The Vatican Dogma

  • Thread starter Thread starter militantsparrow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
CONTINUED
A bit. And I have no objection to the above.
👍
Yes. It should be noted that it’s impossible for the above to happen if the Pope is speaking ex cathedra.
Agreed. But I thought we were talking about the context of an Ecum Council?
But we’re morally bound not to follow BECAUSE the error is destructive to the Church, NOT BECAUSE he does not heed the correction of his brother bishops.
Agreed. But, again, I thought we were talking about the context of an Ecumenical Council. I was unclear, so I apologize. When I cited St. Bellarmine’s principle, I actually meant it in the context of an Ecum Council. When I said “we,” I actually meant “his brother bishops.” Sorry for my lack of precision. In an Ecum Council, the Holy Spirit works in and through the entire Council. The Pope has no unique infallibility in an Ecum Council. Every action in the Council of individual bishops is considered as an act of the one body. So within an Ecum Council, it could be the case that the Pope corrects his brother bishops, but it could also be the case that the Pope is corrected by his brother bishops. What matters is the resulting COLLEGIAL decision coming from BOTH the head bishop (i.e, the Pope) and his brother bishops. Earlier, I gave two examples where the Pope was corrected by his brother bishops in the context of an Ecum Council (the Fifth Ecumenical Council, and Vatican 1).
No. 1 is certainly erroneous. It is true that ecumenical council necessarily needs the pope to be ecumenical but the authority does not flow from the pope alone. Quite hair splitting but that’s the way it is.
No. 2 is also erroneous for the same reason as above.
Thank you for your support. Permit me to explain the matter a little more. When I (and others) challenged brothers Abu and SteveB on their errors about what constitutes the authority and infallibility of an Ecum Council, what they did was appeal to the Decrees of V1 that really had nothing to do with an Ecumenical Council, but was rather focused on Papal primacy and the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium. They applied the teaching of V1 to an Ecum Council (and also generally to the College of Bishops), and thereby felt that their position - that the authority and infallibility of an Ecum Council is by virtue of the authority and the infallibility of the Pope ALONE - was justified.

Brothers Ambrose SJ, Vico, and I opposed this error by asserting that
(1) the infallibility of an Ecum Council (and, generally, of the College of Bishops) is not from the Pope, but from God, and the Holy Spirit grants the ENTIRE Council infallibility, not the Pope alone.
(2) the authority of an Ecum Council (and, generally, of the College of Bishops) comes not from the authority of the Pope ALONE, but from the COLLEGIAL authority of ALL the bishops combined.

I hope brothers AmbroseSJ, Vico and I can count you in support of the High Petrine position.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Thank you for your (name removed by moderator)ut, brother Vico. Agreed, as usual.

Blessings,
Marduk
Mardukm wrote: “The collective assent of all the Church faithful and the Magisterium” is otherwise known as the sensus fidei of the Church. So according to you, it is an error to believe that the Pope can only teach according to the sensus fidei of the Church.

The Holy Spirit is source of the sense of faith.

We know that the source of the sense of faith of the Church, *sensus fidei *is the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit is guiding the faithful and the Magisterium. We know that there are three specific ways this exists, mentioned in the decrees of the councils, which are infallible: ex cathedra expression of the Holy Spirit’s guidance through the discharge of the office of the Supreme Pontiff, and the infallible expression of the concilliar Church, and the infallible united teaching of the ordinary Magisterium out of council. There are also the forms of fallible expression, also guided by the Holy Spirit; those statements made by the Magisterium which are not irreformale but yet are to be held as true.

As an example of how this may occur, we see that Constantinople 381 was a local council and came to be accepted by the Latin Church only at Constantinople 553 with Pope Vigilus, when it became a general council, yet the truths of Constantinople 381 were ever the same from 381 to 553, not yet recognized in the west. There are degrees of certainty of promulgated doctrines, which may be at different degress in various locations at once. The Holy Spirit is still at work to bring acceptance.
 
In the extreme case you have given Beng (God forbid such a thing,) the Faithful would look upon the Pope in disagreement with the council bishops, and be forced to decide for themselves (infallibility of the Faithful) who was on the side of Truth. Sensus Fidelium.

The truth can not be opposed to itself.

Ultimately, Church infallibility will always be protected by the Holy Spirit, either through the Pope, and/or the Ordinary Magisterium and/or the Faithful. They are complementary, not antagonistic to one another.
Amen and Amen, brother!

