The Vatican Dogma

  • Thread starter Thread starter militantsparrow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
CONTINUED
Yes. See Lumen Gentium 12
How does LG12 support your opinion that the College of Bishops is insufficient to give witness to the Faith of the flock. LG12 specifically states the teaching which constitutes the Faith of the flock is from the bishops. Seems to be more self-contradiction in your views. Further, LG12 dramatically refutes your error that the infallibility of the Church can ever reside only in the the Pope alone. “The WHOLE BODY OF THE FAITHFUL who have an anointing that comes from the Holy One cannot err in matters of belief.”
The Pope does not need to determine the sensus fidei to make an infallible statement.
In opposition to the Offical Relatio, and hence, in opposition to V1.
But if the Pope wants to know what the sensus fidei is, he has to ask every single catholics.
Since LG12 teaches that the teaching which constitutes the sensus fidei comes from the bishops, it stands to reason that he can consult the bishops to determine the sensus fidei. He does not absolutely need to consult the bishops to determine the sensus fidei, but he still has the obligation to determine the sensus fidei before he can define anything, according to the Official Relatio. I do hope that at some point, you submit to the wisdom of the V1 Fathers instead of your own opinions.
How is that a contradiction?
I admit that from your perspective, it is not a contradiction, since you don’t adhere to V1’s teaching from the Official Relatio that the Pope needs to discern the agreement of the Whole Magisterium (the sensus fidei) before he can make an ex cathedra decree. However, if one is faithful to V1, then it is a contradiction:
Assuming you adhere to V1 that the Pope needs to determine the sensus fidei before he can validly promulgate an ex cathedra decree, if you claim that determining the sensus fide is a practical impossibility, then no ex cathedra decree can be pronounced outside of powers that the Pope clearly does not possess by virtue of the charism of infallibility (i.e., omniscience, supernatural knowledge, inspiration, or revelation). So the Pope could never in fact pronounce infallibly.

But even if you don’t adhere to V1, you admitted that the Pope cannot contradict the sensus fidei. The most obvious result of this admission is that the Pope needs to determine the sensus fidei before he can make his ex cathedra decree, otherwise there is a danger that his teaching will be opposed to the sensus fidei. You get around this by claiming that the sensus fidei must include the teaching of the Pope, otherwise it cannot be considered the sensus fidei. The obvious conclusion is that no sensus fidei exists prior to a definition of the Pope. But that is a contradiction of the very definition of sensus fidei, which is the collective faith of the past and present Church. And please don’t attempt to claim that you can separate the faith of the past Church from the faith of the present Church in any way.
And would you mind cutting down the condescending remarks? I don’t think I’m dumber than you and I don’t think that I’m making less money than you [if that’s even relevant].
I seriously don’t know what remarks I’ve made that are condescending. Perhaps you find certain remarks condescending because it is hard for you to accept correction? If you can point out to me from Magisterial documents where I have error, please feel free to call me out on it. I welcome correction.
Yes. If he finalized it by promulgating it it will be the truth (not that it will become the truth, since “become” means that it was never a truth to begin with).
Well, according to V1 (both in the Decree and in the Official Relatio), the Pope can only exercises the charism of infallibility in response to the needs of Church (when some heresy or question of faith arises). I don’t know where your opinion that he can just wake up one morning and decide to make an ex cathedra decree fits into the teaching of V1. This is just your opinion, right? You are not actually claiming that V1 teaches what you are proposing?
Yes. He does not absolutely need it. But it would be better to have the help.
According to the Official Relatio, the Pope needs help, and will get the aid suitable as the means to help him make his decision. Can you give me any other source of aid for the Pope other than the Church?

CONTINUED
 
CONTINUED
Mardukm said:
You have effectively claimed that his infallibility is separate from Church infallibility.
No. Because the Pope is member of the Church. It’s you who are separating it by suggesting that the rest of Catholics is the Church while the pope is not a part of it. When the pope is alone he is still part of the Church. He is never detach from the Church (except for heresy, schism and apostasy).

