The Vatican Dogma

  • Thread starter Thread starter militantsparrow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dear brother SteveB,

Can you please answer the question:

“What are the Church requirements for the Pope to be able to exercise the infallible Magisterium of the Church.?”

Thanks.

Blessings,
Marduk
Session 4 Ch 4 Vat I
  1. Therefore, faithfully adhering to the tradition received from the beginning of the Christian faith, to the glory of God our savior, for the exaltation of the Catholic religion and for the salvation of the Christian people, with the approval of the Sacred Council, we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman Pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole Church, he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed his Church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals. Therefore, such definitions of the Roman Pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the Church, irreformable.
    So then, should anyone, which God forbid, have the temerity to reject this definition of ours: let him be anathema.
So the pope exercising his full authority as successor to St Peter and Vicar of Christ
  • needs to define a doctrine.
  • it must be regarding faith or morals
  • the teaching must be held by the entire Church
That’s how the council defined it.

BTW, This is why the Honorius issue didn’t apply towards infallibility. He never defined a doctrine, and he never said what he and Sergius were talking about was to be held by the entire Church. IOW it failed the definition for infallibility.
 
Dear brother SteveB,

Can you not include your replies in quotes? It just makes it easier to respond.
a pope’s perogatives and exercise of those perogatives belong to the pope.
No one denies that the Pope’s unique prerogatives are PERSONAL. But are they exercised ALONE? Does he have the capacity to exercise his prerogatives without any consideration of his brother bishops? It is a question that you have consistently failed to answer in the affirmative from the quotes you have given.
  1. And so…the apostolic see and the roman pontiff hold a world-wide primacy, and that the roman pontiff is the successor of blessed peter, the prince of the apostles, true vicar of christ, head of the whole church and father and teacher of all christian people.
    to him, in blessed peter, full power has been given by our lord jesus christ to tend, rule and govern the universal church.
He’s got the primacy. Does he exercise universal authority ALONE? This portion is silent.
  1. …the roman church possesses a pre-eminence of ordinary power over every other church, and that this jurisdictional power of the roman pontiff is both episcopal and immediate. both clergy and faithful, of whatever rite and dignity, both singly and collectively…
He’s got this prerogative, but does he exercise it ALONE? This portion is silent.
  1. In this way, by unity with the roman pontiff in communion and in profession of the same faith , the church of christ becomes one flock under one supreme shepherd [50].
.
Nothing here about the exercise of prerogatives. However, the clause “unity with” implies collegiality, or are you going to claim that unity is only a one-way street - that everyone must be united to the Pope, but the Pope does not have to be united to anyone?
  1. this power of the supreme pontiff by no means detracts from that ordinary and immediate power of episcopal jurisdiction, by which bishops, who have succeeded to the place of the apostles by appointment of the holy spirit, tend and govern individually the particular flocks which have been assigned to them. on the contrary, this power of theirs is asserted, supported and defended by the supreme and universal pastor; for st. Gregory the great says: “my honor is the honor of the whole church. My honor is the steadfast strength of my brethren. Then do i receive true honor, when it is denied to none of those to whom honor is due.” [51]
Though this section is also silent as to the exercise of the papal prerogatives, it contains the strongest implication on the collegial nature of that exercise. Here V1 teaches that the Pope’s universal jurisdiction cannot impede the local jurisdiction of his brother bishops. But how would he know if he was doing so? This dictates the reality that even in the Pope’s exercise of his PERSONAL universal authority, the interests and needs of his brother bishops MUST be taken into consideration. No man is an island, and the Pope is, after all, only a man.
  1. Furthermore…he has the right, in the performance of this office of his, to communicate freely with the pastors and flocks of the entire church, so that they may be taught and guided by him in the way of salvation.
  2. And therefore we condemn and reject the opinions of those who hold that this communication of the supreme head with pastors and flocks may be lawfully obstructed; or that it should be dependent on the civil power…
That he can communicate freely with his flock has no bearing on the question of whether he exercises his prerogatives ALONE.
  1. since the roman pontiff, by the divine right of the apostolic primacy, governs the whole church,
Yes, it is his PERSONAL prerogative to govern, but who here believes that the Pope actually exercises this prerogative ALONE? The practical exigencies of governance dictates that its exercise is collegial in nature.
we likewise teach and declare that he is the supreme judge of the faithful…The sentence of the apostolic see (than which there is no higher authority) is not subject to revision by anyone, nor may anyone lawfully pass judgment thereupon [54]. And so they stray from the genuine path of truth who maintain that it is lawful to appeal from the judgments of the roman pontiffs to an ecumenical council as if this were an authority superior to the roman pontiff.
But even the Pope may be corrected, as you have admitted. This is exactly what the CDF stated in that self-contradictory quote provided by brother Abu. That there is a juridical authority above the Pope is false, but the Pope must nevertheless listen to the Church, and must accept correction, accordingly changing his judgment, when necessary (this is where the spiritual fruit of humility comes in, which is a NECESSARY quality for anyone weilding authority, even though it seems strange to your Absolutist Petrine mindset).
  1. So, then, if anyone says that the roman pontiff has merely an office of supervision and guidance, and not the full and supreme power of jurisdiction over the whole church, and this not only in matters of faith and morals, but also in those which concern the discipline and government of the church dispersed throughout the whole world; or that he has only the principal part, but not the absolute fullness, of this supreme power; or that this power of his is not ordinary and immediate both over all and each of the churches and over all and each of the pastors and faithful: Let him be anathema.
Again, these are doctrinal principles, and do not touch the question of the exercise of these prerogatives.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
mardukm
Casti Connubii – a Decree that reflected the mind of the Church, not the Pope alone,
  1. mardukm misrepresents an infallible definition as a “decree” which is disciplinary not doctrinal – he has always confused terminology.
    As one so prejudiced against papal primacy and infallibility as defined by Christ’s Church, he fails to see that the “mind of the Church” is the “mind of Christ” as in papal infallible definitions of dogmas and doctrines which are NOT collegial; the Pope is defining on his own.
Part of his confusion is that he cannot accept the infallible ex cathedra definitions against contraception in *Casti Connubii *(Pius XI, 1930) and *Humanae Vitae *(Paul VI, 1968), and in the Apostolic Epistle *Ordinatio Sacerdotalis *(John Paul II, 1994) for what they are – in papal Encyclicals or Epistles issued on his own supreme authority given by Christ– NOT in an Ecumenical Council in which collegiality is exercised.