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Scalco,

Thank you for the exhortation. Steve B and I are old buddies, so I guess I take certain liberties with him that I normally would not with others. Brother Abu is a different story, and his self-contradictions really do make me laugh.

I confess a certain exasperation at certain moments, given my background as coming from Oriental Orthodoxy. I do not know your background, but I want to let you know that Eastern and Oriental Catholics have a very keen awareness and sensitivity to the issue of the papacy which may be lost on cradle Latin Catholics. If you follow the usual debates between the Orthodox and Catholics, the main sticking point is always the papacy. The fact that the dogmas of the papacy are fully patristic and can potentially be accepted by Orthodox hits one roadblock - the misinterpretations of Absolutist Petrine advocates (normally from the Latin Catholic Church) and Low Petrine advocates (normally from the Eastern Orthodox Church). Ironically, both the Absolutist and Low Petrine positions interpret the dogmas on the papacy in exactly the same way - i.e., in an exaggerated fashion. The only difference between them is that the Low Petrine position does this as a means to demean the papacy (i.e., their usual rhetoric is "to you the Pope is the only authority in the Church which is unpatristic and to be rejected), while the Absolutist Petrine position does this with a view to promoting the papacy (i.e., their usual rhetoric is "the Pope IS the only authority in the Church, and that’s the way it has to be).

Can you imagine the frustration of being so close yet being (seemingly) so far? In Christendom, unity with the Orthodox has the greatest potential to be realized, and it is a goal eagerly pursued by all the Popes in the past two centuries (at least). But it is being hampered by the errors that I and others are trying to combat here.

But I do thank you, once again, for your exhortation, and I will prayerfully keep it in mind.

Blessings,
Marduk
Thank you! 👍
 
Btw, brother Scalco. Please do ask questions if you want clarification.

Blessings,
Marduk
Thank you Mardukm. I feel I can find the answers to most of my questions in here if I take the time and effort. I’m thinking about reading this thread again from the beginning, I think that will help.

God bless.
Scalco
 
Amen and Amen, brother!

Blessings,
Marduk
I just want to say I really appreciate all of the good points you have been making in this thread, and that I have learned some good things. I didn’t understand the distinctions between the Absolutist, High and Low Petrine viewpoints. I also was unaware of the neo-ultramontane party. I’m glad you are keeping me up to speed with all of the latest. 🙂

I have been associating the neo-ultramontanes with the ultramontanes that John Henry Newman battled. I think I have drunk so deeply of the writings of John Henry Newman, it has perhaps expanded my awareness of the scope of Catholic teaching. In any event I certainly have to agree with the direction of your arguments.
 
CONTINUED

The Pope has no unique infallibility in an Ecum Council.
Is his infallibility dependent on anyone else? No. Is the council’s infallibility dependent on anyone else? Yes. The one who confirms or doesn’t confirm their decisions.
.
 
Dear brother SteveB,

But your (and brother Abu’s) position has consistently been that ONLY the Pope grants an Ecumenical Council (or the College of Bishops) its authority. You have defended this position by myopically focusing only on particular texts of your quotes. And this is a perfect example. You claim that you have given the entire context, but you yourself don’t actually take into account the entire context to support your erroneous position.

Blessings,
Marduk
Is this enough context?

[Ch 3 #22 LG] va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19641121_lumen-gentium_en.html

But the college or body of bishops has no authority unless it is understood together with the Roman Pontiff, the successor of Peter as its head. The pope’s power of primacy over all, both pastors and faithful, remains whole and intact. In virtue of his office, that is as Vicar of Christ and pastor of the whole Church, the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And he is always free to exercise this power.

The order of bishops, which succeeds to the college of apostles and gives this apostolic body continued existence, is also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.(27*) This power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff. For our Lord placed Simon alone as the rock and the bearer of the keys of the Church,(156) and made him shepherd of the whole flock;(157) it is evident, however, that the power of binding and loosing, which was given to Peter,(158) was granted also to the college of apostles, joined with their head.(159)(28*) This college, insofar as it is composed of many, expresses the variety and universality of the People of God, but insofar as it is assembled under one head, it expresses the unity of the flock of Christ. In it, the bishops, faithfully recognizing the primacy and pre-eminence of their head, exercise their own authority for the good of their own faithful, and indeed of the whole Church, the Holy Spirit supporting its organic structure and harmony with moderation. The supreme power in the universal Church, which this college enjoys, is exercised in a solemn way in an ecumenical council. A council is never ecumenical unless it is confirmed or at least accepted as such by the successor of Peter; and it is prerogative of the Roman Pontiff to convoke these councils, to preside over them and to confirm them.(29*) This same collegiate power can be exercised together with the pope by the bishops living in all parts of the world, provided that the head of the college calls them to collegiate action, or at least approves of or freely accepts the united action of the scattered bishops, so that it is thereby made a collegiate act.

