The Vatican Dogma

  • Thread starter Thread starter militantsparrow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dear brother AmbroseSJ,

Did you notice this new example of brother Abu’s consistent practice of providing self-contradictory quotes? :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:

Sorry for the “rotfl’s”, but I literally almost fell out of my seat with laughter when I read it.😃

In case he doesn’t see it, I will be explaining it shortly in my further response to brother SteveB.

Blessings,
Marduk
The Vatican I Dogma ensures the Primacy
Pastor Aeternus (Ecumenical Council Vatican I)
“Chapter 3.
On the power and character of the primacy of the Roman Pontiff
8. Since the Roman Pontiff, by the divine right of the apostolic primacy, governs the whole Church, we likewise teach and declare that he is the supreme judge of the faithful [52], and that in all cases which fall under ecclesiastical jurisdiction recourse may be had to his judgment [53]. The sentence of the Apostolic See (than which there is no higher authority) is not subject to revision by anyone, nor may anyone lawfully pass judgment thereupon [54]. And so they stray from the genuine path of truth who maintain that it is lawful to appeal from the judgments of the Roman pontiffs to an ecumenical council as if this were an authority superior to the Roman Pontiff. 9. So, then, if anyone says that the Roman Pontiff has merely an office of supervision and guidance, and not the full and supreme power of jurisdiction over the whole Church, and this not only in matters of faith and morals, but also in those which concern the discipline and government of the Church dispersed throughout the whole world; or that he has only the principal part, but not the absolute fullness, of this supreme power; or that this power of his is not ordinary and immediate both over all and each of the Churches and over all and each of the pastors and faithful: let him be anathema.” [My emphasis].

Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith
THE PRIMACY OF THE SUCCESSOR OF PETER IN THE MYSTERY OF THE CHURCH
vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19981031_primato-successore-pietro_en.html

In answer to the Holy Father’s invitation, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith decided to study the matter by organizing a strictly doctrinal symposium on The Primacy of the Successor of Peter, which was held in the Vatican from 2 to 4 December 1996. Its Proceedings have recently been published.

“Since the power of the primacy is supreme, there is no other authority to which the Roman Pontiff must juridically answer for his exercise of the gift he has received: “prima sedes a nemine iudicatur”.42 This does not mean, however, that the Pope has absolute power. listening to what the Churches are saying is, in fact, an earmark of the ministry of unity, a consequence also of the unity of the Episcopal Body and of the sensus fidei of the entire People of God; and this bond seems to enjoy considerably greater power and certainty than the juridical authorities - an inadmissible hypothesis, moreover, because it is groundless - to which the Roman Pontiff would supposedly have to answer.”
  • Joseph Card. Ratzinger, Prefect
  • Tarcisio Bertone, S.D.B., Archbishop Emeritus of Vercelli, Secretary
Note
42. CIC, can. 1404
; CCEO, can. 1058. Cf. First Vatican Council, Dogm. Const. Pastor aeternus, Chap. 3: Denz-Hun, n. 3063
Can 1404: The First See is judged by no one.
 
TO CONTINUE:
What if they and the pope disagree? Who prevails? the pope

From Canon Law

Can. 341
§1. The decrees of an ecumenical council do not have obligatory force unless they have been approved by the Roman Pontiff together with the council fathers, confirmed by him, and promulgated at his order.
§2. To have obligatory force, decrees which the college of bishops issues when it places a truly collegial action in another way initiated or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff need the same confirmation and promulgation.
​

Are you actually using Canon 341 to support your statement “the Pope prevails?” :rotfl: I can’t take this anymore! Between the inconsistencies (meant in the secondary sense as “self-contradictory”) from both you and brother Abu, my sides are aching from laughter! Canon 341 explicity asserts “the Roman Pontiff together with the council Fathers,” and you think this actually proves your point? What you need, brother, is a good dose of reality.

Have you ever studied the circumstances of the Fifth Ecumenical Council? The Pope needed correction, and he conceded to the wisdom of his brother bishops. Thereafter, it was, as Canon 341 asserts, the approval of “the Roman Pontiff together with the Council Fathers” that gave that Council its ecumenical standing.

And did you know that even Pio Nono did not get everything he wanted at Vatican 1? He had chided a Patriarch with the words “I AM Tradition!” Yet, he fully conceded to the addition of the historical Proem to the Decree on Infallibility that was intended by the rest of the Council Fathers to ensure that even the Pope was bound by Sacred Tradition.

Absolutist Petrine advocates claim the error that the head is always correct. Low Petrine advocates claim the error that the majority is always correct. The High Petrine position asserts that it is only with the head acting together with the body, the body never apart from the head, nor the head apart from the body, that ensures both Truth and unity for the Church. If there is disagreement between the head and the body, neither one dominates. What occurs is that there is discussion - and even debate. But the outcome is not a result of the head imposing its views on the body, nor the body imposing its views on the head. Rather, the outcome is the result of the members of the Council AGREEING TOGETHER, not through force, but through a willful and conscientious deliberation.
IOW the council can’t act alone.
I don’t understand this comment. A Council by definition is [the bishop of Rome + his brother bishops]. So you’re saying the Pope with his brother bishops don’t have sufficient authority? It’s obvious you are confused about what a Council is.
Can the pope act ALONE? Yes
Nope. Nothing you’ve quoted states the Pope can act alone. Everything you’ve quoted so far has only asserted what the Pope’s prerogatives are. The exercise of those prerogatives is another matter altogether. (I thought that was worth repeating :p)
Wrong

There is no switch and bait.

The resources I’ve used are Vat I, Vat II, Trent, & canon law

Did I camp out on any one of those alone? No, I used them all.
So what if you used them all? You’re still blatantly confused between collegial authority, on the one hand, and papal authority, on the other.

