The Vatican Dogma

  • Thread starter Thread starter militantsparrow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is his infallibility dependent on anyone else? No.
Wrong, it is dependent on God.
Is the council’s infallibility dependent on anyone else? Yes.
Confirmation does not grant infallibility. It is an expression of AGREEMENT WITH what has been taught and judged by his brother bishops. His agreement COMPLETES the authority of the college, but by no means is the ONLY thing that grants a college its authority. Only God can grant infallibility. That you think that the Pope has the power to grant infallibility only demonstrates how poorly you understand the matter. Please accept correction, brother Steve.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Beng,
Are you saying that what the Apostles taught us are mere “practical requirements” and can be denied according to circumstance?
First of all, even teachings in the Bible can be denied according to circumstances, such as the Holy Spirit inspired teaching in Acts 15:28-29.

Second of all, according to CE: Apostolic Canons, its “claim to genuine Apostolic origin is quite false and untenable.”
It depends on what you mean by “consensus.” If you mean “consent” as a form of judgment, I agree with you that “consensus is not necessary.” But if it is “consent”
in terms of being in agreement with the sensus fidei of the Church, I most definitely disagree with you.
If sensus fidei is “all bishops + all faithful.” Then no, the Pope does not need the consent

Sensus fidei, like conciliar infallibility, must include the Pope. Thus the equation of sensus fidei is: “all bishops + all faithful + the pope” (note: conciliar infallibility equation is “all bishops + the pope”)
Actually, no. It simply means that, by the Grace of God, the Pope will never publicly teach error as the Faith of the Church.
Do you disagree that infallibility is a negative charism?
The circumstance you give is actually impossible, for it would mean that infallibility affects Pope’s free will. I humbly urge you to put that thought out of your mind. It could indeed be the case that a Pope desires to teach error publicly as the Church’s Faith. But by God’s grace, circumstances will occur that will not permit him to do so. God might strike him dead. He might be forced to resign through pressure from his brother bishops. War might break out in Europe and delay that Pope’s attempt to promulgate error, and before the war ends, he dies naturally. Whatever the case may be, infallibility only ensures that error will not be taught by the Pope. It has nothing to do with the inner workings of his mind.
I don’t understand you’re disagreement because I don’t see any disagreement. I did not say that infallibility affects the Pope’s free will.
Actually, no. You must understand that the Pope is simply exercising the infallibility that Christ promised to His Church (that’s exactly what Vatican 1 teaches). The Pope exercises the Church’s infallibility in a special way in the final decision, but it is nevertheless ALWAYS in the context of the CHURCH’s infallibility. Everything leading up to that decision is actually the movement of the Holy Spirit in the Church as a whole - from the solicitiude of bishops who alert the Pope to the helps that the Pope obtains from the Church in order to make his final decision. This is the infallibility of the Church as a whole at work (i.e., the movement of the Holy Spirit through the WHOLE Church, not just the Pope alone).
The infallibility of the Church is a teaching that has never been define clearly by the Church (as opposed to the clear definition of papal infallibility and conciliar infallibility).

So, to say that papal infallibility is ALWAYS in the context of Church infallibility is going beyond a clearly define doctrine. Not that it is wrong, and not that it is right either, but it is something that has not been clearly define by the Church.

