TSA ejects Oceanside man from airport for refusing security check

  • Thread starter Thread starter wabrams
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Profiling is not perfect, but it is an alternative that has worked well in other countries.

How do you know that is a nun? You don’t.
But security should already know who bought the ticket and be able to check that credential fairly quickly. There would be effort in perfecting the process, but it would certainly relieve the current problems we are having and likely be more effective.

Most tickets are sold in advance. Perhaps we should begin the security check at that point. By the time of the security checkpoint, they should know exactly who and what the person is and be able to assess their threat based on solid infoirmation.

Point the ‘enhanced’ pat downs and scanners at the real threats. Don’t waste time and resource trying to work everyone over.
This is an excellent point. Why aren’t they starting at the very beginning with the purchase of the ticket? If you start there than you can avoid a lot of this nonsense that’s currently going on and you would be more likely to catch the guys before they get to the airport.

I honestly can not see how this jives with the Constitution. The Constitution specifically states that we are protected against unlawful search and seizure. As it was already pointed out the police can not even do what the TSA is being allowed to do.

It’s a sad day when the law abiding citizen in the US gets treated like a common criminal. 😦
 
Mr Skeptic;7274407:
It is improbable that a Nun would be a security threat, but not impossible.
Ya, I just checked. The Interwebs is teeming with reports of nuns blowing themselves to smithereens in the name of Jesus.
If that were the case, then my remarks, especially the “improbable” part, would not apply, smartass.
 
If that were the case, then my remarks, especially the “improbable” part, would not apply, smartass.
Is it your contention that we should continue to devote resources to the improbable rather then the probable?

Remember, the funding for TSA is finite, so it is a zero sum game.
Focus on the improbable necessitates moving focus from the probable.
 
I merely made a passing remark. Nothing more.

“It is improbable that a Nun would be a security threat, but not impossible.”

Is that statement true or false?
 
Whatever we “do about it”, the rules should be applied equally. That’s all I am saying.
All I (and others) are saying is that we have a finite amount of resources to dedicate to airport security, so focusing on this 'one size fits all" solution is patently stupid, ineffective, and a blatant waste of taxpayer resources. To rejoin my earlier comment, a quick search for “violence perpetrated by nuns” and even “violence perpetrated by people posing as nuns” comes up with zilch. Doing body cavity searches on nuns is, without a doubt, a utter waste of time, energy, money, manpower, and dignity.
 
All I (and others) are saying is that we have a finite amount of resources to dedicate to airport security, so focusing on this 'one size fits all" solution is patently stupid, ineffective, and a blatant waste of taxpayer resources. To rejoin my earlier comment, a quick search for “violence perpetrated by nuns” and even “violence perpetrated by people posing as nuns” comes up with zilch. Doing body cavity searches on nuns is, without a doubt, a utter waste of time, energy, money, manpower, and dignity.
First off, you’re embellishing in order to make some point. The nun in the picture was getting patted down, not body cavity searched.

Would you like it if the TSA exempted all nuns from being searched?
 
Whatever we “do about it”, the rules should be applied equally. That’s all I am saying.
Agreed!

We should use the same criteria across the board to determine who is or is not the greatest threat.
Then we should concentrate our security checkpoints upon those individuals that represent the greatest threat.
 
First off, you’re embellishing in order to make some point. The nun in the picture was getting patted down, not body cavity searched.
That’s coming. just wait.
Would you like it if the TSA exempted all nuns from being searched?
I would prefer it if TSA did minimal searches upon those that pose minimum risk and more invasive searches upon those that pose a higher risk.

Exempting anyone should not be an option.
The question should be one of degrees.
 
Since 9/11 the majority of terrorist attempts have not been by men of middle-eastern descent nor were the obvious Muslims. The only easy and effective profiling we could have based on current data is that adult males are more likely to be a source of trouble. Even then terrorists haven’t been above using children in other cases so that profiling wouldn’t even be terribly effective if they made it obvious. Really profiling is most effective when you don’t tell people you are doing it. The best method the TSA could possibly employ if they were going to profile people is constantly denying that profiling occurred.
 
Since 9/11 the majority of terrorist attempts have not been by men of middle-eastern descent nor were the obvious Muslims. The only easy and effective profiling we could have based on current data is that adult males are more likely to be a source of trouble. Even then terrorists haven’t been above using children in other cases so that profiling wouldn’t even be terribly effective if they made it obvious. Really profiling is most effective when you don’t tell people you are doing it. The best method the TSA could possibly employ if they were going to profile people is constantly denying that profiling occurred.
And yet Israel has been employing profiling for a couple of decades now and have a relatively spotless record.
 
