Thousands protest over abortion legislation

  • Thread starter Thread starter IrishKnight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Our Lady of Knock, please pray for Ireland!

Saint Patrick, adopted son of Ireland, please pray for them!

If Ireland gives in, then the Devil has won a battle.
 
It is so sick that it looks like abortion is going to be legal in Ireland soon. This really infuriates me. I hate that pro-abortion activists have been able to do this. :mad:

Lord, have mercy! Amen.
 
This is the the first time abortions will happen in Ireland.
I think you meant to say that this is the first time *legal *abortions will happen in Ireland. Also “If enacted, the bill will legalise abortion where there is a real and substantial risk to the life of the mother, including the threat of suicide.” I think that the first change that the government officials will try for will be to change the part about suicide. It could have been a lot worse.
 
I think you meant to say that this is the first time *legal *abortions will happen in Ireland. Also “If enacted, the bill will legalise abortion where there is a real and substantial risk to the life of the mother, including the threat of suicide.” I think that the first change that the government officials will try for will be to change the part about suicide. It could have been a lot worse.
Where is the evidence that abortion has ever saved the life of a mother?

Eminent Irish oncologist Dr John Crown has said
I don’t think I ever had a case where abortion was necessary to save mom
lifesitenews.com/news/no-case-where-abortion-was-necessary-to-save-mom-eminent-irish-oncologist

A panel of experts at the International Symposium on Maternal Health in Dublin said in the Dublin Declaration
As experienced practitioners and researchers in Obstetrics and Gynaecology, we affirm that direct abortion - the purposeful destruction of the unborn in the termination of pregnancy - is not medically necessary to save the life of a woman
We uphold that there is a fundamental difference between abortion, and necessary medical treatments that are carried out to save the life of the mother, even if such treatment results in the loss of life of her unborn child.
We confirm that the prohibition of abortion does not affect, in any way, the availability of optimal care to pregnant women.
dublindeclaration.com

Any woman who wants an abortion could say they feel suicidal in order to get an abortion, how could it be properly and accurately determinedly that a woman genuinely feels suicidal and if a woman genuinely feels suicidal she shouldn’t have the legal right to kill her baby, she should be getting help with her mental health.
Abortion is not an effective treatment for any mental health disorder, according to the heads of Ireland’s leading psychiatric hospital.
independent.ie/irish-news/abortion-is-not-effective-for-any-mental-illness-29023191.html
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
A report was done into Savita Halappanavar’s death and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:

…
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

At the time of Savita Halappanavar’s death it said in the Irish Medical Councils guidelines:
In current obstetrical practice, rare complications can arise where therapeutic intervention (including termination of a pregnancy) is required at a stage when, due to extreme immaturity of the baby, there may be little or no hope of the baby surviving. In these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to intervene to terminate the pregnancy to protect the life of the mother, while making every effort to preserve the life of the baby
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
A report was done into and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:

…
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

At the time of Savita Halappanavar’s death it said in the Irish Medical Councils guidelines:
In current obstetrical practice, rare complications can arise where therapeutic intervention (including termination of a pregnancy) is required at a stage when, due to extreme immaturity of the baby, there may be little or no hope of the baby surviving. In these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to intervene to terminate the pregnancy to protect the life of the mother, while making every effort to preserve the life of the baby
:eek:
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
A report was done into and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:

…
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

At the time of Savita Halappanavar’s death it said in the Irish Medical Councils guidelines:
In current obstetrical practice, rare complications can arise where therapeutic intervention (including termination of a pregnancy) is required at a stage when, due to extreme immaturity of the baby, there may be little or no hope of the baby surviving. In these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to intervene to terminate the pregnancy to protect the life of the mother, while making every effort to preserve the life of the baby
:mad:
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
A report was done into and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:

…
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

At the time of Savita Halappanavar’s death it said in the Irish Medical Councils guidelines:
In current obstetrical practice, rare complications can arise where therapeutic intervention (including termination of a pregnancy) is required at a stage when, due to extreme immaturity of the baby, there may be little or no hope of the baby surviving. In these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to intervene to terminate the pregnancy to protect the life of the mother, while making every effort to preserve the life of the baby
:eek::eek:
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
A report was done into and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:

