The Vatican Dogma

  • Thread starter Thread starter militantsparrow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
mardukm, post #179
Brother Vico did not say there were “contradictions.” I don’t know what causes both you and brother SteveB to constantly impose misinterpretations on our statements.
mardukm seems incapable of reasoning logically and consistently, as Vico claimed that Vatican II is “inconsistent” which means: “self-contradictory”/ “inconsistent statements cannot both be true at the same time”/ “not in agreement”.

Hence the logical conclusion: “There is nothing substantial showing that there is a contradiction between Vatican I and Vatican II or a statement in one which can be termed to be untrue with regard to the other Council.”
 
mardukm, post #177
This whole debate started because I challened brother Abu’s errors regarding the authority and infallibility of a Council and collegiality - namely, (1) that only the Pope has authority in the context of an Ecumenical council and the College of bishops; and (2) that only the Pope has infallibility in the context of an Ecumenical Council and the College of Bishops.
mardukm seems incapable of a logical, reasoned discussion, for he is still in error as well as being unable to express the truth of the Church’s teaching.
1**) No one has tried to say that ONLY the Pope has authority or infallibility in an Ecumenical Council.**

2) mardukm’s basic errors above, were answered in post #32:
So trying to “prove” that the Pope’s ratification is necessary for an Ecumenical Council to be infallible is a fruitless endeavor because its premise is flawed in the first place.
The feeling that an Ecumenical Council might be able to issue an infallible teaching without papal approval is incorrect.

newadvent.org/cathen/04423f.htm
Ecumenical Councils are those to which the bishops, and others entitled to vote, are convoked from the whole world (oikoumene) under the presidency of the pope or his legates, and the decrees of which, **having received papal confirmation, bind all Christians. A council, Ecumenical in its convocation, may fail to secure the approbation of the whole Church or of the pope, and thus not rank in authority with Ecumenical councils.

“The college of bishops exercises power over the universal Church in a solemn manner in an ecumenical council. . . .The infallibility promised to the Church is also present in the body of bishops, when together with Peter’s successor, they exercise the supreme Magisterium**” (CCC 884, 891). Encyclopedia of Catholic Doctrine, Our Sunday Visitor, CD].
“And it is the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff to convene such councils, to preside over them and to confirm them.”
Code of Canon Law #337].

This error was persistent:
mardukm, post #25
I know that many Catholics think that “the Pope confirms an Ecumenical Council.” But such language perpetuates the gross misconception… The Pope does not confirm (ratify) the decisions of an Ecumenical Council.
Mardukm, post #177
What I’ve asserted is (1) the Pope cannot exercise universal authority without the support of his brother bishops, and (2) the Pope’s universal authority cannot be separated from the authority of the Church. That is collegiality both in principle and in action
  1. This was shown to be in error and corrected in Abu’s post #27:
    *Pastor Aeternus *(Ecumenical Council Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus)
    “Chapter 3.
    On the power and character of the primacy of the Roman Pontiff
  1. Since the Roman Pontiff, by the divine right of the apostolic primacy, governs the whole Church, we likewise teach and declare that he is the supreme judge of the faithful [52], and that in all cases which fall under ecclesiastical jurisdiction recourse may be had to his judgment [53]. The sentence of the Apostolic See (than which there is no higher authority) is not subject to revision by anyone, nor may anyone lawfully pass judgment thereupon [54]. And so they stray from the genuine path of truth who maintain that it is lawful to appeal from the judgments of the Roman pontiffs to an ecumenical council as if this were an authority superior to the Roman Pontiff. [My emphasis].
  2. So, then, if anyone says that the Roman Pontiff has merely an office of supervision and guidance, and not the full and supreme power of jurisdiction over the whole Church, and this not only in matters of faith and morals, but also in those which concern the discipline and government of the Church dispersed throughout the whole world; or that he has only the principal part, but not the absolute fullness, of this supreme power; or that this power of his is not ordinary and immediate both over all and each of the Churches and over all and each of the pastors and faithful: let him be anathema.”
 
mardukm seems incapable of reasoning logically and consistently, as Vico claimed that Vatican II is “inconsistent” which means: “self-contradictory”/ “inconsistent statements cannot both be true at the same time”/ “not in agreement”.