And if you say that “everything leading up to that decision is actually the movement of the Holy Spirit in the Church as a whole - from the solicitiude of bishops who alert the Pope to the helps that the Pope obtains from the Church in order to make his final decision” doesn’t that mean you are going against what you’ve already written? Since as I understand it you agree that the Pope does not need any counsel from the Bishop, he could act in solo, to pronounce infallibly. Or maybe I misunderstand something.
But your statement here would be opposed to the teaching of Vatican 1. Please answer the following questions carefully:
  1. Do you consider yourself a faithful Catholic who adheres to the mind and teaching of Vatican 1? (Yes or No)
  1. Are you aware that the Official Relatio of Bishop Gasser is the OFFICIAL interpretation of the V1 Decrees? (Yes or No)
  1. The Official Relatio states that the agreement of the Whole Magisterium is the RULE OF FAITH, even for definitions of the Pope. Do you understand what the term “Rule of Faith” means? (Yes or No)
  1. Do you think that the “Rule of Faith” is something that is merely “practical” or is it something of divine/apostolic origin?
  1. Do you think that the Pope can oppose the sensus fidei of the Church when promulgating an ex cathedra decree?
  • If “yes,” how can you claim that the Pope is being faithful to Sacred Tradition in an ex cathedra decree?
  • if “no,” how can you claim that the Pope does not need to learn the mind of the Church before promulgating an ex cathedra decree?
  1. Do you think that when the Pope exercises the Church’s infallible Magisterium, God supernaturally infuses him with all the knowledge he needs for an ex cathedra declaration? If not, how can you claim that he can just wake up one day and make an ex cathedra decree without first learning the mind of the Church?
  1. Yes
  2. No. Never heard of it.
  3. Yes
  4. The latter
  5. Sensus fidei is “the pope + all bishops + all faithful.” Sensus fidei is NOT “the bishops + all faithful.” So the answer to the question would be a “no” because a “yes” would be a logical impossibility (ie. the Pope at the same time, while in person and while being a part of the sensus fidei, saying “A” and “not A.”)
It’s really a hair splitting discussion. So maybe I agree and disagree on certain minute and detail aspect. Plus I’m a late comer.
 
Dear brother Beng,
40.png
beng:
If the matter is about dogmatic teachings then it’s obviously the faithful and the rest of the bishops who are in error. If it is the Pope Vs the rest of the Church [the bishops plus all the faithful] on dogmatic teachings, the pope would be ALWAYS in the right. That is the Catholic faith.
Well, that is actually not the Catholic faith. That is an interpretation of certain Latin Catholics.

The true Catholic Faith teaches that the CHURCH as a body is infallible, and the Pope is able to exercise the infallible Magisterium of the Church in certain unique circumstances.

Were you unaware that the Church teaches that the CHURCH as a body is infallible? If you were aware, please explain how you can square that with your statement that “It is the Pope versus the rest of the Church?”

Blessings,
Marduk
The Church body INCLUDES the Pope.

So in the case of the Pope VS “all bishops + all faithful,” the later is NOT the Church body (because the Pope is not in it). Since it’s not the Church body, it could err.
 
In his relatio, Bishop Gasser answered the very question before the people here, in this way:

“It is true that the consent of the present preaching of the whole Magisterium of the Church, united with its head, is the rule of faith even for pontifical definitions. But from that it can in no way be deduced that there is a strict and absolute necessity of seeking that consent from the rulers of the Churches or from the bishops. I say this because the consent is very frequently able to be deduced from the clear and manifest testimonies of Sacred Scripture, from the opinion of theologians and from other private means, all of which suffice for full informaton about the fact of the Church’s consent. Finally it must never be overlooked that there is present to the Pope the tradition of the Church of Rome, that is of the Church to which faithlessness has no access, and with which, because of its more powerful primacy, every Church must agree.”

Previously he gave Mt 28:20 for evidence of the infallibility of the Magisterium of the Church, and Mt 16:18 and Lk 22:32 as evidence of infallibility of the Pope (definitions of faith and morals).

The Gift of Infallibility, Gasser, O’Connor, pp. 54-55
 
Dear brother Beng,
First of all, even teachings in the Bible can be denied according to circumstances, such as the Holy Spirit inspired teaching in Acts 15:28-29.
The ruling of the Jerusalem Council was a disciplinary matter, not a teaching (i.e., doctrine), so of course it could be changed according to circumstances. In distinction, that there must be consensus between the head bishop and his brother bishops for the unity of the Church to be realized is a teaching - a “principle,” if you will. It is the teaching of Christ to the Apostles that they must be united applied to the successors of the Apostles.
Second of all, according to CE: Apostolic Canons, its “claim to genuine Apostolic origin is quite false and untenable.”
I know that the Latin Church does not consider the Canons as Apostolic in origin. But regardless of its origin, these Canons have obtained the acceptance of the Ecumenical Councils, to which even the Latin Church is bound. This would dictate that you cannot interpret the Vatican Decrees contrary to the principles contained in these Apostolic Canons. If you look at your own Latin Code of Canons, it specifically states that immemorial laws are retained by the current Code. Obviously, once again, no Latin Catholic has the right to (mis)interpret the Vatican Decrees contrary to Apostolic Canon 34.
If sensus fidei is “all bishops + all faithful.” Then no, the Pope does not need the consent.
Sensus fidei, like conciliar infallibility, must include the Pope. Thus the equation of sensus fidei is: “all bishops + all faithful + the pope” (note: conciliar infallibility equation is “all bishops + the pope”).
First of all, why do you separate the Pope from “all bishops”?

