I ever give you even the remotest impression that I was going to do that? I stated at least twice that if you wanted to have such a discussion then you should have started a new thread in the philosophy forum, set down your parameters and see who would hop on board. But you didn’t do that, but rather chose to high-jack sadiebelle’s thread. I was willing to engage you in this debate simply to defend my own material, but it is beyond me why you think I was also going to also jump through all the hoops you set down.

So rather than starting your own thread, you chose to respond directly to my material. It is the material of Catholic apologist, and that is exactly what you got – a Catholic apologist defending Catholic material. I’m not going to put my Catholic faith on the shelf because it offends your atheist sensibilities. So keep that in mind the next time you contemplate trying to refute one of my posts on CAF. What you are going to get is the Catholic Faith and everything that goes with it, including the Bible, Sacred Tradition, Early Church Fathers, magisterial documents, Thomas Aquinas, and some doses of Fulton Sheen and C.S. Lewis thrown into the mix. In short, I will give you the truth. At the risk of sounding negative, whether or not the truth meshes with your atheistic conception of reality is really no concern of mine.

(Continued in my next post)
 
(Continued…)
But, just for the fun of it, let’s say that you scored a point and God actually interfered a few thousand years ago on behalf of 3 poor Jews. Obviously God took an extended vacation and when the Holocaust happened with about exterminating 6 million victims (a majority of which was Jews) he was busy elsewhere. Where was God?
So people can start wars and atrocities but it’s God’s moral obligation to stop them? And here I thought the obligation was ours’. So God should have saved the 6 million people who died in the Holocaust? And of course, if it was his moral obligation to stop the Nazis then it was likewise his obligation to stop the Khmer Rouge, right? After all, Pol Pot killed about 2 million people. And how about the Communists, both past and present? Joseph Stalin alone racked up a body count that makes him one of the worst mass murderers in history. And I guess we have to say that God had a moral obligation to save the Rwandans in 1994, and the Kurds of Iraq before that, and let’s not forget all that stuff in Chechnya. After all, there are other attempts at genocide out there.

And if God was supposed to stop the Holocaust, why stop there? Why shouldn’t he have also been morally obligated to stop the entire Second World War? And if he has to stop the Second World War, naturally he should have stopped the First World War. I guess if God is going to measure up to your expectations, God has to stop all wars from ever happening. And if killing is problematic in wartime situations, it is problematic in other situations as well. So in order for you to give God a satisfactory job evaluation, he has to prevent all killing from ever happening.

And why only be concerned about people getting killed? What about maiming someone for life? God should stop people from, say, getting their limbs cut off, or being blinded. And what about physical damage that does not result in maiming (such as a black eye or a broken nose)? Does God have to intervene in these cases also, or can we draw a line here? If we don’t draw the line here that means that God has to personally break up every bar brawl.

What about other crimes people commit against other people? What about rape? What about emotional abuse? Those are very serious and horrific things, aren’t they? So God has to stop them from ever happening, too. And what about theft? Well, maybe only if it is truly horrific (and therefore warranting God’s special intervention), such as if it involves a significantly high dollar amount. So maybe God has a moral obligation to stop bank robberies, but not someone who shoplifts a pack of gum. But on the other hand, stealing $50 from a poor old widow would be a horrific crime if that is all the money she had and had no food. Looks like to be safe we’d better say that God has a moral obligation to stop all theft, so we should accuse God of not doing his job unless he sends Michael the Archangel to bust the kid shoplifting the gum.

What I am doing here is basically the same thing I did way back in Post #11. Once we start criticizing God for permitting a certain evil act to happen, then we start envisioning all the other evil acts we think he should have stopped as well. In light of this, I asked the question in Post #11: “Where would the list stop? I submit that humans would continue to add atrocities to this list until we basically tell God that we want him to prevent all evil. And in order to do that, he has to remove our capacity to choose evil, which means robbing us of our freedom. We are told that God created us to love him and to love one another. If the lover robs the beloved of freedom, then it is not true love.”
You should know that the Jews actually put God on trial (in absentia, of course) and convicted him for beaking his covenant. It seems that the Jews have a spinal cord and integrity to spell out that God did not fulfill his obligation put down in the covenant with them. So much for God’s credibility. And yours…
And you should know that you are referring to an apocryphal story that may not have actually happened. There is a testimony given by one Holocaust survivor about a trial conducted by three men in an Auschwitz barracks. He said, “It happened at night; there were just three people. At the end of the trial, they used the word chayav, rather than ‘guilty’. It means ‘He owes us something’. Then we went to pray." (Source: thejc.com/news/uk-news/wiesel-yes-we-really-did-put-god-trial).

