Thousands protest over abortion legislation

  • Thread starter Thread starter IrishKnight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you meant to say that this is the first time *legal *abortions will happen in Ireland. Also “If enacted, the bill will legalise abortion where there is a real and substantial risk to the life of the mother, including the threat of suicide.” I think that the first change that the government officials will try for will be to change the part about suicide. It could have been a lot worse.
The camel’s’ nose under the tent…😦
 
Where is the evidence that abortion has ever saved the life of a mother?
Uhh…come on now, you know there are many such cases. In the past few years, there have been cases where an abortion could have saved the life of the mother. Why do you want to make points that can so easily be refuted?
 
NeedsMercy, you are talking about innocent little babies here. New life created by God. All life is precious. Why is the mother’s life deserving of being saved but not the baby’s? Why is it ok to just kill a baby without a second thought, but, the mother’s life must be saved at all cost? Why the preferential treatment? An unborn baby deserves life just as his mother does. All attempts should be made to save the lives of both mother and baby. One life is not more precious than another.
So the mother’s life is meaningless? The mother who is sentient, has friends and family members, who is emotionally developed just doesn’t matter as much to you, huh? By the way, Catholicism teaches that abortion is acceptable to save the mother.
 
I can’t accept the statement that “an abortion is **never **needed to save the life of a mother”. The Church acknowledges that there **are **such cases. There may be a few instances e.g. an ectopic (tubal) pregnancy where the removal of the Fallopian tube—to treat the condition and save the life of the mother–results in the loss of the fetus. This is not considered abortion, yet the death of the fetus is the end result.
Exactly, I’m not even Catholic anymore, and I know this stuff. Do people here think they’re holier than the official teachings?
 
Uhh…come on now, you know there are many such cases. In the past few years, there have been cases where an abortion could have saved the life of the mother. Why do you want to make points that can so easily be refuted?
Clearly they’re so easily refuted that you failed to list even one example. There has never been a single case.
So the mother’s life is meaningless? The mother who is sentient, has friends and family members, who is emotionally developed just doesn’t matter as much to you, huh? By the way, Catholicism teaches that abortion is acceptable to save the mother.
Catholicism does not teach that. In addition, no one here is saying the mother’s life is meaningless. We are saying that the baby has just as much a right to life as the mother, and that while a baby may die in the course of treatment of a health issue of the mother, there has never been a case where an abortion saved the life of the mother. No one has ever said that the mother could not be treated, and certainly such treatments are allowed. Abortion is not a medical ‘treatment.’
 
So the mother’s life is meaningless? The mother who is sentient, has friends and family members, who is emotionally developed just doesn’t matter as much to you, huh? By the way, Catholicism teaches that abortion is acceptable to save the mother.
Where did I say the mother’s life is meaningless? Where did I say her life does not matter? What I did say was that BOTH lives are precious and all attempts should be made to save BOTH.

My question was, why is the life of the mother worthy of killing the life of another? The baby’s life is of no less worth than it’s mother’s. A person’s worth is not (should not) be measured by friends, family, or emotional developement.

Catholicism does not condone the murder of a person to save the life of another.
 
Catholicism does not condone the murder of a person to save the life of another.
Erm…this isn’t actually true. There is a direct comparison exemption to the eighth mode of responsibility that the ends don’t justify the means. In cases where the end result is directly comparable (one life for two), the Church does find it morally acceptable to pick the lesser of two evils. However, that does not apply to abortion because the abortion is never necessary, and there is always a third choice of treating the mother without an abortion (though pro-abortion activists will never let anyone discuss that).
 
Exactly, I’m not even Catholic anymore, and I know this stuff. Do people here think they’re holier than the official teachings?
No, we just actually know the official teachings. Unlike you.
 
Are you guys using some technicality with terms? I’m not sure what you’re arguing in here when you say that abortions haven’t saved the life of a mother. Ectopic pregnancies? I’m not going to bring up all kinds of cases because I’m pretty sure everyone knows what I mean. Recently a woman in Ireland was denied and abortion and died. This stuff happens, and it’s usually not even disputed in here. Why are you guys trying to argue that abortions can’t save a woman from a difficult pregnancy? There are many, many documented cases on this. Catholicism acknowledges this. It’s seen as permissible to perform an abortion to save the mother. It’s considered a life-saving procedure with the fetal death as the unintended outcome. Are you arguing that it isn’t technically an abortion because the end goal is to save the mother? I’m trying to figure out if I’m just arguing against a technicality.

cnn.com/2012/11/14/world/europe/ireland-abortion-controversy
 
Are you guys using some technicality with terms? I’m not sure what you’re arguing in here when you say that abortions haven’t saved the life of a mother. Ectopic pregnancies? I’m not going to bring up all kinds of cases because I’m pretty sure everyone knows what I mean. Recently a woman in Ireland was denied and abortion and died. This stuff happens, and it’s usually not even disputed in here. Why are you guys trying to argue that abortions can’t save a woman from a difficult pregnancy? There are many, many documented cases on this. Catholicism acknowledges this. It’s seen as permissible to perform an abortion to save the mother. It’s considered a life-saving procedure with the fetal death as the unintended outcome. Are you arguing that it isn’t technically an abortion because the end goal is to save the mother? I’m trying to figure out if I’m just arguing against a technicality.

cnn.com/2012/11/14/world/europe/ireland-abortion-controversy
An abortion is a procedure that aims primarily at killing the fetus. What you describe is not an abortion. It is the intent that makes the difference.
 