This is the Pope defining on his own, as per the above:
“we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole Church, he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed His Church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals.”
“Therefore, such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the church, irreformable.
“So then, should anyone, which God forbid, have the temerity to reject this definition of ours: let him be anathema.” (Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus, 9).
“The collective assent of all the Church faithful and the Magisterium” is otherwise known as the sensus fidei of the Church. So according to you, it is an error to believe that the Pope can only teach according to the sensus fidei of the Church. I hope everyone reading this thread will realize by now how mistaken brother Abu’s position is.
  1. This again illustrates his persistent confusion that the Pope has to teach only what is approved by the “faithful”, and what he calls the “Magisterium” as though the Pope is subject to some other “teaching authority”.
“Thus, however much the Sacred Magisterium avails itself of the contemplation, life and study of the faithful, its office is not reduced merely to ratifying the assent already expressed by the latter; indeed, in the interpretation and explanation of the written or transmitted Word of God, the Magisterium can anticipate or demand their assent.(23)
23. Cf. Vatican Council I: Dogmatic Consitution, Pastor aeternus, ch. 4"

“Pope Paul VI, by divine providence Supreme Pontiff, in the audience granted to the undersigned Prefect of the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith on May 11, 1973, has ratified and confirmed this Declaration in defense of Catholic doctrine on the Church against certain errors of the present day and has ordered its publication.”
saint-mike.org/library/curia/congregations/faith/mysterium_ecclesiae.html

“Not only are some equating the possession of the truth with the right to decide what is truth, but they are obscuring the role of the papacy in the exercise of the Church’s teaching authority.” (Fr John A Hardon, S.J., *The Teaching Church In Our Time,*1978, Daughters of St Paul, p 114].
 
I’m a late comer and only see the first and last page… but…

It’s in accordance with Catholic teaching that the pope could single handedly outrule all the other bishops combine.

And that there’s no appeal after the pope, not even ecumenical council (unless, a pope in that ecumenical council reverse the previous pope ruling [this, of course, assumes a non dogmatic ruling]).

This is not ultramontanism. This is the Catholic position.
 
Dear brother SteveB,

Thanks for the response. I would like to offer some clarifications.
Session 4 Ch 4 Vat I
  1. Therefore, faithfully adhering to the tradition received from the beginning of the Christian faith, to the glory of God our savior, for the exaltation of the Catholic religion and for the salvation of the Christian people, with the approval of the Sacred Council, we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman Pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole Church, he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed his Church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals. Therefore, such definitions of the Roman Pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the Church, irreformable.
    So then, should anyone, which God forbid, have the temerity to reject this definition of ours: let him be anathema.
So the pope exercising his full authority as successor to St Peter and Vicar of Christ
  • needs to define a doctrine.
  • it must be regarding faith or morals
  • the teaching must be held by the entire Church
This is the usual response since it is contained in the definition. But the Decree itself actually contains other conditions established by the Fathers of V1 for the Pope’s exercise of the Church’s infallible Magisterium. These are:
(4) The Pope’s exercise of the Church’s infallibility must be initiated/activated by the appeal of his brother bishops. This is contained in Paragraph 5 of the Decree on Infallibility:
"Therefore, the bishops of the whole world, sometimes singly, somtimes assembled in councils, following the long-standing custom of the Churches and the form of the ancient rule, reported to the Apostolic See those dangers especially which came up in the matters of faith…
The Pope cannot just wake up one morning and decide on his own that he is going to make a new dogma. This was affirmed recently by HH for an interview with Peter Seewald contained in his book Light of the World: The Pope, the Church, and the Signs of the Times. I have not read the book myself, but a book reviewer summarized the matter thus:
“Vatican I has, of course, been seen (often incorrectly, in my judgment) as a huge impediment to Orthodox-Catholic unity. Much of that is based on misunderstanding, which the pope is at pains here briefly to correct, insisting that the pope can never act “arbitrarily” but only in concert with other bishops and only “when tradition has been clarified” so as to proclaim “the faith of the Church.”” easternchristianbooks.blogspot.com/2010/12/pope-of-rome-and-christian-east.html