Collegial authority is not mere papal authority used in a collegial setting. Collegial authority is the authority of ALL the bishops involved. Papal authority is a unique ELEMENT of collegial authority, but it by no means constitutes the entirety of collegial authority. Like I said, you can’t prove your “Pope alone” innovative error in the context of the College of Bishops or of the Ecumenical Council from Magisterial documents. So you (and brother Abu) had to impose Decrees on papal authority (I can confidently say at this point that your confusion was intentional) into the debate on collegial authority to try to save face.

give me the quote from any of the documents and sources I’ve already supplied, Trent, Vat I, Vat II, Canon law, that supports that opinion.
As stated, the exercise of prerogatives is a different issue from the prerogatives themselves. None of your sources so far have stated that the Pope can act alone. His particular prerogatives are certainly his alone, but the issue of exercising those prerogatives is not treated by Trent or Vatican 1. If we stop there, and depend on Sacred Tradition, we can only conclude that the Pope must act collegially, even for prerogatives that are uniquely his. What we do have from Vatican 2 and the Canons are statements on the exercise of the prerogatives of the College. On this, Vatican 2 and the Canons are clear (from the self-contradictory quotes - self-contradictory with respect to your opinion - given by you and brother Abu) that the prerogatives of the College are exercised by the body together with the head, not apart from each other.

You do provide a quote from Canon 333 which deserves some comment. But first, this:

CONTINUED​
 
CONTINUED

Really, I don’t have to do any homework on the matter. If we wait long enough, brother Abu will inadvertently always provide all the proof we need to refute your (and his) “the Pope can act alone” error (thanks brother Abu 👍). He did this with his pervious post, wherein he quoted then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, with the approbation of HH JP2 of thrice-blessed memory:
"Since the power of the primacy is supreme, there is no other authority to which the Roman Pontiff must juridically answer for his exercise of the gift he has received: “prima sedes a nemine iudicatur”.42 This does not mean, however, that the Pope has absolute power. listening to what the Churches are saying is, in fact, an earmark of the ministry of unity, a consequence also of the unity of the Episcopal Body and of the sensus fidei of the entire People of God; and this bond seems to enjoy considerably greater power and certainty than the juridical authorities - an inadmissible hypothesis, moreover, because it is groundless - to which the Roman Pontiff would supposedly have to answer.”

This is completely consistent with what I stated in an earlier post - namely, that while the juridical and executive aspects of papal infallibility and authority are singular, the legislative aspect (i.e., the formulation of an authoritative decree or an infallible definition) is collegial.
The pope “enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith (Luke 22:32), he proclaims by a definitive act some doctrine of faith or morals. Therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter.” [LG25]
Yes. This is the prerogative of the Pope. It is his and his alone by potestas. It’s exercise, however, is a different thing altogether, and that is governed by considerations of auctoritas, which is collegial in nature, as evinced by the quote from brother Abu above.
From Canon Law

Can. 333
§1. By virtue of his office, the Roman Pontiff not only possesses power offer the universal Church but also obtains the primacy of ordinary power over all particular churches and groups of them. Moreover, this primacy strengthens and protects the proper, ordinary, and immediate power which bishops possess in the particular churches entrusted to their care.
​

As HH JP2 of thrice blessed memory taught us in one of his Wednesday audiences:
“Inasmuch as the Church is a group of human beings called to carry out in history God’s plan for the salvation of the world, power in her appears as an indispensable requirement of mission. Nevertheless, the analogical value of the language used allows power to be conceived in the sense provided by Jesus’ maxim on “power in order to serve” and by the Gospel idea of the pastoral leader. The power required by the mission of Peter and his successors is identified with this authoritative leadership guaranteed of divine assistance, which Jesus himself called the ministry (service) of a shepherd…”
“Power” in the context of the Body of Christ is the “power to serve,” not the power to control. I would much rather listen to HH JP2 than to your own innovative, unbiblical and unpatristic errors, brother Steve.
§2. In fulfilling the office of supreme pastor of the Church, the Roman Pontiff is always joined in communion with the other bishops and with the universal Church. He nevertheless has the right, according to the needs of the Church, to determine the manner, whether personal or collegial, of exercising this office.
Here’s the section of Canon 333 that I stated earlier deserved some comment in relation to your error of the Pope exercising his prerogatives “alone.” Notice that this section does not state that the Pope can exercise his prerogatives “alone.” Rather, it says, distinctly, that he can exercise his prerogatives in a “personal” manner.

CONTINUED​
 
CONTINUED

Recall what I stated in an earlier post about potestas. Potestas is authority by virtue of (some may say “force of”) the law, whether ecclesiastical or divine. Potestas denotes something inherent in the one wielding authority (i.e., by virtue of the law itself). When the Canon here speaks of exercising his prerogatives in a “personal” or “collegial” manner, it is referring to his potestas. Indeed, the Pope can exercise his office of supreme pastor by virtue of his “personal” prerogative to be able to speak to and for the universal church, or he can exercise it within the College of bishops. But nowhere does the Canon state that he can exercise his prerogative (whether in a personal or collegial manner) ALONE. This is plainly evident from the self-contradictory quote given above by brother Abu from the CDF. The quote explains the exercise of the Pope’s PERSONAL authority as supreme judge. But though the role of supreme judge is a PERSONAL prerogative of the Pope, does it state that this personal prerogative is exercised “ALONE?” Absolutely not. Indeed, the Church’s involvement is not to judge the Pope, but the Pope must nevertheless listen to the Church before he can make his judgment. This is fully consistent with Bishop Gasser’s assertion (reflecting the OFFICIAL interpertation of the Fathers at V1) that the agreement of the WHOLE Magisterium is the RULE OF FAITH, EVEN FOR DEFINITIONS BY THE POPE.

