Three Derby men guilty over gay hate leaflets

  • Thread starter Thread starter FightingFat
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, come on, it is there:
13“‘If a man lies with a man as one lies with a woman, both of them have done what is detestable. They must be put to death; their blood will be on their own heads.
but if it’s any consolation, Gays are hardly being singled out. There’s plenty of stone-able offenses here:

niv.scripturetext.com/leviticus/20-1.htm

I’m just guessing that there are those that are fuming over no mention of pedos.

Unless you count giving your children to Molech.
 
Noe here is the rub on this, how on earth would anyone know if you were gay unless you told them. This is not like a racial attack were skin color or physical features are obvious to all, but a particular perversion being raised up by worshipful leftist.
In the case of some attacks I’ve read about, the community the person is in knows they’re gay, including those who then attacks them. Also, people coming out of gay nightclubs have been the subject of attacks, as well as those attending LGBT events and other such events where in all likelihood, it’s likely people attending are gay.
 
So we’re creating a tu quoque fallacy between OT text (in Islamic terms, “abrogated” by the New Covenant), and support of all five major schools of Islamic jurisprudence, centuries of practice, and codified modern law in Islamic countries?

If you can find a “death penalty to homosexuals” in the catechism, or in practice in any majority christian nation, your argument might have legs.
 
So we’re creating a tu quoque fallacy between OT text (in Islamic terms, “abrogated” by the New Covenant), and support of all five major schools of Islamic jurisprudence, centuries of practice, and codified modern law in Islamic countries?

If you can find a “death penalty to homosexuals” in the catechism, or in practice in any majority christian nation, your argument might have legs.
Does the majority christian nation have to belong to the 20/21st century?
 
👍
The answer to speech we disagree with is more speech, not censorship. If their rights aren’t safe neither are any of our’s. I’m so glad to live in a country that respects the free speech rights of even its most unpopular citizens.
👍
 
The answer to speech we disagree with is more speech, not censorship. If their rights aren’t safe neither are any of our’s. I’m so glad to live in a country that respects the free speech rights of even its most unpopular citizens.
I agree. I searched the articles looking for the actual wording on the pamphlets. The only words I found were that homosexuals should get the death penalty. I took that to mean a government thing. Which would mean that they were petitioning for a change in laws. That looks like political speech to me. Ugly speech should be allowed too. That’s when the other side is supposed to show how ugly their opponent’s argument is. Censorship is not the answer.

And they physically attack Christians too, not to mention what the do to women. But I still believe it’s free speech. Illegal actions are punished. Not speech.
 
I agree. I searched the articles looking for the actual wording on the pamphlets. The only words I found were that homosexuals should get the death penalty. I took that to mean a government thing. Which would mean that they were petitioning for a change in laws. That looks like political speech to me. Ugly speech should be allowed too. That’s when the other side is supposed to show how ugly their opponent’s argument is. Censorship is not the answer.

And they physically attack Christians too, not to mention what the do to women. But I still believe it’s free speech. Illegal actions are punished. Not speech.
They advocate Sha’ria law. Moderate Muslims here in the UK argue that these people represent a vocal minority. They certainly do not listen to reason, this is what a similar group did to a Muslim Member of Parliament:

youtube.com/watch?v=dzZLwN1eLEM
 
Does the majority christian nation have to belong to the 20/21st century?
If we are applying the same standard, yes.

Iran, Mauritania, Saudi Arabia, North Sudan, Yemen, and parts of Nigeria and Somalia CURRENTLY carry a death penalty for homosexual acts.
 
So we’re creating a tu quoque fallacy between OT text (in Islamic terms, “abrogated” by the New Covenant), and support of all five major schools of Islamic jurisprudence, centuries of practice, and codified modern law in Islamic countries?

If you can find a “death penalty to homosexuals” in the catechism, or in practice in any majority christian nation, your argument might have legs.
I live in a Christian country which only 50 years ago (within living memory) prosecuted homosexual men and women and sent them to prison for often long sentences simply for a consenting act done in private between two consenting adults.

Ever heard of Alan Turing? He was a mathematical genius, who helped to crack the crucial Enigma Code which helped win the war. But far from being lauded as a hero and given the appropriate honors, he was prosecuted and threatened with chemical castration or prison because he happened to be gay and with another consenting man, had homosexual relations in private. He ended up taking his own life because his name was dragged into the mud.

And I cannot find any evidence of Christian countries which practice the death penalty for homosexuality, but Tanzania (a Christian majority country) has a 20years-life imprisonment for homosexuals, as well as some other Christian African countries which still carry massive prison terms, including terms in labour camps, for gay people.
 
Three men have been found guilty of stirring up hatred on the grounds of sexual orientation after handing out anti-homosexual leaflets.

bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-derbyshire-16656679

Trust our Muslim friends to demonstrate what real homophobic hatred looks like. I have to admit feeling slightly relieved, I mean this is extremely nasty, and I’m glad they were prosecuted. I’d begun to think Islam in this country, was immune from prosecution. I guess when they went up against that powerful pro-gay lobby, it was a step too far eh?
What gave you that idea? :confused:
 
The answer to speech we disagree with is more speech, not censorship. If their rights aren’t safe neither are any of our’s. I’m so glad to live in a country that respects the free speech rights of even its most unpopular citizens.
I’m glad to live in a country where hatred isn’t protected.
 