…
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

At the time of Savita Halappanavar’s death it said in the Irish Medical Councils guidelines:
In current obstetrical practice, rare complications can arise where therapeutic intervention (including termination of a pregnancy) is required at a stage when, due to extreme immaturity of the baby, there may be little or no hope of the baby surviving. In these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to intervene to terminate the pregnancy to protect the life of the mother, while making every effort to preserve the life of the baby
:mad::confused:
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
A report was done into and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:

…
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

At the time of Savita Halappanavar’s death it said in the Irish Medical Councils guidelines:
In current obstetrical practice, rare complications can arise where therapeutic intervention (including termination of a pregnancy) is required at a stage when, due to extreme immaturity of the baby, there may be little or no hope of the baby surviving. In these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to intervene to terminate the pregnancy to protect the life of the mother, while making every effort to preserve the life of the baby
👍👍
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
A report was done into and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:

…
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

At the time of Savita Halappanavar’s death it said in the Irish Medical Councils guidelines:
In current obstetrical practice, rare complications can arise where therapeutic intervention (including termination of a pregnancy) is required at a stage when, due to extreme immaturity of the baby, there may be little or no hope of the baby surviving. In these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to intervene to terminate the pregnancy to protect the life of the mother, while making every effort to preserve the life of the baby
🤷:eek:
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
A report was done into and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:

…
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

At the time of Savita Halappanavar’s death it said in the Irish Medical Councils guidelines:
In current obstetrical practice, rare complications can arise where therapeutic intervention (including termination of a pregnancy) is required at a stage when, due to extreme immaturity of the baby, there may be little or no hope of the baby surviving. In these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to intervene to terminate the pregnancy to protect the life of the mother, while making every effort to preserve the life of the baby
:eek::eek::eek::eek:
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
A report was done into and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:

…
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

At the time of Savita Halappanavar’s death it said in the Irish Medical Councils guidelines:
In current obstetrical practice, rare complications can arise where therapeutic intervention (including termination of a pregnancy) is required at a stage when, due to extreme immaturity of the baby, there may be little or no hope of the baby surviving. In these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to intervene to terminate the pregnancy to protect the life of the mother, while making every effort to preserve the life of the baby
:eek:🤷
 
It looks as though it was the death last year of that Indian dentist who was continuously denied an abortion in a life-threatening situation, plus the country’s own disillusionment with the local priests involved in that big sex abuse scandal, that swayed the tide on this issue for many citizens and the voting lawmakers as well, as per a recent poll in the Irish Times:

"But the catalyst for change was Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist who died last year in a western Ireland hospital one week after being admitted in severe pain at the start of a miscarriage. Doctors cited Ireland’s ill-defined and Catholic-influenced laws when denying her pleas for an abortion, even though her uterus had ruptured and exposed her to increased risk of blood poisoning.

By the time doctors authorized an abortion, Halappanavar had already been hospitalized for four days and the 17-week-old fetus was stillborn. She fell into a state of toxic shock, then into a coma, and died from massive organ failures three days later. Two fact-finding investigations since have found that an abortion one or two days before the fetus’ death would have increased Halappanavar’s chance of survival, but said the hospital was guilty of many other failures in her care.

In years past, a government that took on Catholic orthodoxy in Ireland would have feared damaging splits and electoral annihilation. But Tuesday’s vote illustrates changed social mores and widespread disenchantment with Catholic leaders following two decades of revelations of the Irish church’s role in protecting pedophile priests from public exposure and prosecution