From Canon Law

Can. 341
§1. The decrees of an ecumenical council do not have obligatory force unless they have been approved by the Roman Pontiff together with the council fathers, confirmed by him, and promulgated at his order.

§2. To have obligatory force, decrees which the college of bishops issues when it places a truly collegial action in another way initiated or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff need the same confirmation and promulgation.
 
Dear brother SteveB,

No one denies that the Pope’s unique prerogatives are PERSONAL. But are they exercised ALONE? Does he have the capacity to exercise his prerogatives without any consideration of his brother bishops? It is a question that you have consistently failed to answer in the affirmative from the quotes you have given.
If he can’t exercise his roll alone if necessary, then he’s not over anybody, primacy and supremacy is hot air, thus he’s merely 1st among equals. But that’s NOT the way it is.

my comments in blue

[LG ch3 #25]

And this is the infallibility which the Roman Pontiff, the head of the college of bishops, enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith,(166) by a definitive act he proclaims a doctrine of faith or morals.(42*) And therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly styled irreformable, since they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, promised to him in blessed Peter, and therefore they need no approval of others, nor do they allow an appeal to any other judgment.

Do you see that the pope enjoys in virtue of his office, the power to define doctrine in faith and morals on his own without consent of the Church?

For then the Roman Pontiff is not pronouncing judgment as a private person, but as the supreme teacher of the universal Church, in whom the charism of infallibility of the Church itself is individually present, he is expounding or defending a doctrine of Catholic faith.(43*)

Do you see that infallibility for the universal Church is individually present in the pope without anyone’s approval or consent?

The infallibility promised to the Church resides also in the body of Bishops, when that body exercises the supreme magisterium with the successor of Peter. To these definitions the assent of the Church can never be wanting, on account of the activity of that same Holy Spirit, by which the whole flock of Christ is preserved and progresses in unity of faith.(44*)

The bishops are also able to exercise infallibility WHEN that body exercises their authority with the pope. Their infallibility therefore, is conditional on the pope’s confirming their actions. And notice, everyone needs to assent to this.

From Vat I
  1. This gift of truth and never-failing faith was therefore divinely conferred on Peter and his successors in this See so that they might discharge their exalted office for the salvation of all, and so that the whole flock of Christ might be kept away by them, from the poisonous food of error, and be nourished with the sustenance of heavenly doctrine. Thus the tendency to schism is removed and the whole Church is preserved in unity, and, resting on its foundation, can stand firm against the gates of hell.
  2. But since in this very age when the salutary effectiveness of the apostolic office is most especially needed, not a few are to be found who disparage its authority, we judge it absolutely necessary to affirm solemnly the prerogative which the only-begotten Son of God was pleased to attach to the supreme pastoral office.
I think #8 we see too much arguing against papal authority, and diobedience to authority via taking away from Church documents what one thinks the “spirit” of the document says. “spirit” of the document is a type of code for gut what you don’t like and rewrite it so it reads better to ones sensibilities.
M]

He’s got the primacy. Does he exercise universal authority ALONE? This portion is silent.
Vat I session 4 ch3 #1-2 ewtn.com/library/councils/v1.htm#6

the Apostolic See and the Roman Pontiff hold a world-wide primacy, and that the Roman Pontiff is the successor of blessed Peter, the prince of the apostles, true vicar of Christ, head of the whole Church and father and teacher of all Christian people.
To him, in blessed Peter, full power has been given by our lord Jesus Christ to tend, rule and govern the universal Church.