Hence the logical conclusion: “There is nothing substantial showing that there is a contradiction between Vatican I and Vatican II or a statement in one which can be termed to be untrue with regard to the other Council.”
Actually, the primary meaning of “inconsistent” is “no regularity” not “self-contradiction.” The language of V1 is not exactly the same as V2 (i.e., no regularity), but it doesn’t mean there is contradiction.:whistle:

But brother Vico can speak for himself.

Blessings
 
mardukm seems incapable of a logical, reasoned discussion, for he is still in error as well as being unable to express the truth of the Church’s teaching.
1**) No one has tried to say that ONLY the Pope has authority or infallibility in an Ecumenical Council.**
No one, but you and brother Steve. I (as well as others) have constantly asserted that the Pope alone is not the only authority or infallibility in an Ecumenical Council nor in a College, while you and brother Steve have consistently tried to oppose that statement through a misplaced appeal to the Decrees of Vatican 1. The only ones who have exercised a lack of logic here are you and brother Steve. Now, instead of humbly admitting your error, you try to slyly turn the tables and claim that we were the ones in error.:rolleyes:
2) mardukm’s basic errors above, were answered in post #32:
You’re just trying to save face now. You were wrong. Just admit it.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
There is nothing substantial showing that there is a contradiction between Vatican I and Vatican II or a statement in one which can be termed to be untrue with regard to the other Council.
Due to the new terms or phrasing and the subsequent changes to the canon law in 1983, there was much speculation generated. Read the source I quoted for a better understanding and you will see I did not make this up. One can look at how the canon law is written and at the current practice, which is what I said in my post. “The Canon law of 1983 and actual practice help in that matter: …”
 
There are those who may not read an entire thread for lack of time, and instead only read the last page, especially in a long thread such as this. Though brother Abu’s statements below have already been refuted previously, it might be well to repeat the refutations at this point in the thread, in case someone who does not know the context of the entire thread might be misled by his statements:
mardukm said:
So trying to “prove” that the Pope’s ratification is necessary for an Ecumenical Council to be infallible is a fruitless endeavor because its premise is flawed in the first place.
The feeling that an Ecumenical Council might be able to issue an infallible teaching without papal approval is incorrect.

As usual, brother Abu misinterprets the statements of those with whom he disagrees (intentionally or not, I cannot say). Anyone who has bothered to read the entire thread knows I never stated that papal approval is not necessary in an Ecumenical Council. I made the foregoing statement (in red above) in order to oppose brother Abu’s error that the Pope’s actions for an Ecumenical Council are done apart from, above, and in judgment of an Ecumenical Council. Brother Abu cited statements such as those immediately below in an attempt to “prove” his point.

Abu said:
newadvent.org/cathen/04423f.htm
Ecumenical Councils are those to which the bishops, and others entitled to vote, are convoked from the whole world (oikoumene) under the presidency of the pope or his legates, and the decrees of which, having received papal confirmation, bind all Christians. A council, Ecumenical in its convocation, may fail to secure the approbation of the whole Church or of the pope, and thus not rank in authority with Ecumenical councils.
In fact, the above statement contradicts brother Abu’s assumptions, since the statement above only asserts what is constitutive of an Ecumenical Council, not what goes on beyond or above it. I have repeatedly stated that all the Pope’s actions for an Ecumenical Council (convening, presiding, confirming, promulgating its decrees) are actions of the Pope as a member of an Ecumenical Council, not apart from or above it. In other words, from an outside perspective, they are the actions of the Council itself.
40.png
Abu:
This error was persistent.
mardukm, post #25
I know that many Catholics think that “the Pope confirms an Ecumenical Council.” But such language perpetuates the gross misconception… The Pope does not confirm (ratify) the decisions of an Ecumenical Council.
There is no error in my statement. A Pope does not confirm the decisions of an Ecumenical Council, but rather confirms the decisions of his brother bishops after which it may be called an “Ecumenical Council.” Without the approval of his brother bishops, without the approval and confirmation of the Pope, there is no “Ecumenical Council” to speak of. So it is ludicrous for the Pope to confirm the decisions of something that does not yet exist.