The most recent opinion poll found that 89 percent want abortions to be granted in cases where a woman’s life is endangered by continued pregnancy. Some 83 percent also want abortion legalized in cases where the fetus could not survive at birth, 81 percent for cases of pregnancy caused by rape or incest, and 78 percent where a woman’s health – not simply her life – was undermined by pregnancy. The government bill excludes those three scenarios. The June 13 poll in the Irish Times had an error margin of three percentage points."
Here is an analysis by National Right to Life of a draft report by Prof Arulkumaran that was done and a bunch of failures were found to have occurred in the lead up to her death:
The draft report reveals:
  • Blood tests were carried out on Savita on the day of her admission but not followed up. The tests showed an elevated white cell count—a signal for suspected blood poisoning.
  • There was a lack of clarity on who was responsible for the follow-up. The senior specialist registrar in obstetrics ordered the tests, but the samples were taken under instruction by a junior doctor who also denied responsibility. A midwife said follow-up was not her job.
  • The review team could find no examination of Savita’s pulse, blood pressure or temperature to test for early possibility of infection on her second day in hospital.
  • There was no review of treatment options, and the pattern was to “await events.” Doctors monitored the foetal heartbeat in case “accelerated delivery” might be possible.
  • There was over-emphasis on the need not to intervene until the foetal heartbeat stopped.
  • On Tuesday her pulse rate at 9pm should have triggered a medical review, but the junior doctor was too busy caring for other patients. He did not attend her until 1am when he carried out a chart review. She was asleep and he did not wake her. “With the possibility of sepsis at this point, help from a senior medic should have been requested,” the review says. Although the junior doctor was busy with other patients, this could have been overcome by calling a senior doctor who was on call to see serious cases. A nurse found Savita cold and shivery at 4.20am and checked her two hours later.
The report, which was first revealed by the Evening Herald, details a difference in recollections of a phone call between a junior doctor and a registrar about Savita’s rising temperature that morning. The registrar did not recall being told of her heart rate and blood pressure, but the junior doctor said he gave the facts but was not told “anything extra.” It was not until Wednesday that a diagnosis of probable sepsis was made and more antibiotics were given.
nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2013/02/savita-report-highlights-litany-of-failures
The jury in the inquest into a woman who died in hospital in Ireland four days after suffering a miscarriage has given a verdict of medical misadventure.
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22213630

A case where multiple failures occurred should not be a catalyst for legalizing abortion, what should be done is making sure that such failures do not occur again.
 
Maybe they are putting in place procedures so that such failures can not happen again, but legalizing abortion should not be pursued.
 
Maybe they are putting in place procedures so that such failures can not happen again, but legalizing abortion should not be pursued.
You are right. Procedures do need to be put in place so that nothing like what happened with Savita, the dentist, can happen again. Abortion absolutely should not be legalized under any circumstances.
 
Where is the evidence that abortion has ever saved the life of a mother?

Eminent Irish oncologist Dr John Crown has said

lifesitenews.com/news/no-case-where-abortion-was-necessary-to-save-mom-eminent-irish-oncologist

A panel of experts at the International Symposium on Maternal Health in Dublin said in the Dublin Declaration

dublindeclaration.com

Any woman who wants an abortion could say they feel suicidal in order to get an abortion, how could it be properly and accurately determinedly that a woman genuinely feels suicidal and if a woman genuinely feels suicidal she shouldn’t have the legal right to kill her baby, she should be getting help with her mental health.

independent.ie/irish-news/abortion-is-not-effective-for-any-mental-illness-29023191.html
Okay, if only a minute amount of abortions are done to save the life of the mother, that would mean there would be few abortions. If that is so, what’s the problem? The new law would save the lives of a couple of mothers. Did I miss something? :confused:
 
Okay, if only a minute amount of abortions are done to save the life of the mother, that would mean there would be few abortions. If that is so, what’s the problem? The new law would save the lives of a couple of mothers. Did I miss something? :confused:
I do not understand what you fully you mean. Any abortion leads to the killing of a baby and that is wrong. What evidence is there that an abortion has ever saved the live of a mother?
 
I do not understand what you fully you mean. Any abortion leads to the killing of a baby and that is wrong. What evidence is there that an abortion has ever saved the live of a mother?
You don’t understand. I accept your statement that few abortions are done in order to save the life of the mother. If Ireland has legalized abortion only in the cases where the mother’s life is in danger, there will be few abortions, by your own premise. That there was never an abortion done to save the life of the mother in the whole history of medicine is pretty idealistic, though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top