M
mardukm
Guest
CONTINUED

Brothers Ambrose SJ, Vico, and I opposed this error by asserting that
(1) the infallibility of an Ecum Council (and, generally, of the College of Bishops) is not from the Pope, but from God, and the Holy Spirit grants the ENTIRE Council infallibility, not the Pope alone.
(2) the authority of an Ecum Council (and, generally, of the College of Bishops) comes not from the authority of the Pope ALONE, but from the COLLEGIAL authority of ALL the bishops combined.
I hope brothers AmbroseSJ, Vico and I can count you in support of the High Petrine position.
Blessings,
Marduk
A bit. And I have no objection to the above.
Agreed. But I thought we were talking about the context of an Ecum Council?Yes. It should be noted that it’s impossible for the above to happen if the Pope is speaking ex cathedra.
Agreed. But, again, I thought we were talking about the context of an Ecumenical Council. I was unclear, so I apologize. When I cited St. Bellarmine’s principle, I actually meant it in the context of an Ecum Council. When I said “we,” I actually meant “his brother bishops.” Sorry for my lack of precision. In an Ecum Council, the Holy Spirit works in and through the entire Council. The Pope has no unique infallibility in an Ecum Council. Every action in the Council of individual bishops is considered as an act of the one body. So within an Ecum Council, it could be the case that the Pope corrects his brother bishops, but it could also be the case that the Pope is corrected by his brother bishops. What matters is the resulting COLLEGIAL decision coming from BOTH the head bishop (i.e, the Pope) and his brother bishops. Earlier, I gave two examples where the Pope was corrected by his brother bishops in the context of an Ecum Council (the Fifth Ecumenical Council, and Vatican 1).But we’re morally bound not to follow BECAUSE the error is destructive to the Church, NOT BECAUSE he does not heed the correction of his brother bishops.
No. 1 is certainly erroneous. It is true that ecumenical council necessarily needs the pope to be ecumenical but the authority does not flow from the pope alone. Quite hair splitting but that’s the way it is.
Thank you for your support. Permit me to explain the matter a little more. When I (and others) challenged brothers Abu and SteveB on their errors about what constitutes the authority and infallibility of an Ecum Council, what they did was appeal to the Decrees of V1 that really had nothing to do with an Ecumenical Council, but was rather focused on Papal primacy and the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium. They applied the teaching of V1 to an Ecum Council (and also generally to the College of Bishops), and thereby felt that their position - that the authority and infallibility of an Ecum Council is by virtue of the authority and the infallibility of the Pope ALONE - was justified.No. 2 is also erroneous for the same reason as above.
Brothers Ambrose SJ, Vico, and I opposed this error by asserting that
(1) the infallibility of an Ecum Council (and, generally, of the College of Bishops) is not from the Pope, but from God, and the Holy Spirit grants the ENTIRE Council infallibility, not the Pope alone.
(2) the authority of an Ecum Council (and, generally, of the College of Bishops) comes not from the authority of the Pope ALONE, but from the COLLEGIAL authority of ALL the bishops combined.
I hope brothers AmbroseSJ, Vico and I can count you in support of the High Petrine position.
Blessings,
Marduk