The Vatican Dogma

  • Thread starter Thread starter militantsparrow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dear brother Beng,
The ruling of the Jerusalem Council was a disciplinary matter, not a teaching (i.e., doctrine), so of course it could be changed according to circumstances.
In distinction, that there must be consensus between the head bishop and his brother bishops for the unity of the Church to be realized is a teaching - a “principle,” if you will. It is the teaching of Christ to the Apostles that they must be united applied to the successors of the Apostles.
I think that is a definition of a “doctrine/teaching” that would confuse the distinction between “doctrine/teaching” and “dogma.”
I know that the Latin Church does not consider the Canons as Apostolic in origin. But regardless of its origin, these Canons have obtained the acceptance of the Ecumenical Councils, to which even the Latin Church is bound. This would dictate that you cannot interpret the Vatican Decrees contrary to the principles contained in these Apostolic Canons. If you look at your own Latin Code of Canons, it specifically states that immemorial laws are retained by the current Code. Obviously, once again, no Latin Catholic has the right to (mis)interpret the Vatican Decrees contrary to Apostolic Canon 34.
The canons would only have the same force as the non-dogmatic canons of various ecumenical councils. To bound a dogmatic teaching to such canons would be … giving them too much credit.
First of all, why do you separate the Pope from “all bishops”?
Secondly, if the Pope is included in the sensus fidei (which refers to the WHOLE Church), then it stands to reason that he must never contradict the sensus fidei, correct?
First, because the Pope is not just a bishop.

Second, well yes. Because it would be a logical impossibility. That is, the Pope at the same time is agreeing and disagreeing on something.
You just stated that “the Pope is not moved, aroused, or even inspired to pronounce infallible teaching.” You are stating that infallibility will not permit him to do this. How is that not affecting the Pope’s free will? The difference between our statements is that I asserted that the Pope indeed has the free will to do what you claim he cannot do - namely, to intend to teach error publicly. The charism of Infallibilty does nothing more nor less than PREVENT him from teaching error. We don’t know how this will come about, but we do know that it does not occur by affecting his free will.
I still don’t understand how a Pope who is not moved, aroused or even inspired is suppose to have his free will affected.

And I never said, or meant, that the Pope could never have intention to teach error. He could (but in light of Luk 22:32, he would not be aware that it is an error. AKA the Pope could not be a formal heretic [a material one he could, but not a formal one]).
Two things I need to point out:
  1. This is something that I think is problematic in the Latin mindset. It borders on legalism.
  1. The doctrine of the infallibilty of the Church was a given at Vatican 1. It did not really need to be defined as far as the Church was concerned because there was no challenge or question about it.
I was just pointing out that what you have written is going beyond what was clearly define so they can not be said to have the same dogmatic clarity. And yes, I do realize that there are many things that are not clearly define yet they are part of the deposit of faith (thus, infallible).
Yes, I stated he does not absolutely need the counsel of his brother bishops. But he still needs to determine the mind of the Church (i.e., its consensus - not its judgment, but its agreement) before he can validly exercise the infallibility of the Church. He does not need to consult his brother bishops in order to make this determination, but he has to make the determination nonetheless.
Well, that surely common sense. Even a president of a country or a hotel would need to determine the mind of their institution.
The Official Relatio asserts that the agreement of the whole Magisterium is the Rule of Faith, EVEN FOR DEFINITIONS BY THE POPE. So the V1 Fathers had this understanding in mind when they passed the Decree on the Infallibility (remember, that “agreement” is not the same as “judgment”).
You say that you are faithful to the mind and teaching of Vatican 1. But, you claim that the Pope does not need the agreement of the whole Magisterium when he defines ex cathedra. Isn’t that being contradictory?
I googled a bit and as I understand it the agreement is needed for the infallible pronouncement to be effective (if a King makes a law and his subject does not follow it then the law is effectively void), but it still retained validity as an article of faith that every members of the Church must believe.
Now, in what way is the sensus fidei evident in the Church?
Sensus fidei is really impractical. You have to get unanimous consent from every single Catholics.
  1. Do you think that when the Pope exercises the Church’s infallible Magisterium, God supernaturally infuses him with all the knowledge he needs for an ex cathedra decree? If not, how can you claim that he can just wake up one day and make an ex cathedra decree without first learning the mind of the Church?
No. His impulse to make such decision does not need to be affected by the Holy Spirit but by sheer impulsive thought.
 
Dear brother Beng,
  1. It is impossible that there will ever be a time when ONLY the Pope possesses the Truth because it is the ENTIRE CHURCH that is infallible. Would you agree with that?
  2. Since there will never be a time when ONLY the Pope possesses the Truth, would you agree that there will be others in the Church who possess that Truth?
  3. Would you agree that whatever Truth it is that the Pope may define, it must agree with the Truth that others in the Church also possess?
  4. Is the charism of infallibility the same thing as the charism of inspiration?
  5. Does the charism of infallibility grant the Pope the power of telepathy?
  6. Does the charism of infallibility grant the Pope omniscience?
  7. Does the charism of infallibility grant the Pope some supernatural sense of certitude that what he teaches will always be right?
  8. If it is not 4 thru 7 (I hope you answered “no” to questions 4 - 7), how does he know that what he will teach is actually God’s Truth? There are only three possible answers:
    (a) he looks at a crystal ball
    (b) he determines the consensus of the Church.
    (c) he just teaches and it will automatically become the Truth.
What is your response?

Blessings,
Marduk
  1. Disagree. It’s theoretically possible.
  2. See 1.
  3. Disagree
  4. No
  5. No
  6. No
  7. Yes. That would be the point of infallibility. If I’m the Pope then whatever I teach ex cathedra would always be right. If I were to teach error, something would happen to stop me from teaching that error.
  8. Because the doctrine of infallibility assures him that he will not ruin the Church by teaching error.
 
Dear brother SteveB,
You know what I meant. The pope in making an infallible decision is not dependent on council, or anyone else in the Church,
Incorrect.

First of all, your use of the word “dependence” is loaded, so inappropriate. It makes it seem as if the Pope or some other earthly entity is the SOURCE of infallibility, which is a wholly erroneous concept. God is the ONLY SOURCE of infallibility.

Secondly, in Council, it is never the Pope alone. The infallibility of a Council is collegial, not papal. And in the papal exercise of Church’s Magisterium for an ex cathedra decree, his infallibility is only the infallibility of the Church herself, so it can never be separated from the Church. As far as infallibility in the Church, there is no such thing as a one-way dependence. Rather, it is a matter of INTERdependence (if you want to put it in terms of dependence, though, as stated, it is inappropriate for the reason given above).
BECAUSE such a decision doesn’t come from him but the HS in a special way promised him in Peter…
Yes, the decision itself comes from him, but the infallibility that he possesses in making that decision is NOT HIS ALONE, but is simply the infallibility OF THE CHURCH. That’s exactly what the Vatican definition states. So you will never convince me that you are expressing Truth (i.e., all you have been expressing is your mere opinion), or that you are being faithful to the Vatican Decrees when you claim that the Pope’s infallibility is independent of the rest of the Church.
That’s what I’ve been quoting over and over and over again.
And as I’ve stated, just because you quote it doesn’t mean you are being faithful to it. I have consistently demonstrated how you only focus on PARTS of the Vatican Decrees to defend your error.
Bottomline, what happens if the pope doesn’t confirm his brothers in a particular matter?

And if the pope doesn’t agree with his fellow bishops and doesn’t confirm their decisions? Please answer that
No problem. Response:
There will be discussion and even debate until either the Pope changes his mind or the rest of the bishops change their mind.

