Top misconceptions Non-Catholic Christians have of Catholics

  • Thread starter Thread starter catholica
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Another that gets me is the
“Catholic repeat prayers when counting beads and Christ said that we should not repeat prayers in vain”

:whacky:
 
The upside down cross at St. Peters Bascilica is Satanic…
(Peter was crucified upside down by Nero)

I get really sick of that one…
 
Catholics are not allowed to read the Bible.

The Pope is the Anti Christ - the Church is the Whore of Babylon from the book of Revelation (which they add Catholics would know if they were allowed to read the Bible)

:nope:
 
40.png
Ignatius:
You were very poorly taught. Please take the time to correctly learn the Catholic Faith and what it teaches.

There are basically three ways you can be a christian; as a Catholic, as an Orthodox, or as a Protestant. If you follow the teachings of the 16th century “reformers”, then you are a protestant even if you don’t want to admit it.

May the Lord bless and keep you.
Seems to me that if the Church had done a good job all through my Catechism and Confirmation classes, I wouldn’t have had to go down this road…

Example: A month ago I go to my Priest to ask for advice on where to find answers (books, scripture, etc.) on the early church, on protestantism. He says he’ll get back to me- and never does.
 
I am not a Protestant, I was raised Catholic- but I have many questions regarding the RC Church.
It seems that the Church believes that Christ died on the cross to give us the “opportunity” to go to heaven.
Catholics have to partake in the sacraments and do good works to even hope of getting into purgatory.
Seems against the scripture and it makes insufficient our Lord’s sacrifice
Not at all.

It’s very biblical, in fact.

Without Christ’s sacrifice, no one could have the “opportunity” to go to heaven. Does any Christian say otherwise? Does any Christian say that he or she is WORTHY of heaven? Catholics don’t. We acknowledge that His death and resurrection is THE most important event in history.

Regarding works, haven’t you read James? Faith without works is dead. We are saved by grace (there’s that sacrifice of Christ), through faith (yep, we believe in faith) and a LIVING faith MUST have works. As James says, loosely paraphrased, if I see my poor, starving, naked neighbor and greet him blithely with “Good luck and God keep you (that faith statement)–keep warm and well fed” and I MYSELF do NOTHING to clothe or feed said neighbor (there’s those works), then my “faith”, my belief in God, my words of “God keep you” MEAN NOTHING.

Whatever you do for the least of these, YOU DO FOR ME.

Sacraments are part of our lives in Christ. Baptism is required for a Christian–in baptism we die to sin and live in Christ. Jesus instituted Reconciliation (and Paul and James second him) by telling us to confess our faults, and by Jesus giving his apostles (and those in succession) the right to “bind and loose”. Holy Eucharist is the unbloody sacrifice of Jesus which He asked of us to do “in remembrance of Me”. And of course we know from John that Jesus told us to “eat His flesh and drink His blood”, and that those who did so, “remain in Me, and I in them”, and that unless we do eat of His flesh, we shall not have life within us. Confirmation makes us all “priests, prophets and kings” through the power of the Holy Spirit (sent to us by Christ). Holy Orders brings men into succession of the apostles; Christ Himself was a priest in the order of Melchisedek–who predates ABRAHAM, let alone Aaron’s priests. . .Matrimony was given its sacramental character by Jesus when He noted that a man and a woman were to marry and become one flesh; Extreme Unction or Sacrament of the Sick is also biblical; we are reminded in the NT. . .is any among you sick? Bring him to the leaders (priests) for healing and prayer, for the prayer of a righteous man does much. . .
 
40.png
GodSoldier:
I am not a Protestant, I was raised Catholic- but I have many questions regarding the RC Church.

It seems that the Church believes that Christ died on the cross to give us the “opportunity” to go to heaven.

Catholics have to partake in the sacraments and do good works to even hope of getting into purgatory.

Seems against the scripture and it makes insufficient our Lord’s sacrifice.
Time for some real Catholic Answers LOL!
GS… have a look at this site that will hook you up with some of the best Catholic courses around and are all FREE.
It’s Catholic Home Study Service amm.org/chss/chss.htm
I completed them all and it brought me “home”. I discovered that a great deal of what I’d heard “about” the faith form n-Cs was waaay wrong. Enjoy! They really are some of the best stuff I’ve found.
Pax vobiscum,
 
The Catholic Church is an institution of unbelieving men. The real Church is made up of all “true believers.”
 