The answer to all of this is simple. If you don’t want a stranger gawking at your junk on a flouroscopy, don’t fly. If you don’t want a stranger fondling your junk or your children, don’t fly. Flying in an airplane is not a Constitutional right, it is a privelege. Therefore, if you choose to participate in this priviledged method of rapid travel, you are volunteering to be searched, invasively. I don’t, so I don’t fly. Its simple. If enough people adopt this philosophy, the airlines will feel their junk get squeezed enough that they will lobby Congress to get the methods changed. But us little peon tax-slaves mean nothing to big daddy government.
 
The answer to all of this is simple. If you don’t want a stranger gawking at your junk on a flouroscopy, don’t fly. If you don’t want a stranger fondling your junk or your children, don’t fly. Flying in an airplane is not a Constitutional right, it is a privelege. Therefore, if you choose to participate in this priviledged method of rapid travel, you are volunteering to be searched, invasively. I don’t, so I don’t fly. Its simple. If enough people adopt this philosophy, the airlines will feel their junk get squeezed enough that they will lobby Congress to get the methods changed. But us little peon tax-slaves mean nothing to big daddy government.
But it’s not that simple. Countless people have no choice but to fly, especially if their job requires it. They are faced with the decision to either be groped or lose their livelihood. That’s what this ultimately comes down to.

As for me? I will not be flying, neither will my kids…unless/until this madness is dealt with. But not everybody has the luxury to make that decision for themselves. I know my mom doesn’t. She will have to fly for work, and she will be traumatized by these security procedures.

Another issue brought up in an article I read is there are a lot of abuse survivors struggling with this.
 
Then why are we leaving the government in charge of it? What smart thing does the government ever do? They spend too much and take too long to do a half-a** job of everything. I do know that the charter flight industry is totally loving the TSA Peep and Grope Show. You can fly on a chartered plane without all of the nonsense. Costs more, but maintaining my personal dignity and the dignity of my children is worth it to save them from the mechanations of some paid-by-the-hour TSA security rube pawing all over them.
👍
 
But it’s not that simple. Countless people have no choice but to fly, especially if their job requires it. They are faced with the decision to either be groped or lose their livelihood. That’s what this ultimately comes down to.

As for me? I will not be flying, neither will my kids…unless/until this madness is dealt with. But not everybody has the luxury to make that decision for themselves. I know my mom doesn’t. She will have to fly for work, and she will be traumatized by these security procedures.

Another issue brought up in an article I read is there are a lot of abuse survivors struggling with this.
I saw Mark Steyn and Lennie Davis debating this on Hannity tonight. Steyn (who was great, as always) made the observation that two days he had to go through a Burlington, Vermont Airport Security Check and there was a woman whom he observed as INDEED being TRAUMATIZED by one of these “security procedures.” Davis, of course, defended the whole thing and refused to admit there was an element of Political Correctness regarding Muslims and Middle Eastern people in general regarding this. But Steyn called him u; onit. Good episode. So I know what you are talking about, 👍
 
And yet Israel has been employing profiling for a couple of decades now and have a relatively spotless record.
Indeed.

I always remember Wesley Snipes’s line in “Passenger 57” (I think that was the name of the movie)----where he said something to the effect that the BEST Airport Screening was the Israeli Model because the Terrorists “never get on the Plane.”😛

Still remember that line and agree with it.
 
The answer to all of this is simple. If you don’t want a stranger gawking at your junk on a flouroscopy, don’t fly. If you don’t want a stranger fondling your junk or your children, don’t fly. Flying in an airplane is not a Constitutional right, it is a privelege. Therefore, if you choose to participate in this priviledged method of rapid travel, you are volunteering to be searched, invasively. I don’t, so I don’t fly. Its simple.
Now that is the case. One thing I am ticked off about this is how it was instituted and became instantaneously mandatory. Most people going through this indignity this month did** not** agree to this evasive procedure when they bought the ticket. I expect now that this policy is in place that airline travel will drop off.
 
Most people going through this indignity this month did** not** agree to this evasive procedure when they bought the ticket. I expect now that this policy is in place that airline travel will drop off.
Right.
And once the bottom line for the airlines is hit, the pendulum will begin swinging back.

I expect we will never see a happy medium such has been found in other countries.
The atmosphere in the US is simply too politically charged.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top