(5) The Pope must determine the mind of the Church before he can make his definition. This is also contained in Paragraph 5 of the Decree on Infallibility:
“The Roman Pontiffs, on their part, according as the condition of the times and the circumstances dictated, sometimes calling together ecumenical councils or sounding out the mind of the Church throughout the world, sometimes through regional councils, or sometimes by using other helps which divine Providence supplired, have, with the help of God, defined as to be held such matters as they had found consonant with the Holy Scripture and with the apostolic tradition.”
This is prefectly consonant with Bishop Gasser’s OFFICIAL explanation that the agreement of the whole Magisterium must be determined as the RULE OF FAITH, EVEN FOR DEFINITIONS BY THE POPE.

(6) The Pope cannot define or go beyond a matter that is not contained in Sacred Tradition. This is also contained in Paragraph 5 of the Decree on Infallibility:
“The Holy Spirit was promised to the successors of St. Peter not that they might make known new doctrine by His revelation, but rather, that with His assistance, they might religiously guard and faithfully explain the revelation or deposit of faith that was handed down through the Apostles.”
The condition that it is a “matter of faith and morals” is not enough. This condition #6 is necessary to ensure that the Pope will not teach anything novel or unpatristic.

CONTINUED
 
CONTINUED

This Paragraph 5 to which I have been referring was termed by the Council Fathers “the historical Proem.” The Proem was one of the latest additions to the Decree on Infallibility and caused quite a sensation at the Council. Not only did it cause several neo-ultramontanists to leave the Council in disgust (complaining that the Council was now teaching nothing more than attenuated form of Gallicanism), but it managed to sway a good number of votes from the Minority Party from non-placet or placet juxta modem to placet, including, I happily add, two of the remaining non-Latin bishops - an Oriental bishop (Armenian) and an Eastern bishop (Byzantine, but I forget off-hand from what country). We can only wonder how many more Eastern and Oriental votes the Decree would have garnered if the Eastern and Oriental bishops had remained longer at the Council.

The addition of the historical Proem was a victory for collegiality at Vatican 1. I can’t speak for brother AmbroseSJ, but I’ll bet this is what he was referring to when he asserted that your position is a “cut-and-paste partial truth” of the Church’s true teaching. You myopically focus on the definition, giving no heed to the entire Decree. And even your focus on the definition is tainted with a bias towards only selective portions.
BTW, This is why the Honorius issue didn’t apply towards infallibility. He never defined a doctrine, and he never said what he and Sergius were talking about was to be held by the entire Church. IOW it failed the definition for infallibility.
Yes. And not only was it not intended to be held by the entire Church, it was never even taught by him in the Church of Rome itself! The Church of Rome never held the monothelite belief, which proves that Pope Honorius’ private views were never taught publicly by Pope Honorius. A further proof that opponents of the papacy always overlook is the fact that Pope Honorius was not on the original list of heretics that was considered by the Sixth Ecum Council (btw, I’ve never read any Catholic apologetics that mention that fact - you’re welcome to take that fact and spread it around far and wide). If Pope Honorius was going around publicly teaching Monothelitism, how is it possible that the Council Fathers were completely unaware that he was doing so when the Council was convened? The Council Fathers came to the knowledge of Pope Honorius’ private views only after the monothelites produced his letters to Sergius.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
I’m a late comer and only see the first and last page… but…