Secondly, if the Pope is included in the sensus fidei (which refers to the WHOLE Church), then it stands to reason that he must never contradict the sensus fidei, correct?
Do you disagree that infallibility is a negative charism?
Agreed.
I don’t understand you’re disagreement because I don’t see any disagreement. I did not say that infallibility affects the Pope’s free will.
You just stated that “the Pope is not moved, aroused, or even inspired to pronounce infallible teaching.” You are stating that infallibility will not permit him to do this. How is that not affecting the Pope’s free will? The difference between our statements is that I asserted that the Pope indeed has the free will to do what you claim he cannot do - namely, to intend to teach error publicly. The charism of Infallibilty does nothing more nor less than PREVENT him from teaching error. We don’t know how this will come about, but we do know that it does not occur by affecting his free will.
The infallibility of the Church is a teaching that has never been define clearly by the Church (as opposed to the clear definition of papal infallibility and conciliar infallibility).
So, to say that papal infallibility is ALWAYS in the context of Church infallibility is going beyond a clearly define doctrine. Not that it is wrong, and not that it is right either, but it is something that has not been clearly define by the Church.
Two things I need to point out:
  1. This is something that I think is problematic in the Latin mindset. It borders on legalism. The idea that something must be defined in order for it to have dogmatic importance is thoroughly alien to Eastern and Oriental Catholics. I think many Latin Catholics fail to understand that the Church only defines a teaching when its truth is being challenged. But there are Truths that have never been challenged - one of these is the infallibility of the Church. The idea that this ancient Truth needs to be challenged first and then defined in order for it to have dogmatic status is, the idea that the certainty of this Truth is somehow less than the certainty of the Truth of “papal infallibility” just because it has never been “defined” — well, I can’t think of a kind work to describe it. But do you understand what I’m saying? You don’t need a definition on the infallibility of the Church to judge the merit of my statement.
  2. The doctrine of the infallibilty of the Church was a given at Vatican 1. It did not really need to be defined as far as the Church was concerned because there was no challenge or question about it. But the Fathers were concerned about how to relate “papal infallibility” to the infallibility of the Church. I already specifically pointed out to you what this relationship was according to V1’s Decree on the infallibility of the Magisterium of the Pope which states, “the Roman Pontiff, when he speaks ex cathedra…possesses through the Divine Assistance…the infallibility with which the divine Redeemer willed his Church to have…” It can get any clearer than that. The charism that the Pope obtains is simply to possess that which the Church already has. Obviously, “papal infallibility” cannot wholly be considered apart from the infallibility of the Church.
CONTINUED
 
CONTINUED
And if you say that “everything leading up to that decision is actually the movement of the Holy Spirit in the Church as a whole - from the solicitiude of bishops who alert the Pope to the helps that the Pope obtains from the Church in order to make his final decision” doesn’t that mean you are going against what you’ve already written? Since as I understand it you agree that the Pope does not need any counsel from the Bishop, he could act in solo, to pronounce infallibly. Or maybe I misunderstand something.
Yes, I stated he does not absolutely need the counsel of his brother bishops. But he still needs to determine the mind of the Church (i.e., its consensus - not its judgment, but its agreement) before he can validly exercise the infallibility of the Church. He does not need to consult his brother bishops in order to make this determination, but he has to make the determination nonetheless.
  1. No. Never heard of it.
OK. In case you did not know, Bishop Gasser was the spokesman for the Committee called De Fide at V1. This Committee was responsible for formulating the Decrees on which the Council Fathers were to give their vote. The Official Relatio was the official interpretation of the Decrees of V1 from the Committee. Whatever it was that the Fathers at V1 were voting for, it was to be understood in the sense as expressed in the Official Relatio.