The Collegial reality of the Church is supported by every quote that you and brother Abu have given. Your unpatristic, unbiblical, and plainly illogical “pope alone” paradigm must be rejected for the sake of Truth, and for the sake of unity.
§3. No appeal or recourse is permitted against a sentence or decree of the Roman Pontiff.
But the sentence or decree always comes in a collegial context.
Can. 335 When the Roman See is vacant or entirely impeded, nothing is to be altered in the governance of the universal Church; the special laws issued for these circumstances, however, are to be observed.
This only demonstrates the collegial nature of the Church (i.e., body with head). It does not support the “head alone” monstrosity that you defend.
What have the documents said? Can a pope act alone without an E council? Yes.
True, but his actions must be collegial nevertheless.😛
Can an E Council act alone without the pope? No
And neither can an E Council act alone without the rest of the bishops.😃 Of course, I’m just expressing myself using your terms to humor you. In fact, I believe your language is completely erroneous. The question should not be “Can an E Council act alone without the Pope?” Rather the question should be “Can the bishops act without the Pope IN an Ecumenical Council?” In this true version of the question, one can ask “Can the Pope act without the bishops in an Ecumenical Council?” The answer is a resounding NO.
What’s so hard to understand about any of the quotes I’ve given, particularly the following?

The pope “enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith (Luke 22:32), he proclaims by a definitive act some doctrine of faith or morals. Therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter.” [LG 25]
There’s nothing hard about it, if one actually accepts the ENTIRE teaching of Vatican 1, instead of the myopic snippets you utilize. V1 1 taught IN ADDITION to the myopic snippet you gave above, that “the Roman Pontiff, when he speaks ex cathedra…possesses through the divine assistance …the infallibility with which the divine Redeemer willed his Church to be endowed…” Further, among other things, the Council also explicitly changed the title of the Decree from “the Infallibility of the Pope” to “the Infallibility of the Magisterium of the Pope,” precisely to indicate that the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium can never be considered apart from the Church’s infallible Magisterium.

It seems your Cafeteria Catholicism is what causes you to have great difficulty in giving a simple “yes” or “no” to the simple question I asked.

The other problem is that you are imposing this V1 definition in the context of the E Council in order to defend the utterly fantastic error that ONLY the Pope has infallibility and authority in the context of an E Council or the College of Bishops. As constantly stated, my problem is not with V1 or V2 or the Canons - rather, it is with your Absolutist Petrine misinterpretations of them.
I considered that a cheap shot my friend. Accepting correction doesn’t interfere with one’s authority or independence. That’s the same stuff protestants pull when confusing impeccability with infalibility etc.
It doesn’t interfere with his authority, but it amply demonstrates that his authority is not exercised alone.
Am I to assume you’re more interested in trying to score points and cheap shots
.
You were wrong. And I pointed that out in a very lighthearted manner. 🙂

Blessings,
Marduk
 
I think we are engaging in this debate for the benefit of others who may not have made their minds up yet.
Hi Mardukm,

You’re right, I’ve been somewhat following this thread and haven’t made up my mind! I’m thankful for everyone who takes time for these discussions. They can make me feel uneducated and behind though. This issue is still fairly new to me.

Briefly, this discussion has been spirited, with some of the rhetoric and the way the emoticons have been used, the :p, the :rotfl:, etc, sometimes coming across as arrogant, provocative, and unhelpful. I’m sure I’m misinterpreting them. But, I humbly suggest toning some of that down or making it more lighthearted like in some of your other posts.

Thanks and God bless.
scalco
 
Dear brother Scalco,

Thank you for the exhortation. Steve B and I are old buddies, so I guess I take certain liberties with him that I normally would not with others. Brother Abu is a different story, and his self-contradictions really do make me laugh.

I confess a certain exasperation at certain moments, given my background as coming from Oriental Orthodoxy. I do not know your background, but I want to let you know that Eastern and Oriental Catholics have a very keen awareness and sensitivity to the issue of the papacy which may be lost on cradle Latin Catholics. If you follow the usual debates between the Orthodox and Catholics, the main sticking point is always the papacy. The fact that the dogmas of the papacy are fully patristic and can potentially be accepted by Orthodox hits one roadblock - the misinterpretations of Absolutist Petrine advocates (normally from the Latin Catholic Church) and Low Petrine advocates (normally from the Eastern Orthodox Church). Ironically, both the Absolutist and Low Petrine positions interpret the dogmas on the papacy in exactly the same way - i.e., in an exaggerated fashion. The only difference between them is that the Low Petrine position does this as a means to demean the papacy (i.e., their usual rhetoric is "to you the Pope is the only authority in the Church which is unpatristic and to be rejected), while the Absolutist Petrine position does this with a view to promoting the papacy (i.e., their usual rhetoric is "the Pope IS the only authority in the Church, and that’s the way it has to be).

Can you imagine the frustration of being so close yet being (seemingly) so far? In Christendom, unity with the Orthodox has the greatest potential to be realized, and it is a goal eagerly pursued by all the Popes in the past two centuries (at least). But it is being hampered by the errors that I and others are trying to combat here.

But I do thank you, once again, for your exhortation, and I will prayerfully keep it in mind.

Blessings,
Marduk
Hi Mardukm,

You’re right, I’ve been somewhat following this thread and haven’t made up my mind! I’m thankful for everyone who takes time for these discussions. They can make me feel uneducated and behind though. This issue is still fairly new to me.