It’s in accordance with Catholic teaching that the pope could single handedly outrule all the other bishops combine.
I’ve never heard or read of such a thing from Magisterial documents, so I seriously doubt it is “Catholic teaching.” It might be a popular interpretation of the Decrees of Vatican 1 from some Latin Catholic circles, but it’s not common (not common, but it can be found) among Eastern or Oriental Catholic crowds.
And that there’s no appeal after the pope, not even ecumenical council.
Not exactly. There’s no appeal to an Ecumenical Council ONLY if one were to assume that the E Council is a greater authority than the Pope. Otherwise, you can indeed, but you admit that in your next sentence (for which I must commend you; this nuance is very often lost on Catholics, especially those who hold an Absolutist Petrine position).
(unless, a pope in that ecumenical council reverse the previous pope ruling [this, of course, assumes a non dogmatic ruling]).
And it would be through the solicitude of his brother bishops who will correct the Pope if necessary.
This is not ultramontanism. This is the Catholic position.
Actually, ultramontanism IS the Catholic position. What brothers Abu and Steve have been proposing is not ultramontanism, but is known as neo-ultramontanism. Neo-ultramontanists were present at Vatican 1, but their views were rejected by the majority of the Council Fathers. The difference between neo-ultramontanism and ultramontanism is the same difference between the Absolutist Petrine and the High Petrine positions.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
:yawn::sleep:
  1. mardukm misrepresents an infallible definition as a “decree” which is disciplinary not doctrinal – he has always confused terminology.
    As one so prejudiced against papal primacy and infallibility as defined by Christ’s Church, he fails to see that the “mind of the Church” is the “mind of Christ” as in papal infallible definitions of dogmas and doctrines which are NOT collegial; the Pope is defining on his own.
Part of his confusion is that he cannot accept the infallible ex cathedra definitions against contraception in *Casti Connubii *(Pius XI, 1930) and *Humanae Vitae *(Paul VI, 1968), and in the Apostolic Epistle *Ordinatio Sacerdotalis *(John Paul II, 1994) for what they are – in papal Encyclicals or Epistles issued on his own supreme authority given by Christ– NOT in an Ecumenical Council in which collegiality is exercised.

This is the Pope defining on his own, as per the above:
“we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole Church, he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed His Church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals.”
“Therefore, such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the church, irreformable.
“So then, should anyone, which God forbid, have the temerity to reject this definition of ours: let him be anathema.” (Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus, 9).
  1. This again illustrates his persistent confusion that the Pope has to teach only what is approved by the “faithful”, and what he calls the “Magisterium” as though the Pope is subject to some other “teaching authority”.
“Thus, however much the Sacred Magisterium avails itself of the contemplation, life and study of the faithful, its office is not reduced merely to ratifying the assent already expressed by the latter; indeed, in the interpretation and explanation of the written or transmitted Word of God, the Magisterium can anticipate or demand their assent.(23)
23. Cf. Vatican Council I: Dogmatic Consitution, Pastor aeternus, ch. 4"

“Pope Paul VI, by divine providence Supreme Pontiff, in the audience granted to the undersigned Prefect of the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith on May 11, 1973, has ratified and confirmed this Declaration in defense of Catholic doctrine on the Church against certain errors of the present day and has ordered its publication.”
saint-mike.org/library/curia/congregations/faith/mysterium_ecclesiae.html

“Not only are some equating the possession of the truth with the right to decide what is truth, but they are obscuring the role of the papacy in the exercise of the Church’s teaching authority.” (Fr John A Hardon, S.J., *The Teaching Church In Our Time,*1978, Daughters of St Paul, p 114].
 
I’ve never heard or read of such a thing from Magisterial documents, so I seriously doubt it is “Catholic teaching.” It might be a popular interpretation of the Decrees of Vatican 1 from some Latin Catholic circles, but it’s not common (not common, but it can be found) among Eastern or Oriental Catholic crowds.
I would digress. It is your interpretation that is most common among EASTERN CATHOLIC (not among Western Catholic or Orthodox), which I found very troubling since ever.

Your post to steve b, which highlight paragraph 4 of Pastor Aeternus to back up your assertion, is used incorrectly. How? Well, there’s the word “sometime” in the next paragraph (paragraph 5). Thus it means that sometime the Pope could, by his own decision, consult his brother bishops. But other time, he may choose not to if he so wishes.
  1. The Roman pontiffs, too, as the circumstances of the time or the state of affairs suggested, sometimes by summoning ecumenical councils or consulting the opinion of the Churches scattered throughout the world, sometimes by special synods, sometimes by taking advantage of other useful means afforded by divine providence, defined as doctrines to be held those things which, by God’s help, they knew to be in keeping with Sacred Scripture and the apostolic traditions.
Not exactly. There’s no appeal to an Ecumenical Council ONLY if one were to assume that the E Council is a greater authority than the Pope. Otherwise, you can indeed, but you admit that in your next sentence (for which I must commend you; this nuance is very often lost on Catholics, especially those who hold an Absolutist Petrine position).
And it would be through the solicitude of his brother bishops who will correct the Pope if necessary.
The brother bishops could only counsel the Pope. The pope has the final say. If the pope does not want any correction then, even if all the brother bishops demand for such correction, there would be no correction.
Actually, ultramontanism IS the Catholic position. What brothers Abu and Steve have been proposing is not ultramontanism, but is known as neo-ultramontanism. Neo-ultramontanists were present at Vatican 1, but their views were rejected by the majority of the Council Fathers. The difference between neo-ultramontanism and ultramontanism is the same difference between the Absolutist Petrine and the High Petrine positions.
Blessings,
Marduk
My mistake

Btw, I read steve’s writing (page 15 only). He seems within bound of orthodoxy.
 
