TSA ejects Oceanside man from airport for refusing security check

  • Thread starter Thread starter wabrams
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Pretty much. I am digging the “refuse the scan” protest that people are encouraging the day before Thanksgiving, called the “National Opt-Out Day”.

palmbeachpost.com/accent/travel/body-scanners-prompt-opt-out-protest-on-peak-1050347.html?showComments=true

Actually, the Airlines are going to have to do the heavy lifting on this one. As soon as this nonsense affects their bottom lines, they will petition Congress to change the rules. We just have to vote with our wallets. With the exception of a family emergency trip to Puerto Rico last year, I haven’t flown anywhere in over 5 years. I take the train, the bus, or I drive. In fact, the Accela from Washington DC to New York City takes less time than flying, if you take into account going through security, the flight itself, baggage claim, and taking a cab in from the outskirts of town. Plus, its cheaper.
Hitting them in the pocketbook is the only thing that will get their attention. What good is an electronic strip search machine at an airport with nobody to use it on?
 
Hitting them in the pocketbook is the only thing that will get their attention. What good is an electronic strip search machine at an airport with nobody to use it on?
Exactly. Not interested in some puppet in a “private room” looking at effectively nude pictures of my 5 year old daughter or her being subject to an “enhanced pat-down”, which includes a groin search. If I can’t drive there, I don’t need to be there. Airlines are getting wackadoo with their additional fees and stuff anyway. I refuse to fly. Plus, we are getting an RV for our long trips. We will actually get a chance to slow down and see the wonderful country we live in as a family.
 
The reality is that when flying you have a much better chance of dying in a crash than you do because someone turned their underwear into a bomb. Blowing up a plane accomplishes almost nothing, and it is pretty much impossible to hijack a plane with an underpants bomb anyway (what with armed air marshals and locked cockpit doors that won’t be opened in flight).

Getting on a plane is always a risk, security is a good way to minimize that risk, but there are limits to just how much you can minimize it.
 
I do not recall any public complaints that security was not tight enough from anyone.

Can you post some kind of reference for this supposition?
This was my personal account. I heard it from loads of people after 9-11. But hey, that’s just me.
 
The reality is that when flying you have a much better chance of dying in a crash than you do because someone turned their underwear into a bomb. Blowing up a plane accomplishes almost nothing, and it is pretty much impossible to hijack a plane with an underpants bomb anyway (what with armed air marshals and locked cockpit doors that won’t be opened in flight).

Getting on a plane is always a risk, security is a good way to minimize that risk, but there are limits to just how much you can minimize it.
To say destroying a plane accomplishes nothing is silly. Of course it accomplishes something. It instills terror and a fear of flying which would disrupt air-traffic immensely.

Additionally, all it takes is one successful bomb deployed midair to take down a plane and guess who everyone is going to blame? The government - for not protecting its citizens.

Percents or statistics of such and such happening aren’t the case here. It’s been shown, and attempts have been made, therefore the threat is real. And a real threat, must be considered and dealt with accordingly.

You can’t guard against “likelihood” - you have to prevent it from ever becoming a reality.

It seems the technology offered by back-scatter x-rays offers a better chance a prevention than anything we’ve been able to come up with so far, hence the governments use of it. Until someone else comes up with a better plan (and I haven’t read of any yet) what else can we do? I hear a lot of complaining, but no alternative solutions offered.
 
How far does Gov’t TSA security have to go before enough is enough? Many European countries have MUCH tighter security at every border than we do, yet there’s nothing remotely as intrusive or dangerous to our health as these STUPID “precautions.”

We don’t know what the radiation damage may be – it hasn’t been in use long enough, nor was it tested long enough, to say for sure. For that matter, we don’t know long-term effects of any electronic device or medical scan.

Why should we give up our Constitutionally-guaranteed civil rights just to get on an airplane?

I’ve traveled to Europe enough in the last ten years to know I won’t even consider getting on a flight, either to a domestic or foreign destination, until this security BS is greatly modified to not include unchosen radiation risks and what amounts to legalized molestation.

The TSA has the most far-reaching authority and control of any government agency and its employees are, by far, the rudest, least-well-trained, uneducated, and over-the-top power monger buffoons I’ve ever seen (example: Miami and Atlanta airports).

It’s criminal (literally) what is being done in the name of “security” and we’ve been too brainwashed to stand up and say NO.
 
Then why are we leaving the government in charge of it? What smart thing does the government ever do? They spend too much and take too long to do a half-a** job of everything. I do know that the charter flight industry is totally loving the TSA Peep and Grope Show. You can fly on a chartered plane without all of the nonsense. Costs more, but maintaining my personal dignity and the dignity of my children is worth it to save them from the mechanations of some paid-by-the-hour TSA security rube pawing all over them.
+1
 
To say destroying a plane accomplishes nothing is silly. Of course it accomplishes something. It instills terror and a fear of flying which would disrupt air-traffic immensely.

Additionally, all it takes is one successful bomb deployed midair to take down a plane and guess who everyone is going to blame? The government - for not protecting its citizens.

Percents or statistics of such and such happening aren’t the case here. It’s been shown, and attempts have been made, therefore the threat is real. And a real threat, must be considered and dealt with accordingly.

You can’t guard against “likelihood” - you have to prevent it from ever becoming a reality.

