Dear brother Beng,
That the Pope needs … necessarily needs… consent, agreement, assent, counsel in any form to be infallible or to govern the whole Church.
Thank you for the explanation. I partially agree with my fellow Easterns on this point, but I also partially disagree. I have in fact recently debated an Eastern Catholic on this issue in another website. He insisted that the Pope must at least consult, or obtain counsel from, his brother bishops before an
ex cathedra decree can be held as infallible. I disagreed with him, but before I could respond, the thread was closed. So I will take the opportunity now to respond (in case we have lurkers who were also present at the debate in the other website).
I disagreed with my fellow Eastern Catholic because there is no patristic warrant for the claim that the Pope must absolutely, necessarily consult or take counsel with his brother bishops in order to promulgate an
ex cathedra decree.
The principle of the ancient Apostolic Canon 34 asserts that consensus must be obtained between the head bishop and his brother bishops before a matter affecting the universal Church can be enacted or resolved. The Canon basically states that the bishops of every nation must recognize him who is their head, and can do nothing of great importance without his consent, but neither can he do anything of great importance without their consent, in order to ensure the unity of the Church (are you familiar with this Canon, or do you want me to give you an exact quote?). The Apostolic Canon does not say that the head must consult his brother bishops. It simply states that consensus must be realized. But consensus does not necessarily need to be determined through direct consultation; consensus can be determined by other means. This is why I disagreed with my fellow Eastern Catholic that consultation or counsel is a necessary condition for an
ex cathedra decree.
Now, you also mentioned “consent,” “agreement,” and “assent.” For our purposes, I’ll asume they are synonyms (though “consent” and “assent” are actually two distinct canonical terms). I do agree with my fellow Eastern (and Oriental) Catholics that “consent” is necessary, because this is the prescription of the ancient Apostolic Canon 34.
The Vatican teaching is that the definition of the Pope
ex cathedra is considered irreformible in and of itself, not from the consent of the Church. This was intended by the Fathers of Vatican 1 in the sense that no one can make a
judgment on the merit of the definition as God’s Truth after it is made. And neither can one make a judgment on the merit of the definition before it is promulgated (normally, the promulgation is part of the definition, so it is not distinguished in common parlance). I thoroughly agree with the Vatican Council Fathers, that no one can pass judgment on the definition of the Pope, both before or after it is promulgated (or, in common parlance, no one can pass judgment before or after the definition). In this sense, I submit to the Vatican teaching that the “consent of the Church” is not necessary for an
ex cathedra decree to be valid. But “consent” does not necessarily denote “judgment.” It is in this other,
non-juridical sense that I understand the term “consent” when I say that I agree with my fellow Eastern and Oriental Catholics that “consent is necessary.”
Bishop Gasser, who issued the OFFICIAL interpretation of the Vatican 1 Decrees in his
Official Relatio, asserted that “
It is true that the present preaching of the whole Magisterium of the Church united with its Head is the rule of faith, even for definitions by the Pope.” Indeed, he also asserted that consultation is not absolutely necessary. But consultation is not the same thing as agreement, for agreement can be determined by other means aside from direct consultation (which formed the basis for my disagreement with my Eastern Catholic brother for that debate in the other website). So, before the Pope can even issue an
ex cathedra decree, he must never fail to determine the Faith of the Church prior to his definition. He must ensure that what he is going to present for the definition is indeed consonant with the Faith of the past AND present Church. Now, the normative means for this determination is indeed consultation with his brother bishops. But this is not the only means open to him, according to the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
I would appreciate your (name removed by moderator)ut on what I wrote.
I would also point out that at every point during this discussion, brothers Abu and SteveB have consistently opposed the official interpretation given by Bishop Gasser. They insist that the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium is exercised ALONE, without any relation to or dependence on the Magisterium of the Church. I and brother Vico have pionted out to them that the Magisterium of the Pope and the Magisterium of the Church flow from one and the same Holy Spirit and cannot be separated, but brothers Abu and SteveB have consistently opposed even this most basic tenet of orthodox Catholic ecclesiology.
CONTINUED