Besides, I persisted in my “error” only because brother Abu persisted in his erroneous opinion that the Pope’s actions for an Ecumenical Council are made apart from or above an Ecumenical Council - an error he continues to defend.
40.png
Abu:
Mardukm, post #177
What I’ve asserted is (1) the Pope cannot exercise universal authority without the support of his brother bishops, and (2) the Pope’s universal authority cannot be separated from the authority of the Church. That is collegiality both in principle and in action
  1. This was shown to be in error and corrected in Abu’s post #27:
    *Pastor Aeternus *(Ecumenical Council Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus)
    “Chapter 3.
    On the power and character of the primacy of the Roman Pontiff
  1. Since the Roman Pontiff, by the divine right of the apostolic primacy, governs the whole Church, we likewise teach and declare that he is the supreme judge of the faithful [52], and that in all cases which fall under ecclesiastical jurisdiction recourse may be had to his judgment [53]. The sentence of the Apostolic See (than which there is no higher authority) is not subject to revision by anyone, nor may anyone lawfully pass judgment thereupon [54]. And so they stray from the genuine path of truth who maintain that it is lawful to appeal from the judgments of the Roman pontiffs to an ecumenical council as if this were an authority superior to the Roman Pontiff. [My emphasis].
  2. So, then, if anyone says that the Roman Pontiff has merely an office of supervision and guidance, and not the full and supreme power of jurisdiction over the whole Church, and this not only in matters of faith and morals, but also in those which concern the discipline and government of the Church dispersed throughout the whole world; or that he has only the principal part, but not the absolute fullness, of this supreme power; or that this power of his is not ordinary and immediate both over all and each of the Churches and over all and each of the pastors and faithful: let him be anathema.”
    The Sections of Pastor Aeternus that brother Abu quotes only establishes the prerogatives that the papal office possesses. It says nothing about the actual exercise of those prerogatives. The history contained in the Church’s Sacred Tradition dictates that papal authority is always exercised collegially.
Some may ask, “can one distinguish a prerogative from it’s exercise?” Of course. It is actually a basic principle in Catholic ecclesiology. For example, it is a fact that bishops obtain certain prerogatives during their consecration, but the exercise of those prerogatives is a different matter altogether, and this exercise is governed by the Church.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Steveb,

All the quotes you gave are sufficient to refute your “Pope alone” opinion. That you myopically focus only on those particular portions of the texts that support your innovation, and refuse to consider the entire context of the Decrees and magisterial statements you have quoted isn’t my fault.🤷
I asked you for quotes to answer my question. I’m still waiting
M:
Thank you for admitting your error.
I was giving you an out. I wasn’t admitting anything other than to put this politely, you took a cheap shot.
M:
This whole debate started because I challened brother Abu’s errors regarding the authority and infallibility of a Council and collegiality - namely,

(1) that only the Pope has authority in the context of an Ecumenical council and the College of bishops; and
(2) that only the Pope has infallibility in the context of an Ecumenical Council and the College of Bishops.
Re: “only”

What provisions are necessary for a council to act such that all must follow their instruction with faith?

from [LG25]
  • must be in union with each other
  • must be in union with the pope
  • must be on matters of faith and morals
  • must concur in a single viewpoint and must be held conclusively
When those provisions happen, then “Their definitions must be adhered to”

What if they and the pope disagree? Who prevails? the pope

From Canon Law

Can. 341
§1. The decrees of an ecumenical council do not have obligatory force unless they have been approved by the Roman Pontiff together with the council fathers, confirmed by him, and promulgated at his order.
§2. To have obligatory force, decrees which the college of bishops issues when it places a truly collegial action in another way initiated or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff need the same confirmation and promulgation.
IOW the council can’t act alone.

Don’t absolutize "together with the council fathers" as if that supports your opinion. We already know they are assembled for a council. They can’t act without the pope’s approval, confirmation, and promulgation. That’s the point.