Briefly, this discussion has been spirited, with some of the rhetoric and the way the emoticons have been used, the :p, the :rotfl:, etc, sometimes coming across as arrogant, provocative, and unhelpful. I’m sure I’m misinterpreting them. But, I humbly suggest toning some of that down or making it more lighthearted like in some of your other posts.

Thanks and God bless.
scalco
 
Hi Mardukm,

You’re right, I’ve been somewhat following this thread and haven’t made up my mind! I’m thankful for everyone who takes time for these discussions. They can make me feel uneducated and behind though. This issue is still fairly new to me.
Btw, brother Scalco. Please do ask questions if you want clarification.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
steve b:
IOW the council can’t act alone.

Don’t absolutize “together with the council fathers” as if that supports your opinion. We already know they are assembled for a council. They can’t act without the pope’s approval, confirmation, and promulgation. That’s the point.

Can the pope act ALONE? Yes
Here, I think, is the problem being addressed in this thread in a simple phrase.

The problem is this cut and paste battle of document quotes. It does NO GOOD to post quotes as “proof” of a point unless that point is firmly understood by both sides of the debate. In the quote above, I think we have the MAIN POINT being made by steve b, with a secondary point being the Pope IS NOT the first among equals, which is purely gratuitous, and hints of past arguments since no one in this thread has ever advanced this point.

steve b accuses Mardukm and his confreres as having denied the truth in his statement above. Yet Mardukm and others have categorically stated that they adhere to all the teachings of Vatican I and II (and Trent etc.) Which they do.

steve b does NOT understand that his statement is not the full truth, but rather a partial truth, and as a partial truth, I think we can all assent to its truth! 🤷 For example the sky is always blue. Well yes and no. If you are flying in a plane at 35000 ft, above the thunderheads, yes it’s true. Or Scientifically speaking, the sky is always blue, since clouds don’t count, etc. etc. But someone else might argue that it is often gray or red or pink etc.

The IMPORTANT thing for steve b to remember is that the Pope does not teach ANYTHING EVER, that has not ALWAYS BEEN a part of the Deposit of Faith, as promulgated over the centuries through the teaching Magisterium. In other words, the Pope NEVER EVER suddenly comes up with some new teaching that no one has ever heard before, nor can he do so. Why, because the PRIMARY FUNCTION of the Magisterium is to preserve and transmit the Deposit of Faith, without loss or addition.

So, NO, the Pope is NEVER operating by himself, without at the same time being in the context of the teaching Magisterium, in his own time, and all previous time.

However, that does not mean that the Pope cannot teach within the context of the teaching Magisterium, on his own authority, without any* legal requirement *for further episcopal approval. But even then, what he teaches, may or may not be infallible. It depends ultimately on the collective assent of all Church faithful and Magisterium. However this assent may already exist, such as the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception and Papal Infallibility itself.

Before Abu gets all excited about my saying that the infallibility depends “ultimately” on the collective assent etc., he should stop and realize that what I am really saying is that, even when the pope teaches without an official “ex cathedra” solemn statement, he may still be teaching infallibly. But it just won’t be known immediately.
 
Originally Posted by AmbroseSJ
Just as the Holy Spirit can not be reduced to a mere incantation of words or legal mumbo-jumbo, neither can Papal infallibility be precisely defined in the abstract. Yes, it can be theologically defined, but what I mean is it can not be said that “if the Pope says such and such, regardless of what his brother Bishops and the Faithful think, it is infallible.” That is what you have done above. However it can be observed by the Faithful in a given situation, and a given time after the fact.
My comments: PJM

My friend, one misses a very important factor in discusing “Infallibility” of ANY Biblical Author. Th issue is, or ought to be; MUTE.

Either the Bible in it’s intireity is TRUE or every part of it is suspect of TRUTH, and open to individual understanding [al of which wouls subjectively be “true”; and Objectively, possibiliy none of them being true…** READ John. 14:16-17 an John 17:15-19; then re-read
2nd. Tim. 3:16-17.

In an absolute sese there exist NO, Zip, Zero opportunity for un-trutfulnress; as TESTIFIED by Jesus Christ Himself. There can be “stories”; there can be mis-statemnt of historical facts [the Bible claims NOT to be a History Book; and certainly there are statements not meant to be taken literally; but present a MORAL Teaching:

[[COLOR=“Red”]Example: Matt.5 29 “If your right eye causes you to sin, pluck it out and throw it away; it is better that you lose one of your members than that your whole body be thrown into hell.”… This is Not a literal Truth; [all-though is is true]; rather Christ here is expressing how critically important it is to avoid temptation wrought through sight.]

PART OF THE original REPLY:
Just to draw this out a little more
.
Lets say in our extreme example above, the Pope had said something which he declared infallible and ex cathedra, yet without the consent of his brother bishops and the Faithful. The Magisterium would then teach that the pope had not taught infallibly (for whatever reason) But then some time later, maybe centuries later, what the Pope had said would be revisited and seen in a whole new light, due to the ever changing conditions of history. It would then be received by the whole Church in this new light (new perspective.)
NOT POSSIBLE!

The Pope is impowered to make an Infallible proclaimation on His OWN AUTHORITY, as the Vicor of Christ. Whereas, the Mgisterium MUST have the aproval of the reigning Pontiff.

Further Canon Law makes this statements:

THE ROMAN PONTIFF

Can. 331 The bishop of the Roman Church, in whom continues the office given by the Lord uniquely to Peter, the first of the Apostles, and to be transmitted to his successors, is the head of the college of bishops, the Vicar of Christ, and the pastor of the universal Church on earth. By virtue of his office he possesses supreme, full, immediate, and universal ordinary power in the Church, which he is always able to exercise freely.