The Official Relatio asserts that the agreement of the whole Magisterium is the Rule of Faith, EVEN FOR DEFINITIONS BY THE POPE. So the V1 Fathers had this understanding in mind when they passed the Decree on the Infallibility (remember, that “agreement” is not the same as “judgment”).

You say that you are faithful to the mind and teaching of Vatican 1. But, you claim that the Pope does not need the agreement of the whole Magisterium when he defines ex cathedra. Isn’t that being contradictory?
  1. Sensus fidei is “the pope + all bishops + all faithful.” Sensus fidei is NOT “the bishops + all faithful.” So the answer to the question would be a “no” because a “yes” would be a logical impossibility (ie. the Pope at the same time, while in person and while being a part of the sensus fidei, saying “A” and “not A.”)
Good, so far. You agree that the Pope cannot oppose the sensus fidei of the Church when he makes an infallible decree.
Now, in what way is the sensus fidei evident in the Church?
(a) The Pope alone.
(b) The whole Magisterium (all the bishops, including the bishop of Rome).
(c) You have to do a poll of all Catholics.
  1. Do you think that when the Pope exercises the Church’s infallible Magisterium, God supernaturally infuses him with all the knowledge he needs for an ex cathedra decree? If not, how can you claim that he can just wake up one day and make an ex cathedra decree without first learning the mind of the Church?
You forgot to answer this question.

Thank you for your replies, brother.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Beng,
The Church body INCLUDES the Pope.

So in the case of the Pope VS “all bishops + all faithful,” the later is NOT the Church body (because the Pope is not in it). Since it’s not the Church body, it could err.
  1. It is impossible that there will ever be a time when ONLY the Pope possesses the Truth because it is the ENTIRE CHURCH that is infallible. Would you agree with that?
  2. Since there will never be a time when ONLY the Pope possesses the Truth, would you agree that there will be others in the Church who possess that Truth?
  3. Would you agree that whatever Truth it is that the Pope may define, it must agree with the Truth that others in the Church also possess?
  4. Is the charism of infallibility the same thing as the charism of inspiration?
  5. Does the charism of infallibility grant the Pope the power of telepathy?
  6. Does the charism of infallibility grant the Pope omniscience?
  7. Does the charism of infallibility grant the Pope some supernatural sense of certitude that what he teaches will always be right?
  8. If it is not 4 thru 7 (I hope you answered “no” to questions 4 - 7), how does he know that what he will teach is actually God’s Truth? There are only three possible answers:
    (a) he looks at a crystal ball
    (b) he determines the consensus of the Church.
    (c) he just teaches and it will automatically become the Truth.
What is your response?

Blessings,
Marduk
 
40.png
beng:
It would be wise for the Pope to learn the mind of the Church prior to any judgment. Because, it’s possible, that in case the pope is trying to dogmatically teach an error, the Holy Spirit would kill him to prevent him from making that error and simultaneously protect the Church from error.
I would like an example, if you please, of the Holy Spirit killing a Pope to prevent him from teaching an error. Is that the reason Popes all eventually die?
 
40.png
Abu:
Yes; and the purpose of infallibility is to have and define the truth, NOT that the “faithful” must approve a teaching to make it true.
At last we are getting to the root of your problem. Infallibility is a protection of the Holy Spirit upon the whole Church to keep her always in the way of Truth.

Your first principle is that infallibility has to do with definitions, which it doesn’t. Yes, it protects definitions too, but that is not all. Infallibility also is protected by the Listening Church, the Faithful. That is why I brought up the example of the Arian heresy of the 4th c. That was a particular example of the listening church recognizing unorthodox teaching and resisting it.

You brush this aside as unimportant and not having to do with infallibility. But if you could understand the importance of the Listening Church to infallibility, you would understand infallibility in general better.
 
There is also another obvious example of the Church’s involvement in the pope’s exercise of the Church’s infallible Magisterium. Though canonization was explicitly excluded from the definition of “papal infallibility” at V1, it is still a very popular doctrine (not dogma) among many Catholics. I think brother Abu adheres to this belief (he cited someone promoting it). The fact is, canonization is a bottom-up exercise of the papal Magisterium. The Pope explicitly canonizes based on the faith of the local Churches.

Blessings,
Marduk
At last we are getting to the root of your problem. Infallibility is a protection of the Holy Spirit upon the whole Church to keep her always in the way of Truth.