Can the pope act ALONE? Yes

The pope “enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith (Luke 22:32), he proclaims by a definitive act some doctrine of faith or morals. Therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter.” [LG 25]

Now if you’re not getting this my friend, I don’t know what more I can say.
M:
Neither you nor brother Abu could support your innovative errors on the matter from Magisterial documents,
Wrong
M:
so you slyly did a “switch and bait.” Instead of admitting your errors, you appealed to Decrees regarding the Pope’s universal authority and exercise of the infallible Magisterium from V1. Of course, this really did not address the original issue.
There is no switch and bait.

The resources I’ve used are Vat I, Vat II, Trent, & canon law

Did I camp out on any one of those alone? No, I used them all.
M:
Why defend something I never stated? Seems to be your common tactic - trying to put words in my mouth.😉 What I’ve asserted is (1) the Pope cannot exercise universal authority without the support of his brother bishops, and
give me the quote from any of the documents and sources I’ve already supplied, Trent, Vat I, Vat II, Canon law, that supports that opinion.
M:
(2) the Pope’s universal authority cannot be separated from the authority of the Church. That is collegiality both in principle and in action. Do you require further explanation? Please accept my offer (because I really think you need it :D). In any case, I will explain the matter more in the section below where re: St. Paul.
The pope “enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith (Luke 22:32), he proclaims by a definitive act some doctrine of faith or morals. Therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter.” [LG25]

From Canon Law

Can. 333
§1. By virtue of his office, the Roman Pontiff not only possesses power offer the universal Church but also obtains the primacy of ordinary power offer all particular churches and groups of them. Moreover, this primacy strengthens and protects the proper, ordinary, and immediate power which bishops possess in the particular churches entrusted to their care.
§2. In fulfilling the office of supreme pastor of the Church, the Roman Pontiff is always joined in communion with the other bishops and with the universal Church. He nevertheless has the right, according to the needs of the Church, to determine the manner, whether personal or collegial, of exercising this office.
§3. No appeal or recourse is permitted against a sentence or decree of the Roman Pontiff.
Can. 335 When the Roman See is vacant or entirely impeded, nothing is to be altered in the governance of the universal Church; the special laws issued for these circumstances, however, are to be observed.
 
CONTINUED

So you admit that brother Abu was wrong in claiming that infallibility in an Ecumenical Council is dependant on the Pope’s exercise of the infallible Magisterium alone. In other words, infallibility is exercised COLLEGIALLY. Thank you.
What have the documents said? Can a pope act alone without an E council? Yes. Can an E Council act alone without the pope? No
M:
You seem to be wishy washy on the matter. Can you answer straight up with a “yes” or “no?” The answer is obvious to me (as well as brothers Vico and AmbroseSJ). Is the Absolutist Petrine position so confused on the matter? 😃
What’s so hard to understand about any of the quotes I’ve given, particularly the following?

The pope
“enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith (Luke 22:32), he proclaims by a definitive act some doctrine of faith or morals. Therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter.” [LG 25]
M:
What “trap” did you fall into before?🤷
In post #161 you said
  • I do assert that he is not above correction.
  • To serve requires humility, and humility requires that one can accept correction.
  • It is the moral duty of bishops to correct the Pope if necessary, and it is the divine duty of the Pope to confirm the bishops, whether to correct his brother bishops, or after he himself has been corrected
I didn’t disagree with what you wrote.
http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=7569462&postcount=161

You responded to that as follows

Aaaah! So you admit that the Pope’s authority is not independent of the rest of the bishops. If it is truly independent, if the Pope is truly “over” his brother bishops as you have claimed, then he would be above correction. Steve has spoken! The case is closed! You have lost the debate. 🙂
http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=7571184&postcount=166

I considered that a cheap shot my friend. Accepting correction doesn’t interfere with one’s authority or independence. That’s the same stuff protestants pull when confusing impeccability with infalibility etc.

Am I to assume you’re more interested in trying to score points and cheap shots, than have honest, albeit a spirited discussion? I’m thinking now, in hindsight I have to ask you to qualify anything that looks like a set-up. Is that what I’m going to have to do? Or can we get passed that kind of stuff?

That’s what I meant when I said “C’mon Marduk, you’re better than that.”
 