My understanding is based on the explicit teaching of V1, which states that papal infallibility is the assistance of the Holy Spirit that enables him to possess the infallibility of the CHURCH. LG12 teaches us that it is the ENTIRE BODY of the Church that is infallible (the head with the other members). Your position posits the possibility that ONLY the Pope is infallible, which destroys the whole teaching on the infallibility of the Church, for it is no longer the head with the other members, but only the head. Again, don’t attempt to claim that I am the one separating the head from the rest of the body. You are the one separating the rest of the body from the head.
It’s a supernatural certitude in the sense that you and I are certain that any ex cathedra definition by a pope would be free from error since that is the teaching of papal infallibility. The Pope would have the same kind of certitude (as mine and yours).
You’re still trying to attach certitude to infallibility itself (i.e., "that is the teaching of papal infallibility). Please. I already asked you to give us a direct quote from a Magisterial source that states that the gift of infallibility has anything to do with certitude. Aren’t you able to do that?
When the pope has not promulgate the decree he wouldn’t know whether his spontaneous thought is infallible. But he would know that IF he succeeded in finalizing the ex cathedra process, then that spontaneous thought would be infallible.
First of all, asserting a principle of certitude on a possibility (“IF”) is simply laughable.
Secondly, the whole problem here, as already stated, is that your whole premise is wrong - that the Pope can spontaneously exercise infallibility. As the Fathers of V1 specifically taught, it is only ever utilized in response to the needs of the Church. Can you admit that your premise was wrong?
It’s just a logical conclusion of infallibility being a negative charism.
So you are admitting there are no magisterial sources for your opinion?
I don’t understand how is that contradictory.
The whole Church is infallible. The whole Church is “pope+bishops+faithful.” Sensus fidei.
Papal infallibility is the infallibility of the Pope as the supreme Shepard of the Church. No other Catholics has it.
The pope is not the whole Church. Yet papal infallibility is not an infallibility of every single Catholics.
No one else has the special assistance of the Holy Spirit to exercise the infallibility of the Church in a personal way, but the infallibility of the Church is - by definition - a COLLECTIVE infallibility, which you have just admitted (Pope+bishops+faithful). You are saying that there will be a time that collective infallibility (i.e., the infallibility of the Church) no longer exists. You really can’t see any contradiction from the teaching of the Church in your position?
The Pope is a member of the Church. He is incorporated in the mystical body of the Church. I’m sure you won’t deny this.
Another contradiction. You just admitted that the Church is a body. Is a body composed of a head together with other members, or just a head? If the Church is truly a body composed of a head together with other members - as you just admitted -then the statement “infallibility of the Church” can only mean the “infallibility of the head together with other members.”
A single person can constitute a Church, theoretically.
Can a mere theory stand up to the Truths of the Church? This idea of possibilities being a basis for interpretation is highly problematic. It is the same method non-Catholic polemicists use to try to discredit the papacy - they claim, “well, this or that or this or that COULD happen, so it must be false.” The only difference here is that your claim is “this or that or this or that COULD happen, so it must be true.” Hardly a solid basis for acceptance, brother Beng.
And you’re statement is not a self-evident truth at all.
Another contradiction. You just admitted that the Church is a body, which is exactly what I stated. And now you claim this is not a self-evident truth? If it is truly not a self-evident truth, why do you try use it as a basis for your arguments?

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Steve,

judging from your responses, what you actually mean is that God gives infallibility to the Pope ALONE, and the Pope in turn grants it to the rest of the Church.
Infallibility belongs to the pope in a special way. The pope has an infallibility that no other single bishop has. That is ALSO in the docs I’ve quoted. The pope recognizes truth and confirms it. He doesn’t grant it, as if he was the author or the inventor of it.
M:
That actually contradicts the very definition of V1, since V1 asserted that the Pope is merely permitted to possess the infallibility of the Church, not the other way around.
What you’ve written contradicts the constitutions of Vat I and Vat II & canon law.

his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter." [LG 25]
M:
if you intend this to mean that he can exercise his authority to impede the authority of local bishops, you are in error.
It happens rarely and reluctantly, but a pope can depose a bishop .
M:
if you intend the term “free” to mean “any time, any where, by his mere will” you are in error. The term “free” does not mean “unrestricted.” It primarily means “uncoerced.” It refers to the fact that when the Pope exercises his prerogatives, he does it volitionally, and is not forced to do so - he is not forced to exercise it, and neither is he forced not to exercise it. It’s obvious that “free” does not mean “unrestricted” because the V1 Decree itself states that the Pope is not free to impede the authority of local bishops. Canonically, neither is the Pope free to damage the acquired rights of individuals. Morally, neither is the Pope free to oppose the Faith of the Church. ETC., ETC., ETC.
The quote you refer to is

“the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And is always free to exercise this power” [LG ch 3 #22]

What do you think this means?
M:
if you intend this to mean that the authority of the College is merely papal authority exercise in a college, instead of actual collegial authority (i.e., the authority of ALL the members COMBINED), then you are in error.
What did the quote say?