Your first principle is that infallibility has to do with definitions, which it doesn’t. Yes, it protects definitions too, but that is not all. Infallibility also is protected by the Listening Church, the Faithful. That is why I brought up the example of the Arian heresy of the 4th c. That was a particular example of the listening church recognizing unorthodox teaching and resisting it.

You brush this aside as unimportant and not having to do with infallibility. But if you could understand the importance of the Listening Church to infallibility, you would understand infallibility in general better.
 
There is also another obvious example of the Church’s involvement in the pope’s exercise of the Church’s infallible Magisterium. Though canonization was explicitly excluded from the definition of “papal infallibility” at V1, it is still a very popular doctrine (not dogma) among many Catholics. I think brother Abu adheres to this belief (he cited someone promoting it). The fact is, canonization is a bottom-up exercise of the papal Magisterium. The Pope explicitly canonizes based on the faith of the local Churches.

Blessings,
Marduk
Yes. That is a good example of an ongoing, modern circumstance of the Faithful being consulted on matters of doctrine (canonization) which the Absolutist Petrine followers consider an exercise of Papal infallibility. Good catch. 😉
 
Wrong, it is dependent on God.
You know what I meant. The pope in making an infallible decision is not dependent on council, or anyone else in the Church, BECAUSE such a decision doesn’t come from him but the HS in a special way promised him in Peter…

That’s what I’ve been quoting over and over and over again.

“enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith (Luke 22:32), he proclaims by a definitive act some doctrine of faith or morals. Therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter.” [LG 25]

I’ve lost count how many times I’ve quoted that.
M:
Wrong. It is dependent on God, and God ALONE. The Pope has no authority to grant infallibility because it is not his to give in the first place.
Can. 337
§1 The College of Bishops exercises its power over the universal Church in solemn form in an Ecumenical Council.
§2 It exercises this same power by the united action of the Bishops dispersed throughout the world, when *this action is as such proclaimed or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff, so that it becomes a truly collegial act. *
§3 It belongs to the Roman Pontiff to select and promote, according to the needs of the Church, ways in which the College of Bishops can exercise its office in respect of the universal Church in a collegial manner.

Can. 338
§1 It is the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff alone to summon an Ecumenical Council, to preside over it personally or through others, to transfer, suspend or dissolve the Council, and to approve its decrees.
§2 It is also the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff to determine the matters to be dealt with in the Council, and to establish the order to be observed. The Fathers of the Council may add other matters to those proposed by the Roman Pontiff, but these must be approved by the Roman Pontiff.

Can. 341
§1 The decrees of an Ecumenical Council do not oblige unless they are approved by the Roman Pontiff as well as by the Fathers of the Council, confirmed by the Roman Pontiff and promulgated by his direction.
§2 If they are to have binding force, the same confirmation and promulgation is required for decrees which the College of Bishops issues by truly collegial actions in another manner introduced or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff

Also consider the opening quote

Bottomline, what happens if the pope doesn’t confirm his brothers in a particular matter?
M:
Confirmation does not grant infallibility. It is an expression of AGREEMENT WITH what has been taught and judged by his brother bishops.
And if the pope doesn’t agree with his fellow bishops and doesn’t confirm their decisions? Please answer that
M:
His agreement COMPLETES the authority of the college, but by no means is the ONLY thing that grants a college its authority.
Can. 341
§1 The decrees of an Ecumenical Council do not oblige unless they are approved by the Roman Pontiff as well as by the Fathers of the Council, confirmed by the Roman Pontiff and promulgated by his direction.
§2 *If they are to have binding force, the same confirmation and promulgation is required for decrees *

What if the pope doesn’t agree with the council? Then their decrees don’t oblige the faithful.

That’s canon law my friend. I can’t say it any differently.
M:
Only God can grant infallibility. That you think that the Pope has the power to grant infallibility only demonstrates how poorly you understand the matter. Please accept correction, brother Steve.