Can. 332 §1
. The Roman Pontiff obtains full and supreme power in the Church by his acceptance of legitimate election together with episcopal consecration. Therefore, a person elected to the supreme pontificate who is marked with episcopal character obtains this power from the moment of acceptance. If the person elected lacks episcopal character, however, he is to be ordained a bishop immediately.

Can. 333 §1. By virtue of his office, the Roman Pontiff not only possesses power offer the universal Church but also obtains the primacy of ordinary power offer all particular churches and groups of them. Moreover, this primacy strengthens and protects the proper, ordinary, and immediate power which bishops possess in the particular churches entrusted to their care.

§2. In fulfilling the office of supreme pastor of the Church, the Roman Pontiff is always joined in communion with the other bishops and with the universal Church. He nevertheless has the right, according to the needs of the Church, to determine the manner, whether personal or collegial, of exercising this office.
*

§3. No appeal or recourse is permitted against a sentence or decree of the Roman Pontiff.

In SUMMURY: ALL intended Infallible Pronouncemnts either by the Pope Himself; or in unity with the Magesterium; ARE NEVER CHANAGEABLE. It might be possible to gain a further understanding; but the CORE belief as orginally defined and proclaimed is unchangeable.*

God Bless, Pat
 
And also CIC 336 the College of Bishops has supreme and full power over the universal Church, in union with its head:

Can. 336 The head of the College of Bishops is the Supreme Pontiff, and its members are the Bishops by virtue of their sacramental consecration and hierarchical communion with the head of the College and its members. This College of Bishops, in which the apostolic body abides in an unbroken manner, is, in union with its head and never without this head, also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church.

Can. 337 §1 The College of Bishops exercises its power over the universal Church in solemn form in an Ecumenical Council.

§2 It exercises this same power by the united action of the Bishops dispersed throughout the world, when this action is as such proclaimed or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff, so that it becomes a truly collegial act.

§3 It belongs to the Roman Pontiff to select and promote, according to the needs of the Church, ways in which the College of Bishops can exercise its office in respect of the universal Church in a collegial manner.
 
The confusion and misrepresentation will continue as long as these posters reject the teaching of Vatican I and II by confusing themselves. As shown below, they make their own trouble, and fantasise that they agree with Vatican I and II, yet can never support the mirage from Vatican I or II.
  1. mardukm, posts #202, 203
    while the juridical and executive aspects of papal infallibility and authority are singular, the legislative aspect (i.e., the formulation of an authoritative decree or an infallible definition) is collegial…his actions must be collegial nevertheless
  2. AmbroseSJ, post #207
    **that does not **mean that the Pope cannot teach within the context of the teaching Magisterium, on his own authority, **without any *legal requirement ***for further episcopal approval. But even then, what he teaches, may or may not be infallible. It depends ultimately on the collective assent of all Church faithful and Magisterium.
  1. Casti Connubii (Pius XI), Humanae Vitae (Paul VI), *Ordinatio Sacerdotalis *(John Paul II) all contain infallible, definitive exercises of papal infallibility NOT collegial. The bishops are bound to assent and teach what the Pope has defined in these Encyclicals if they are faithful to Christ and His Supreme Vicar, and the faithful are bound to assent, to remain faithful.
  2. **That additional continued error **is to fantasise that the infallibility of a Pope’s definition is dependant “on the collective assent of all the Church faithful and the Magisterium.” It is guaranteed by Christ through His Supreme Vicar who confirmed and promulgated the dogma at Vatican I, agreed collegially with the bishops.
“we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole Church, he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed His Church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals.”
“Therefore, such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the church, irreformable.
“So then, should anyone, which God forbid, have the temerity to reject this definition of ours: let him be anathema.” (Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus, 9).

Cardinal Ratzinger identifies the primacy and its exercise:
“Since the power of the primacy is supreme, there is no other authority to which the Roman Pontiff must juridically answer for his exercise of the gift he has received: “prima sedes a nemine iudicatur”.42
42. CIC, can. 1404: The First See is judged by no one.

As Vatican I and II have taught, Cardinal Ratzinger identifies clearly the error:
It is “an inadmissible hypothesis, moreover, because it is groundless” to presume that “This does not mean, however, that the Pope has absolute power. Listening to what the Churches are saying is, in fact, an earmark of the ministry of unity, a consequence also of the unity of the Episcopal Body and of the sensus fidei of the entire People of God; and this bond seems to enjoy considerably greater power and certainty than the juridical authorities.”

Vico knows that the full and supreme power of an Ecumenical Council derives from union with it’s head, the Pope, and never without his confirmation, while for the “absolute fullness” of the supreme power of Papal definitions “such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the Church, irreformable.”.
 
Here, I think, is the problem being addressed in this thread in a simple phrase.

The problem is this cut and paste battle of document quotes. It does NO GOOD to post quotes as “proof” of a point unless that point is firmly understood by both sides of the debate.
quoting Church documents,gives Church teaching, not one’s personal opinions.
A:
In the quote above, I think we have the MAIN POINT being made by steve b, with a secondary point being the Pope IS NOT the first among equals, which is purely gratuitous, and hints of past arguments since no one in this thread has ever advanced this point.

steve b accuses Mardukm and his confreres as having denied the truth in his statement above. Yet Mardukm and others have categorically stated that they adhere to all the teachings of Vatican I and II (and Trent etc.) Which they do.

steve b does NOT understand that his statement is not the full truth, but rather a partial truth, and as a partial truth, I think we can all assent to its truth! 🤷
My friend,

I entered this discussion 130+ post ago.
  • In that time I’ve quoted from Canon Law, Trent, Vat I, and Vat II copiously. I didn’t do any quote mining or take text out of context. I gave links to the documents I used, so one doesn’t have to go looking for the sources I used… Nothing was hidden. That quote you refer to, has been given by me before in far greater context to make my point.
  • By you suggesting there is only partial truth from ANY quote I’ve given, is to beg the question. Show me where it is, with quotes from Church documents, don’t just tell me. Anything else is just one’s personal opinion.
A:
The IMPORTANT thing for steve b to remember is that the Pope does not teach ANYTHING EVER, that has not ALWAYS BEEN a part of the Deposit of Faith, as promulgated over the centuries through the teaching Magisterium. In other words, the Pope NEVER EVER suddenly comes up with some new teaching that no one has ever heard before, nor can he do so. Why, because the PRIMARY FUNCTION of the Magisterium is to preserve and transmit the Deposit of Faith, without loss or addition.
Are you talking there about papal authority over all the Church? Or are you talking about papal infallibility?