But the college or body of bishops has no authority unless it is understood together with the Roman Pontiff, the successor of Peter as its head. The pope’s power of primacy over all, both pastors and faithful, remains whole and intact. In virtue of his office, that is as Vicar of Christ and pastor of the whole Church, the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And he is always free to exercise this power. The order of bishops, which succeeds to the college of apostles and gives this apostolic body continued existence, is also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.(27*) This power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff.For our Lord placed Simon alone as the rock and the bearer of the keys of the Church,(156) and made him shepherd of the whole flock;(157)
[LG ch 3 #22]

Seems straight forward. Where’s the problem?
M:
It is his administrative prerogative to dissolve a Council, but he never does it without the solicitation of his brother bishops.
Did you miss the word “alone” in the canon?

Can. 338
§1 It is the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff alone to summon an Ecumenical Council, to preside over it personally or through others, to transfer, suspend or dissolve the Council, and to approve its decrees.
§2 It is also the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff to determine the matters to be dealt with in the Council, and to establish the order to be observed. The Fathers of the Council may add other matters to those proposed by the Roman Pontiff, but these must be approved by the Roman Pontiff.
M:
And without the agreement of his brother bishops, his decrees ALONE don’t oblige either (Canon 341).
Let’s test that out.

Can. 341
§1 The decrees of an Ecumenical Council do not oblige unless they are approved by the Roman Pontiff as well as by the Fathers of the Council, confirmed by the Roman Pontiff and promulgated by his direction.
§2 *If they are to have binding force, the same confirmation and promulgation is required for decrees *

Re: Vat I, was the council closed? As you pointed out, No. Did all the bishops agree with papal infallibility? No. Was the dogma of papal infallibility confirmed by the pope even though there was much opposition by his fellow bishops? Yes.
 
Dear brother Steve,

I’m not sure of your point. Please explain.
my question was

“are you talking about a split council of opposing bishops”

maybe I could have said that better. A council where bishops were not in agreement with each other.

As in Vat I.
 
Dear brother SteveB,

I see you are still doing your dance and jig, never directly answering my points. I suspect it’s because you know that a direct answer would simply expose the error of your views. In any case, I’ll play along with your game for now.😉
Infallibility belongs to the pope in a special way. The pope has an infallibility that no other single bishop has. That is ALSO in the docs I’ve quoted. The pope recognizes truth and confirms it. He doesn’t grant it, as if he was the author or the inventor of it.
So you are claiming that because of this, infallibility belongs to the Pope ALONE?
What you’ve written contradicts the constitutions of Vat I and Vat II & canon law.

his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly held irreformable, for they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, an assistance promised to him in blessed Peter." [LG 25]
How? The statement simply states that his definition is irreformible not from the consent of the Church. How does that contradict my statement that the Pope is simply exercising the infallibility of the Church? Please explain without a dance and jig.
It happens rarely and reluctantly, but a pope can depose a bishop.
Not “freely.” The Pope is restricted by rules, correct?
The quote you refer to is

“the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And is always free to exercise this power” [LG ch 3 #22]

What do you think this means?
I just gave you what I think it means. Are you purposely being obtuse? Seriously.
What did the quote say?

But the college or body of bishops has no authority unless it is understood together with the Roman Pontiff, the successor of Peter as its head. The pope’s power of primacy over all, both pastors and faithful, remains whole and intact. In virtue of his office, that is as Vicar of Christ and pastor of the whole Church, the Roman Pontiff has full, supreme and universal power over the Church. And he is always free to exercise this power. The order of bishops, which succeeds to the college of apostles and gives this apostolic body continued existence, is also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.(27*) This power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff.For our Lord placed Simon alone as the rock and the bearer of the keys of the Church,(156) and made him shepherd of the whole flock;(157)

Seems straight forward. Where’s the problem?
The problem is your misinterpretation. The quote explicitly states, without benefit of your misinterpretation, that the College exercises authority TOGETHER WITH the Roman Pontiff. It does not say that the Pope exercises personal authority THROUGH the College, which is your opinion. It also says that the College of Bishops TOGETHER WITH the head bishop is the subject of supreme authority in the Church.
Did you miss the word “alone” in the canon?

Can. 338
It is the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff alone to summon an Ecumenical Council, to preside over it personally or through others, to transfer, suspend or dissolve the Council, and to approve its decrees.
Sure, these are his prerogatives, but it doesn’t say anything about how they are to be exercised. Regardless, it is obvious that these are his prerogatives WITHIN the Council as a member of it, not as an entity outside of or above the Council. You’ll have to do better than this to prove your claims.
It is also the prerogative of the Roman Pontiff to determine the matters to be dealt with in the Council, and to establish the order to be observed. The Fathers of the Council may add other matters to those proposed by the Roman Pontiff, but these must be approved by the Roman Pontiff.
This is even MORE explicit that these are his prerogatives WITHIN the Council as a member of it, not as an entity outside of or above the Council.
Let’s test that out.