The Pope’s confirmation is NOT the bottom line in terms of an Ecumenical Council or Collegiality. The bottom line is the resulting COLLEGIAL decision. The bottom line is the AGREEMENT of the ENTIRE College. The Pope’s confirmation is ONLY ONE ELEMENT of this collegial authority, but is by no means the ONLY thing that constitutes the collegial authority of an Ecum Council or the College of Bishops.
Can. 341
§1 The decrees of an Ecumenical Council do not oblige unless they are approved by the Roman Pontiff as well as by the Fathers of the Council, *confirmed by the Roman Pontiff *and promulgated by his direction.
§2 If they are to have binding force, the same confirmation and promulgation is required for decrees

What if the pope doesn’t agree with the council? Then their decrees don’t oblige the faithful

That’s canon law my friend. I can’t say it any differently.
The question is not “What if the Pope doesn’t agree with the Council?” A Council is [head + body], remember? The real question is “what if the Pope doesn’t agree with the rest of the bishop IN the Council?” I already answered this in a previous post, but AS USUAL, you failed to respond. Is it really that hard for you to admit your error, brother? Now, let me ask you, brother. According to this Canon law you just quoted, what happens if the rest of the bishop don’t agree with the Pope in the Council? Is it a valid Council? Please respond (I suspect you won’t because it will most definitely expose the error of your views). Umm - that’s canon law my friend. I can’t say it any differently.
Look at the opening quote. Do you see the HS in the definition? Of course it’s GOD behind the pope’s infallibility. And He’s there in a special way for the pope.
Look at the ENTIRE Decree instead of depending on your cut-and-paste hack jobs to defend your error. What is this “special way” that God is there for the Pope in terms of infallibility? The Vatican Decree states that it permits him to possess the INFALLIBILITY OF THE CHURCH. It doesn’t give him ANY SPECIAL infallibility, but simply allows him to possess the infallibility that the Church already possesses.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Go back and look at any of my posts. Have I ever said the pope grants infallibility? Those are Marduks words NOT mine. God is the one who assures what the pope confirms is infallible. Look at the quotes I gave. Have some respect for Church docs.
Oh please! Don’t start playing at sophistry now, brother. That’s very disappointing. You have CONSISTENTLY claimed that an Ecumenical Council or College is not infallible WITHOUT THE POPE’s CONFIRMATION. You have stated that their infallibility DEPENDS ON THE POPE. Don’t deny the intent of your words just because you or I use different terms. You know very well that just because you did not use the term “grant,” that is nevertheless exactly what you meant.

Like brother AmbroseSJ requested, just say what you mean. Throughout this thread, you have consistently danced around the questions and points we have posed with indirect, ambiguous answers by giving cut-and-paste quotes from Magisterial sources, as if you expect us to accept your interpretation just by giving these quotes. But I and others have shown you that not only is your interpretation based on a myopic focus on only certain portions of your quotes (not the entire context), but that those quotes themselves are wrenched out of a larger context that don’t support your interpretation at all.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
steve b:
If you look over my 40+ posts on this thread, you’ll find I keep my opinions to a minimum, and instead quote and feed off of Church docs. Just so that you know, I will always defer to the Church over my own opinions or the opinions of others.
OK, that is commendable and I can assure you we ALL feel the same way.

However, it is dangerous, as well as unreal to suppose that you can selectively quote documents without it also betraying your own opinion. It is this same righteous principle that prevents Protestants from accepting Catholic teaching. They can’t see that even while living in a world of quotes and snips from the bible they are really embracing personal opinion, judgment and interpretation. That is why Catholics have the Church.

My point is, you can’t consider yourself to be free from personal opinions, or that others can’t see your underlying opinions when you quote select passages from Vatican docs, (especially when in reply to specific questions.) Those documents must be understood in the light of ALL Church teaching. Those documents assume such a basis, and are *not intended *to be all encompassing, without possibility for misinterpretation.

For example the catechism of Trent was specifically intended for priests only. The laity was not supposed to be reading it without a priest to act as interpreter. Maybe there’s still something in that even today.
 
Dear brother Johnnykins,

Thank you so much for your valuable (name removed by moderator)ut!👍 I have two comments on your more complete citation of the Official Relatio, by way of agreement, and one comment on your use of the term “ultramontanist”:
We do not exclude the cooperation of the Church because the infallibility of the Roman Pontiff does not come to him in the manner of inspiration or of revelation but through a divine assistance. **Therefore, the Pope, by reason of his office and the gravity of the matter, is held to use the means suitable for properly discerning and aptly enunciating the truth. **These means are councils, or the advice of the bishops, cardinals, theologians, etc. Indeed the means are diverse according to the diversity of situations, and we should piously believe that, in the divine assistance promised to Peter and his successors by Christ, there is simultaneously contained a promise about the means which are necessary and suitable to make an infallible pontifical judgment.
Absolutist Petrine advocates (mis)interpret this passage to mean that the Pope does not need the rest of the Church for an ex cathedra decree. Their misinterpretation depends completely on one little term - the “etc.” in the third sentence of your citation above. The Official Relatio indicates clearly that the Pope needs help in the formulation of an ex cathedra decree (since the divine assistance does not come to him by way of inspiration or revelation). The idea that the Pope will get this help from anywhere else or from anyone else aside from the Church is fantastically ludicrous!!!
Finally we do not separate the Pope, even minimally, from the consent of the Church, as long as that consent is not laid down as a condition which is either antecedent or consequent. We are not able to separate the Pope from the consent of the Church because this consent is never able to be lacking to him. Indeed, since we believe that the Pope is infallible through the divine assistance, by that very fact we also believe that the assent of the Church will not be lacking to his definitions since it is not able to happen that the body of bishops be separated from its head, and since the Church universal is not able to fail. (11)"
I want to point out that Absolutist Petrine advocates (employing their usual tactic of wrenching things out of context) take this portion completely in isolation from the rest of the Official Relatio. They claim that the agreement of the Church that is required by the ancient apostolic canon 34 (the RULE OF FAITH, as Bishop Gasser put it) can ONLY come after the definition - in terms of a conscientious necessity to accept it. They fail to take into account the full context of the Official Relatio that has already been quoted earlier - that the Pope must first discern the consensus of the Church (i.e., the sensus fidei) before he can validly promulgate an ex cathedra decree.
Ultramontanist stretching simply is not supported by Vatican i - and Gasser was certainly an ultramontanist.
Ultramontanists who do the stretching are not properly “ultramontanists,” they are NEO-ultramontanists who are trying to revive the errors of the neo-ultramontanists at V1 that the Fathers of V1 explicitly and collegially rejected. These neo-ultramontanists are trying to pass themselves off as ultramontanists - i.e., they pretend to represent the correct understanding of Vatican 1. But we know they do not, and they are actually misrepresenting the true patristic teaching and intentions of Vatican 1 and the Catholic Church.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother SteveB,

Incorrect.

God is the ONLY SOURCE of infallibility.
Just as I’ve quoted from the docs.
M:
Yes, the decision itself comes from him, but the infallibility that he possesses in making that decision is NOT HIS ALONE, but is simply the infallibility OF THE CHURCH. That’s exactly what the Vatican definition states.
From Lumen Gentium #22
vatican.va/archive/hist_c…entium_en.html

But the college or body of bishops has no authority unless it is understood together with the Roman Pontiff, the successor of Peter as its head. The pope’s power of primacy over all, both pastors and faithful, remains whole and intact. In virtue of his office, that is as Vicar of Christ and pastor of the whole Church, the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And he is always free to exercise this power. The order of bishops, which succeeds to the college of apostles and gives this apostolic body continued existence, is also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided*** we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head****.(27)This power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff. For our Lord placed Simon alone as the rock and the bearer of the keys of the Church,(156) and made him shepherd of the whole flock;(157)