I agree. I searched the articles looking for the actual wording on the pamphlets. The only words I found were that homosexuals should get the death penalty. I took that to mean a government thing. Which would mean that they were petitioning for a change in laws. That looks like political speech to me. Ugly speech should be allowed too. That’s when the other side is supposed to show how ugly their opponent’s argument is. Censorship is not the answer.

And they physically attack Christians too, not to mention what the do to women. But I still believe it’s free speech. Illegal actions are punished. Not speech.
So basically you’re trying to paint this as the UK government censoring political campaigning for a change in the law?

Well, then that makes it alright then. We should tell them to carry on. No indeed, they should have their own campaign office.

Heck, while we’re at it, those who committed the 7/7 terror attacks in London were probably making a political statement too. Let’s give them an office.

Or maybe those men who killed the homosexual man a few months ago was just demonstrating how the change in the law would be implemented. Let him out of jail!
 
If we are applying the same standard, yes.

Iran, Mauritania, Saudi Arabia, North Sudan, Yemen, and parts of Nigeria and Somalia CURRENTLY carry a death penalty for homosexual acts.
The paralell works. Both the Qur’an and the Bible condemn homosexuality and suggest the death penalty.

Both majority Christian groups and Muslim groups do not condone/agree with that.

However, some Christians and some Muslims believe it should be implemented.
 
I live in a Christian country which only 50 years ago (within living memory) prosecuted homosexual men and women and sent them to prison for often long sentences simply for a consenting act done in private between two consenting adults.

Ever heard of Alan Turing? He was a mathematical genius, who helped to crack the crucial Enigma Code which helped win the war. But far from being lauded as a hero and given the appropriate honors, he was prosecuted and threatened with chemical castration or prison because he happened to be gay and with another consenting man, had homosexual relations in private. He ended up taking his own life because his name was dragged into the mud.

And I cannot find any evidence of Christian countries which practice the death penalty for homosexuality, but Tanzania (a Christian majority country) has a 20years-life imprisonment for homosexuals, as well as some other Christian African countries which still carry massive prison terms, including terms in labour camps, for gay people.
So you admit you applied a tu quoque fallacy that wasn’t factual?

Thank you.
 
The paralell works. Both the Qur’an and the Bible condemn homosexuality and suggest the death penalty.

Both majority Christian groups and Muslim groups do not condone/agree with that.

However, some Christians and some Muslims believe it should be implemented.
I apprciate the vagueness of “majority groups”.

While not monolithic, Sunni Islam has 5 major schools of jurisprudence.

What do they say?

I know the “all religion=Islam” meme is popular among those who are hostile to any faith, but the facts simply don’t bear this out.
 
What gave you that idea? :confused:
Might have something to do with the fact that there have been several major cases where extremist Islamist preachers have been pretty much allowed to do as they please with little fear of prosecution despite their preaching of killing homosexuals/Jewish people/anyone they don’t like, as well as their calls for terrorist acts and graphic abuses of human rights in this country, including those against women. Abu Hamza is one example.

Even when they’re prosecuted, they’re kept from being deported to Muslim countries to face criminal charges there based on their ‘human rights’ from torture and for a fair trial, despite the seriousness of the charges being levelled against them. And then they get pathetic sentences, often being allowed to recruit and preach extremist Islam in prison.

Then there’s the myriad number of cases where Muslims have been through the court system and their religion is used as a ‘get out of jail free’ card to do as they please. There’s been civil cases where a Muslim man had handled alcohol for a number of years without problem as part of his job, only for him to go to court claiming his religion forbade him from doing that all of a sudden. There’s also a case in the paper even now where a Muslim pilot with terrorist links has been removed from his job, but he is now calling the aviation authorities ‘anti-Islam’ and ‘racist’ for doing so.
 
So basically you’re trying to paint this as the UK government censoring political campaigning for a change in the law?

Well, then that makes it alright then. We should tell them to carry on. No indeed, they should have their own campaign office.

Heck, while we’re at it, those who committed the 7/7 terror attacks in London were probably making a political statement too. Let’s give them an office.

Or maybe those men who killed the homosexual man a few months ago was just demonstrating how the change in the law would be implemented. Let him out of jail!
Can you tell the difference between acts and speech? I’ll give you a hint. When you use action words in your sentence, like “committed” or “killed” that indicates an action. Speech is when someone talks, or in this case writes.

An action can be a crime. Free speech is considered a right.

Our founding fathers put free speech in the constitution because experience taught them how important it is.
 
Can you tell the difference between acts and speech? I’ll give you a hint. When you use action words in your sentence, like “committed” or “killed” that indicates an action. Speech is when someone talks, or in this case writes.

An action can be a crime. Free speech is considered a right.

Our founding fathers put free speech in the constitution because experience taught them how important it is.
Not all speech is recognized as a right. A person can be jailed for inciting another to rape or kill. A person can be jailed or fined for libel. If I stand outside of your house shouting obscenities through a bullhorn in the middle of the night, it is not recognized as free speech. There are many instances in which speech can be prosecuted, and rightfully so.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top