Can. 341
§1 The decrees of an Ecumenical Council do not oblige unless they are approved by the Roman Pontiff as well as by the Fathers of the Council, confirmed by the Roman Pontiff and promulgated by his direction
§2 If they are to have binding force, the same confirmation and promulgation is required for decrees
You challenge my statement that within an E Council, the Pope’s decrees ALONE do not oblige, but requires the agreement of his brother bishops by quoting the canon that asserts that the approval of his brother bishops is just as necessary as his own actions? I wish I could use the ROTFL smiley!!!
Re: Vat I, was the council closed? As you pointed out, No.
So what?
Did all the bishops agree with papal infallibility? No. Was the dogma of papal infallibility confirmed by the pope even though there was much opposition by his fellow bishops? Yes.
Was the Pope the ONLY one who approved the Decrees of the Council? No. Did the Pope want the Council to affirm the secular power of the Pope? Yes. Did the Pope want the Council to affirm that he was Tradition by himself? Yes. Did the Council Fathers do this? No.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
my question was

“are you talking about a split council of opposing bishops”

maybe I could have said that better. A council where bishops were not in agreement with each other.

As in Vat I.
It doesn’t matter. One group is obviously wrong, and the other group is right. Whichever group is right, it will be evident by a collegial action of BOTH Pope AND his brother bishops who have judged rightly TOGETHER.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother SteveB,

So you are claiming that because of this, infallibility belongs to the Pope ALONE?
He has a special infallibility granted in Peter, not so for individual bishops…

“Although the individual bishops do not enjoy the prerogative of infallibility, they can nevertheless proclaim Christ’s doctrine infallibly. This is so, even when they are dispersed around the world, provided that while maintaining the bond of unity among themselves and with Peter’s successor, and while teaching authentically on a matter of faith or morals, they concur in a single viewpoint as the one which must be held conclusively. This authority is even more clearly verified when, gathered together in an ecumenical council, they are teachers and judges of faith and morals for the universal Church. Their definitions must then be adhered to with the submission of faith” (Lumen Gentium 25).

What does the red highlighted mean to you? Do they (the bishops) conclusively have to concur in a single viewpoint 100% of the time? 75% of the time, 51% of the time, less that that to be conclusive? What about for infallibility?
M:
How? The statement simply states that his definition is irreformible not from the consent of the Church. How does that contradict my statement that the Pope is simply exercising the infallibility of the Church? Please explain without a dance and jig.
What percentage of bishops disagreed with papal infallibility at Vat I? What percentage agreed? Who was infallible? Can’t be both.
M:
Not “freely.” The Pope is restricted by rules, correct?
The constitution is a document of rules. Canon law is a document of rules. It shows rules and how they are to apply to everyone
M:
The problem is your misinterpretation. The quote explicitly states, without benefit of your misinterpretation, that the College exercises authority TOGETHER WITH the Roman Pontiff. It does not say that the Pope exercises personal authority THROUGH the College, which is your opinion.
WHERE did I say what is underlined?
M:
It also says that the College of Bishops TOGETHER WITH the head bishop is the subject of supreme authority in the Church.
provided we understand it’s *never without this head.(27) This power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff. **[LG ch 3 #22]
M:
Sure, these are his prerogatives, but it doesn’t say anything about how they are to be exercised.
all you have to know is they are his prerogatives ALONE.
M:
Regardless, it is obvious that these are his prerogatives WITHIN the Council as a member of it, not as an entity outside of or above the Council. You’ll have to do better than this to prove your claims.
They are his prerogatives alone. That’s what alone means. Alone means alone. His, by himself.
M:
This is even MORE explicit that these are his prerogatives WITHIN the Council as a member of it, not as an entity outside of or above the Council.
He is above the council.
M:
You challenge my statement that within an E Council, the Pope’s decrees ALONE do not oblige, but requires the agreement of his brother bishops by quoting the canon that asserts that the approval of his brother bishops is just as necessary as his own actions? I wish I could use the ROTFL smiley!!!
I was clear on what I wrote. I don’t need you to rewrite or mischaracterize what I wrote. In Vat I the bishops were Not of one accord. They were deeply divided. Both sides couldn’t be right.

You said
Originally Posted by M
And without the agreement of his brother bishops, his decrees ALONE don’t oblige either (Canon 341).