All this is to be found in the acts of the ecumenical councils and the sacred canons
  1. Wherefore we teach and declare that, by divine ordinance, the Roman Church possesses a pre-eminence of ordinary power over every other Church, and that this jurisdictional power of the Roman Pontiff is both episcopal and immediate. Both clergy and faithful, of whatever rite and dignity, both singly and collectively, are bound to submit to this power by the duty of hierarchical subordination and true obedience, and this not only in matters concerning faith and morals, but also in those which regard the discipline and government of the Church throughout the world.
  2. In this way, by unity with the Roman Pontiff in communion and in profession of the same faith , the Church of Christ becomes one flock under one Supreme Shepherd [50].
 
mardukm,
  1. post #231: Abu had claimed that (1) the authority of an Ecumenical Council is from the Pope ALONE, and (2) the infallibility of an Ecumenical Council is from the Pope ALONE.
  1. Vatican II teaches “the college or body of bishops has no authority unless…we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.(27) This power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontif*f. For our Lord placed Simon ALONE as the rock and the bearer of the keys of the Church
**The Vatican II Dogmatic Constitution on the Church ensures the Primacy
“22. But **the college or body of bishops has no authority unless *it is understood together with the Roman Pontiff, the successor of Peter as its head. The pope’s power of primacy over all, both pastors and faithful, remains whole and intact. In virtue of his office, that is as Vicar of Christ and pastor of the whole Church, the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And he is always free to exercise this power. The order of bishops, which succeeds to the college of apostles and gives this apostolic body continued existence, is also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.(27) This power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff. For our Lord placed Simon ALONE as the rock and the bearer of the keys of the Church,(156) and made him shepherd of the whole flock;(157) it is evident, however, that the power of binding and loosing, which was given to Peter,(158) was granted also to the college of apostles, joined with their head.(159)

The Code of Canon Law is quite clear.
“Can. 338 ß1 **It is the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff ALONE **to summon an Ecumenical Council, to preside over it personally or through others, to transfer, suspend or dissolve the Council, and to approve its decrees.
“ß2 It is also the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff to determine the matters to be dealt with in the Council, and to establish the order to be observed. The Fathers of the Council may add other matters to those proposed by the Roman Pontiff, but these must be approved by the Roman Pontiff.”

In post #247 steve b has again given the truth for Canons #341,and #342.
 
The problem with relying strictly on quotes becomes analogous to the Sola Scriptura Protestants. They will overwhelm anything you can say to them with a blizzard of Biblical Quotes. How does that help a discussion? It becomes a mere quote battle.
I personally think some Catholics jump on protestants too fast when they use scripture.

Re:quote battles on Church docs,
  • Not everybody knows the text or is even familiar with the text. It;s NOT like scripture. If Church docs aren’t known, or known very well, then the text needs to be presented so everyone knows the boundries and what one is specifically talking about…true?
  • When one hears another use phrases that are against texts being discussed, then it’s easy to present the text so the person can be corrected.
  • In the case of Vatican Dogma, the subject of the thread, it’s very helpful to quote Church docs, otherwise the subject can get derailed, or misrepresented. Plus the texts bring authority to the discussion that an individual expressing their opinion, just doesn’t have.
A:
The Vatican documents MUST be seen in the light of ALL church teaching since Apostolic times. To Ignore History, Tradition and the Deposit of Faith, and keep one’s focus entirely on the Vatican Documents to the exclusion of everything else, IS TO LOSE the understanding that underlies all Magisterial teachings. You have lost sight of the forest because of the trees.
Since we’re talking about Vatican Dogma, don’t you think it’s appropriate to dig into Vatican documents?
 
  1. mardukm, post #239: Abu and Steve b insist that the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium is exercised ALONE, without any relation to or dependence on the Magisterium of the Church.
  1. The Church’s teaching has been emphasised repeatedly.
    There is no other “Magisterium” (teaching authority) of the Church on which the Pope is “dependant”. The Magisterium exercises infallibility in an Ecumenical Council of Bishops confirmed by the Pope, which defines dogma or doctrine. The Pope exercises infallibility on his own when he defines dogma or doctrine. The Pope uses the contemplation and study of the faithful – hierarchy and lay – to define on his own, with the authority of Christ.
Post #222:
“Thus, however much the Sacred Magisterium avails itself of the contemplation, life and study of the faithful, its office is not reduced merely to ratifying the assent already expressed by the latter; indeed, in the interpretation and explanation of the written or transmitted Word of God, the Magisterium can anticipate or demand their assent.(23)
23. Cf. Vatican Council I: Dogmatic Consitution, Pastor aeternus, ch. 4”

Post #174:
“And this is the infallibility which the Roman Pontiff, the head of the college of bishops, enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith,(166) by a definitive act he proclaims a doctrine of faith or morals.(42*) And therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly styled irreformable, since they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, promised to him in blessed Peter, and therefore they need no approval of others, nor do they allow an appeal to any other judgment.” (Vatican II, Lumen Gentium, 25).
 