If it’s authority

The Pope (catechism of trent)

Above all these, the Catholic Church has always placed the Supreme Pontiff of Rome, whom Cyril of Alexandria, in the Council of Ephesus, named the Chief Bishop, Father and Patriarch of the whole world. He sits in that chair of Peter in which beyond every shadow of doubt the Prince of the Apostles sat to the end of his days, and hence it is that in him the Church recognizes the highest degree of dignity, and a universality of jurisdiction derived, not from the decrees of men or Councils, but from God Himself. Wherefore he is the Father and guide of all the faithful, of all the Bishops, and of all the prelates, no matter how high their power and office; and as successor of St. Peter, as true and lawful Vicar of Christ our Lord, he governs the universal Church.

or from [LG 22]

The pope’s power of primacy over all, both pastors and faithful, remains whole and intact. In virtue of his office, that is as Vicar of Christ and pastor of the whole Church, the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And he is always free to exercise this power.

If it’s re: infallibility, this is from [LG 25]

Infallibility belongs in a special way to the pope as head of the bishops (Matt. 16:17–19; John 21:15–17). As Vatican II remarked, it is a charism the pope “enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith (Luke 22:32), he proclaims by a definitive act some doctrine of faith or morals. Therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter.” [LG 25]
A:
So, NO, the Pope is NEVER operating by himself, without at the same time being in the context of the teaching Magisterium, in his own time, and all previous time.

However, that does not mean that the Pope cannot teach within the context of the teaching Magisterium, on his own authority, without any* legal requirement *for further episcopal approval.
Actually it’s within the context of his office as supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful

And again, the quote I used above from [LG 25] says the HS is the one who makes the pope’s pronouncements irreformable, an assistance promised to him in Blessed Peter.
A:
But even then, what he teaches, may or may not be infallible. It depends ultimately on the collective assent of all Church faithful and Magisterium.
see [LG 25] above.
A:
Before Abu gets all excited about my saying that the infallibility depends “ultimately” on the collective assent etc., he should stop and realize that what I am really saying is that, even when the pope teaches without an official “ex cathedra” solemn statement, he may still be teaching infallibly. But it just won’t be known immediately.
Re: papal infallibility
plase give Church requirements for papal infallibility. It’s very specific, It’s not general, and it is definitional.
 
  1. Casti Connubii (Pius XI)
Possibly. But, nevertheless, it was a Decree that reflected the mind of the Church, not the Pope alone, or do you deny that?
Humanae Vitae (Paul VI)
Nope. It was merely an ordinary exercise of the infallible Magisterium. And the ordinary Magisterium is collegial. Of course, there are those who say it was an extraordinary exercise of the infallible Magisterium, though even the extraordinary exercise of the infallible Magisterium by the Pope has a definite collegial element involved.
*Ordinatio Sacerdotalis *(John Paul II)
Nope. Ordinary Magisterium.
all contain infallible, definitive exercises of papal infallibility NOT collegial.
Casti connubi had a collegial element. Humanae Vitae and Ordinatio Sacerdotalis were definitely collegial in nature.
The bishops are bound to assent and teach what the Pope has defined in these Encyclicals if they are faithful to Christ and His Supreme Vicar, and the faithful are bound to assent, to remain faithful.
And the Pope is bound to define only that which is the Faith of the Church, and nothing else.
  1. **That additional continued error **is to fantasise that the infallibility of a Pope’s definition is dependant “on the collective assent of all the Church faithful and the Magisterium.”
“The collective assent of all the Church faithful and the Magisterium” is otherwise known as the sensus fidei of the Church. So according to you, it is an error to believe that the Pope can only teach according to the sensus fidei of the Church. I hope everyone reading this thread will realize by now how mistaken brother Abu’s position is.
It is guaranteed by Christ through His Supreme Vicar who confirmed and promulgated the dogma at Vatican I, agreed collegially with the bishops.
I think this is actually the first sensible thing you have stated in the whole thread. Thank you.
“we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole Church, he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed His Church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals.”
“Therefore, such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the church, irreformable.
Yes, after the definition is made, there is no room to gainsay that teaching. But before the definition is made, the Church has a definite bearing on the formulation of what will eventually be the definition.
“So then, should anyone, which God forbid, have the temerity to reject this definition of ours: let him be anathema.” (Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus, 9).
Yes. The definition states specifically that the infallibility exercised by the Pope is the infallibility that Christ endowed to his Church. Anyone who seeks to separate the Pope’s exercise of the infallible Magisterium from the Church’s infallible Magisterium is going against the definition of Vatican 1 and places themselves under anathema.
As Vatican I and II have taught, Cardinal Ratzinger identifies clearly the error:
It is “an inadmissible hypothesis, moreover, because it is groundless” to presume that “This does not mean, however, that the Pope has absolute power. Listening to what the Churches are saying is, in fact, an earmark of the ministry of unity, a consequence also of the unity of the Episcopal Body and of the sensus fidei of the entire People of God; and this bond seems to enjoy considerably greater power and certainty than the juridical authorities.”
Brother Abu, your deliberate “cut and paste” hack job of the CDF’s statement is shocking. The lengths to which Absolutist Petrine advocates will twist the truth to defend their unpatristic and unbiblical position I guess knows no bounds.