My response to you

Let’s test that out.

Can. 341
§1 The decrees of an Ecumenical Council do not oblige unless they are approved by the Roman Pontiff as well as by the Fathers of the Council, *confirmed by the Roman Pontiff and promulgated by his direction.
§2 If they are to have binding force
, the same confirmation and promulgation is required for decrees *

Re: Vat I, was the council closed? As you pointed out, No. Did all the bishops agree with papal infallibility? No. Was the dogma of papal infallibility confirmed by the pope even though there was much opposition by his fellow bishops? Yes.
M:
Was the Pope the ONLY one who approved the Decrees of the Council? No. Did the Pope want the Council to affirm the secular power of the Pope? Yes. Did the Pope want the Council to affirm that he was Tradition by himself? Yes. Did the Council Fathers do this? No.
Why would the pope agree to secular power, or that he was tradition by himself ?

Try to Calm down, take few deep breaths. Don’t take this so personal. We’re just having a conversation.
 
…the pope is the one person who fills that “universal” requirement. Therefore he is the only one seperating universal authority from local authority…
…DISagree.
In an Ecumenical Council, the Pope does not fill the “universal” requirement alone. It is universal because of a united action of all the bishops…
The primary center of Christianity was moved to Constantinople and there, over time, it became more civilized and sane. Eventually it there grew up to the point where it no longer needed a pope. Just like modern day Judaism is more civilized and sane since it no longer practices animal sacrifice and stones woman to death for adultery, so too the Christian East de facto has become Universal because the Divine and the human have become one in a communion of Churches. By walling off the communion of Rome by economia, endless debates, like this one, that never lead to unity are ended. - I’m not saying join the EO, I’m saying learn to grow up as the East has set an example. I’ve heard that even Jews would be willing to accept Christ if only they didn’t have to! The wall could be taken down and the East could communion with Rome again likewise, if only it wasn’t said by so many (weather officially or otherwise) that it has to be done or else you are “anathema”!

The Pope is not the Head of an Ecumenical Council, only a substitute Head. The real Head is Christ. And when that which is the actual arrives, that which is the shadow fades away. Only Christ is infallible, and the closer we get to Him the less fallible we shall be.
 
Steve b
post #300…304 – more excellent posts.

The doctrine of Papal infallibility is found in Scripture (Mt 16:17-19; Jn 21: 15-17; Mt 28:19-20; 1 Tim 3:15), and for the final proposed dogma of Vatican I there were 471 bishops for and 130 against; more than two-thirds bishops for. Sixty-six bishops then returned to their dioceses before the Public Session, but all eventually declared full acceptance of the defined doctrine. [Dr Leslie Rumble, *Questions People Ask, Chevalier, 1975, p 159].

The denigration of the dogma of papal primacy and infallibility is a monstrous fantasy, and Vatican II repeats this teaching in the *Dogmatic Constitution on the Church *(Lumen Gentium) (#18):
“This sacred synod following in the steps of the First Vatican Council… This teaching concerning the institution, the permanence, the nature and import of the sacred primacy of the Roman Pontiff and his infallible teaching office, the sacred synod proposes anew to be firmly believed by all the faithful….”
 
mardukm, Post #222: So according to you, it is an error to believe that the Pope can only teach according to the sensus fidei of the Church.
post #291: If the Pope’s teaching departs from the sensus fidei (the consensus of the Church), then he has NO AUTHORITY to teach that doctrine ex cathedra.
post #293: After this charism is exercised, then the Church can be certain that the teaching is the Faith of the Church, BUT NOT BEFORE IT…. certitude is an effect that comes AFTER the charism of infallibility has been exercised.
post #298: LG12….“The WHOLE BODY OF THE FAITHFUL who have an anointing that comes from the Holy One cannot err in matters of belief."
Post #299: LG12 teaches us that it is the ENTIRE BODY of the Church that is infallible (the head with the other members).
mardukm has fallen into the trap, as I have seen often on this, by misrepresenting Vatican II’s *Lumen Gentium *#12 by failing to realise that “the whole body of the faithful….cannot err in matters of belief” ONLY WHEN as “the People of God guided by the sacred teaching authority (Magisterium) and OBEYING it, receives not the mere word of men but truly the word of God (CF. 1Th. 2:13)",….

Yet it follows from his understanding in post #293 that the “certitude” comes after infallibility has been exercised in dogma and doctrine by the Holy Father or by an Ecumenical Council confirmed by the Holy Father, to which the faithful assent. Those who don’t, as those who dissent from the definition against contraception in Humanae Vitae, are no longer part of the whole body of the faithful.

