(ContinuedâŚ)
EricFilmer;7770912:
But the responsibility of God is not to outright stop evil, but to ultimately do something about it.
Says who? It would be the responsibility of a
benevolent God.
As I have repeatedly stated in this thread, God created us to be in a loving relationship with him (and with one another). In a relationship of true love, the beloved must be free to accept or reject the lover, and it is by evil action that we reject God. Therefore, when you say âA loving being does not ever allow evil to happen,â that is the same thing as saying, âA lover must always prevent the beloved from rejecting him.â Therefore we are back to my love potion example from
Post #11. So it seems that we keep going over old ground in this discussion.
Nonsense. Our freedom of action is already limited. As long as God does not âbrainwashâ us into âworshippingâ him, we have enough freedom to commit âevilâ. After all violating the first commandment is already a mortal sin.
And to this I will simply repeat what I stated in
Post #98:
âGod intended to create a world where we are not simply to love God, but to also love one another. God intended to create a world where it is possible to not simply love, but to love powerfully as champions of virtue. Apparently you envision a world where everyone lives in seclusion to one another, make a daily devotional prayer to God, but without the freedom to do much of anything else. Some life. â
So once again we are just going back over old ground in this thread.
Not a violation of love - it is an expression of love. I simply donât care about the âchampions of virtueâ, because it is not an argument.
It most certainly is an argument because it is my argument, and is clearly stated in Post #4, the very post you decided to respond to when you began participating in this thread. If you intend to continue debating against me then that means debating against my argument, which includes the concept of being champions of virtue. This is now at least the
nineteenth time that I have had to point this out to you in this thread.
Just out of curiosity, where in the Bible (which is the only ârevelationâ) does God explictly say that his âultimateâ goal is to have humans turn into âchampions of virtueâ? Chapter and verse, please.
First of all, no Christian believes that the Bible is the âonly revelationâ. After all, the ultimate revelation of God is in the person of Jesus Christ. There are certain
Protestant denominations that believe the Bible is to be the only source for the formation of Christian doctrine (i.e., Sola Scriptura), but Catholics and Orthodox Christians have always held that Godâs revelation includes both Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition.
Nevertheless, I will be happy to comply with your request:
âBe perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect.â (Matthew 5:48)
For a biblical analysis on this idea of perfection, see
âGod Says that We Must Become Perfect as God is Perfectâ. Although this particular Scripture study does not use the exact term, âchampion of virtueâ it is describing the same basic concept.
You confuse eros with agape.
Iâm not confusing anything and you are dodging the question. So I will present it for the second time:
I ask you to determine what freedoms are âlogically necessaryâ for the loving relationship between a husband and wife. I imagine that once we narrow down the field as to what a husband and wife should do for one another in terms of what is âlogically necessaryâ it wonât be a relationship really worth having. The same could be said of a relationship between God and people.
Genesis, Garden of Eden. A benevolent God would have made that tree inaccessible. An equivalent human example: A loving father would not place a loaded gun where a child can get access to it.
The account from Genesis is a description of human freedom. Human freedom is very broad (Adam and Eve were told that they could eat the fruit of any tree in the garden). Nevertheless, human freedom has limits (God made a sole exception concerning the tree of knowledge of good and evil). As I have repeatedly pointed out in this thread, God created us to be in a loving relationship with him (and with one another). In a relationship of true love, the beloved must be free to accept or reject the lover, and it is by evil action that we reject God.
Whether we interpret the forbidden fruit of Genesis as a literal fruit or as a metaphor (symbolizing the sin of pride and lack of trust in God), it represents the ability of Adam & Eve to reject God in the context of a loving relationship. So when you say, âA benevolent God would have made that tree inaccessible,â thatâs the same thing as saying âGod should have made the rejection of his love inaccessible.â In other words, he would have to deny Adam & Eve the free will to accept or reject his love, and
force them to love him instead. Once again, we are back to my love potion example from
Post #11.