In the original citation, the clause “inadmissible hypothesis, moreover, because it is groundless” is specifically attached to the term “juridical authorities.” What is an inadmissible hypothesis according to the CDF is the idea that there is a juridical authority above the Pope. But you purposely wrench that clause from its context, and conveniently place it before the statement that the Pope must listen to the Churches for him to effectively fulfill his ministry of unity. You are purposely misleading people here.
Vico knows that the full and supreme power of an Ecumenical Council derives from union with it’s head, the Pope, and never without his confirmation,
Nope. The Supreme authority of an Ecumenical Council derives from the WHOLE body of bishops. The Pope’s agreement and confirmation as protos is ONLY ONE ELEMENT of what makes up the authority of an Ecumenical Council. The agreement of his brother bishops is ALSO JUST AS IMPORTANT AN ELEMENT, and an Ecumenical Council is not ecumenical without that agreement of the bishops.
while for the “absolute fullness” of the supreme power of Papal definitions “such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the Church, irreformable.”.
Yes, they are irreformible after the definition has been made. But during the formulation of what will eventually be the “definition,” the Church has a definite role in the matter, and it is not the Pope alone.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother SteveB,
quoting Church documents,gives Church teaching, not one’s personal opinions.
But when you highlight only certain portions of it to defend your partial truth, then you are giving your mere opinion, not the WHOLE Truth that the Church teaches. And I have consistently shown you that this is what you and brother Abu have been doing all along in your quotations.
*]In that time I’ve quoted from Canon Law, Trent, Vat I, and Vat II copiously. I didn’t do any quote mining or take text out of context. I gave links to the documents I used, so one doesn’t have to go looking for the sources I used… Nothing was hidden. That quote you refer to, has been given by me before in far greater context to make my point.
*]By you suggesting there is only partial truth from ANY quote I’ve given, is to beg the question. Show me where it is, with quotes from Church documents, don’t just tell me. Anything else is just one’s personal opinion.
As stated, you have quotes, but only focused on certain portions of those quotes, not the entire context.
Are you talking there about papal authority over all the Church? Or are you talking about papal infallibility?
Why do you make this distinction now when you yourself confuse the matter in your past posts?
If it’s authority

If it’s re: infallibility, this is from [LG 25]
This is the whole problem with the position that you and brother Abu have been advocating. You can’t give any straight answers but have to dance around it. Do you or do you not agree with brother AmbroseSJ’s statement that the Pope CANNOT define ANYTHING beyond the sensus fidei of the Church? Please answer with a simple yes or no.
Re: papal infallibility
plase give Church requirements for papal infallibility. It’s very specific, It’s not general, and it is definitional.
Here is a perfect example of the partial truth that you keep proposing. You want brother AmbroseSJ to focus just on the “requirements for papal infallibility.” In distinction from your myopic focus, we want you to focus on the ENTIRE Decree. The ENTIRE Decree states explicitly that the infallibility exercised by the Pope is the infallibility that Christ endowed HIS CHURCH - i.e., not the Pope ALONE.

Once you are able to take into consideration the ENTIRE Decree, and not mere snippets of it, then you will realize that your request to brother AmbroseSJ, “Please give the Church requirements for papal infallibility” is wrong. Your request should rather be, “Please give the Church requirements for the Pope to be able to exercise the infallible Magisterium of the Church.”

Blessings,
Marduk
 
ONCE AGAIN. I guess you missed the part where it says “together with the council Fathers.”

NOTE: As stated initially in this post, your usual tactic has been to ignore what I have pointed out to you in the very texts you give. Please keep this current example in mind.

:rotfl: You plead with me not to absolutize, when you’re the only one who is absolutizing one specific portion of the text while NEGLECTING the rest of it. Does it say “the Pope’s approval ALONE?” :rotfl: What’s your answer brother? Watch and learn. Your next response will be to avoid answering my question. As stated in earlier posts, you have not give a single iota of evidence for your unpatristic and unbiblical position from Magisterial texts.
From Canon Law

Can. 341
§1. The decrees of an ecumenical council do not have obligatory force unless they have been approved by the Roman Pontiff together with the council fathers, confirmed by him, and promulgated at his order.

§2. To have obligatory force, decrees which the college of bishops issues when it places a truly collegial action in another way initiated or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff need the same confirmation and promulgation.

In all circumstances, what happens if the pope doesn’t approve and confirm the council fathers decrees,?
  • the decrees have no obligatory force
  • Can the council fathers out vote the pope? No.
  • Can they override the pope? No.
  • Is there recourse? No.
 
40.png
steve:
Re: “only”

What provisions are necessary for a council to act such that all must follow their instruction with faith?
  • must be in union with each other
  • must be in union with the pope
  • must be on matters of faith and morals
  • must concur in a single viewpoint and must be held conclusively
When those provisions happen, then “Their definitions must be adhered to”
M:
I guess you missed “must be in union with each other” part, and skipped right to “must be in union with the Pope.” :rolleyes: As stated, your position is based completely on a myopic reading of the texts, while utterly neglecting the context.

NOTE: As stated initially in this post, your usual tactic has been to ignore what I have pointed out to you in the very texts you give. Please keep this current example in mind.
40.png
steve:
Did I leave “must be in union with each other” out? No. It’s right there for everyone to see. I left nothing out. I didn’t do any funny editing. All the provisions are there. The context is intact.