So
  • the pope is over all pastors and faithful
  • the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And is always free to exercise this power.
  • bishops also have supreme and full power over the Church *provided *they are united with the pope and this power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff
Obniously you don’t believe this
M:
There will be discussion and even debate until either the Pope changes his mind or the rest of the bishops change their mind.
What if he dissolves the council?
M:
The Pope’s confirmation is NOT the bottom line in terms of an Ecumenical Council or Collegiality. The bottom line is the resulting COLLEGIAL decision. .
Without his confirmation their decrees don’t oblige. [Can 341]
M:
The question is not “What if the Pope doesn’t agree with the Council?” A Council is head + body], remember? The real question is “what if the Pope doesn’t agree with the rest of the bishop IN the Council?”
Are you talking about a split council, of opposing bishops?
M:
Now, let me ask you, brother. According to this Canon law you just quoted, what happens if the rest of the bishop don’t agree with the Pope in the Council? Is it a valid Council? Please respond (I suspect you won’t because it will most definitely expose the error of your views). Umm - that’s canon law my friend. I can’t say it any differently.
As I’ve already said. if the pope doesn’t confirm an E council, no one is obliged to follow it’s decrees. [can 341 section 1 & 2]

Can you have a valid council where no one is obliged to follow the decrees?
M:
The outbreak of the Franco-Prussian war led to the interruption of the council. It was in fact never resumed, nor was it ever officially closed.
however,

On 24 April, the first Constitution, was formally confirmed and promulgated by the pope. (which I’ve quoted from)

On Monday, 18 July, 1870, Pope Pius IX. promulgated the dogma of papal infallibility.
 
Mardukm, post #283
the Pope must first discern the consensus of the Church (i.e., the sensus fidei) before he can validly promulgate an ex cathedra decree.
False perpetually.
  1. No need for a CONSENSUS from the sensus fidei (=unanimity) which is often missing. The sensus fidei proclaims the infallibility of the Church ONLY when in obedience to a doctrine taught. No one who dissents from a doctrine is part of the sensus fidei.
Reiterating this in the Post-Synodal Apostolic Exhortation *Christifideles Laici *(on the Vocation and the Mission of the Lay Faithful in the Church and in the World) 1988, John Paul II detailed “the ‘Criteria of Ecclesiality’ for Lay Groups” as requiring “The responsibility of professing the Catholic faith, embracing and proclaiming the truth about Christ, the Church and humanity, IN OBEDIENCE TO THE CHURCH’S MAGISTERIUM, AS THE CHURCH INTERPRETS IT.” [p 79, my emphasis].
  1. The Holy Father determines what definition is TRUTH and binding, protected by the Holy Spirit, not merely from how he has consulted.
  2. It is a DEFINITION, NOT a decree, for the Holy Father defines dogma or doctrine.
    In Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus, the Roman pontiff stands over the Church universal, possessing “supreme” apostolic authority and the infallibility of Peter when exercising his role as “pastor and teacher of all Christians.” Papal definitions are “irreformable of themselves and not from the consent of the Church.” (9)
**From Christ Himself:
All four promises to Peter alone: **
“You are Peter and on this rock I will build My Church.” (Mt 16:18)
“The gates of hell will not prevail against it.”(Mt 16:18)
I will give you the keys of the Kingdom of heaven.” ( Mt 16:19)
“Whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven.” (Mt 16:19)

**Sole authority: **“Strengthen your brethren.” (Lk 22:32)
“Feed My sheep.”(Jn 21:17).
 
Dear brother Beng,
I think that is a definition of a “doctrine/teaching” that would confuse the distinction between “doctrine/teaching” and “dogma.”
Not all “doctrine/teaching” is “dogma,” but all “dogma” is in fact “doctrine/teaching.” So you can’t make such a solid distinction in the first place, esp. not on the doctrine expressed in the immemorial Apostolic Canon 34. As stated, Apostolic Canon 34 is simply the very teaching of Christ applied to the Apostle’s successors.
The canons would only have the same force as the non-dogmatic canons of various ecumenical councils. To bound a dogmatic teaching to such canons would be … giving them too much credit.
It seems you’re confusing mere disciplinary canons with canons formulated from Church doctrine. The necessity of the consensus of the College of bishops for the sake of the unity of the Church is not a mere disciplinary matter. It is formulated from Christ’s own teaching of the necessity of the consensus of the Apostolic College.
First, because the Pope is not just a bishop.
He is just a bishop, a bishop with greater responsibilities and prerogatives, but still just a bishop. Maybe you are not aware, but one of the debates at V1 centered on the addition of the term “episcopal” to the Decree on Primacy. Please read the Decree if you have it off-hand. You will see that the Pope’s primatial prerogatives are described as “episcopal” (among other things).
Second, well yes. Because it would be a logical impossibility. That is, the Pope at the same time is agreeing and disagreeing on something.
Agreed.
I still don’t understand how a Pope who is not moved, aroused or even inspired is suppose to have his free will affected.
And I never said, or meant, that the Pope could never have intention to teach error. He could (but in light of Luk 22:32, he would not be aware that it is an error.
Whether he is aware of it or not is irrelevant. If it is heresy, it is heresy, regardless of awareness. The point is that the Church’s infallibility will somehow prevent him from teaching it to the Church. So it has nothing to do with “impulse.” He could certainly have the “impulse” to teach heresy, even if he was not aware it was heresy. Infallibility has nothing to do with desires (my point) or impulses (your point).
AKA the Pope could not be a formal heretic [a material one he could, but not a formal one]).
“Formal/material heretic” is irrelevant. The Pope can indeed become a formal heretic. The charism of the Church’s infallibility will simply and only prevent him from ever teaching his heresy as the Church’s Faith.
I was just pointing out that what you have written is going beyond what was clearly define so they can not be said to have the same dogmatic clarity.
V1 clearly defined that “papal infallibility” is nothing more than the assistance of the Holy Ghost so the Pope may possess the infallibility of the Church. Do you concede to this explicit teaching of V1?
And yes, I do realize that there are many things that are not clearly define yet they are part of the deposit of faith (thus, infallible).
Agreed.
Well, that surely common sense. Even a president of a country or a hotel would need to determine the mind of their institution.
Agreed.
I googled a bit and as I understand it the agreement is needed for the infallible pronouncement to be effective (if a King makes a law and his subject does not follow it then the law is effectively void), but it still retained validity as an article of faith that every members of the Church must believe.
Agreed. But the Church’s involvement in the Pope’s personal exercise of the Church’s infallibility is not simply about the Church’s agreement after the definition for its effectiveness. The Church’s agreement is also evident before the definition, as the Pope can define only that which is the Faith of the Church. Indeed, the Church’s agreement does not come by way of judgment, but neither does the Pope have any authority to go beyond that which is the Faith of the past or present Church. Do you agree with this last sentence? Yes or no.
Sensus fidei is really impractical. You have to get unanimous consent from every single Catholics.
Sorry I was unclear. I expected you to choose an answer from the three options provided. To repeat. In what way is the sensus fidei evident in the Church? (a) The Pope alone; (b) the whole Magisterium (all bishops); (c) a poll of all Catholics. What’s your answer? Or are you saying that the only way to evince the sensus fidei is to poll all Catholics?
mardukm said:
6) Do you think that when the Pope exercises the Church’s infallible Magisterium, God supernaturally infuses him with all the knowledge he needs for an ex cathedra decree? If not, how can you claim that he can just wake up one day and make an ex cathedra decree without first learning the mind of the Church?
No.

Are you saying “No, God does not supernaturally infuse him with all knowledge”?
His impulse to make such decision does not need to be affected by the Holy Spirit but by sheer impulsive thought.
This really has nothing to do with my original question. You claimed that the Pope can just wake up one morning and decide to make an ex cathedra decree. Can you please cite any Magisterial source for this statement, or are you simply expressing your opinion?

