B
beng
Guest
I think that is a definition of a “doctrine/teaching” that would confuse the distinction between “doctrine/teaching” and “dogma.”Dear brother Beng,
The ruling of the Jerusalem Council was a disciplinary matter, not a teaching (i.e., doctrine), so of course it could be changed according to circumstances.
In distinction, that there must be consensus between the head bishop and his brother bishops for the unity of the Church to be realized is a teaching - a “principle,” if you will. It is the teaching of Christ to the Apostles that they must be united applied to the successors of the Apostles.
The canons would only have the same force as the non-dogmatic canons of various ecumenical councils. To bound a dogmatic teaching to such canons would be … giving them too much credit.I know that the Latin Church does not consider the Canons as Apostolic in origin. But regardless of its origin, these Canons have obtained the acceptance of the Ecumenical Councils, to which even the Latin Church is bound. This would dictate that you cannot interpret the Vatican Decrees contrary to the principles contained in these Apostolic Canons. If you look at your own Latin Code of Canons, it specifically states that immemorial laws are retained by the current Code. Obviously, once again, no Latin Catholic has the right to (mis)interpret the Vatican Decrees contrary to Apostolic Canon 34.
First of all, why do you separate the Pope from “all bishops”?
First, because the Pope is not just a bishop.Secondly, if the Pope is included in the sensus fidei (which refers to the WHOLE Church), then it stands to reason that he must never contradict the sensus fidei, correct?
Second, well yes. Because it would be a logical impossibility. That is, the Pope at the same time is agreeing and disagreeing on something.
I still don’t understand how a Pope who is not moved, aroused or even inspired is suppose to have his free will affected.You just stated that “the Pope is not moved, aroused, or even inspired to pronounce infallible teaching.” You are stating that infallibility will not permit him to do this. How is that not affecting the Pope’s free will? The difference between our statements is that I asserted that the Pope indeed has the free will to do what you claim he cannot do - namely, to intend to teach error publicly. The charism of Infallibilty does nothing more nor less than PREVENT him from teaching error. We don’t know how this will come about, but we do know that it does not occur by affecting his free will.
And I never said, or meant, that the Pope could never have intention to teach error. He could (but in light of Luk 22:32, he would not be aware that it is an error. AKA the Pope could not be a formal heretic [a material one he could, but not a formal one]).
Two things I need to point out:
- This is something that I think is problematic in the Latin mindset. It borders on legalism.
I was just pointing out that what you have written is going beyond what was clearly define so they can not be said to have the same dogmatic clarity. And yes, I do realize that there are many things that are not clearly define yet they are part of the deposit of faith (thus, infallible).
- The doctrine of the infallibilty of the Church was a given at Vatican 1. It did not really need to be defined as far as the Church was concerned because there was no challenge or question about it.
Well, that surely common sense. Even a president of a country or a hotel would need to determine the mind of their institution.Yes, I stated he does not absolutely need the counsel of his brother bishops. But he still needs to determine the mind of the Church (i.e., its consensus - not its judgment, but its agreement) before he can validly exercise the infallibility of the Church. He does not need to consult his brother bishops in order to make this determination, but he has to make the determination nonetheless.
The Official Relatio asserts that the agreement of the whole Magisterium is the Rule of Faith, EVEN FOR DEFINITIONS BY THE POPE. So the V1 Fathers had this understanding in mind when they passed the Decree on the Infallibility (remember, that “agreement” is not the same as “judgment”).
I googled a bit and as I understand it the agreement is needed for the infallible pronouncement to be effective (if a King makes a law and his subject does not follow it then the law is effectively void), but it still retained validity as an article of faith that every members of the Church must believe.You say that you are faithful to the mind and teaching of Vatican 1. But, you claim that the Pope does not need the agreement of the whole Magisterium when he defines ex cathedra. Isn’t that being contradictory?
Sensus fidei is really impractical. You have to get unanimous consent from every single Catholics.Now, in what way is the sensus fidei evident in the Church?
No. His impulse to make such decision does not need to be affected by the Holy Spirit but by sheer impulsive thought.
- Do you think that when the Pope exercises the Church’s infallible Magisterium, God supernaturally infuses him with all the knowledge he needs for an ex cathedra decree? If not, how can you claim that he can just wake up one day and make an ex cathedra decree without first learning the mind of the Church?