It seems the technology offered by back-scatter x-rays offers a better chance a prevention than anything we’ve been able to come up with so far, hence the governments use of it. Until someone else comes up with a better plan (and I haven’t read of any yet) what else can we do? I hear a lot of complaining, but no alternative solutions offered.
Well you can follow the solution we adopted in this family, if we can’t get there without flying we don’t go. You know, as many Hardee’s as I’ve pulled into on the road not one has asked to do a strip search!
 
To say destroying a plane accomplishes nothing is silly. Of course it accomplishes something. It instills terror and a fear of flying which would disrupt air-traffic immensely.
I didn’t say it accomplishes nothing, I said it accomplishes almost nothing. Given that failed attempts make people so paranoid that they would agree to be molested in order to fly means that actually doing it would result in even more paranoia.
Additionally, all it takes is one successful bomb deployed midair to take down a plane and guess who everyone is going to blame? The government - for not protecting its citizens.
No crazy radicals are to blame, anyone who didn’t do their job properly in screening is to blame, the government is to blame only if they could have done something reasonable to prevent it. Feeling up passengers is not reasonable in my book. Metal detectors and regular x-ray scans are fine.
Percents or statistics of such and such happening aren’t the case here. It’s been shown, and attempts have been made, therefore the threat is real. And a real threat, must be considered and dealt with accordingly.
No one said there isn’t a threat. A real threat should be considered and dealt with accordingly. Violating people because of a slim one in a million threat is not reasonable. I’d rather have a .00001% higher chance of dying on a plane than go through this sort of stupidity.
You can’t guard against “likelihood” - you have to prevent it from ever becoming a reality.
Well clearly the best way to prevent anything is to prevent people from bringing anything on the plane, even the clothes on their backs, and having a proctologist examine them before boarding. We’re only about two steps away from that now, might as well go the rest of the way.
It seems the technology offered by back-scatter x-rays offers a better chance a prevention than anything we’ve been able to come up with so far, hence the governments use of it. Until someone else comes up with a better plan (and I haven’t read of any yet) what else can we do? I hear a lot of complaining, but no alternative solutions offered.
I just came up with a better plan. It would catch 100% of all things. None of this selective screening nonsense. You wouldn’t even need metal detectors. It’s about as reasonable as molesting people before boarding.
 
I hope you’re joking, b/c that picture is an example of something improper. I’ve yet to here of Catholics declaring holoy war against the USA.
Yet you demonstrate the exact reason profiling does not work well. How do you know this is a nun, or how would a security person know this was a nun?

Profiling allows for any serious terrorist to modify appearance to avoid his or her appearance in order to avoid screen. Right now, such a modification is unnecessary,
 
Exactly. Not interested in some puppet in a “private room” looking at effectively nude pictures of my 5 year old daughter or her being subject to an “enhanced pat-down”, which includes a groin search. If I can’t drive there, I don’t need to be there. Airlines are getting wackadoo with their additional fees and stuff anyway. I refuse to fly.
Ditto. I told my wife last week that I am not going to fly again until the TSA backs off of this madness. The rest of country, even real police, are not allowed to conduct unwarranted searches and need probable cause. Yet somehow we have allowed the Constitution to be suspended for airports.
 
Yet you demonstrate the exact reason profiling does not work well. How do you know this is a nun, or how would a security person know this was a nun?

Profiling allows for any serious terrorist to modify appearance to avoid his or her appearance in order to avoid screen. Right now, such a modification is unnecessary,
Profiling is not perfect, but it is an alternative that has worked well in other countries.

How do you know that is a nun? You don’t.
But security should already know who bought the ticket and be able to check that credential fairly quickly. There would be effort in perfecting the process, but it would certainly relieve the current problems we are having and likely be more effective.

Most tickets are sold in advance. Perhaps we should begin the security check at that point. By the time of the security checkpoint, they should know exactly who and what the person is and be able to assess their threat based on solid infoirmation.

Point the ‘enhanced’ pat downs and scanners at the real threats. Don’t waste time and resource trying to work everyone over.
 
From the article:

“By buying your ticket you gave up a lot of rights,” countered the TSA supervisor.

How did we ever let things progress this far in America. Totalitarian indeed. No, I will not fly again until basic human dignity applies to the TSA and the Constitution extends past the ticket counter.
 
It is improbable that a Nun would be a security threat, but not impossible.
Ya, I just checked. The Interwebs is teeming with reports of nuns blowing themselves to smithereens in the name of Jesus.
 
Most tickets are sold in advance. Perhaps we should begin the security check at that point. By the time of the security checkpoint, they should know exactly who and what the person is and be able to assess their threat based on solid infoirmation.
The Israelis do this, from what I hear. My former classmate spent time studying in Israel, and when she said that when she showed up at the airport, the airline’s security staff knew all about her and her family, and asked her a lot of questions.

Now, I think there are a lot of people who would protest that kind of background check as invasive etc., and perhaps with good reason, but that kind of system also is likely to be far more effective than the current system, which is primarily security theater.

(PS – the head of Israeli airport security has said in numerous media interviews that the full-body scanners are a waste of money. I’m more inclined to trust his word than TSA’s, since the former secretary of the Department of Homeland Security is now making money from the company making these scanners. Hmm.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top