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Beng,

I think we are making good progress here. We agree on a lot of things (e.g., the Pope cannot contradict the sensus fidei; the agreement of the Church is necessary for the effectiveness of an ex cathedra decree). But there are still a few matters to attend to before we can state, as St. Paul exhorted us, that we are of one mind on the matter:
mardukm said:
1) It is impossible that there will ever be a time when ONLY the Pope possesses the Truth because it is the ENTIRE CHURCH that is infallible. Would you agree with that?
  1. Since there will never be a time when ONLY the Pope possesses the Truth, would you agree that there will be others in the Church who possess that Truth?
  2. Would you agree that whatever Truth it is that the Pope may define, it must agree with the Truth that others in the Church also possess?
  1. Disagree. It’s theoretically possible.
  2. See 1.
  3. Disagree.
So, in fact, you don’t adhere to the Church doctrine on the infallibility of the Church. You believe that there will be a time that ONLY the bishop of Rome will be infallible, but that the rest of the Church will be in error. I hope you are not expecting us to believe that “the Church” is ONLY the Pope. If so, please don’t even attempt to use that rhetoric, because it will be rejected right off the bat.

I suspect you are confusing the indefectibility of the Church with the infallibility of the Church. Indefectibility refers to the fact that the Church as a whole and in the long run will never fall away from the Truth. In distinction, infallibility refers to the fact that the Church as a whole and at any point in time will always possess and teach the Truth.

While you apparently believe in the indefectibility of the Church, you obviously reject (perhaps unintentionally) the Catholic teaching that the Church as a whole at any point in time will always possess and teach the Truth. After all, you just admitted to the possibility that only the head and not the body as a whole will be infallible.

Further also consider this: Do you suppose that among the hierarchy, the papacy is the only one of divine institution?

Are you aware that the Church teaches that the episcopate is also of divine institution?

Are you aware that the episcopate was established by God to be authentic teachers of the Faith?

If so, would you agree that there will never be a time when the Church will only have the Pope as the single and lone voice of the Church who can teach the Faith?

Btw, though the infallibility of the Church has never been defined (because it has not needed to be defined), it is a teaching contained in the Catholic Catechism.

Are you willing to change your view on the 3 questions above?
mardukm said:
7) Does the charism of infallibility grant the Pope some supernatural sense of certitude that what he teaches will always be right?
Yes. That would be the point of infallibility. If I’m the Pope then whatever I teach ex cathedra would always be right. If I were to teach error, something would happen to stop me from teaching that error.

No. That is not the point of infallibility, and you contradict yourself in your answer. You claim that it is about a supernatural certitude, yet you simultaneously admit that if a Pope were to attempt to teach error, something would stop him. You also admitted in a previous post that (1) the Pope has free will and (2) the Pope may not know that what he intends to teach is actually error. Certitude is involved with the will. So if you admit the possibility that a Pope might attempt to teach error (though something will stop him by virtue of the Church’s charism of infallibility), how can you possibly claim it is about a supernatural sense of certitude. A Pope can be certain that what he will teach is right, but it is possible that it will be totally wrong, and God will somehow put a stop to that. God’s prevention of that erroneous teaching is what infallibility is all about. It has NOTHING to do with the certitude of the Pope about what he intends to teach.

Are you willing to change your view on question number 7, or are you intent on remaining in your inconsistency?
mardukm said:
8) If it is not 4 thru 7 (I hope you answered “no” to questions 4 - 7), how does he know that what he will teach is actually God’s Truth? There are only three possible answers:
(a) he looks at a crystal ball
(b) he determines the consensus of the Church.
(c) he just teaches and it will automatically become the Truth.
I think you are misunderstanding my point.

Because the doctrine of infallibility assures him that he will not ruin the Church by teaching error.

Sorry for being unclear. The Pope’s personal exercise of the Church’s infallibility involves several steps -
  1. his brother bishops alert him of the need to exercise his personal prerogative.
  2. he does his investigation to ascertain the consensus of the Church (sensus fidei)
  3. he makes a decision based on that consensus
  4. he promulgates his decree.
Now at some point before #3, I assume you agree that he must be certain that his teaching will be true. What I am asking is how this certainty will come about. Your response to #7 was obviously a mass of self-contradictions. So if you are basing your answer to #8 on your answer to #7, I sincerely hope you do a bit more thinking on the matter. After you do that, I would appreciate a new response to #8.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Beng,

Not all “doctrine/teaching” is “dogma,” but all “dogma” is in fact “doctrine/teaching.” So you can’t make such a solid distinction in the first place, esp. not on the doctrine expressed in the immemorial Apostolic Canon 34. As stated, Apostolic Canon 34 is simply the very teaching of Christ applied to the Apostle’s successors.
How is Apostolic Canon the teaching of Christ when it’s not even the teaching of apostle? It could only be said to be the teaching of Christ as much as a RCIA textbook is base on the teaching of Jesus.

It seems that you have put too much authority on The Apostolic Canon which I, or maybe others, do not share. We could side-argue about Apostolic Canon authority, but that would be too burdensome. For simplicity’s sake let’s not base argument on Apostolic Canons. I’m sure both side could argue without it.
He is just a bishop, a bishop with greater responsibilities and prerogatives, but still just a bishop. Maybe you are not aware, but one of the debates at V1 centered on the addition of the term “episcopal” to the Decree on Primacy. Please read the Decree if you have it off-hand. You will see that the Pope’s primatial prerogatives are described as “episcopal” (among other things).
That greater responsibilities and prerogatives makes him more than just a bishop. To equate him with other bishops would be un-Catholic.
Whether he is aware of it or not is irrelevant. If it is heresy, it is heresy, regardless of awareness. The point is that the Church’s infallibility will somehow prevent him from teaching it to the Church. So it has nothing to do with “impulse.” He could certainly have the “impulse” to teach heresy, even if he was not aware it was heresy. Infallibility has nothing to do with desires (my point) or impulses (your point).
“Formal/material heretic” is irrelevant. The Pope can indeed become a formal heretic. The charism of the Church’s infallibility will simply and only prevent him from ever teaching his heresy as the Church’s Faith.
I disagree. It’s relevant in light of Lk 22:32. But it’s not directly relevant to our discussion.

And because of that verse not only the Pope would not be able to teach error, he could not be a formal heretic.
V1 clearly defined that “papal infallibility” is nothing more than the assistance of the Holy Ghost so the Pope may possess the infallibility of the Church. Do you concede to this explicit teaching of V1?
Yes. Because it does not do away with what I have said.
Agreed. But the Church’s involvement in the Pope’s personal exercise of the Church’s infallibility is not simply about the Church’s agreement after the definition for its effectiveness. The Church’s agreement is also evident before the definition, as the Pope can define only that which is the Faith of the Church. Indeed, the Church’s agreement does not come by way of judgment, but neither does the Pope have any authority to go beyond that which is the Faith of the past or present Church. Do you agree with this last sentence? Yes or no.
Agreement with previous definitions by past magisterium, yes. Agreement with the current bishops and faithful, no.
Or are you saying that the only way to evince the sensus fidei is to poll all Catholics?
Yes.
Are you saying “No, God does not supernaturally infuse him with all knowledge”?
Yes.
This really has nothing to do with my original question. You claimed that the Pope can just wake up one morning and decide to make an ex cathedra decree. Can you please cite any Magisterial source for this statement, or are you simply expressing your opinion?
Have you ever wake up one day and just feel like doing something [e.g. going to the swimming pool]? Now, that impulsive thought does not have to be inspire by the Holy Spirit nor cause by previous preponderance (for example, the night before you watch Micheal Phelps). It’s a spontaneous thought. This is what I meant. The pope could just wake up and have a spontaneous thought that he want to pronounce infallible. And if that thought is genuinely part of the deposit of faith, it will be infallible and the whole church is bound to it.
 