There’s a distinction being made between the bishops in council, and the pope.
 
Dear brother SteveB,
Did I leave “must be in union with each other” out? No. It’s right there for everyone to see. I left nothing out. I didn’t do any funny editing. All the provisions are there. The context is intact.

There’s a distinction being made between the bishops in council, and the pope.
But your (and brother Abu’s) position has consistently been that ONLY the Pope grants an Ecumenical Council (or the College of Bishops) its authority. You have defended this position by myopically focusing only on particular texts of your quotes. And this is a perfect example. You claim that you have given the entire context, but you yourself don’t actually take into account the entire context to support your erroneous position.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother SteveB,
In all circumstances, what happens if the pope doesn’t approve and confirm the council fathers decrees,?
  • the decrees have no obligatory force
  • Can the council fathers out vote the pope? No.
  • Can they override the pope? No.
  • Is there recourse? No.
In all circumstances, what happens if the rest of the bishops don’t give their approval.
  • The decrees have no obligatory universal (you forgot that part) force, though it can have a local authority.
  • Can the Pope out-vote the Council Fathers? No. The principle of authority of an Ecumenical Council is that it must have the agreement of both the body + head (or at least a moral majority of the body + head).
  • Can the Pope override the Council Fathers? Yes and no. He can direct the deliberations of the Council, but the final judgment is an action of the Holy Spirit throughout the Council, not just the Pope. So the decisions of the Council Fathers do not have universal authority without the Pope’s approval, but neither does the Pope’s approval alone constitute the universal authority of the Council, which also requires the approval of his brother bishops.
  • Is there recourse? On a matter of discipline, yes. On a matter of doctrine on faith and morals, generally no, but there can be future clarifications.
Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother SteveB,

Can you please answer the question:

“What are the Church requirements for the Pope to be able to exercise the infallible Magisterium of the Church.?”

Thanks.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
nope. Vatican 1 only established what the papal prerogatives are. The exercise of those prerogatives is another thing altogether. I gave you the ecclesiological principle involved in my last post. I see you failed to respond to that portion. That’s ok. You know when you’ve lost the debate.😉
40.png
steve:
a pope’s perogatives and exercise of those perogatives belong to the pope.

Vat I
session 4 chapter 3.on the power and character of the primacy of the roman pontiff
  1. And so, supported by the clear witness of holy scripture, and adhering to the manifest and explicit decrees both of our predecessors the roman pontiffs and of general councils, we promulgate anew the definition of the ecumenical council of florence [49], which must be believed by all faithful christians, namely that the apostolic see and the roman pontiff hold a world-wide primacy, and that the roman pontiff is the successor of blessed peter, the prince of the apostles, true vicar of christ, head of the whole church and father and teacher of all christian people.
    to him, in blessed peter, full power has been given by our lord jesus christ to tend, rule and govern the universal church.
    all this is to be found in the acts of the ecumenical councils and the sacred canons.
  2. Wherefore we teach and declare that, by divine ordinance, the roman church possesses a pre-eminence of ordinary power over every other church, and that this jurisdictional power of the roman pontiff is both episcopal and immediate. both clergy and faithful, of whatever rite and dignity, both singly and collectively, are bound to submit to this power by the duty of hierarchical subordination and true obedience, and this not only in matters concerning faith and morals, but also in those which regard the discipline and government of the church throughout the world.
  3. In this way, by unity with the roman pontiff in communion and in profession of the same faith , the church of christ becomes one flock under one supreme shepherd [50].
  4. This is the teaching of the catholic truth, and no one can depart from it without endangering his faith and salvation.
  5. this power of the supreme pontiff by no means detracts from that ordinary and immediate power of episcopal jurisdiction, by which bishops, who have succeeded to the place of the apostles by appointment of the holy spirit, tend and govern individually the particular flocks which have been assigned to them. on the contrary, this power of theirs is asserted, supported and defended by the supreme and universal pastor; for st. Gregory the great says: “my honor is the honor of the whole church. My honor is the steadfast strength of my brethren. Then do i receive true honor, when it is denied to none of those to whom honor is due.” [51]
  6. Furthermore, it follows from that supreme power which the roman pontiff has in governing the whole church, that he has the right, in the performance of this office of his, to communicate freely with the pastors and flocks of the entire church, so that they may be taught and guided by him in the way of salvation.
  7. And therefore we condemn and reject the opinions of those who hold that this communication of the supreme head with pastors and flocks may be lawfully obstructed; or that it should be dependent on the civil power, which leads them to maintain that what is determined by the apostolic see or by its authority concerning the government of the church, has no force or effect unless it is confirmed by the agreement of the civil authority.
  8. since the roman pontiff, by the divine right of the apostolic primacy, governs the whole church, we likewise teach and declare that he is the supreme judge of the faithful [52], and that in all cases which fall under ecclesiastical jurisdiction recourse may be had to his judgment [53]. The sentence of the apostolic see (than which there is no higher authority) is not subject to revision by anyone, nor may anyone lawfully pass judgment thereupon [54]. And so they stray from the genuine path of truth who maintain that it is lawful to appeal from the judgments of the roman pontiffs to an ecumenical council as if this were an authority superior to the roman pontiff.
  9. So, then, if anyone says that the roman pontiff has merely an office of supervision and guidance, and not the full and supreme power of jurisdiction over the whole church, and this not only in matters of faith and morals, but also in those which concern the discipline and government of the church dispersed throughout the whole world; or that he has only the principal part, but not the absolute fullness, of this supreme power; or that this power of his is not ordinary and immediate both over all and each of the churches and over all and each of the pastors and faithful: Let him be anathema.
.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top