If these haven’t been quoted:

Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma - Ludwig Ott (p. 286-287)

g) an immediate power, that is, the pope can exercise his power, without the intervention of an intermediary, over the bishops and the faithful of the whole Church

…

c) as supreme judge of the Church, the Pope has the right of bringing every Church law-matter before his court, and to receive appeal in all Church disputes. He himself is judged by nobody (CIC 1556: Prima sedes a nemine iudicatur), because there is no higher judge on earth than he. For the same reason there is no appeal to a higher court against the judgment of the Pope. The Church rejects an appeal from the Pope to General Council as this would mean putting General Council above the Pope. D 1830; CIC 228, Par. 2. Cf. D 1323 (22nd Galican article)

…

A consequence of the infallibility is that the decisions, ex cathedra, of the popes are “of themselves,” that is, without intervention of further authority, immutable and not by reason of the assent of the whole Church,as the Gallicans taught. D 1325 (4th Galican article)
 
Dear brother Beng,

Thank you for your responses. I appreciate a fresh voice in this discussion.
I would digress. It is your interpretation that is most common among EASTERN CATHOLIC (not among Western Catholic or Orthodox), which I found very troubling since ever.
I’m not sure I understand. Are you saying that the Eastern Catholic interpretation is troubling you? If so, what is it about the Eastern Catholic interpretation that is troubling you?

FYI, I have met one or two Eastern Catholics on the I-net that propose a Low Petrine view of the papacy, which I also find troubling and reject. Low Petrine advocates believe that the papacy is not necessary. High Petrine (my and brother AmbroseSJ’s position, and also what would generally be the Eastern and Oriental Catholic position) advocates believe that the papacy and the episcopacy are equally necessary. Absolutist Petrine (brother Abu and SteveB’s position) advocates believe that only the papacy is necessary.
Your post to steve b, which highlight paragraph 4 of Pastor Aeternus to back up your assertion, is used incorrectly. How? Well, there’s the word “sometime” in the next paragraph (paragraph 5). Thus it means that sometime the Pope could, by his own decision, consult his brother bishops. But other time, he may choose not to if he so wishes.
  1. The Roman pontiffs, too, as the circumstances of the time or the state of affairs suggested, sometimes by summoning ecumenical councils or consulting the opinion of the Churches scattered throughout the world, sometimes by special synods, sometimes by taking advantage of other useful means afforded by divine providence, defined as doctrines to be held those things which, by God’s help, they knew to be in keeping with Sacred Scripture and the apostolic traditions.
Thank you for your solicitude. If you look closely, I did not say that the Pope must consult his brother bishops. I stated that the Pope must determine the mind of the Church. I’m referring to the sensus fidei. Consulting his brother bishops or calling an ecumenical council is one of the ways that the Pope can determine the mind of the Church (or the sensus fidei), but it is not the only way. Do you see the difference?
The brother bishops could only counsel the Pope. The pope has the final say. If the pope does not want any correction then, even if all the brother bishops demand for such correction, there would be no correction.
If the Pope were to persist in an error that is destructive of the Faith or of the Church, according to St. Robert Bellarmine, we are morally bound to oppose him. We can’t judge him - he’ll still be our Pope - but we would not be morally bound to accept something that is destructive of the Faith or of the Church, even if it comes from the Pope. Would you agree with that? So if the Pope actually needs correction, and his brother bishops correct him, and he does not heed the correction, then we are morally bound not to follow.

This has actually happened several times in the history of the Church. I can think of two examples off-hand - 1) the Fifth Ecumenical Council, where Pope Vigilius accepted the correction of his brother bishops; 2) Pope John XXII’s preaching on the Beatific Vision, which was opposed by soooooo many of his contemporaries. Even Pio Nono conceded to the work of the Holy Spirit through his brother bishops at Vatican 1. It is not well-known, but Pope Pius IX actually did not get everything he wanted out of Vatican 1.
Btw, I read steve’s writing (page 15 only). He seems within bound of orthodoxy.
Well, you’re going to have to read earlier than that. This whole discussion became a debate because brother Abu had claimed that (1) the authority of an Ecumenical Council is from the Pope ALONE, and (2) the infallibiltiy of an Ecumenical Council is from the Pope ALONE. Brother SteveB came a little bit afterwards to defend brother Abu and his errors. Brother SteveB has nuanced his opinions a bit as the debate progressed, so it might seem that he is within the bounds of orthodoxy, but not really.

Again, I appreciate your (name removed by moderator)ut.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Beng,

Thank you for this, but, tbh, quoting Latin theologians is not very helpful. We have been trying to restrict our citations to Magisterial sources (bishops or councils). But thank you for the effort.

Having said that, I don’t find anything wrong with what Ludwig Ott says here - properly understood, that is.