In the extreme case you have given Beng (God forbid such a thing,) the Faithful would look upon the Pope in disagreement with the council bishops, and be forced to decide for themselves (infallibility of the Faithful) who was on the side of Truth. Sensus Fidelium.

The truth can not be opposed to itself.

Ultimately, Church infallibility will always be protected by the Holy Spirit, either through the Pope, and/or the Ordinary Magisterium and/or the Faithful. They are complementary, not antagonistic to one another.
If the matter is not about dogmatic teaching then the faithful plus the rest of the bishops may disagree, but they must treat the Pope ruling with reverence.

If the matter is about dogmatic teachings then it’s obviously the faithful and the rest of the bishops who are in error. If it is the Pope Vs the rest of the Church [the bishops plus all the faithful] on dogmatic teachings, the pope would be ALWAYS in the right. That is the Catholic faith.
 
The principle of the ancient Apostolic Canon 34 asserts that consensus must be obtained between the head bishop and his brother bishops before a matter affecting the universal Church can be enacted or resolved. The Canon basically states that the bishops of every nation must recognize him who is their head, and can do nothing of great importance without his consent, but neither can he do anything of great importance without their consent, in order to ensure the unity of the Church (are you familiar with this Canon, or do you want me to give you an exact quote?). The Apostolic Canon does not say that the head must consult his brother bishops. It simply states that consensus must be realized. But consensus does not necessarily need to be determined through direct consultation; consensus can be determined by other means. This is why I disagreed with my fellow Eastern Catholic that consultation or counsel is a necessary condition for an ex cathedra decree.
I’m not familiar with the canon. But if the canon is talking about a practical requirement, then I have no disagreement. It would be better to have bishops cooperation. But theoretically a consensus is not necessary for an ex cathedra to be valid. It might have poor result, but it’s still a valid decision of the Church that must be recognize as a divinely revealed article of faith.
But “consent” does not necessarily denote “judgment.” It is in this other, non-juridical sense that I understand the term “consent” when I say that I agree with my fellow Eastern and Oriental Catholics that “consent is necessary.”
Bishop Gasser, who issued the OFFICIAL interpretation of the Vatican 1 Decrees in his Official Relatio, asserted that “It is true that the present preaching of the whole Magisterium of the Church united with its Head is the rule of faith, even for definitions by the Pope.” Indeed, he also asserted that consultation is not absolutely necessary. But consultation is not the same thing as agreement, for agreement can be determined by other means aside from direct consultation (which formed the basis for my disagreement with my Eastern Catholic brother for that debate in the other website). So, before the Pope can even issue an ex cathedra decree, he must never fail to determine the Faith of the Church prior to his definition. He must ensure that what he is going to present for the definition is indeed consonant with the Faith of the past AND present Church. Now, the normative means for this determination is indeed consultation with his brother bishops. But this is not the only means open to him, according to the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
I would appreciate your (name removed by moderator)ut on what I wrote.
It would be wise for the Pope to learn the mind of the Church prior to any judgment. Because, it’s possible, that in case the pope is trying to dogmatically teach an error, the Holy Spirit would kill him to prevent him from making that error and simultaneously protect the Church from error.

Infallibility is a negative charism. Which means the Pope is not moved, aroused, or even inspired to pronounce infallible teaching. This means that infallibility has nothing to do with anything that happens prior to the infallible decision. Thus, even if a pope suddenly wakes up in the morning and out of the blue decides to dogmatically pronounce an infallible teaching, that teaching would be an infallible ex cathedra teaching. He does not need to learn the mind of the Church.
I would also point out that at every point during this discussion, brothers Abu and SteveB have consistently opposed the official interpretation given by Bishop Gasser. They insist that the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium is exercised ALONE, without any relation to or dependence on the Magisterium of the Church. I and brother Vico have pionted out to them that the Magisterium of the Pope and the Magisterium of the Church flow from one and the same Holy Spirit and cannot be separated, but brothers Abu and SteveB have consistently opposed even this most basic tenet of orthodox Catholic ecclesiology.
I would agree with steve b and Abu on this. If today ope Benedict XVI decides to promulgate an infallible decree while the rest of the bishops plus the faithful disagree with the decree, then the decree would still be a true infallible decision of the Church extraordinary magisterium and become a divinely revealed article of faith

As for the rest, I have nothing to say or add, I agree with them.
 