Dear brother Steve,
Just as I’ve quoted from the docs
.
Sure, but judging from your responses, what you actually mean is that God gives infallibility to the Pope ALONE, and the Pope in turn grants it to the rest of the Church. That actually contradicts the very definition of V1, since V1 asserted that the Pope is merely permitted to possess the infallibility of the Church, not the other way around.
*]the pope is over all pastors and faithful.
Agreed, but if you intend this to mean that he can exercise his authority to impede the authority of local bishops, you are in error.
*]the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And is always free to exercise this power.
Agreed, but if you intend the term “free” to mean “any time, any where, by his mere will” you are in error. The term “free” does not mean “unrestricted.” It primarily means “uncoerced.” It refers to the fact that when the Pope exercises his prerogatives, he does it volitionally, and is not forced to do so - he is not forced to exercise it, and neither is he forced not to exercise it. It’s obvious that “free” does not mean “unrestricted” because the V1 Decree itself states that the Pope is not free to impede the authority of local bishops. Canonically, neither is the Pope free to damage the acquired rights of individuals. Morally, neither is the Pope free to oppose the Faith of the Church. ETC., ETC., ETC. So the Pope is obviously not “unrestricted” in his exercise of the papal prerogatives.
bishops also have supreme and full power over the Church *provided *they are united with the pope and this power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff.
Agreed, but if you intend this to mean that the authority of the College is merely papal authority exercise in a college, instead of actual collegial authority (i.e., the authority of ALL the members COMBINED), then you are in error.
Obviously you don’t believe this
As stated above, what I don’t believe is your Absolutist Petrine misinterpretations of the Decrees.
What if he dissolves the council?
It is his administrative prerogative to dissolve a Council, but he never does it without the solicitation of his brother bishops.
without his confirmation their decrees don’t oblige. [Can 341]
And without the agreement of his brother bishops, his decrees ALONE don’t oblige either (Canon 341).
Are you talking about a split council, of opposing bishops?
I’m not sure of your point. Please explain.
As I’ve already said. if the pope doesn’t confirm an E council, no one is obliged to follow it’s decrees. [can 341 section 1 & 2]

As I suspected, NOT A DIRECT ANSWER. I ask “what if the rest of the bishops don’t agree - is it a valid Council?” and all I get is this dance and jig from you. It’s as if to your Absolutist Petrine mindset, the other bishops don’t even exist!!! I hope readers will take note of this so they will know not to be fooled by the sophistry being employed by brother Steve, or any of the Absolutist Petrine advocates.
Can you have a valid council where no one is obliged to follow the decrees?
:confused:
however,

On 24 April, the first Constitution, was formally confirmed and promulgated by the pope. (which I’ve quoted from)

On Monday, 18 July, 1870, Pope Pius IX. promulgated the dogma of papal infallibility.
I’m not sure who stated this originally, but I think the OP meant to point out that there were other things on the Council agenda that were not voted upon just because of the war. These items were more clear on the collegial nature of Church authority and infallibility. The fact that explicit collegiality (I use the adjective “explicit” because collegiality was indeed at least implied even by the Decrees on the papal prerogatives) was not dogmatized at V1 was not the result of a rejection of collegiality at V1, but by circumstances outside of the Council.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
So, in fact, you don’t adhere to the Church doctrine on the infallibility of the Church. You believe that there will be a time that ONLY the bishop of Rome will be infallible, but that the rest of the Church will be in error. I hope you are not expecting us to believe that “the Church” is ONLY the Pope. If so, please don’t even attempt to use that rhetoric, because it will be rejected right off the bat.
Yes. Such event is possible, that is, a Pope defines something infallible while the rest of the church doesn’t agree that it is infallible. If so, the possessor of truth would be the pope, not the rest of the Church. Of course the Church is not the Pope only. Those who err are still part of the Church (since error does not exclude someone from the church, as heresy, schism and apostasy does). But the holder of truth is the pope.
I suspect you are confusing the indefectibility of the Church with the infallibility of the Church.
I’m not.
While you apparently believe in the indefectibility of the Church, you obviously reject (perhaps unintentionally) the Catholic teaching that the Church as a whole at any point in time will always possess and teach the Truth. After all, you just admitted to the possibility that only the head and not the body as a whole will be infallible.
How did I deny that if I assert that in an extreme case we have AT LEAST one Catholic would be holding the truth, ie. the Pope? Thus I hold that at any point in time the church will always possess and teach the truth.
Further also consider this: Do you suppose that among the hierarchy, the papacy is the only one of divine institution?
Are you aware that the Church teaches that the episcopate is also of divine institution?
Are you aware that the episcopate was established by God to be authentic teachers of the Faith?
If so, would you agree that there will never be a time when the Church will only have the Pope as the single and lone voice of the Church who can teach the Faith?
Yes. Yes. Yes. No, it’s possible to have a situation where the Pope is the sole possessor of truth and if this happens no Church dogmas (especially infallibility and indefectibility) will be compromised.
No. That is not the point of infallibility,
If I am pope any teaching that I will promulgate ex cathedra would be free from error. I’m absolutely sure of this because this is what the doctrine of infallibility teaches. If I have in mind a teaching that is erroneous, which is possible, I won’t be able to promulgate it

Where’s your disagreement on this?
Sorry for being unclear. The Pope’s personal exercise of the Church’s infallibility involves several steps -
  1. his brother bishops alert him of the need to exercise his personal prerogative.
  2. he does his investigation to ascertain the consensus of the Church (sensus fidei)
  3. he makes a decision based on that consensus
  4. he promulgates his decree.
Now at some point before #3, I assume you agree that he must be certain that his teaching will be true. What I am asking is how this certainty will come about. Your response to #7 was obviously a mass of self-contradictions. So if you are basing your answer to #8 on your answer to #7, I sincerely hope you do a bit more thinking on the matter. After you do that, I would appreciate a new response to #8.
Blessings,
Marduk
Leaving aside that 1-3 is not absolutely necessary for ex cathedra, the certainty comes from the dogma. That is, any teaching that will be promulgated by a pope ex cathedra would be infallible.
 
False perpetually.
  1. No need for a CONSENSUS from the sensus fidei (=unanimity) which is often missing. The sensus fidei proclaims the infallibility of the Church ONLY when in obedience to a doctrine taught. No one who dissents from a doctrine is part of the sensus fidei.
Yes, INCLUDING THE POPE. If the Pope’s teaching departs from the sensus fidei (the consensus of the Church), then he has NO AUTHORITY to teach that doctrine ex cathedra. Hence, since the charism of infallibility is not inspiration, nor revelation, nor telepathy, nor omniscience, nor supernatural certitude, if the Pope does not first discern that what he will be defining is part of the sensus fidei (i.e., the consensus of the Church) then he has NO AUTHORITY to declare that teaching ex cathedra.

Simple. case solved.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Beng,
How is Apostolic Canon the teaching of Christ when it’s not even the teaching of apostle? It could only be said to be the teaching of Christ as much as a RCIA textbook is base on the teaching of Jesus.
You have no certainty that it is not from Christ. In any case, you still have to deal with its authority as Ecumenical according to the approval of the Ecumenical Councils. You still have to deal with the fact that it is a TEACHING, not a mere discipline.
It seems that you have put too much authority on The Apostolic Canon which I, or maybe others, do not share. We could side-argue about Apostolic Canon authority, but that would be too burdensome. For simplicity’s sake let’s not base argument on Apostolic Canons. I’m sure both side could argue without it.
It’s not possible to argue without it, because the Fathers of V1 explicitly used it to interpret their Decrees. Don’t you recall my quotation from Bishop Gasser on the RULE OF FAITH - i.e., the consensus of the WHOLE Magisterium? He was referring to Apostolic Canon 34 (unless you can cite some other source - and I guarantee you won’t be able to). Don’t you remember that Bishop Gasser expressed the OFFICIAL interpretation of the decrees? If you attempt to interpret the V1 Decrees apart from Apostolic Canon 34, you are not being faithful to the intent of the Fathers of V1. So I hope you will correct your attitude towards Apostolic Canon 34 accordingly.
That greater responsibilities and prerogatives makes him more than just a bishop. To equate him with other bishops would be un-Catholic.
I just gave you explicit proof that V1 intended the papal prerogatives to be interpreted within the scope of the Pope AS BISHOP, and you disagree with V1. Yet you claim my view is the one that is UN-Catholic? Very strange.
And because of that verse not only the Pope would not be able to teach error, he could not be a formal heretic.
That’s where you’re stretching the dogma of the Pope’s exercise of the Church’s infallible Magisterium too far. The dogma only refers to the preservation of the PUBLIC TEACHING of the Church. It has absolutely no bearing on the PRIVATE BELIEF of the Pope. The Pope can indeed be a formal heretic. It is simply that he will never be able to teach his private heresy as the public faith of the Church. The PUBLIC FAITH of the Church is the ONLY thing that Infallibility guarantees.