Blessings,
Marduk
If these haven’t been quoted:

Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma - Ludwig Ott (p. 286-287)

g) an immediate power, that is, the pope can exercise his power, without the intervention of an intermediary, over the bishops and the faithful of the whole Church

…

c) as supreme judge of the Church, the Pope has the right of bringing every Church law-matter before his court, and to receive appeal in all Church disputes. He himself is judged by nobody (CIC 1556: Prima sedes a nemine iudicatur), because there is no higher judge on earth than he. For the same reason there is no appeal to a higher court against the judgment of the Pope. The Church rejects an appeal from the Pope to General Council as this would mean putting General Council above the Pope. D 1830; CIC 228, Par. 2. Cf. D 1323 (22nd Galican article)

A consequence of the infallibility is that the decisions, ex cathedra, of the popes are “of themselves,” that is, without intervention of further authority, immutable and not by reason of the assent of the whole Church,as the Gallicans taught. D 1325 (4th Galican article)
 
Mardukm wrote: “The collective assent of all the Church faithful and the Magisterium” is otherwise known as the sensus fidei of the Church. So according to you, it is an error to believe that the Pope can only teach according to the sensus fidei of the Church.

The Holy Spirit is source of the sense of faith.

We know that the source of the sense of faith of the Church, *sensus fidei *is the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit is guiding the faithful and the Magisterium. We know that there are three specific ways this exists, mentioned in the decrees of the councils, which are infallible: ex cathedra expression of the Holy Spirit’s guidance through the discharge of the office of the Supreme Pontiff, and the infallible expression of the concilliar Church, and the infallible united teaching of the ordinary Magisterium out of council. There are also the forms of fallible expression, also guided by the Holy Spirit; those statements made by the Magisterium which are not irreformale but yet are to be held as true.

As an example of how this may occur, we see that Constantinople 381 was a local council and came to be accepted by the Latin Church only at Constantinople 553 with Pope Vigilus, when it became a general council, yet the truths of Constantinople 381 were ever the same from 381 to 553, not yet recognized in the west. There are degrees of certainty of promulgated doctrines, which may be at different degress in various locations at once. The Holy Spirit is still at work to bring acceptance.
 
Dear brother Beng,

Thank you for your responses. I appreciate a fresh voice in this discussion.

I’m not sure I understand. Are you saying that the Eastern Catholic interpretation is troubling you? If so, what is it about the Eastern Catholic interpretation that is troubling you?
That the Pope needs … necessarily needs… consent, agreement, assent, counsel in any form to be infallible or to govern the whole Church.
Thank you for your solicitude. If you look closely, I did not say that the Pope must consult his brother bishops. I stated that the Pope must determine the mind of the Church. I’m referring to the sensus fidei. Consulting his brother bishops or calling an ecumenical council is one of the ways that the Pope can determine the mind of the Church (or the sensus fidei), but it is not the only way. Do you see the difference?
A bit. And I have no objection to the above.
If the Pope were to persist in an error that is destructive of the Faith or of the Church, according to St. Robert Bellarmine, we are morally bound to oppose him. We can’t judge him - he’ll still be our Pope - but we would not be morally bound to accept something that is destructive of the Faith or of the Church, even if it comes from the Pope. Would you agree with that?
Yes. It should be noted that it’s impossible for the above to happen if the Pope is speaking ex cathedra…
So if the Pope actually needs correction, and his brother bishops correct him, and he does not heed the correction, then we are morally bound not to follow.
But we’re morally bound not to follow BECAUSE the error is destructive to the Church, NOT BECAUSE he does not heed the correction of his brother bishops.
Well, you’re going to have to read earlier than that. This whole discussion became a debate because brother Abu had claimed that (1) the authority of an Ecumenical Council is from the Pope ALONE, and (2) the infallibiltiy of an Ecumenical Council is from the Pope ALONE. Brother SteveB came a little bit afterwards to defend brother Abu and his errors. Brother SteveB has nuanced his opinions a bit as the debate progressed, so it might seem that he is within the bounds of orthodoxy, but not really.
No. 1 is certainly erroneous. It is true that ecumenical council necessarily needs the pope to be ecumenical but the authority does not flow from the pope alone. Quite hair splitting but that’s the way it is.

No. 2 is also erroneous for the same reason as above. It’s true that the Pope’s infallibility does not depend on the other bishops (or all of them combined for that matter). It’s also true that to be infallible an ecumenical council necessarily needs the Pope. But it’s not true that the infallibility of an ecumenical council flow from the Pope alone. Again, this is splitting hair, but that’s the way it is.
 
Originally Posted by AmbroseSJ

My comments: PJM

My friend, one misses a very important factor in discusing “Infallibility” of ANY Biblical Author. Th issue is, or ought to be; MUTE.