This is precisely what the good Fr. John A Hardon, S.J., made clear:
“Not only are some equating the possession of the truth with the right to decide what is truth, but they are obscuring the role of the papacy in the exercise of the Church’s teaching authority.” (Fr John A Hardon, S.J., The Teaching Church In Our Time,1978, Daughters of St Paul, p 114].

Or as Msgr George A Kelly explains: “The *sensus fidei *of the Catholic Church calls for Catholics to be trained “to think with the mind of the Church…” (Battle for the American Church (Revisited), Ignatius, 1995, p 33).

Msgr Eugene Kevane reinforces this truth in his work Creed and Catechetics, Christian Classics, 1978, p 83, in quoting from theologian Candido Pozo, S.J.: “The acceptance of this profession of faith by the People of God,” concludes Pozo, “confers on it [the People of God] a consequent infallibility.” And he points out that a doctrinal definition ex cathedra possesses “antecedent infallibility,” rooted in the very act of its definition, prior to any acceptance. “This infallibility of which we speak now is consequent upon the acceptance.”
 
…to which the faithful assent. Those who don’t, as those who dissent from the definition against contraception in Humanae Vitae, are no longer part of the whole body of the faithful. …

\quote]

I believe you mean to say they are at least material, if not formal, heretics. The faithful are those baptised, even though in a state of apostacy or heresy or schism.

871 “The Christian faithful are those who, inasmuch as they have been incorporated in Christ through Baptism, have been constituted as the people of God; for this reason, since they have become sharers in Christ’s priestly, prophetic, and royal office in their own manner, they are called to exercise the mission which God has entrusted to the Church to fulfill in the world, in accord with the condition proper to each one.”

vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p123a9p4.htm
  1. It remains clear, in any event, that the sacramental bond of belonging to the Body of Christ that is the Church, conferred by the baptismal character, is an ontological and permanent bond which is not lost by reason of any act or fact of defection. – ACTUS FORMALIS DEFECTIONIS AB ECCLESIA CATHOLICA (2006)
vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/intrptxt/documents/rc_pc_intrptxt_doc_20060313_actus-formalis_en.html
 
40.png
Abu:
…to which the faithful assent. Those who don’t, as those who dissent from the definition against contraception in Humanae Vitae, are no longer part of the whole body of the faithful. …
I think what Abu means is that they are no longer considered a part of the “Faithful” as understood when we speak of the sensus fidelium. They are still members of the Mystical Body of Christ by their baptism of course.

If this is his sense, I would agree. The Faithful are those who adhere to the teachings of the Church. It is their “sense of the Faith” that will discover unorthodoxy from true Church teachings. This is yet another way that Church infallibility is protected by the Holy Spirit. The Faithful is made up of the Pope, bishops, priests, religious and laity, it is not just the laity.

That is why Mardukm keeps hammering home the importance of the Pope being united with the Faithful, by consulting with them on Church teachings. Consulting used in the sense that John Henry Newman meant it. Meaning the way someone consults a thermometer to learn the temperature. Not in the sense that the Pope needs their “OK.”
 
To repeat what I wrote from an earlier post, this OFFICIAL interpretation of Bishop Gasser was given DURING the Council, not after it. It was provided by the Commission De Fide (which was responsible for formulating the Decree on Infallibility), along with the Decree which they formulated, to the Fathers of the First Vatican Council. When the Fathers of the Council voted for the Decree on Infallibility, they voted for it with this OFFICIAL interpretation in mind. So this official interpretation IS the mind of the Council Fathers at Vatican 1. If you contradict the Official Relatio, you contradict Vatican 1.
Blessings,
Marduk
A small note: the presentation by Bishop Gasser - Relatio - explaining the meaning of the VI formula was given not just “DURING” the Council, but IMMEDIATELY BEFORE the Council vote. In essence Bishop Gasser was telling the Council Fathers when you vote on this, this is what it means.

BTW I always enjoy you informative, irenic and erudite posts.
 
I think what Abu means is that they are no longer considered a part of the “Faithful” as understood when we speak of the sensus fidelium. They are still members of the Mystical Body of Christ by their baptism of course.

If this is his sense, I would agree. The Faithful are those who adhere to the teachings of the Church. It is their “sense of the Faith” that will discover unorthodoxy from true Church teachings. This is yet another way that Church infallibility is protected by the Holy Spirit. The Faithful is made up of the Pope, bishops, priests, religious and laity, it is not just the laity.