I read my fair share of apologetics, and the only time that I have ever read of the terms “formal heretic” and “material heretic” in reference to the papacy is with regards to the case of Pope Honorius. The apologetic states simply that Pope honorius was simply a material heretic, not a formal heretic, because his private heresy had not yet been formally defined. But I have NEVER read ANYWHERE that as a general principle, the Pope can NEVER be a formal heretic. Your beliefs are very novel, brother Beng, and I hope you accept correction regarding them. I’m not sure about brother Abu, but I am pretty certain that even brother SteveB does not subscribe to the notion that infallibility applies to the PRIVATE belief of the Pope. If brother SteveB is reading this, I hope he replies.
Yes. Because it does not do away with what I have said.
Actually, it does. You denied that the infallibility of the Pope is ALWAYS in the context of the infallibility of the Church. Please read the dogma of V1 to yourself again. It DOES NOT SAY that the Pope receives a SPECIAL infallibility. It says that the Pope receives an assistance from the Holy Spirit to be able to possess the infallibility OF THE CHURCH. It is the CHURCH’s infallibility that the Pope is exercising, not a special infallibility that he alone possesses. Do you understand that? And do you understand how it contradicts your claim that “papal infallibility” is not always in the context of the Church’s infallibility?
Agreement with previous definitions by past magisterium, yes. Agreement with the current bishops and faithful, no.
Your opinion is obviously based on the error that there will ever be a time when ONLY the Pope possesses the Truth (we’ll discuss that more later). You have misunderstood that papal infallibility is merely the Pope being permitted to possess the CHURCH’S infallibility, and is not a special infallibility that he alone possesses. And you fail to submit to the official interpretation of the Vatican 1 Decree in the Official Relatio which states that "the agreement of the PRESENT preaching of the WHOLE Magisterium " is the RULE OF FAITH, EVEN FOR DEFINITIONS BY THE POPE. I pray you will have the humility to submit yourself to the authority of Vatican 1.
Or are you saying that the only way to evince the sensus fidei is to poll all Catholics?
Yes.

Interesting point of view. So I guess in your understanding, the bishops (which includes the Pope, of course, since he is ALSO ONLY a bishop) are insufficient to give witness to the faith of their flock.

But then, this would contradict your statement that the Pope does not need anyone to determine the sensus fidei. Maybe its time you reassess your views? It’s obvious there are a lot of contradictions in them. Maybe it will be best if you divest yourself of your extreme views of the papacy, since that seems to be the source of your self-contradicting statements.

CONTINUED
 
CONTINUED
Have you ever wake up one day and just feel like doing something [e.g. going to the swimming pool]? Now, that impulsive thought does not have to be inspire by the Holy Spirit nor cause by previous preponderance (for example, the night before you watch Micheal Phelps). It’s a spontaneous thought. This is what I meant. The pope could just wake up and have a spontaneous thought that he want to pronounce infallible. And if that thought is genuinely part of the deposit of faith, it will be infallible and the whole church is bound to it.
I can’t believe what I’m reading. So anything the Pope spontaneously thinks of, if he decides to pronounce it ex cathedra, will become Truth. Don’t attempt to defend your belief by claiming, “but I said 'if it is genuinely part of the deposit of faith.” You have claimed the Pope does not need the aid of the present Church. You have effectively claimed that his infallibility is separate from Church infallibility. You have admitted that infallibility is not inspiration, revelation, omniscience, or telepathy. You have attempted to claim unsuccessfully that infallibility is some sort of supernatural certitude given to the Pope. There is really no other way for him to know that his spontaneous thought will be consonant with the Faith of the Church except by a supernatural infusion of knowledge. But you have denied even that. Your views are completely self-contradictory and confusing.

Can you please give ANY source for this strange belief you are expressing? Unless you do that, I will assume this is merely your opinion, and is not at all a teaching or belief of the Church.
Of course the Church is not the Pope only. Those who err are still part of the Church (since error does not exclude someone from the church, as heresy, schism and apostasy does). But the holder of truth is the pope.
I don’t know if you are being self-contradictory on purpose. The teaching on the infallibility of the Church states that the Church AS A WHOLE is infallible. You just admitted that the Pope is not the whole Church, but at the same time, you say that only the Pope is infallible. What you are saying does not add up. 1 + 1 does not equal 3. If the Church as a whole is infallible, and the whole Church is not the Pope alone, then it is impossible that only the Pope can ever be the ONLY one that is infallible.
Mardukm said:
I suspect you are confusing the indefectibility of the Church with the infallibility of the Church.
I’m not.

It doesn’t look like it all. But we’ll see as the discussion progresses.
mardukm said:
While you apparently believe in the indefectibility of the Church, you obviously reject (perhaps unintentionally) the Catholic teaching that the Church as a whole at any point in time will always possess and teach the Truth. After all, you just admitted to the possibility that only the head and not the body as a whole will be infallible.
How did I deny that if I assert that in an extreme case we have AT LEAST one Catholic would be holding the truth, ie. the Pope? Thus I hold that at any point in time the church will always possess and teach the truth.

Because you admitted that the Pope is not the whole Church. The “Church” by definition is a body of believers. It is not one person. If we take that self-evident Truth, then it is obvious that the statement “the Church is infallible” CANNOT be fulfilled by the idea that ONLY ONE MAN is infallible.
Yes. Yes. Yes. No, it’s possible to have a situation where the Pope is the sole possessor of truth and if this happens no Church dogmas (especially infallibility and indefectibility) will be compromised.
You have yourself compromised it by claiming that there will ever be a time that ONLY ONE MAN will be infallible, since, as you admit, only one man cannot be “the Church.” As stated earlier, you have repeatedly expressed self-contradictory views. I humbly suggest that the source of the contradiction is are your extreme beliefs about the papacy, so maybe you should just reject those views.
If I am pope any teaching that I will promulgate ex cathedra would be free from error. I’m absolutely sure of this because this is what the doctrine of infallibility teaches. If I have in mind a teaching that is erroneous, which is possible, I won’t be able to promulgate it
Where’s your disagreement on this?
I disagree because you are wrongly applying the certitude that comes with the definition after it is promulgated to what occurs before the definition is made. The charism of infallibility has absolutely nothing to do with certitude. It is simply a charism that prevents error from ever becoming part of the Faith of the Church. After this charism is exercised, then the Church can be certain that the teaching is the Faith of the Church, BUT NOT BEFORE IT. For you to claim that infallibility grants the Pope some kind of supernatural certitude is simply wrong. To repeat, certitude has nothing to do with the charism of infallibilty itself. Rather, certitude is an effect that comes AFTER the charism of infallibility has been exercised.