Dear brother Beng,
IIf the matter is about dogmatic teachings then it’s obviously the faithful and the rest of the bishops who are in error. If it is the Pope Vs the rest of the Church [the bishops plus all the faithful] on dogmatic teachings, the pope would be ALWAYS in the right. That is the Catholic faith.
Well, that is actually not the Catholic faith. That is an interpretation of certain Latin Catholics.

The true Catholic Faith teaches that the CHURCH as a body is infallible, and the Pope is able to exercise the infallible Magisterium of the Church in certain unique circumstances.

Were you unaware that the Church teaches that the CHURCH as a body is infallible? If you were aware, please explain how you can square that with your statement that “It is the Pope versus the rest of the Church?”

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Mardukm
The true Catholic Faith teaches that the CHURCH as a body is infallible
Yes; and the purpose of infallibility is to have and define the truth, NOT that the “faithful” must approve a teaching to make it true. The prerogative of deciding what is true and what is false does not belong to all of the faithful. Dissenters never can produce any dogma or doctrine to support that outlandish opinion. Centuries of conflict on essentials of faith and morals have demonstrated this truth.

Beng
BTW, the Holy Father defines either a dogma or a doctrine on faith or morals, rather than a “decree” which is disciplinary, to the whole Church as Supreme Pastor, to exercise infallibility as defined in the dogma on papal infallibility of Vatican I, to which the following examples testify.
Examples are:
The infallible Dogma of the Immaculate Conception, in Ineffabilis Deus, (Pius IX, 1854)
The infallible doctrine against contraception, in Casti Connubii, (Pius XI, 1930).

The truth is well served by this Answer by David Gregson of EWTN to me on Nov-22-2002:
“You are correct in stating that the Pope exercises his charism of infallibility not only in dogmatic definitions issued, ex cathedra, as divinely revealed (of which there have been only two), but also in doctrines definitively proposed by him, also ex cathedra, which would include canonizations (that they are in fact Saints, enjoying the Beatific Vision in heaven), moral teachings (such as contained in Humanae vitae), and other doctrines he has taught as necessarily connected with truths divinely revealed, such as that priestly ordination is reserved to men. Further details on levels of certainty with which the teachings of the Magisterium (either the Pope alone, or in company with his Bishops) may be found in Summary of Categories of Belief.”
 