That is why Mardukm keeps hammering home the importance of the Pope being united with the Faithful, by consulting with them on Church teachings. Consulting used in the sense that John Henry Newman meant it. Meaning the way someone consults a thermometer to learn the temperature. Not in the sense that the Pope needs their “OK.”
Sensus fidelium is an interesting topic.

CCC 67 “… Guided by the Magisterium of the Church, the sensus fidelium knows how to discern and welcome in these revelations whatever constitutes an authentic call of Christ or his saints to the Church.”

CCC 92 “The whole body of the faithful. . . cannot err in matters of belief. This characteristic is shown in the supernatural appreciation of faith (sensus fidei) on the part of the whole people, when, from the bishops to the last of the faithful, they manifest a universal consent in matters of faith and morals.”

vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p1s1c2a1.htm
  1. In every Christian who is seeking to be faithful to Christ and is fully incorporated into the life of the Church, there is a sensus fidei. This sensus fidei may be described as an active capacity for spiritual discernment, an intuition that is formed by worshipping and living in communion as a faithful member of the Church. When this capacity is exercised in concert by the body of the faithful we may speak of the exercise of the sensus fidelium (cf. Authority in the Church: Elucidation, 3-4). The exercise of the sensus fidei by each member of the Church contributes to the formation of the sensus fidelium through which the Church as a whole remains faithful to Christ. By the sensus fidelium, the whole body contributes to, receives from and treasures the ministry of those within the community who exercise episcope, watching over the living memory of the Church (cf*. Authority in the Church I*, 5-6). In diverse ways the “Amen” of the individual believer is thus incorporated within the “Amen” of the whole Church.
vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/documents/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_12051999_gift-of-autority_en.html
The Ravenna document in 2007 expressed the sensus fidelium as the conscience of the Church of those incorporated by virtue of Christian initiation:
7. The whole community and each person in it bears the “conscience of the Church” (ekklesiastike syneidesis), as Greek theology calls it, the sensus fidelium in Latin terminology. By virtue of Baptism and Confirmation (Chrismation) each member of the Church exercises a form of authority in the Body of Christ. In this sense, all the faithful (and not just the bishops) are responsible for the faith professed at their Baptism. It is our common teaching that the people of God, having received “the anointing which comes from the Holy One” (1 Jn 2, 20 and 27), in communion with their pastors, cannot err in matters of faith (cfr. Jn 16, 13).

vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/ch_orthodox_docs/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_20071013_documento-ravenna_en.html

Can we discount the effects of actual grace of the Holy Spirit given through Christian initiation that allows us to live the faith and say that only those that remain in a state of sanctifying grace have the gift of discenment of the Holy Spirit, i.e., do weak or severed members of the Church have discrimination? It appears that they do have faith and hope of baptism, per Fr. John Hardon wrote: “To become an actual member one must be baptized and thereby receive (ordinarily) sanctifying grace, the principle of deiform life. An actual member in sanctifying grace will thus be a living member. But there can be in the Mystical Body “dead” members: Catholics who by mortal sin lose sanctifying grace and the Indwelling Spirit. They still retain ordinarily the virtues of faith and hope; the baptismal character still marks them as persons configured to Christ and dedicated to His service. And this remnant of divine life and of union, though it leaves sinners weak members of Christ, enables them to remain in the Mystical Body. Schism, heresy, apostasy, excommunication, however, sever a man from the Body of the Church.”
therealpresence.org/archives/Grace/Grace_004.htm
 
The primary center of Christianity was moved to Constantinople and there, over time, it became more civilized and sane. Eventually it there grew up to the point where it no longer needed a pope. Just like modern day Judaism is more civilized and sane since it no longer practices animal sacrifice and stones woman to death for adultery, so too the Christian East de facto has become Universal because the Divine and the human have become one in a communion of Churches
Just to make a few comments on what you’ve said
  • Constantinople in terms of ranking, put itself 1st in the East ahead of Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem in that order. It was never ahead of Rome. Rome has always been 1st in ranking. And in case it’s necessary to say, Constantinople doesn’t exist anymore. It’s Istanbul, and muslim.
  • The papacy has always been there in the person of Peter. His position is established by Christ. Who is ANYONE to say his office is no longer needed?
  • The Christian East in union with the pope is one. The Christian East that is EO is NOT in union with the pope, NOT one Church, and It’s NOT universal.
JV:
By walling off the communion of Rome by economia, endless debates, like this one, that never lead to unity are ended. - I’m not saying join the EO, I’m saying learn to grow up as the East has set an example.