Vico
Due to the new terms or phrasing and the subsequent changes to the canon law in 1983, there was much speculation generated.
When has there ever been no speculation? Look at the speculation and prejudices here – so entrenched that some speculators are quite unable to assent to the dogma and doctrine of Vatican I and II on the subject of the thread.
Look at the harm caused by dissenting theologians, before and after Vatican II, to today.

In his first post #19 mardukm became enmeshed in error with “It’s not really a matter of “proving,” but a matter of understanding….…. So trying to “prove” that the Pope’s ratification is necessary for an Ecumenical Council to be infallible is a fruitless endeavor because its premise is flawed in the first place."

For,** “And it is the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff to convene such councils, to preside over them and to confirm them.” [Code of Canon Law #337].**

We are all aware that mardukm has no authority to rewrite Canon Law, and he has been quite unable to extricate himself from his dilemmas, although given every help.

The updated CCC #88 is complemented by Canon 750 #2 for a truth proposed definitively (definitive proponuntur) which must be firmly accepted and held. Ad Tuendam Fidem, John Paul II, Apostolic Letter Motu Proprio (= on his own authority), 1998].

Thus CCC #88 clearly combines exactly with Pope John Paul’s Motu Proprio Apostolic Letter Ad Tuendam Fidem, 1998 (ATF) which requires the assent of divine and Catholic faith to believe (credenda sunt) dogmas (a category one truth) (Canon #750.1).
A category two truth requires the assent of ecclesial faith, as a secondary truth, “proposed definitively” (definitive proponuntur) to be “firmly embraced and held” (now Canon 750.2). So both the dogmas and the infallible (definitive) doctrines that are secondary truths, require an assent of faith, though there is a distinction between theological faith and ecclesial faith.
The category 3 truths are non-definitive (non-infallible) and require intellectual assent (“loyal submission of the will and intellect”, *Lumen Gentium 25), not an assent of faith. [See the Explanatory Note on ATF by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith].

Also, the 1983 revision of Canon Law replaced in Canon 749:3 “dogmatically (‘dogmatice’) declared or defined” with “infallibly defined”. This removes any occasion for equating “infallible” with “dogmatic”, an equation which unduly limits papal infallibility. Such a limitation is clearly not contained in the Vatican I dogma on papal infallibility.
 
mardukm
If he confirms and promulgates as a member of the Council, then it cannot be said that he is above an Ecumenical Council.
steve b
Very informative post, #103.
As the president of the The Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, Cardinal Kurt Koch has stated
THE VERY GOOD REPLY! [PJM]
“According to the thought of the present Pope, ‘without primacy, the Catholic Church would also have disintegrated a long time ago into national and sui iuris Churches, which would have confused and complicated the ecumenical landscape.’ ” (Plenary Session in November 2010).
What Vatican II teaches is that only the hierarchy under the Pope is divinely authorized to determine infallible truth – they are infallible if they agree with him; he can teach infallibly without, in the same way, depending on them.
MY ADDITIONAL COMMENT to:
mardukm
If he confirms and promulgates as a member of the Council, then it cannot be said that he is above an Ecumenical Council.
The HUGE singular difference my friend, is that the Supreme Pontiff can on His own, using ONLY His OWN authority; make such a proclaimation with or without the Council; whereas the Councils MUST always gain approval from the reigning Pontiff.

God Bless,
Pat
 
When has there ever been no speculation? Look at the speculation and prejudices here – so entrenched that some speculators are quite unable to assent to the dogma and doctrine of Vatican I and II on the subject of the thread.
…
It is particularly difficult though with Vatican II, as the commentary source I gave put it, p. 428-429:

“The forgoing examples demonstrate that from a juridical standpoint the texts of Vatican II are full of problems and inconsistencies. At least Vatican I used clear language, something that Vatican II did not achieve, and probably did not strive for. This was particularly true for a central issue of Vatican I, the demarcation of papal and episcopal power, and the jurisdictional primacy of the pope.” – from New Commentary on the Code of Canon Law.