Dear brother Beng,
I’m not familiar with the canon. But if the canon is talking about a practical requirement, then I have no disagreement. It would be better to have bishops cooperation.
To Eastern and Oriental Catholics, the Apostolic Canons come from the Apostles themselves, transmitted by the apostolic Fathers, and finally codified in the 2nd - 4th centuries. Are you saying that what the Apostles taught us are mere “practical requirements” and can be denied according to circumstance?
But theoretically a consensus is not necessary for an ex cathedra to be valid. It might have poor result, but it’s still a valid decision of the Church that must be recognize as a divinely revealed article of faith.
It depends on what you mean by “consensus.” If you mean “consent” as a form of judgment, I agree with you that “consensus is not necessary.” But if it is “consent”
in terms of being in agreement with the sensus fidei of the Church, I most definitely disagree with you.
Infallibility is a negative charism. Which means the Pope is not moved, aroused, or even inspired to pronounce infallible teaching.
Actually, no. It simply means that, by the Grace of God, the Pope will never publicly teach error as the Faith of the Church. The circumstance you give is actually impossible, for it would mean that infallibility affects Pope’s free will. I humbly urge you to put that thought out of your mind. It could indeed be the case that a Pope desires to teach error publicly as the Church’s Faith. But by God’s grace, circumstances will occur that will not permit him to do so. God might strike him dead. He might be forced to resign through pressure from his brother bishops. War might break out in Europe and delay that Pope’s attempt to promulgate error, and before the war ends, he dies naturally. Whatever the case may be, infallibility only ensures that error will not be taught by the Pope. It has nothing to do with the inner workings of his mind.
This means that infallibility has nothing to do with anything that happens prior to the infallible decision.
Actually, no. You must understand that the Pope is simply exercising the infallibility that Christ promised to His Church (that’s exactly what Vatican 1 teaches). The Pope exercises the Church’s infallibility in a special way in the final decision, but it is nevertheless ALWAYS in the context of the CHURCH’s infallibility. Everything leading up to that decision is actually the movement of the Holy Spirit in the Church as a whole - from the solicitiude of bishops who alert the Pope to the helps that the Pope obtains from the Church in order to make his final decision. This is the infallibility of the Church as a whole at work (i.e., the movement of the Holy Spirit through the WHOLE Church, not just the Pope alone).
It would be wise for the Pope to learn the mind of the Church prior to any judgment. Because, it’s possible, that in case the pope is trying to dogmatically teach an error, the Holy Spirit would kill him to prevent him from making that error and simultaneously protect the Church from error…even if a pope suddenly wakes up in the morning and out of the blue decides to dogmatically pronounce an infallible teaching, that teaching would be an infallible ex cathedra teaching. He does not need to learn the mind of the Church.
But your statement here would be opposed to the teaching of Vatican 1. Please answer the following questions carefully:
  1. Do you consider yourself a faithful Catholic who adheres to the mind and teaching of Vatican 1? (Yes or No)
  2. Are you aware that the Official Relatio of Bishop Gasser is the OFFICIAL interpretation of the V1 Decrees? (Yes or No)
  3. The Official Relatio states that the agreement of the Whole Magisterium is the RULE OF FAITH, even for definitions of the Pope. Do you understand what the term “Rule of Faith” means? (Yes or No)
  4. Do you think that the “Rule of Faith” is something that is merely “practical” or is it something of divine/apostolic origin?
  5. Do you think that the Pope can oppose the sensus fidei of the Church when promulgating an ex cathedra decree?
  • If “yes,” how can you claim that the Pope is being faithful to Sacred Tradition in an ex cathedra decree?
  • if “no,” how can you claim that the Pope does not need to learn the mind of the Church before promulgating an ex cathedra decree?
  1. Do you think that when the Pope exercises the Church’s infallible Magisterium, God supernaturally infuses him with all the knowledge he needs for an ex cathedra declaration? If not, how can you claim that he can just wake up one day and make an ex cathedra decree without first learning the mind of the Church?
I would agree with steve b and Abu on this. If today Pope Benedict XVI decides to promulgate an infallible decree while the rest of the bishops plus the faithful disagree with the decree, then the decree would still be a true infallible decision of the Church extraordinary magisterium and become a divinely revealed article of faith. As for the rest, I have nothing to say or add, I agree with them.
So, just to clarify, you agree with brothers AmbroseSJ, Vico and me on collegial infallibility and authority, but agree with brothers SteveB and Abu on “papal infallibilty” and authority.

I hope and pray that the considerations I put before you above will cause you to change your mind on “papal infallibility” (papal authority is another matter; we can discuss it once we are finished with “papal infallibility”).

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother AmbroseSJ,

Thank you for the kind words. I just wanted to explain neo-ultramontanism a little bit more.

As stated, ultramontanism is the official Catholic position. It was the teaching that came out of Vatican 1. At Vatican 1, there were two major Parties - the Majority Party and the Minority Party. Within the Majority Party, however, there were two currents of thought - the ultramontanist and the neo-ultramontanist.

The term “Neo-ultramontanism” was first coined by Wilfrid Ward in his book William George Ward and the Catholic Revival. I’m sure you recognize his name - he was the chief opponent of Bl. John Henry Newman. Neo-ultramontanism got its name because it was new in relation to the more traditional views as expressed by the ultramontanists. The neo-ultramontanists proposed the most extreme form of papalism. It’s main tenets were:
  1. There are no limits to papal infallibility - neither in theory nor practice. In theory, the Pope was infallible in practically everything he wanted to teach. He could be infallible not only in the realm of doctrine and morals, but also in the sciences and politics. Neo-ultramontanists wanted to include such matters as the canonization of saints and the deposing power of the pope over secular authorities under the purview of “papal infallibility.” In practice, the Pope likewise had no limits. He could wake up one morning and decide to make an infallible declaration without consideration of anything other than what he felt God guided him to do.
  2. There are no limits to papal authority. The Pope was the absolute ruler, not only within the Church, but the whole world. The Pope was viewed in the same way as a secular monarch - no practical limits to his power but his own will. Collegiality was out of the question.
There were two kinds of neo-ultramontanism. The one most prevalent in continental Europe was chiefly of a political-religious nature, and focused on papal authority. Outside of continental Europe (such as the British empire), it was chiefly of a theological nature, and thus focused on “papal infallibility.”