Either the Bible in it’s intireity is TRUE or every part of it is suspect of TRUTH, and open to individual understanding [al of which wouls subjectively be “true”; and Objectively, possibiliy none of them being true…** READ John. 14:16-17 an John 17:15-19; then re-read
2nd. Tim. 3:16-17.
In an absolute sese there exist NO, Zip, Zero opportunity for un-trutfulnress; as TESTIFIED by Jesus Christ Himself. There can be “stories”; there can be mis-statemnt of historical facts [the Bible claims NOT to be a History Book; and certainly there are statements not meant to be taken literally; but present a MORAL Teaching:

[[COLOR=“Red”]Example: Matt.5 29 “If your right eye causes you to sin, pluck it out and throw it away; it is better that you lose one of your members than that your whole body be thrown into hell.”… This is Not a literal Truth; [all-though is is true]; rather Christ here is expressing how critically important it is to avoid temptation wrought through sight.]

PART OF THE original REPLY:

.

NOT POSSIBLE!

The Pope is impowered to make an Infallible proclaimation on His OWN AUTHORITY, as the Vicor of Christ. Whereas, the Mgisterium MUST have the aproval of the reigning Pontiff.

Further Canon Law makes this statements:

THE ROMAN PONTIFF

Can. 331 The bishop of the Roman Church, in whom continues the office given by the Lord uniquely to Peter, the first of the Apostles, and to be transmitted to his successors, is the head of the college of bishops, the Vicar of Christ, and the pastor of the universal Church on earth. By virtue of his office he possesses supreme, full, immediate, and universal ordinary power in the Church, which he is always able to exercise freely.

Can. 332 §1
. The Roman Pontiff obtains full and supreme power in the Church by his acceptance of legitimate election together with episcopal consecration. Therefore, a person elected to the supreme pontificate who is marked with episcopal character obtains this power from the moment of acceptance. If the person elected lacks episcopal character, however, he is to be ordained a bishop immediately.

Can. 333 §1. By virtue of his office, the Roman Pontiff not only possesses power offer the universal Church but also obtains the primacy of ordinary power offer all particular churches and groups of them. Moreover, this primacy strengthens and protects the proper, ordinary, and immediate power which bishops possess in the particular churches entrusted to their care.

§2. In fulfilling the office of supreme pastor of the Church, the Roman Pontiff is always joined in communion with the other bishops and with the universal Church. He nevertheless has the right, according to the needs of the Church, to determine the manner, whether personal or collegial, of exercising this office.
*

§3. No appeal or recourse is permitted against a sentence or decree of the Roman Pontiff.

In SUMMURY: ALL intended Infallible Pronouncemnts either by the Pope Himself; or in unity with the Magesterium; ARE NEVER CHANAGEABLE. It might be possible to gain a further understanding; but the CORE belief as orginally defined and proclaimed is unchangeable.*

God Bless, Pat

Hello PJM.

You are falling into the same trap with steve b and Abu. I don’t disagree with anything you have quoted. Yet you say “Impossible” So you are saying the pope can not be afflicted with a sudden delirium, or illness, or be coerced into making statements? Is that really what you’re trying to prove infallibility means?
 
The confusion and misrepresentation will continue as long as these posters reject the teaching of Vatican I and II by confusing themselves. As shown below, they make their own trouble, and fantasise that they agree with Vatican I and II, yet can never support the mirage from Vatican I or II.
I have to object to the uncharitable tone of your comments, and your continual accusation of our rejection of Vatican I and II teachings.

The most I have accused you of is putting too much emphasis on certain statements while ignoring others that are in the Vatican documents.

You have already proven several times that you DO NOT UNDERSTAND our position at all! Your arguments are actually exhibitions of your lack of understanding of what we are trying to say.

I have steadfastly agreed with all of your document quotes, INCLUDING YOUR FAVORITE AUTHOR HARDON. But because I disagree with YOU, and steve b you interpret that as tantamount to rejecting Vatican I and II documents.
 
My friend,
I entered this discussion 130+ post ago.
Code:
* In that time I've quoted from Canon Law, Trent, Vat I, and Vat II copiously. I didn't do any quote mining or take text out of context. I gave links to the documents I used, so one doesn't have to go looking for the sources I used.. Nothing was hidden. That quote you refer to, has been given by me before in far greater context to make my point.
* By you suggesting there is only partial truth from ANY quote I've given, is to beg the question. Show me where it is, with quotes from Church documents, don't just tell me. Anything else is just one's personal opinion.
The problem with relying strictly on quotes becomes analogous to the Sola Scriptura Protestants. They will overwhelm anything you can say to them with a blizzard of Biblical Quotes. How does that help a discussion? It becomes a mere quote battle. The Vatican documents MUST be seen in the light of ALL church teaching since Apostolic times. To Ignore History, Tradition and the Deposit of Faith, and keep one’s focus entirely on the Vatican Documents to the exclusion of everything else, IS TO LOSE the understanding that underlies all Magisterial teachings. You have lost sight of the forest because of the trees.
 