“Despite a difficult struggle, the relationship between papal and episcopal power remained fundamentally that of the regulation of 1870.” – T. Eschenberg, quoted in the New commentary…
 
Vico
“The forgoing examples demonstrate that from a juridical standpoint the texts of Vatican II are full of problems and inconsistencies. At least Vatican I used clear language, something that Vatican II did not achieve, and probably did not strive for. This was particularly true for a central issue of Vatican I, the demarcation of papal and episcopal power, and the jurisdictional primacy of the pope.” – from New Commentary on the Code of Canon Law.”
As I have stressed there are no statements which are self-contradictory” which “cannot both be true at the same time" or “not in agreement”.

Fr William Most examined ten legitimate changes at Vatican II and found not one was a reverse of doctrine. All gave answers to previously debated points. Fr Most concludes: “It is obvious then that Vatican II did not create a revolution in theology. There are no reversals of teaching at all, and some…are only a little different or stronger than previous teachings, but all are in the same direction.” Catholic Apologetics Today: Answers To Modern Critics, Fr William G Most, TAN, 1986, p 200].

How strange that such a contrast should be attributed to Vatican II against Cardinal Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI) who has affirmed:
"It must be stated that Vatican II is upheld by the same authority as Vatican I and the Council of Trent, namely, the Pope and the College of Bishops in communion with him, and that also with regard to its contents, Vatican II is in strictest continuity with both previous councils and incorporates their texts word for word in decisive points…

“The cardinal exhorts all Catholics who wish to remain such “to return to the authentic texts of the original Vatican II.”

Cardinal Ratzinger expressed the required fidelity to Vatican II as: “to defend the true tradition of the Church today is to defend the Council…And this today of the Church is the documents of Vatican II, without reservations that amputate them and without arbitrariness that distorts them.” The Ratzinger Report, Vittorio Messori, Ignatius, 1985, p 28-31].
 
Dear brother Patrick,
MY ADDITIONAL COMMENT to:

The HUGE singular difference my friend, is that the Supreme Pontiff can on His own, using ONLY His OWN authority; make such a proclaimation with or without the Council; whereas the Councils MUST always gain approval from the reigning Pontiff.
Thank you for your (name removed by moderator)ut, but your opinion has already been refuted several times in this thread. In the context of the College of Bishops even when dispersed throughout the world, and in the context of an Ecumenical Council, your statement is simply false - the Pope CANNOT act alone. Why? Because the supreme authority of the College (and a Council) is the Holy Spirit acting through ALL the bishops, not just the Pope (contrary to the misguided opinions of brothers Steve and Abu).

Answer these questions:
  1. When an Ecumenical Council acts for the universal Church, does the Holy Spirit act in and through the bishops in an Ecumenical Council, or does he act only in and through the Pope?
  2. When the College of Bishops acts for the universal Church, does the Holy Spirit act in and through the entire College of bishops even when dispersed throughout the world, or does he act only in and through the Pope?
  3. When the Pope exercises the infallible Magisteirum, does he do so independent of and separated from the infallible Magisterium of the Church?
Blessings,
Marduk
 
I asked you for quotes to answer my question. I’m still waiting.
Not only did I consistently refute your unpatristic and unbiblical interpretations of the Vatican Decrees by appealing to the entire context of the quotes you gave, but I gave you several other quotes besides to refute your opinion. Anyone who has followed this debate can verify that. Your tactic has simply been to ignore what I have shown you, not even bothering to address the quotes I gave. Why should I waste my time now - just so you can dance around the quotes I give with syllogistic novelties once again? You have already been soundly refuted. As stated, if you can’t admit your error, that’s fine.
I was giving you an out. I wasn’t admitting anything other than to put this politely, you took a cheap shot.
OK. So you do admit that the Pope is the ONLY authority in the College of Bishops and in an Ecumenical Council. Clearly, brother Abu was simply releasing some hot air when he exclaimed, “No one has tried to say that ONLY the Pope has authority or infallibility in an Ecumenical Council.”

Absolutist Petrine advocates are consistently inconsistent. When you oppose the Truth, you only put yourselves to shame.
Re: “only”
What provisions are necessary for a council to act such that all must follow their instruction with faith?
  • must be in union with each other
  • must be in union with the pope
  • must be on matters of faith and morals
  • must concur in a single viewpoint and must be held conclusively
When those provisions happen, then “Their definitions must be adhered to”

I guess you missed “must be in union with each other” part, and skipped right to “must be in union with the Pope.” :rolleyes: As stated, your position is based completely on a myopic reading of the texts, while utterly neglecting the context.