The more moderate ultramontanism won the day at Vatican 1, and neo-ultramontanism was repudiated. But a strain of neo-ultramontanism has always remained in the Catholic Church, however, like an intransigent flea refusing to leave its host, and it only had to bide its time before something occurred that could cause it rise from the ashes like a dark phoenix. The main impetus for this rebirth was, ironically, Vatican 2. Vatican 2 asserted the collegial nature of Church authority and infallibilty even more clearly than Vatican 1 and you would think this could not possibly result in a revival of the errors of the neo-ultramontanists. However, the chaos that ensued after Vatican 2 caused an unfortunate and powerful backlash. The liberalism of the world was certainly to blame, but certain elements within Catholicism also found a convenient scapegoat in the principle of collegiality that was strongly asserted by Vatican 2. In a blind overreaction to the chaos following Vatican 2, these elements sought to recover order in the Church by turning the clock back towards centralization once again. Collegiality was a failed experiment in the eyes of these modern neo-ultramontanists. The papacy must recover its former absolutist grandeur for the sake of the Church’s very survivial in the modern world.

Fortunately, none of the Popes since Vatican 2 adhered/adhere to the errors of these modern neo-ultramontanists. For the sake of Truth and the unity of the Church, I pray that our efforts here will help to rid the Church of these views.

Blessings,
Marduk
I just want to say I really appreciate all of the good points you have been making in this thread, and that I have learned some good things. I didn’t understand the distinctions between the Absolutist, High and Low Petrine viewpoints. I also was unaware of the neo-ultramontane party. I’m glad you are keeping me up to speed with all of the latest. 🙂

I have been associating the neo-ultramontanes with the ultramontanes that John Henry Newman battled. I think I have drunk so deeply of the writings of John Henry Newman, it has perhaps expanded my awareness of the scope of Catholic teaching. In any event I certainly have to agree with the direction of your arguments.
 
Dear brother Abu,
Yes; and the purpose of infallibility is to have and define the truth, NOT that the “faithful” must approve a teaching to make it true.
Brother AmbroseSJ nor I have ever claimed that “the faithful must approve a teaching to make it true.” We have consistently claimed that the Pope must ensure that he is in agreement with the rest of the Church before he can make an infallible decree. Btw, the Pope does not “make” anything true in an infallible decree. Not only do you consistenly misrepresent the true teaching of the Church, but you also consistently misrepresent brothers AmbroseSJ, Vico, and me to justify your errors to yourself…
The prerogative of deciding what is true and what is false does not belong to all of the faithful.
It belongs to the bishops - ALL of them, not just the bishop of Rome. Can you show us where it states that ONLY the Pope has this prerogative?
Dissenters never can produce any dogma or doctrine to support that outlandish opinion.
True. Of course, you have to purposefully misrepresent anything and everything that brothers AmbroseSJ, Vico, and I state to convince yourself that this statement applies to us.
Centuries of conflict on essentials of faith and morals have demonstrated this truth.
Yes, and these centuries of conflict were resolved by a multitude of bishops, NOT JUST THE BISHOP OF ROME.
BTW, the Holy Father defines either a dogma or a doctrine on faith or morals, rather than a “decree” which is disciplinary, to the whole Church as Supreme Pastor, to exercise infallibility as defined in the dogma on papal infallibility of Vatican I, to which the following examples testify.
Examples are:
The infallible Dogma of the Immaculate Conception, in Ineffabilis Deus, (Pius IX, 1854)
The infallible doctrine against contraception, in Casti Connubii, (Pius XI, 1930).
:yawn::sleep:
The truth is well served by this Answer by David Gregson of EWTN to me on Nov-22-2002:
“You are correct in stating that the Pope exercises his charism of infallibility not only in dogmatic definitions issued, ex cathedra, as divinely revealed (of which there have been only two), but also in doctrines definitively proposed by him, also ex cathedra, which would include canonizations (that they are in fact Saints, enjoying the Beatific Vision in heaven), moral teachings (such as contained in Humanae vitae), and other doctrines he has taught as necessarily connected with truths divinely revealed, such as that priestly ordination is reserved to men. Further details on levels of certainty with which the teachings of the Magisterium (either the Pope alone, or in company with his Bishops) may be found in Summary of Categories of Belief.”
The man confuses the Pope’s personal exercise of the Church’s infallible Magisterium with his role as the mouthpiece of the College of Bishops which exercises a collegial infallibility.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top