M
mardukm
Guest
CONTINUED
Assuming you adhere to V1 that the Pope needs to determine the sensus fidei before he can validly promulgate an ex cathedra decree, if you claim that determining the sensus fide is a practical impossibility, then no ex cathedra decree can be pronounced outside of powers that the Pope clearly does not possess by virtue of the charism of infallibility (i.e., omniscience, supernatural knowledge, inspiration, or revelation). So the Pope could never in fact pronounce infallibly.
But even if you don’t adhere to V1, you admitted that the Pope cannot contradict the sensus fidei. The most obvious result of this admission is that the Pope needs to determine the sensus fidei before he can make his ex cathedra decree, otherwise there is a danger that his teaching will be opposed to the sensus fidei. You get around this by claiming that the sensus fidei must include the teaching of the Pope, otherwise it cannot be considered the sensus fidei. The obvious conclusion is that no sensus fidei exists prior to a definition of the Pope. But that is a contradiction of the very definition of sensus fidei, which is the collective faith of the past and present Church. And please don’t attempt to claim that you can separate the faith of the past Church from the faith of the present Church in any way.
CONTINUED
How does LG12 support your opinion that the College of Bishops is insufficient to give witness to the Faith of the flock. LG12 specifically states the teaching which constitutes the Faith of the flock is from the bishops. Seems to be more self-contradiction in your views. Further, LG12 dramatically refutes your error that the infallibility of the Church can ever reside only in the the Pope alone. “The WHOLE BODY OF THE FAITHFUL who have an anointing that comes from the Holy One cannot err in matters of belief.”Yes. See Lumen Gentium 12
In opposition to the Offical Relatio, and hence, in opposition to V1.The Pope does not need to determine the sensus fidei to make an infallible statement.
Since LG12 teaches that the teaching which constitutes the sensus fidei comes from the bishops, it stands to reason that he can consult the bishops to determine the sensus fidei. He does not absolutely need to consult the bishops to determine the sensus fidei, but he still has the obligation to determine the sensus fidei before he can define anything, according to the Official Relatio. I do hope that at some point, you submit to the wisdom of the V1 Fathers instead of your own opinions.But if the Pope wants to know what the sensus fidei is, he has to ask every single catholics.
I admit that from your perspective, it is not a contradiction, since you don’t adhere to V1’s teaching from the Official Relatio that the Pope needs to discern the agreement of the Whole Magisterium (the sensus fidei) before he can make an ex cathedra decree. However, if one is faithful to V1, then it is a contradiction:How is that a contradiction?
Assuming you adhere to V1 that the Pope needs to determine the sensus fidei before he can validly promulgate an ex cathedra decree, if you claim that determining the sensus fide is a practical impossibility, then no ex cathedra decree can be pronounced outside of powers that the Pope clearly does not possess by virtue of the charism of infallibility (i.e., omniscience, supernatural knowledge, inspiration, or revelation). So the Pope could never in fact pronounce infallibly.
But even if you don’t adhere to V1, you admitted that the Pope cannot contradict the sensus fidei. The most obvious result of this admission is that the Pope needs to determine the sensus fidei before he can make his ex cathedra decree, otherwise there is a danger that his teaching will be opposed to the sensus fidei. You get around this by claiming that the sensus fidei must include the teaching of the Pope, otherwise it cannot be considered the sensus fidei. The obvious conclusion is that no sensus fidei exists prior to a definition of the Pope. But that is a contradiction of the very definition of sensus fidei, which is the collective faith of the past and present Church. And please don’t attempt to claim that you can separate the faith of the past Church from the faith of the present Church in any way.
I seriously don’t know what remarks I’ve made that are condescending. Perhaps you find certain remarks condescending because it is hard for you to accept correction? If you can point out to me from Magisterial documents where I have error, please feel free to call me out on it. I welcome correction.And would you mind cutting down the condescending remarks? I don’t think I’m dumber than you and I don’t think that I’m making less money than you [if that’s even relevant].
Well, according to V1 (both in the Decree and in the Official Relatio), the Pope can only exercises the charism of infallibility in response to the needs of Church (when some heresy or question of faith arises). I don’t know where your opinion that he can just wake up one morning and decide to make an ex cathedra decree fits into the teaching of V1. This is just your opinion, right? You are not actually claiming that V1 teaches what you are proposing?Yes. If he finalized it by promulgating it it will be the truth (not that it will become the truth, since “become” means that it was never a truth to begin with).
According to the Official Relatio, the Pope needs help, and will get the aid suitable as the means to help him make his decision. Can you give me any other source of aid for the Pope other than the Church?Yes. He does not absolutely need it. But it would be better to have the help.
CONTINUED