NOTE: As stated initially in this post, your usual tactic has been to ignore what I have pointed out to you in the very texts you give. Please keep this current example in mind.
What if they and the pope disagree? Who prevails? the pope

From Canon Law

Can. 341
§1. The decrees of an ecumenical council do not have obligatory force unless they have been approved by the Roman Pontiff together with the council fathers, confirmed by him, and promulgated at his order.
§2. To have obligatory force, decrees which the college of bishops issues when it places a truly collegial action in another way initiated or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff need the same confirmation and promulgation.
IOW the council can’t act alone.
ONCE AGAIN. I guess you missed the part where it says “together with the council Fathers.”

NOTE: As stated initially in this post, your usual tactic has been to ignore what I have pointed out to you in the very texts you give. Please keep this current example in mind.
Don’t absolutize "together with the council fathers" as if that supports your opinion. We already know they are assembled for a council. They can’t act without the pope’s approval, confirmation, and promulgation. That’s the point.
:rotfl: You plead with me not to absolutize, when you’re the only one who is absolutizing one specific portion of the text while NEGLECTING the rest of it. Does it say “the Pope’s approval ALONE?” :rotfl: What’s your answer brother? Watch and learn. Your next response will be to avoid answering my question. As stated in earlier posts, you have not give a single iota of evidence for your unpatristic and unbiblical position from Magisterial texts.
Can the pope act ALONE? Yes.
Nope. Vatican 1 only established what the papal prerogatives are. The exercise of those prerogatives is another thing altogether. I gave you the ecclesiological principle involved in my last post. I see you failed to respond to that portion. That’s OK. You know when you’ve lost the debate.😉
The pope “enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith (Luke 22:32), he proclaims by a definitive act some doctrine of faith or morals. Therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter.” [LG 25]

Now if you’re not getting this my friend, I don’t know what more I can say.
Well. tbh, there’s really nothing you can say that will cause me to accept and adopt your unpatristic and unbiblical errors.🤷 I think we are engaging in this debate for the benefit of others who may not have made their minds up yet.

Btw, do you recall that we were discussing “authority,” as distinct from “infallibility,” according to your own suggestion? Did you think I would not notice that you have surreptitiously imposed the Decree on Infallibility in this discussion, when we should be discussing the Primacy? Like I mentioned earlier, when you oppose the Truth, you only put yourselves to shame.😛

I must be off. I will return in several hours to refute the rest of your post(s).😃

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Abu,

Did you even bother to read the quote given by brother Vico? It stated specifically that the issue was only a matter of clarity. It didn’t say anything about contradiction.

Does anyone else find your comments just a tad bit obtuse?

Blessings
As I have stressed there are no statements which are self-contradictory” which “cannot both be true at the same time" or “not in agreement”.

Fr William Most examined ten legitimate changes at Vatican II and found not one was a reverse of doctrine. All gave answers to previously debated points. Fr Most concludes: “It is obvious then that Vatican II did not create a revolution in theology. There are no reversals of teaching at all, and some…are only a little different or stronger than previous teachings, but all are in the same direction.” Catholic Apologetics Today: Answers To Modern Critics, Fr William G Most, TAN, 1986, p 200].

How strange that such a contrast should be attributed to Vatican II against Cardinal Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI) who has affirmed:
"It must be stated that Vatican II is upheld by the same authority as Vatican I and the Council of Trent, namely, the Pope and the College of Bishops in communion with him, and that also with regard to its contents, Vatican II is in strictest continuity with both previous councils and incorporates their texts word for word in decisive points…

“The cardinal exhorts all Catholics who wish to remain such “to return to the authentic texts of the original Vatican II.”