Nevertheless, even if such a trial never actually took place as depicted in the God on Trial play & movie, we can certainly presume that many victims of the Holocaust subjected God to a trial of sorts in their own minds. This has resulted in what is known as Holocaust Theology, which encompasses a range of various and diverse conclusions.
 
thirddec;7781059:
only kidding but if you spend your time questioning God and never actually experience him I would suggest you are using your Questions as a barrier. 🤷
I am glad you were just joking. By the way, I am not questioning God. I would be most happy to have a friendly chat with God, but he does not seem to have time for me. Maybe he is busy not helping the needy, not feeding the hungry, not healing the sick… it sure seems like taking a lot of time and effort of not doing anything. 😉 So I am questioning the apologists. And the apologists are not very… (well I am looking for a charitable word here, and cannot seem to find it) hmmm, let’s say on top of their chosen task. It would be disappointing, if one had some expectations.
Keeler, how about providing a link to those threads.

I’m curious to see for myself how those apologists failed to live up to the… (well I am looking for a charitable word here, and cannot seem to find it) hmmm, let’s say questionable degree of scholarship that you’ve displayed in this thread.
 
Because the relationship being described is one of love, the choice to not love God also represents the rejection of God. Because God is Life Itself, the choice to reject God is likewise a choice to reject life. This is why it is considered a mortal sin (mortal sin is a deadly sin, just as a mortal wound is a deadly wound).
That is nonsense. Love in this relationship is an emotion - which is not subject to volitional control. Not loving God is simply a lack of this emotion - and it does not imply “hate” or “rejection”. Obviously atheists do not “love” God, since they do not believe that such a being exists. But that is not a rejection of “life”. By definition atheists are simply not capable to “hating” or “rejecting” God - only believers can do that. Atheists are of course able of hating or rejecting the concept of God - but that is totally different (even though I met many idiots who did not see that difference).

Now, if God would declare this lack of emotion as a “sin” (actually as a mortal sin) then God is simply “crazy”. The truth is that you (the apologists in general) describe God as an egotistical and narcisstic megalomaniac, who wants to be worshipped and glorifed, while giving nothing in return. God is described as the ultimate tyrant, who wants to be “loved”, but who does nothing to earn that love. And the funny thing is that you refuse to accept this fact. (The usual answer is that God did all he needed to do by creating us - which is also nonsense. A parent cannot drop the responsibility for the child until the point when the child becomes an adult. And since we humans can never become God, therefore God’s responsibility never ends.)
Therefore, even in this world you envision, the decision to not love God is a fatal decision, although it would presumably be the only fatal decision one could make.
It is fatal only if God considers it “fatal”, if God “rewards” it with eternal suffering. There is nothing “fatal” about a lack of emotion. And I must reiterate that “love” is not a volitional act. Now, if God wants us to participate in some worshipping ritual, that is a different story. Rituals are under volitional control. True, they are pretty meaningless if there is not honest devotion behind them, but one is not able to “whip up” devotion. It is either there or it is not.
**1) A benevolent God cannot brainwash people into worshipping him. Therefore, he must give people at least the freedom to love him or not.
  1. The choice to not** love God is basically the forbidden fruit of the Garden of Eden. It is the “loaded gun” that would lead to a fatal experience if children chose to play with it.
  2. Because you say that “A benevolent God would have made that tree inaccessible”, and that a loving father would not allow his child to have access to a loaded gun, God now has to actually prevent each and every person from choosing not to love him. If God allows the decision to not love him to be accessible then he does not meet your standards of what a loving parent is supposed to do for the sake of his children.
  3. Now that God has made the choice to not love him inaccessible (as per #3), he has now violated the condition you set down in #1. After all, you said people must have at least the freedom to love or not love God, but now they only have one choice to make, which is to love God.
#1 is correct.
#2 is not true. A lack of emotion is just a lack of emotion. As I said above, if God is P.O.-ed about the lack of an emotion, then he is dire need of phsychiatric help.
#3 is also incorrect for the same reason. You keep confusing “love” with “caring”. If a parent feels no emotion toward his children, but gives all the necessary care - then there is no problem at all. However, if the parent keeps on insisting that he loves those children - while doing nothing to show that love, then that parent is a lying hypocrite.
Conclusion: The world you envision cannot actually exist, because it is impossible for God to fulfill both condition #1 and #4 (i.e., they contradict one another).
There is no contradiction at all. Especially since that is not the world I envision that a benevolent God should make. Here is my suggested world.