I’ve heard that even Jews would be willing to accept Christ if only they didn’t have to! The wall could be taken down and the East could communion with Rome again likewise, if only it wasn’t said by so many (weather officially or otherwise) that it has to be done or else you are “anathema”!
Your signature is very vague. What religion are you
JV:
The Pope is not the Head of an Ecumenical Council, only a substitute Head. The real Head is Christ.
Of course it’s Christ. And Jesus said directly to Peter, in front of all the apostles, feed and rule my Church. He said that right after His resurrection and before His ascention back to heaven. Therefore, we know Jesus is in control when we obey Jesus and what He established.

To do otherwisw is to NOT accept Jesus as head.
JV:
And when that which is the actual arrives, that which is the shadow fades away. Only Christ is infallible, and the closer we get to Him the less fallible we shall be.
You get closer and closer to Him by doing what He says.
 
Donum Veritatis (Instruction on the Ecclesial Vocation of the Theologian), CDF 1990, is also very helpful and authoritative on the truth of doctrine and the relationship to the sensus fidei.

“35. Dissent sometimes also appeals to a kind of sociological argumentation which holds that the opinion of a large number of Christians would be a direct and adequate expression of the ‘supernatural sense of the faith’.

“Actually, the opinions of the faithful cannot be purely and simply identified with the ‘sensus fidei’.(31) The sense of the faith is a property of theological faith; and, as God’s gift which enables one to adhere personally to the Truth, it cannot err. This personal faith is also the faith of the Church since God has given guardianship of the Word to the Church. Consequently, what the believer believes is what the Church believes. The ‘sensus fidei’ implies then by its nature a profound agreement of spirit and heart with the Church, ‘sentire cum Ecclesia’.

“Although theological faith as such then cannot err, the believer can still have erroneous opinions since all his thoughts do not spring from faith.(32) Not all the ideas which circulate among the People of God are compatible with the faith. This is all the more so given that people can be swayed by a public opinion influenced by modern communications media. Not without reason did the Second Vatican Council emphasize the indissoluble bond between the ‘sensus fidei’ and the guidance of God’s People by the Magisterium of the Pastors. These two realities cannot be separated.(33) Magisterial interventions serve to guarantee the Church’s unity in the truth of the Lord. They aid her to ‘abide in the truth’ in face of the arbitrary character of changeable opinions and are an expression of obedience to the Word of God.(34) Even when it might seem that they limit the freedom of theologians, these actions, by their fidelity to the faith which has been handed on, establish a deeper freedom which can only come from unity in truth.
“36. The freedom of the act of faith cannot justify a right to dissent. In fact this freedom does not indicate at all freedom with regard to the truth but signifies the free self-determination of the person in conformity with his moral obligation to accept the truth.”

(31) Cf. John Paul. II, Apost. Exhort. Familiaris consortio, n. 5: AAS 74 (1982) 85-86.
(32) Cf, the formula of the Council of Trent, sess. VI, cap. 9: fides “cui non potest subesse falsum”: DS 1534; cf. St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, II-II, q. 1, a. 3, ad 3: “Possibile est enim hominem fidelem ex coniectura humana falsum aliquid aestimare. Sed quod ex fide falsum aestimet, hoc est impossibile”.
(33) Cf. Dogmatic Constitution Lumen gentium, n. 12.
(34) Cf. Dogmatic Constitution Dei Verbum, n. 10.

vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19900524_theologian-vocation_en.html
 
Just to make a few comments on what you’ve said
  • Constantinople in terms of ranking, put itself 1st in the East ahead of Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem in that order. It was never ahead of Rome. Rome has always been 1st in ranking. And in case it’s necessary to say, Constantinople doesn’t exist anymore. It’s Istanbul, and muslim.
  • The papacy has always been there in the person of Peter. His position is established by Christ. Who is ANYONE to say his office is no longer needed?
  • The Christian East in union with the pope is one. The Christian East that is EO is NOT in union with the pope, NOT one Church, and It’s NOT universal.
Steve, perhaps you should refrain from commenting on that which you do not know? 🤷
 
Joseph, which part do you disagree with?
Well lets see.
Constantinople in terms of ranking, put itself 1st in the East ahead of Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem in that order. It was never ahead of Rome. Rome has always been 1st in ranking.
Partially correct. Constantinople was elevated to its position by an Ecumenical Council.
And in case it’s necessary to say, Constantinople doesn’t exist anymore. It’s Istanbul, and muslim.
Ecclesiastically speaking it still exists.
The Christian East that is EO is NOT in union with the pope, NOT one Church
False.
…and It’s NOT universal.
Although I suspect you are erroneously taking the term “catholic” to mean “universal”, you are incorrect again. 😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top