Further, I would like for you to offer us here any proof from any Magisterial documents that the charism of infallibility is about a supernatural sense of certainty given to the Pope. If you cannot, I humbly urge you to divest yourself of this strange belief.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Beng,
You have no certainty that it is not from Christ.
Yes I have, base on Catholic Encyclopedia.
It’s not possible to argue without it, because the Fathers of V1 explicitly used it to interpret their Decrees.
That would be up to you. On my part I will make it simple by passing all arguments base on it.
So I hope you will correct your attitude towards Apostolic Canon 34 accordingly.
Please refrain from using such language.
I just gave you explicit proof that V1 intended the papal prerogatives to be interpreted within the scope of the Pope AS BISHOP, and you disagree with V1. Yet you claim my view is the one that is UN-Catholic? Very strange.
I don’t understand your insistence that Pope is just a bishop. Even less that it’s not un-Catholic.
That’s where you’re stretching the dogma of the Pope’s exercise of the Church’s infallible Magisterium too far.
I did not stretch it because I never said that the impossibility for a Pope to be a formal heretic is part of the dogma of Pastor Aeternus.
But I have NEVER read ANYWHERE that as a general principle, the Pope can NEVER be a formal heretic. Your beliefs are very novel, brother Beng, and I hope you accept correction regarding them.
Your authoritarian tone is unbecoming.

Why don’t you google “pope heretic material formal?” The sedevacantist sites will appear most (not that I’m a sede).
Actually, it does. You denied that the infallibility of the Pope is ALWAYS in the context of the infallibility of the Church. Please read the dogma of V1 to yourself again. It DOES NOT SAY that the Pope receives a SPECIAL infallibility. It says that the Pope receives an assistance from the Holy Spirit to be able to possess the infallibility OF THE CHURCH. It is the CHURCH’s infallibility that the Pope is exercising, not a special infallibility that he alone possesses. Do you understand that? And do you understand how it contradicts your claim that “papal infallibility” is not always in the context of the Church’s infallibility?
Yes. And it still doesn’t do away with what I’ve said. I did not deny that the infallibility of the Pope is ALWAYS in the context of the infallibility of the Church, I didn’t affirm it either (if I recall correctly). I merely pointed out that the infallibility of the Church has never been defined as clear as papal infallibility or conciliar infallibility.

Thus one can not use this or that dogmatic utterance and said “this explicitly teach about the Church infallibility.” Because there is no single dogmatic utterance about the Church infallibility (like papal infallibility in Pastor Aeternus, like Immaculate Conception in ineffabilis deus and so on). An interpretation of a related document (say Pastor Aeternus) on what the Church teach about Infallibility of the Church would be just that, an interpretation.
Your opinion is obviously based on the error that there will ever be a time when ONLY the Pope possesses the Truth (we’ll discuss that more later). You have misunderstood that papal infallibility is merely the Pope being permitted to possess the CHURCH’S infallibility, and is not a special infallibility that he alone possesses. And you fail to submit to the official interpretation of the Vatican 1 Decree in the Official Relatio which states that "the agreement of the PRESENT preaching of the WHOLE Magisterium " is the RULE OF FAITH, EVEN FOR DEFINITIONS BY THE POPE. I pray you will have the humility to submit yourself to the authority of Vatican 1.
The Pope is part of the Church. If the Pope is the only one who posses the the truth how is it that the Church not posses the truth since the Pope is the rock on which the Church built upon. Your error is, if I may be permitted to use the condescending way which you have used, separating the pope from the Church.
Interesting point of view. So I guess in your understanding, the bishops (which includes the Pope, of course, since he is ALSO ONLY a bishop) are insufficient to give witness to the faith of their flock.
Yes. See Lumen Gentium 12.
But then, this would contradict your statement that the Pope does not need anyone to determine the sensus fidei. Maybe its time you reassess your views? It’s obvious there are a lot of contradictions in them. Maybe it will be best if you divest yourself of your extreme views of the papacy, since that seems to be the source of your self-contradicting statements.
The Pope does not need to determine the sensus fidei to make an infallible statement. But if the Pope wants to know what the sensus fidei is, he has to ask every single catholics.

How is that a contradiction?

And would you mind cutting down the condescending remarks? I don’t think I’m dumber than you and I don’t think that I’m making less money than you [if that’s even relevant].

Is it too much to ask?

Cont. below
 
CONTINUED

I can’t believe what I’m reading. So anything the Pope spontaneously thinks of, if he decides to pronounce it ex cathedra, will become Truth.
Yes. If he finalized it by promulgating it it will be the truth (not that it will become the truth, since “become” means that it was never a truth to begin with).
You have claimed the Pope does not need the aid of the present Church.
Yes. He does not absolutely need it. But it would be better to have the help.
You have effectively claimed that his infallibility is separate from Church infallibility.
No. Because the Pope is member of the Church. It’s you who are separating it by suggesting that the rest of Catholics is the Church while the pope is not a part of it. When the pope is alone he is still part of the Church. He is never detach from the Church (except for heresy, schism and apostasy).
You have attempted to claim unsuccessfully that infallibility is some sort of supernatural certitude given to the Pope.
It’s a supernatural certitude in the sense that you and I are certain that any ex cathedra definition by a pope would be free from error since that is the teaching of papal infallibility. The Pope would have the same kind of certitude (as mine and yours).
There is really no other way for him to know that his spontaneous thought will be consonant with the Faith of the Church except by a supernatural infusion of knowledge. But you have denied even that. Your views are completely self-contradictory and confusing.
When the pope has not promulgate the decree he wouldn’t know whether his spontaneous thought is infallible. But he would know that IF he succeeded in finalizing the ex cathedra process, then that spontaneous thought would be infallible.
Can you please give ANY source for this strange belief you are expressing? Unless you do that, I will assume this is merely your opinion, and is not at all a teaching or belief of the Church.
It’s just a logical conclusion of infallibility being a negative charism.
I don’t know if you are being self-contradictory on purpose. The teaching on the infallibility of the Church states that the Church AS A WHOLE is infallible. You just admitted that the Pope is not the whole Church, but at the same time, you say that only the Pope is infallible. What you are saying does not add up. 1 + 1 does not equal 3. If the Church as a whole is infallible, and the whole Church is not the Pope alone, then it is impossible that only the Pope can ever be the ONLY one that is infallible.
I don’t understand how is that contradictory.

The whole Church is infallible. The whole Church is “pope+bishops+faithful.” Sensus fidei.

Papal infallibility is the infallibility of the Pope as the supreme Shepard of the Church. No other Catholics has it.

The pope is not the whole Church. Yet papal infallibility is not an infallibility of every single Catholics.
Because you admitted that the Pope is not the whole Church. The “Church” by definition is a body of believers. It is not one person. If we take that self-evident Truth, then it is obvious that the statement “the Church is infallible” CANNOT be fulfilled by the idea that ONLY ONE MAN is infallible.
The Pope is a member of the Church. He is incorporated in the mystical body of the Church. I’m sure you won’t deny this. A single person can constitute a Church, theoretically.

And you’re statement is not a self-evident truth at all.
You have yourself compromised it by claiming that there will ever be a time that ONLY ONE MAN will be infallible, since, as you admit, only one man cannot be “the Church.” As stated earlier, you have repeatedly expressed self-contradictory views. I humbly suggest that the source of the contradiction is are your extreme beliefs about the papacy, so maybe you should just reject those views.
I don’t think that I ever said that one person CAN NOT be the Church. But I would say this, for Mat 16:18 to be true, the one person left must at least be a bishop. Because if that one person is a laity the sacrament of order would be perish with him and the Church would disappear.
I disagree because you are wrongly applying the certitude that comes with the definition after it is promulgated to what occurs before the definition is made.
The certainty that happens before is the certainty that IF it get promulgated ex cathedra it would be infallible. That’s all what I’ve been saying.
 
I forgot to answer this part of your post:
40.png
mardukm:
Sorry for being unclear. The Pope’s personal exercise of the Church’s infallibility involves several steps -
  1. his brother bishops alert him of the need to exercise his personal prerogative.
  2. he does his investigation to ascertain the consensus of the Church (sensus fidei)
  3. he makes a decision based on that consensus
  4. he promulgates his decree.
Now at some point before #3, I assume you agree that he must be certain that his teaching will be true. What I am asking is how this certainty will come about. Your response to #7 was obviously a mass of self-contradictions. So if you are basing your answer to #8 on your answer to #7, I sincerely hope you do a bit more thinking on the matter. After you do that, I would appreciate a new response to #8.
Leaving aside that 1-3 is not absolutely necessary for ex cathedra
Of course #1 - #3 are necessary. Haven’t you ever read the entire Decree on Infallibility, or have you only just read the definition itself?