Cardinal Ratzinger expressed the required fidelity to Vatican II as: “to defend the true tradition of the Church today is to defend the Council…And this today of the Church is the documents of Vatican II, without reservations that amputate them and without arbitrariness that distorts them.” The Ratzinger Report, Vittorio Messori, Ignatius, 1985, p 28-31].
 
mardukm, post #196
you have surreptitiously imposed the Decree on Infallibility in this discussion, when we should be discussing the Primacy
The Vatican I Dogma ensures the Primacy
Pastor Aeternus (Ecumenical Council Vatican I)
“Chapter 3.
On the power and character of the primacy of the Roman Pontiff
8. Since the Roman Pontiff, by the divine right of the apostolic primacy, governs the whole Church, we likewise teach and declare that he is the supreme judge of the faithful [52], and that in all cases which fall under ecclesiastical jurisdiction recourse may be had to his judgment [53]. The sentence of the Apostolic See (than which there is no higher authority) is not subject to revision by anyone, nor may anyone lawfully pass judgment thereupon [54]. And so they stray from the genuine path of truth who maintain that it is lawful to appeal from the judgments of the Roman pontiffs to an ecumenical council as if this were an authority superior to the Roman Pontiff. 9. So, then, if anyone says that the Roman Pontiff has merely an office of supervision and guidance, and not the full and supreme power of jurisdiction over the whole Church, and this not only in matters of faith and morals, but also in those which concern the discipline and government of the Church dispersed throughout the whole world; or that he has only the principal part, but not the absolute fullness, of this supreme power; or that this power of his is not ordinary and immediate both over all and each of the Churches and over all and each of the pastors and faithful: let him be anathema.” [My emphasis].

Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith
THE PRIMACY OF THE SUCCESSOR OF PETER IN THE MYSTERY OF THE CHURCH
vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19981031_primato-successore-pietro_en.html

In answer to the Holy Father’s invitation, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith decided to study the matter by organizing a strictly doctrinal symposium on The Primacy of the Successor of Peter, which was held in the Vatican from 2 to 4 December 1996. Its Proceedings have recently been published.

“Since the power of the primacy is supreme, there is no other authority to which the Roman Pontiff must juridically answer for his exercise of the gift he has received: “prima sedes a nemine iudicatur”.42 This does not mean, however, that the Pope has absolute power. listening to what the Churches are saying is, in fact, an earmark of the ministry of unity, a consequence also of the unity of the Episcopal Body and of the sensus fidei of the entire People of God; and this bond seems to enjoy considerably greater power and certainty than the juridical authorities - an inadmissible hypothesis, moreover, because it is groundless - to which the Roman Pontiff would supposedly have to answer.”
  • Joseph Card. Ratzinger, Prefect
  • Tarcisio Bertone, S.D.B., Archbishop Emeritus of Vercelli, Secretary
Note
42. CIC, can. 1404
; CCEO, can. 1058. Cf. First Vatican Council, Dogm. Const. Pastor aeternus, Chap. 3: Denz-Hun, n. 3063
Can 1404: The First See is judged by no one.
 
The Vatican II Dogmatic Constitution on the Church ensures the Primacy

“18. And in order that the episcopate itself might be one and undivided, He placed Blessed Peter over the other apostles, and instituted in him a permanent and visible source and foundation of unity of faith and communion.(1) And all this teaching about the institution, the perpetuity, the meaning and reason for the sacred primacy of the Roman Pontiff and of his infallible Magisterium, this Sacred Council again proposes to be firmly believed by all the faithful*.

“22. But the college or body of bishops has no authority unless it is understood together with the Roman Pontiff, the successor of Peter as its head. The pope’s power of primacy over all, both pastors and faithful, remains whole and intact. In virtue of his office, that is as Vicar of Christ and pastor of the whole Church, the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And he is always free to exercise this power. The order of bishops, which succeeds to the college of apostles and gives this apostolic body continued existence, is also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.(27*) This power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff. For our Lord placed Simon alone as the rock and the bearer of the keys of the Church,(156) and made him shepherd of the whole flock;(157) it is evident, however, that the power of binding and loosing, which was given to Peter,(158) was granted also to the college of apostles, joined with their head.(159)(28*)

No “inconsistencies" here with Vatican I – no statements which are “self-contradictory” which “cannot both be true at the same time” or “not in agreement”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top