Uhh…come on now, you know there are many such cases. In the past few years, there have been cases where an abortion could have saved the life of the mother. Why do you want to make points that can so easily be refuted?
Are you guys using some technicality with terms? I’m not sure what you’re arguing in here when you say that abortions haven’t saved the life of a mother. Ectopic pregnancies? I’m not going to bring up all kinds of cases because I’m pretty sure everyone knows what I mean. Recently a woman in Ireland was denied and abortion and died. This stuff happens, and it’s usually not even disputed in here. Why are you guys trying to argue that abortions can’t save a woman from a difficult pregnancy? There are many, many documented cases on this. Catholicism acknowledges this. It’s seen as permissible to perform an abortion to save the mother. It’s considered a life-saving procedure with the fetal death as the unintended outcome. Are you arguing that it isn’t technically an abortion because the end goal is to save the mother? I’m trying to figure out if I’m just arguing against a technicality.

cnn.com/2012/11/14/world/europe/ireland-abortion-controversy
In the case of Savita Halappanavar, there were multiple failures that happened before her death:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=10956143&postcount=7

Hema Divakar, president elect of Federation of Obstetric and Gynecological Societies of India was interviewed

“Delay or refusal to terminate the pregnancy does not in itself seem to be the cause of death. Even if the law permitted it, it is not as if her life would have been saved because of termination,” she said. “Severe septicaemia with disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC), a life-threatening bleeding disorder which is a complication of sepsis, major organ damage and loss of the mother’s blood due to severe infection, is the cause of death in Savita’s case. This is what seems to have happened and this is a sequence which cannot be reversed just by terminating the pregnancy.”

thehindu.com/news/cities/bangalore/city-doctor-defends-irish-counterparts/article4100988.ece

Medical intervention can treat an ectopic pregnancy and abortion itself can create an increased risk of ectopic pregnancy in future pregnancy as a study found

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1649809

A panel of those involved in research and practice in gynecology and obstetrics do not believe abortion is needed to save the life of a woman

dublindeclaration.com
It is absolutely true that the Catholic Church bans direct abortion to save the life of the mother. However (and this is an extremely important point) the mother’s life may be saved by a surgical procedure that does not directly attack the preborn baby’s life.
hli.org/cloning/400?task=view
 
Does that means it’s a done deal? 😦 😦 😦
Unfortunately, yes. I can’t believe it, I feel so deflated.

This government are a weak bunch of brown nosers and atheists - bowing down to their 'secular bosses in Europe to get as many gold stars on their copybooks, as they can. So they’ve now introduced abortion to become a more ‘civilised’ and ‘modern-thinking’ country.😦
**
Irish abortion legislation passed
**
belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/local-national/republic-of-ireland/irish-abortion-legislation-passed-29414137.html
 
Unfortunately, yes. I can’t believe it, I feel so deflated.

This government are a weak bunch of brown nosers and atheists - bowing down to their 'secular bosses in Europe to get as many gold stars on their copybooks, as they can. So they’ve now introduced abortion to become a more ‘civilised’ and ‘modern-thinking’ country.😦
**
Irish abortion legislation passed
**
belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/local-national/republic-of-ireland/irish-abortion-legislation-passed-29414137.html
Church to challenge abortion Bill in courts.
Yesterday, the bishops published a briefing document which said that the Bill did not vindicate the equal right to life of the unborn which “provides grounds for a viable challenge to the Constitutionality of the Bill”.
And a spokesman for the bishops has confirmed that would challenge the legislation in the Supreme Court in the event of it passing into law, the Irish Independent reports.
The bishops plan to mount the challenge claiming the bill’s unconstitutional legislative process or its failure to adequately vindicate the equal right to life of the unborn.
Martin Long, of the Catholic Communications Office, said the bishops would await the outcome of the final vote before making a decision.
ionainstitute.org/index.php?id=3042
 
Church to challenge abortion Bill in courts.

ionainstitute.org/index.php?id=3042
Thank God, for that news. The entire issue is filled with flaws, aside from the obvious. I watched some of the debate, last night, regarding the constitution’s law in relation to jail term if an illegal abortion is carried out in Ireland, and it was pointed out by the ‘government’ that it was in the constitution to protect the life of the unborn child? 🤷

Go figure.
 
I am not sure what Michael Higgins views are on abortion, (although he may be an atheist, as he believes in spirituality as opposed to religion) but let’s pray he and the bishops can get this overturned.

worldnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/07/12/19430914-ireland-set-to-allow-abortion-for-first-time-under-historic-new-law?lite

The bill must still go to the Irish Senate and then be signed into law by President Michael D. Higgins, who could decide to refer it to the Supreme Court to check whether the law is constitutional, according to TV station RTE.
The bill allows medical procedures that result in the ending of “an unborn human life” in order to deal with “a real and substantial risk of loss of the [pregnant] woman’s life.”
It also allows for an abortion if three medical practitioners agree this is necessary to prevent a pregnant woman from taking her own life.
Sinead Ahern, spokeswoman for Choice Ireland, said the decision was “very historic,” given the influence of the Catholic Church in the country.
 
Eamon Gilmore the tanaiste ( like the vice president) said a gay marriage referendum is for next year.
God help Ireland, it could be two blows in row now. We are “cathing up with” the “advanced” EUSSR now.
 
An abortion wouldn’t have saved her, the whole thing is a ruse ! hope the people eject this dictatorship government in the south…anyone that supports murder shouldn’t be allowed to receive Communion, as if Jesus would sign up for this " let the little children come to Me "
 
I live in the Republic and I would vote this current Government out in a heartbeat. :mad:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top