Please read forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=7580338&postcount=224

After you have read that, please take a look at the OFFICIAL interpretation of the Decree on Infallibility at Vatican 1. Brother Johnnykins gave a link to a partial citation of it, and here it is again:matt1618.freeyellow.com/treatise16.html.

Here are some excerpts directly related to steps 1 - 3 that I mentioned above:
“Indeed we do not separate the Pope, defining, from the cooperation and consent of the Church, at least in the sense that we do not exclude this cooperation and this consent of the Church…The special exercise of this prerogative occurs when there arise somewhere in the Church scandals against the faith, i.e., dissensions and heresies which the bishops of the individual churches or even gathered together in provincial council are unable to repress so that they are forced to appeal to the Apostolic See regarding the case, or when the bishops themselves are infected by the sad stain of error. And thereby we do not exclude the cooperation of the Church because the infallibility of the Roman Pontiff does not come to him in the manner of inspiration or of revelation but through a divine assistance. Therefore the Pope, by reason of his office and the gravity of the matter, is held to use the means suitable for properly discerning and aptly enunciating the truth. These means are councils, or the advice of the bishops, cardinals, theologians, etc. Indeed, the means are diverse according to the diversity of situations, and we should piously believe that, in the divine assistance promised to Peter and his successors by Christ, there is simultaneously contained a promise about the means which are necessary and suitable to make an infallible pontifical judgment..”

To repeat what I wrote from an earlier post, this OFFICIAL interpretation of Bishop Gasser was given DURING the Council, not after it. It was provided by the Commission De Fide (which was responsible for formulating the Decree on Infallibility), along with the Decree which they formulated, to the Fathers of the First Vatican Council. When the Fathers of the Council voted for the Decree on Infallibility, they voted for it with this OFFICIAL interpretation in mind. So this official interpretation IS the mind of the Council Fathers at Vatican 1. If you contradict the Official Relatio, you contradict Vatican 1.

You stated in an earlier post that you are faithful to the mind and teaching of Vatican 1. So I hope and pray you will correct your present views accordingly.
the certainty comes from the dogma. That is, any teaching that will be promulgated by a pope ex cathedra would be infallible.
Indeed, the certainty comes FROM the Dogma. But it does not exist BEFORE it has been decided and promulgated by the Pope. In other words, the certainty comes only AFTER the charism of infallibility has been exercised. To repeat, infallibility has nothing to do with granting the Pope (or the Church) some kind of supernatural certitude in order to declare dogma. It is only a negative protection that prevents error from ever being proclaimed as the Faith of the Church. Since the Pope is not granted any sort of supernatural certitude, how is the Pope able to be sure that what he WILL teach (remember, he has not yet decided on the matter) will in fact be faithful to the sensus fidei? The Relatio partially quoted above explicitly states that the Pope has “to properly discern” in order to enunciate the Truth.

So please answer the question: How does the Pope “properly discern?” I gave you three options - (a) look at a crystal ball; (b) determine the consensus of the Church (the sensus fidei); (c) just make a decree and it will automatically be true. Obviously, your choice of (c) is wrong because there is no process of discernment involved. So what is your choice between (a) and (b)? Remember - you already admitted that God does not supernaturally give the Pope the knowledge that he needs.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Beng,
Yes I have, base on Catholic Encyclopedia.
The CE is not a Magisterial source. Did or did not Jesus Christ tell his Apostles that they must be one for the whole world to see? Is not apostolic Tradition the unwritten teachings of Christ? How can you deny that Apostolic Canon 34, which Vatican 1 recognized as a “Rule of Faith” is not from Christ or the Apostles? You admitted earlier that a “Rule of Faith” must either be of divine or apostolic origin. Isn’t that a contradiction in your own claims? It should be noted that the CE does not say that the Apostolic Canons are definitely not from the Apostles. It only states that its apostolic origin is “not certain.” You must also understand that the Apostolic Canons are a COLLECTION of ancient laws. The lack of certainty is in regards to the whole collection as such, but individual canons had greater certainty than others of being apostolic in origin. Apostolic Canon 34 is one of these that have had greater certainty, not only because it so perfectly reflects Christ’s own exhortations to his Apostles, but also because councils in the early fourth century were referring to this specific canon as “ancient.” So you can’t even appeal to the CE to contest my statement that “you have no certainty that it was not from Christ.”
That would be up to you. On my part I will make it simple by passing all arguments base on it.
So you prefer your private judgment over that of Vatican 1? I can see this will be a difficult discussion, and perhaps even fruitless. There is really no common basis to hold a discussion with someone with that outlook. After my response to your current posts, it will probably be best to end the discussion, unless you concede that Apostolic Canon 34 is indeed wholly relevant for this discussion.
Please refrain from using such language.
:confused: Did I inadvertantly curse you?
I don’t understand your insistence that Pope is just a bishop. Even less that it’s not un-Catholic.
Because your opinion that the Papal prerogatives makes him “more than a bishop” does not align with the teaching of V1, which explicitly calls the papal prerogatives “episcopal.” You have implied that you prefer your own private judgment over that of the Fathers of V1. I guess this would be another example of that?
I did not stretch it because I never said that the impossibility for a Pope to be a formal heretic is part of the dogma of Pastor Aeternus.
Thank you. “Stretching” does not have anything do the dogma itself, but with beliefs you think that the dogma supports.
Your authoritarian tone is unbecoming.
What part was authoritarian?
Why don’t you google “pope heretic material formal?” The sedevacantist sites will appear most (not that I’m a sede).
Not interested in stretches of the imagination.😉
Yes. And it still doesn’t do away with what I’ve said. I did not deny that the infallibility of the Pope is ALWAYS in the context of the infallibility of the Church, I didn’t affirm it either (if I recall correctly). I merely pointed out that the infallibility of the Church has never been defined as clear as papal infallibility or conciliar infallibility.
Thus one can not use this or that dogmatic utterance and said “this explicitly teach about the Church infallibility.” Because there is no single dogmatic utterance about the Church infallibility (like papal infallibility in Pastor Aeternus, like Immaculate Conception in ineffabilis deus and so on). An interpretation of a related document (say Pastor Aeternus) on what the Church teach about Infallibility of the Church would be just that, an interpretation.
The direct cause of my appeal to V1’s explicit teaching that papal infallibility is simply the infallibility of the Church was your statement “infallibility has nothing to do with anything that happens prior to the infallible decision.” First of all, the Official Relatio specifically states that the assistance of the Holy Spirit comes not just in the final decision, but also in all the helps that the Pope could possibly need to arrive at that decision. So your original statement was wrong, according to the Fathers of V1.

Secondly, since papal infallibility is simply the infallibility of the Church, and the infallibility of the Church is ever-present in her Ordinary Magisterium, then it is doubly wrong for you to claim that “infallibility has nothing to do with anything that happens prior to the infallible decision.”

Your claim that Church infallibility has never been defined does not mitigate the fact that your statement was in error.
The Pope is part of the Church.
Yes. The Pope is PART of the Church. He is NOT the Church. See the difference?
If the Pope is the only one who posses the the truth how is it that the Church not posses the truth since the Pope is the rock on which the Church built upon. Your error is, if I may be permitted to use the condescending way which you have used, separating the pope from the Church.
You are the one that is attempting to separate the rest of the Church from the infallibility that Christ promised TO HIS CHURCH (which is the teaching of V1). So don’t attempt to claim that I am the one doing any separating here. Btw, if you are in error by virtue of a clear statement/teaching from the Church, how is it condescending to point that out to you?

CONTINUED
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top