To convert a protestant pastor

  • Thread starter Thread starter consuela
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I love all of these book recommendations…But as another poster reminded me on a different thread, you can’t rely completely on a book or conversation to convert someone. You can do a lot to help, but in the end…they are the ones who have to answer God’s call and the nagging feeling in their hearts. Never stop praying for them and don’t give up…everyone responds to God at their own pace. God Bless.
 
40.png
y2daddy:
Karl Keating’s “Catholicism and Fundamentalism.” And I’m not just saying that because it’s his forum 🙂 It’s a great book.
My only problem with this book is that it sometimes takes a negative tone which could be percieved as uncharitable.

Born Fundamentalist, Born again Catholic by Currie is a very good book.
 
The one I like to give out most is the first *Surprised by Truth * book. People relate to conversion stories when they read about others who share their misconceptions finding the Truth.
 
I believe it is called “Confessions of a Roman Catholic”. It is a very brief and consice booklet by a Protestant Pastor outlining why he became Catholic. Not a hardship to read at all. It could probably be read cover to cover in 10 minutes.

Sincerely,

De Maria
 
Karl Keating’s “Romanism Vs Fundamentalism”…

never hurts to suck-up to the big guy… 👍
 
An excellent book for a protestant pastor would be, “History of the Variations of the Protestant Churches” by J.B. Bossuet.

Marilyn L.
 
My brother got a book called “Why Be Catholic?” as a graduation present. It was a pretty good read…but I’m not sure who the author of it is at the moment and I’m too lazy to get up and look. :rolleyes:
 
“The Four Witnesses” A book about the Early Fathers in a supposedly very readable form. I will find out soon, it is part of what I got my husband for Father’s Day.

Marcus Grodi has recommended this book for such people.

(The rest of the Father’s Day gifts are: Another book about the Early Father’s recommended by Karl Keating, and Beginning Aplogetics book, a tshirt about praying the Rosary “Urgent Call Home” “Your Mother hasn’t heard from you in decades” )
 
Gods peace be with you Theophilus,

All the books mentioned are great and I’ve read many of them. Here are three more:

*The Teachings of The Church Fathers.:yup: *This book is great and is nothing but quotes from the early Church ‘Fathers’. See what the first Christians believed and what the Catholic Church alone still holds as true. As neutral as neutral can be, except for what the ‘Fathers’ actually wrote.

The Facts About Luther.:bigyikes: This book was written as a response to the lies and errors Luther preached. It is a great book but attacks Luther as energetically as he attacked Christs Church. The preacher would have to have a very open mind to get through the “pro-Catholic” portions of this book. But the facts are true and the writter has a great passion to correct 500 years of lies from or about Luther.

Hitler The War ANd The Pope.:clapping: Great book that shows how far the Church would go to protect the Jews and risk everything in the process. Pope Pious the XII was a great man and and due to his intervention may have helped save over 800,000 Jews. (Save the lives not the souls)

Now, how are you going to get them to read these books?:hmmm: Anything Catholic goes into the trash when I was a protestant.:banghead: Good luck, there are some open minds out there that will ‘see’ the truth.:love:

A prisoner of Christ
 
Has he said he WANTS to be converted? Or are you taking it upon yourself to try to do it?
 
All of the above. If he is a more evangelical type I would also recommed “Born Fundamentalist, Born Again Catholic”.

dream wanderer
 
space ghost:
Karl Keating’s “Romanism Vs Fundamentalism”…

never hurts to suck-up to the big guy… 👍
well than you should probably actually KNOW the name of his book. it’s “catholicism and fundamentalism”. i’m just joking with you of course but you did get the name of the book wrong 😃

i am a protestant minister researching the catholic church and i found Karl’s book very informative but it does at times just attack (and perhaps rightly so) boettner’s book “roman catholicism” (the “bible” of anti-catholics). “rome sweet rome” is good as well as any other of scott hahn’s books. stephen ray’s “crossing the tiber” is his story and deals with baptism and the eucharist. “catholic for a reason” is a series of essays defending the church and her beliefs. i would say though, anything that deals with issues like mary, purgatory, and the eucharist as all of the other issues are pretty nominal. while books about some one’s story are inspiring, protestants are going to need more “meat” to warrant such a life changing shift.
 
Born Fundamentalist, Born again catholic by david currie

Why catholics genuflect By Al Kresta

Crossing the Tiber by Stephen Ray

Anything by Scott Hahn

Where’s that in the Bible by Patrick Madrid

Where’s that in Tradition by Patrick Madrid

Radio Replies Vol. 1,2 and 3 By fathers Rumble and Mccarty
all great reads!!!
 
40.png
consuela:
If you had an open-minded protestant (not anti-Catholic) willing to read ONE book to convince him or at least give him a start in thinking that the Catholic Church is the True Church which one would you give him?
Suggestions please.
I’ve read most of the books recommended. I think they are all good to excellent suggestions, though I suspect that some are better depending on where the Pastor is.

If you’re aware of his openness, he may be further along the road than you suspect – maybe like Hahn, he will have a voracious appetite for many of those books (quickly advancing to and appetite for the CCC).

I think MParedon asked the “key” question. What’s his style, where’s he coming from, what are his current needs, etc.?

In my experience, my best “successes” in leading people to the truth haven’t been my successes at all. They were already on their way, and merely appreciative of the info that I gave them. What I hope to be “successes” are not demonstrably “on their way” unless you can count the fact that when I point out a truth that conflicts with their view (i.e. a quote from the KJV) they change the subject after a brief blank look. I sincerely hope the “blank look” was from a seed establishing root in the fertile soil that God has provided in their mind. It maybe a total disconnect, treating what I said as a non-sequitur.

What I’m rambling about in that paragraph is “keep up the prayer” it may take a lot longer than you hope for him to see a broad enough quantity of the truth to consider conversion.

(And if he converts quickly and tells you it’s through your efforts, please detail how you did it so I can improve my technique.)

Having said that in the last paragraph, let me go mostly off subject and propose that before the 1930s American success literature (generic) was based in hard work, good work ethic, high moral values and a touch of luck (I call that God-incidence). After that time, most American success literature has focussed on better techniques or gimmicks to get what you want. Much of it gives a nod to ethics and morality, but from what I’ve seen “a nod” ends up in collapse. One must hold firmly to sound moral values (and if need be, picking one’s self up after a fall, repenting, and persisting toward the original [worthy] goal.)
 
James_2:24:
Surprised by Truth… or I think it’s called “Journeys home”
These are 2 different books. Both are really good!

Rome Sweet Home by Scott & Kimberly Hahn

Go to catholicity.com/ & order “The Conversion of Scott Hahn” audio cassette & give it to them. ALL Mary Foundation audio tapes are FREE, & VERY good.
 
Dmath said:
“Crossing The Tiber” is an excellant book. Written by a former Protestant.

I second that. It was written by Steve Ray, a former evangelical. It has a good discussion on Baptism and the Eucharist, central issues in the Catholic-Protestant dispute.

Gerry 🙂
 
If I gave him the catechism I would also give him the companion volume that has all the resources for the footnotes, so he can self-guide his further study.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top