Blessings,
Marduk
Look at the opening quote. Do you see the HS in the definition? Of course it’s GOD behind the pope’s infallibility. And He’s there in a special way for the pope.
 
steve b:
40.png
Mardukm:
Wrong. It is dependent on God, and God ALONE. The Pope has no authority to grant infallibility because it is not his to give in the first place.
Can. 337
§1 The College of Bishops exercises its power over the universal Church in solemn form in an Ecumenical Council.
§2 It exercises this same power by the united action of the Bishops dispersed throughout the world, when this action is as such proclaimed or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff, so that it becomes a truly collegial act.
§3 It belongs to the Roman Pontiff to select and promote, according to the needs of the Church, ways in which the College of Bishops can exercise its office in respect of the universal Church in a collegial manner.

Can. 338
§1 It is the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff alone to summon an Ecumenical Council, to preside over it personally or through others, to transfer, suspend or dissolve the Council, and to approve its decrees.
§2 It is also the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff to determine the matters to be dealt with in the Council, and to establish the order to be observed. The Fathers of the Council may add other matters to those proposed by the Roman Pontiff, but these must be approved by the Roman Pontiff.

Can. 341
§1 The decrees of an Ecumenical Council do not oblige unless they are approved by the Roman Pontiff as well as by the Fathers of the Council, confirmed by the Roman Pontiff and promulgated by his direction.
§2 If they are to have binding force, the same confirmation and promulgation is required for decrees which the College of Bishops issues by truly collegial actions in another manner introduced or freely accepted by the Roman Pontiff
I don’t think I’m alone in seeing the incongruity of answering Mardukm’s comment about the Pope granting infallibility and your cut and paste document quotes which don’t address that issue at all.

Have some respect for the intelligence of your readers.
 
I don’t think I’m alone in seeing the incongruity of answering Mardukm’s comment about the Pope granting infallibility and your cut and paste document quotes which don’t address that issue at all.

Have some respect for the intelligence of your readers.
Go back and look at any of my posts. Have I ever said the pope grants infallibility? Those are Marduks words NOT mine. God is the one who assures what the pope confirms is infallible. Look at the quotes I gave. Have some respect for Church docs.
 
I don’t think I’m alone in seeing the incongruity of answering Mardukm’s comment about the Pope granting infallibility and your cut and paste document quotes which don’t address that issue at all.

Have some respect for the intelligence of your readers.
look at the following post. Specifically my 1st and last entry on that post
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=7585197&postcount=270

No REASONABLE person, will get the idea based on the quote I gave, that the pope grants infallibility.

The pope
“enjoys in virtue of his office, when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith (Luke 22:32), he proclaims by a definitive act some doctrine of faith or morals. Therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter.” [LG 25]

IOW

When the pope teaches, confirms, proclaims, defines a doctrine of faith or morals,
  • are his definitions of themselves, “not from the consent of the Church” held irreformable? Yes
  • Why are they irreformable? Because they are pronounced with the assistance of the HS promised to Peter.
 
Go back and look at any of my posts. Have I ever said the pope grants infallibility? Those are Marduks words NOT mine. God is the one who assures what the pope confirms is infallible. Look at the quotes I gave. Have some respect for Church docs.
You didn’t answer my question. Why would you answer his quote with your cut and paste stuff? MY POINT, is that your cut and paste reply had nothing to do with Mardukm’s statement. Why don’t you just say that you never said such a thing, rather than posting non-relevant cut and paste stuff from Vatican docs. 🤷

Perhaps you were misunderstood.
 
You didn’t answer my question. Why would you answer his quote with your cut and paste stuff? MY POINT, is that your cut and paste reply had nothing to do with Mardukm’s statement. Why don’t you just say that you never said such a thing, rather than posting non-relevant cut and paste stuff from Vatican docs. 🤷

Perhaps you were misunderstood.
  • okay I never said that.
My 3rd entry into this conversation (many posts ago) I said to Marduk

“I would hope what I wrote, is voicing the Church’s position, not my own. The subject of councils (universal and local), papal primacy, authority (local and universal), infallibility etc, covers a large area so condensing it in as few a words as possible, is difficult.”

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=7510313&postcount=78

If you look over my 40+ posts on this thread, you’ll find I keep my opinions to a minimum, and instead quote and feed off of Church docs. Just so that you know, I will always defer to the Church over my own opinions or the opinions of others.
 