40.png
Beng:
40.png
Mardukm:
Not exactly. There’s no appeal to an Ecumenical Council ONLY if one were to assume that the E Council is a greater authority than the Pope. Otherwise, you can indeed, but you admit that in your next sentence (for which I must commend you; this nuance is very often lost on Catholics, especially those who hold an Absolutist Petrine position).
And it would be through the solicitude of his brother bishops who will correct the Pope if necessary.
The brother bishops could only counsel the Pope. The pope has the final say. If the pope does not want any correction then, even if all the brother bishops demand for such correction, there would be no correction.
In the extreme case you have given Beng (God forbid such a thing,) the Faithful would look upon the Pope in disagreement with the council bishops, and be forced to decide for themselves (infallibility of the Faithful) who was on the side of Truth. Sensus Fidelium.

The truth can not be opposed to itself.

Ultimately, Church infallibility will always be protected by the Holy Spirit, either through the Pope, and/or the Ordinary Magisterium and/or the Faithful. They are complementary, not antagonistic to one another.
 
Dear brother Beng,
That the Pope needs … necessarily needs… consent, agreement, assent, counsel in any form to be infallible or to govern the whole Church.
Thank you for the explanation. I partially agree with my fellow Easterns on this point, but I also partially disagree. I have in fact recently debated an Eastern Catholic on this issue in another website. He insisted that the Pope must at least consult, or obtain counsel from, his brother bishops before an ex cathedra decree can be held as infallible. I disagreed with him, but before I could respond, the thread was closed. So I will take the opportunity now to respond (in case we have lurkers who were also present at the debate in the other website).

I disagreed with my fellow Eastern Catholic because there is no patristic warrant for the claim that the Pope must absolutely, necessarily consult or take counsel with his brother bishops in order to promulgate an ex cathedra decree.

The principle of the ancient Apostolic Canon 34 asserts that consensus must be obtained between the head bishop and his brother bishops before a matter affecting the universal Church can be enacted or resolved. The Canon basically states that the bishops of every nation must recognize him who is their head, and can do nothing of great importance without his consent, but neither can he do anything of great importance without their consent, in order to ensure the unity of the Church (are you familiar with this Canon, or do you want me to give you an exact quote?). The Apostolic Canon does not say that the head must consult his brother bishops. It simply states that consensus must be realized. But consensus does not necessarily need to be determined through direct consultation; consensus can be determined by other means. This is why I disagreed with my fellow Eastern Catholic that consultation or counsel is a necessary condition for an ex cathedra decree.

Now, you also mentioned “consent,” “agreement,” and “assent.” For our purposes, I’ll asume they are synonyms (though “consent” and “assent” are actually two distinct canonical terms). I do agree with my fellow Eastern (and Oriental) Catholics that “consent” is necessary, because this is the prescription of the ancient Apostolic Canon 34.

The Vatican teaching is that the definition of the Pope ex cathedra is considered irreformible in and of itself, not from the consent of the Church. This was intended by the Fathers of Vatican 1 in the sense that no one can make a judgment on the merit of the definition as God’s Truth after it is made. And neither can one make a judgment on the merit of the definition before it is promulgated (normally, the promulgation is part of the definition, so it is not distinguished in common parlance). I thoroughly agree with the Vatican Council Fathers, that no one can pass judgment on the definition of the Pope, both before or after it is promulgated (or, in common parlance, no one can pass judgment before or after the definition). In this sense, I submit to the Vatican teaching that the “consent of the Church” is not necessary for an ex cathedra decree to be valid. But “consent” does not necessarily denote “judgment.” It is in this other, non-juridical sense that I understand the term “consent” when I say that I agree with my fellow Eastern and Oriental Catholics that “consent is necessary.”

Bishop Gasser, who issued the OFFICIAL interpretation of the Vatican 1 Decrees in his Official Relatio, asserted that “It is true that the present preaching of the whole Magisterium of the Church united with its Head is the rule of faith, even for definitions by the Pope.” Indeed, he also asserted that consultation is not absolutely necessary. But consultation is not the same thing as agreement, for agreement can be determined by other means aside from direct consultation (which formed the basis for my disagreement with my Eastern Catholic brother for that debate in the other website). So, before the Pope can even issue an ex cathedra decree, he must never fail to determine the Faith of the Church prior to his definition. He must ensure that what he is going to present for the definition is indeed consonant with the Faith of the past AND present Church. Now, the normative means for this determination is indeed consultation with his brother bishops. But this is not the only means open to him, according to the guidance of the Holy Spirit.

I would appreciate your (name removed by moderator)ut on what I wrote.

I would also point out that at every point during this discussion, brothers Abu and SteveB have consistently opposed the official interpretation given by Bishop Gasser. They insist that the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium is exercised ALONE, without any relation to or dependence on the Magisterium of the Church. I and brother Vico have pionted out to them that the Magisterium of the Pope and the Magisterium of the Church flow from one and the same Holy Spirit and cannot be separated, but brothers Abu and SteveB have consistently opposed even this most basic tenet of orthodox Catholic ecclesiology.

CONTINUED
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top