40.png
mercygate:
The Catholic Church is an institution of unbelieving men. The real Church is made up of all “true believers.”
Why, oh why, then would we call ourselves followers of Christ if we are unbelievers? 90% of our tenets are the same as yours: Christ’s divinity, hypostatic union, the Trinity, inerrancy of Scripture etc etc… If you say we are unbelievers, then then 90% of what you believe yourself fall into this category!
 
40.png
catholica:
I’ve been sitting on www.catholictruths.com for over a year now and am moved to get some good content on it. It will never be the awesome site that we have here, but I want to start with some good material on the most common misconceptions Protestants have of Catholics.

What, from your experience, are the top misconceptions Protestants have of Catholics and/or Catholicism.

Thanks, all!
From my debating experience with the prots:

Where does it say that in the Bible?

Catholics place Mary above Jesus.

Catholics worship the Pope.

The Apostolic succession ended with the deaths of Peter and Paul.

The title ‘Pope’ is no where mentioned in the Bible though other titles are, e.g. Bishop, patriarch, elder, etc.

All my debates and research on the protestant line of thinking has just reinforced my belief in Catholic theology all the more. The Protestant line of arguing is very weak.
 
Awesome stuff, folks! Please, others…keep 'em coming!

Y’all are helping me motivate!
 
Paris Blues:
Oh my word! You’ve got to be kidding me!!!:eek: That’s too crazy!
Not just cannibals, but cannibals AND vampires. Whereas they’re just symbolic cannibals and vampires, so they’re OK. 🙂
 
If nobody’s added this one yet, infant baptism (vs. baptism of believers, which is of course just symbolic).

Also, Original Sin. Protestants can’t make up their minds about babies. Are they sinless? In which case, why do they need a savior? Or are they tainted by sin? In which case, what sin have they committed? You’ll get answers all over the lot on these questions from protestants.
 
Remember when the Catholic Church ADDED books to the Bible?
 
Kevin Walker:
From my debating experience with the prots:

Where does it say that in the Bible?

Catholics place Mary above Jesus.

Catholics worship the Pope.

The Apostolic succession ended with the deaths of Peter and Paul.

The title ‘Pope’ is no where mentioned in the Bible though other titles are, e.g. Bishop, patriarch, elder, etc.

Also to continue:

The non-denominational Christian, i.e. Protestant, feels there will be no unity within Christianity because of disagreement about where authority is or where all to gather information about being a Christian; that in scripture acts of obedience are separate from works; that by the time of the Council of Nicea the apostles had all died and the Church split the role of elder into Bishop & Elder; that non-denominational Christians see no scriptural authority for the Pope or positions higher than congregational elders; and because of no Biblical example of an apostle being replaced after Paul joined the group they discount the conjecture of Catholic history because of no Biblical proof of the apostolic succession.

Interesting that for a group of Bible readers who believe in a literal interpretation of the Bible, they’re not afraid of interpretation! Makes me more and more of a (Roman) Catholic every day!

All my debates and research on the protestant line of thinking has just reinforced my belief in Catholic theology all the more. The Protestant line of arguing is very weak.
 
In addition to many misconceptions already listed:

You’re Catholic and you read the bible!?

I’d like to add that a whole lot of what you hear on the internet from Catholics contributes to the misconceptions/accusations we receive about heaven and works.
 
40.png
Pug:
In addition to many misconceptions already listed:

You’re Catholic and you read the bible!?
Not to mention that the Catholic Church forbade the people from reading the bible, and burned bibles.
 
40.png
VociMike:
Not to mention that the Catholic Church forbade the people from reading the bible, and burned bibles.
:eek: You’re right, and I forgot to mention chaining up the bible and always refusing to translate it into the vernacular.
 
I’ve had Protestants state the following:

!. We worship statues and idols
2. They never understand the concept of an annulment
3. We worship Mary
4. They argue there is no purgatory

Karen
 
Holy Smoke!

(…we are allowed to use that colloquialism, aren’t we?😃 )

This reminds me of another potential ‘feature’ for the site: All of the things we say, do and see everyday that have Catholic roots …but I digress.

Not only are you giving me some excellent ideas, you’re taking me back in time. With nearly every post I’m reminded of people and places where I’ve run into these issues.

You’re really bringing me some blasts from the past!

Thank you, thank you, thank you all!
 
40.png
mercygate:
Peter was never in Rome.
Virtually every unbiased scholar who has done any research in the area at all will agree that Peter was indeed in Rome. Not only was he there, but he was killed there by being crucified upside down, and was buried there. The evidence, for those who truly seek the truth, is readily available from multiple public sources. You need to do a little homework and stop parroting the falsehoods that were told to you.

I apologize for being so blunt, but it takes so little effort to determine the truth of these matters that failure to do so is really inexcusable.

God Bless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top