To understand infallibility as set forth in VI you must read the Relatio. Further, VI was supposed to talk about the whole issue of infallibility - including the Bishops - which it did not. That is why VII took up the issue with respect to the relationship of the Papacy and the Bishops. In all it’s a very nuanced issue.

Bishop Vincent Gasser, in his famous defense of papal infallibility (the Relatio) at the First Vatican Council, discussed the aspects of collegiality and community (he also discussed absolute infallibility and other issues):

"We do defend the infallibility of the person of the Roman Pontiff, not as an individual person but as the person of the Roman Pontiff or a public person, that is,** as head of the Church in his relation to the Church Universal** . . .

We do not exclude the cooperation of the Church because the infallibility of the Roman Pontiff does not come to him in the manner of inspiration or of revelation but through a divine assistance. **Therefore, the Pope, by reason of his office and the gravity of the matter, is held to use the means suitable for properly discerning and aptly enunciating the truth. **These means are councils, or the advice of the bishops, cardinals, theologians, etc. Indeed the means are diverse according to the diversity of situations, and we should piously believe that, in the divine assistance promised to Peter and his successors by Christ, there is simultaneously contained a promise about the means which are necessary and suitable to make an infallible pontifical judgment.

Finally we do not separate the Pope, even minimally, from the consent of the Church, as long as that consent is not laid down as a condition which is either antecedent or consequent. We are not able to separate the Pope from the consent of the Church because this consent is never able to be lacking to him. Indeed, since we believe that the Pope is infallible through the divine assistance, by that very fact we also believe that the assent of the Church will not be lacking to his definitions since it is not able to happen that the body of bishops be separated from its head, and since the Church universal is not able to fail. (11)"
Here is a site for the Relatio matt1618.freeyellow.com/treatise16.html

What’s clear to me when reading the Relatio - wherein those who wrote the formula explained its meaning with ample clarity immediately before the vote and with the approbation of the Supreme Pontiff - is that the Council understood that: absolute infallibility belongs to God alone; papal infallibility is personal to the Pope only in his person as head of the College of Bishops and Vicar of Christ; the infallibility of the Church and the Pope is limited; and the Pope can never be separated from the Church, and vice-versa, when exercising the charism of infallibility.

Ultramontanist stretching simply is not supported by Vatican i - and Gasser was certainly an ultramontanist.
 
Some matters set forth in Vatican II that clearly comport with Vatican I:

cin.org/v2bishop.html

"DECREE CONCERNING THE PASTORAL OFFICE OF BISHOPS IN THE CHURCH - CHRISTUS DOMINUS
  1. Bishops, sharing in the solicitude for all the churches, exercise this episcopal office of theirs, which they have received through episcopal consecration,[6] in communion with and under the authority of the supreme pontiff. As far as their teaching authority and pastoral government are concerned, all are united in a college or body with respect to the universal Church of God.…
CHAPTER I THE RELATIONSHIP OF BISHOPS TO THE UNIVERSAL CHURCH
I. The. Role of the Bishops in the Universal Church …
4…”The order of bishops is the successor to the college of the apostles in teaching and pastoral direction, or rather, in the episcopal order, the apostolic body continues without a break. Together with its head, the Roman pontiff, and never without this head it exists as the subject of supreme, plenary power over the universal Church. But this power cannot be exercised except with the agreement of the Roman pontiff."[2] This power, however, “is exercised in a solemn manner in an ecumenical council.”

6…For by divine institution and the rule of the apostolic office each one together with all the other bishops is responsible for the Church.…"

The continued reiteration of the unity of the Pope with the episcopal college is clear. It is also clear that the “order of bishops” including and never without the Pope is the supreme body of the Church. When, therefore, the Pope acts in the exercise of the charism of infallibility or jurisdiction He is acting as a part of the College - as the head which with the body comprises the episcopal order. See the quote from Gasser above.

It’s obvious to me - at any rate.
 
I would like an example, if you please, of the Holy Spirit killing a Pope to prevent him from teaching an error. Is that the reason Popes all eventually die?
Patrick Madrid use the example of one Sixtus (can’t remember which, and can’t really be sure if it was a “Sixtus,” I’ll check later) who was trying to promulgate his poor translation of the bible as the official Bible (akin to the place the Vulgate holds after Trent). The letter of promulgation was ready and signed. He died.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top