Let’s say that God creates the Garden of Eden - without planting that tree. Without knowing the difference between “good and evil”, humans are truly and really “children”, who are not moral agents. Whatever they do is not a morally charged decision. They are nevertheless capable of unconditional love, just like a child can love. There is no force involved at all. There is plentiful of fruits to eat, nice weather so no need for clothing, no hate, no envy, no property, no diseases, just a nice Utopistic society. No commandments to break. There is plenty of love around.

Next remark about your idea that God wants us to be the “champions of virtue”. The story of genesis flatly contradicts that assertion. God did not want us to become moral agents in the first place.
 
Yeah, sure, how funny was that? Who would have suspected that a Catholic on a Catholic forum would actually answered your question with material derived from Catholicism???
Hilarious. But not what you think. What is funny is that you use a lot of time and energy on composing a post that you should know will be unacceptable. Going back to the exchange, I asked if you have an example of God visibly interfering with some evil. Now, your proper answer (as many apologists actually did before) should have been: “No example that you would accept”. And after this you could have included your quote from the Bible. The funny thing is this: the way you composed your response indicated that you might think that I will reply: “Ah, yes, indeed. I see now that there was an instance when God interfered”.
In other words, of course I was sincere, and my response was, indeed, meaningful, even if you disagree.
It was a waste of your time to write it, and a waste of my time to read it.
I stated at least twice that if you wanted to have such a discussion then you should have started a new thread in the philosophy forum, set down your parameters and see who would hop on board. But you didn’t do that, but rather chose to high-jack sadiebelle’s thread.
Been there, done it, have a t-shirt to prove it. The reason I hopped into this one is that I hate to see the misconceptions about the “problem of evil”. During the centuries this problem has been considered, no one could offer a valid theodicy to resolve the question. Indeed it is obvious that the “problem of evil” is the ultimate thorn in the side of Christianity.
 
Well how have you tried to talk to God; on your terms or his? 😊
I have no idea what God’s terms might be. I have been a believer way back when I was a kid. God never spoke to me then and does not speak to me now. I am open and that is the best I can do. The ball is in his court.
 
First of all, I want to preface this by saying that I am a cradle Catholic. I have really been struggling with my faith for the last couple years. I came to this forum once before and got a bit involved in a discussion that was helpful to me, but I’m still looking for some answers. Please be gentle and know that this is coming from a place of honest searching for deeper meaning in my religious life. Thank you in advance.

I have searched the forum, but didn’t find another thread on the problem of evil. If I missed it, please point me in the right direction.

So my basic question is why is their evil. I would ask a bit more, though. I have gotten the free will answer, but I guess it doesn’t satisfy me. Neither does the “we don’t know what good consequences come from bad actions” line of reasoning.

I’m not sure exactly where I’m going with this, but the classic “if God is all good, all knowing and all powerful, then why is there evil?” is a good place to start.
Evil comes from evil angels, devil.
Evil angels are spiritual being, we are spirith and body.
They can easy suggest us on evil,we must be careful all time.
 
…
Indeed it is obvious that the “problem of evil” is the ultimate thorn in the side of Christianity.
The POE doesn’t survive the free will defense. The POE doesn’t survive a non-sequitir attack, there is no reason to conclude that the Omni Attributes conflict with the existence of evil. The POE doesn’t survive epistemic attacks, statements concerning “best practice” require omniscience. And so on. The POE is one of those things that make sense if you don’t think about it.lol
 
I have no idea what God’s terms might be. I have been a believer way back when I was a kid. God never spoke to me then and does not speak to me now. I am open and that is the best I can do. The ball is in his court.
Now you are on the right track when you say you are open 👍. Do you still go to Mass ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top