UN staff killed in Afghan protest over Quran burning in US

  • Thread starter Thread starter SwizzleStick
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Did I say that? You need to hone your reading or reasoning skills.
So it was stupid for the pastor to burn the Koran, but you’re not going to hold him liable in any form for the harm it causes. This is called giving free range to his (the pastors) hate speech. If you can’t agree he needs to be held accountable for his actions then it seems to me like you think this is ok. Are there other moral issues that you feel strongly about but don’t hold people accountable for?
 
This isn’t a butterfly effect insofar as a butterfly wing will cause a hurricane in Japan. These killers very clearly reacted directly to the burning of their holy text. If the pastor didn’t commit this kind of hate speech those people would probably be alive today. When you can clearly see the effects of your actions then we’re past butterfly here.
I think that you are confusing between a trigger and a source of moral responsibility. Again I something that triggers my reaction does not have automatically responsibility for my bad behaviors. Usually it is about my issues and not about the trigger. Unrelated factors can trigger my reactions.
 
"UN death toll in Afghan attack may hit 20

Deaths occur when demonstrations turn violent over a reported Quran burning in the US, official says

KABUL, Afghanistan — The death toll in an attack on the U.N. compound in the northern Afghan city of Mazar-i-Sharif could be as high as 20 after a protest turned violent in response to a reported Quran-burning in the United States, officials tell Reuters. "…

Entire article: msnbc.msn.com/id/42376051/ns/world_news-south_and_central_asia/
 
This isn’t a butterfly effect insofar as a butterfly wing will cause a hurricane in Japan. These killers very clearly reacted directly to the burning of their holy text. If the pastor didn’t commit this kind of hate speech those people would probably be alive today. When you can clearly see the effects of your actions then we’re past butterfly here.
These …people…would have found another religiously inspired reason to kill other innocents. Being Christian, gay, female who dares to show her face in public or get an education, etc…
 
So it was stupid for the pastor to burn the Koran, but you’re not going to hold him liable in any form for the harm it causes. This is called giving free range to his (the pastors) hate speech. If you can’t agree he needs to be held accountable for his actions then it seems to me like you think this is ok. Are there other moral issues that you feel strongly about but don’t hold people accountable for?
Are you saying that it was right to kill innocents in order to held the pastor accountable? Are you say that religious terrorism is justified against Christians? Is this your moral take? Should we give free range to murderers?
 
I think that you are confusing between a trigger and a source of moral responsibility. Again I something that triggers my reaction does not have automatically responsibility for my bad behaviors. Usually it is about my issues and not about the trigger. Unrelated factors can trigger my reactions.
I don’t think so. Example, guns don’t kill people, people who pull the trigger on guns kill people. Burning the Koran doesn’t incite violence. A pastor going out of his way to make it public / worldwide knowledge that he’s burning the Koran can incite violence.
 
These …people…would have found another religiously inspired reason to kill other innocents. Being Christian, gay, female who dares to show her face in public or get an education, etc…
These killers might have found another excuse, or maybe not. You’re jumping to conclusions. This doesn’t excuse the pastor for giving them one.
 
Are you saying that it was right to kill innocents in order to held the pastor accountable?
No. That should be clear by now.
Are you say that religious terrorism is justified against Christians?
Didn’t say that either.
Is this your moral take? Should we give free range to murderers?
No, but we should hold everyone who incites violence, to those who commit it accountable for their actions.
 
I’m guessing he hated the people who read the book. Why else would you burn the Koran if not to dishearten its readers?

So you’re saying it’s ok to burn any book, like the bible? And that clearly, burning the bible in no way is directing hate towards Christians? That’ll be a tough to justify IMO.
If someone burned a bible, I’d offer them a fire extinguisher and some aloe if they hurt themselves. God isn’t contained in a book. Thats the wonky thing about some Muslims. They are forbidden to make images of God or Muhammed, yet they commit idolatry in how they treat the Koran. Its just paper, glue, ink, and leather.
 
If someone burned a bible, I’d offer them a fire extinguisher and some aloe if they hurt themselves. God isn’t contained in a book. Thats the wonky thing about some Muslims. They are forbidden to make images of God or Muhammed, yet they commit idolatry in how they treat the Koran. Its just paper, glue, ink, and leather.
So because the cultural significance to you is minimal, you’re going to hold the middle east to that standard? Personally, I think you might feel differently if I left a burning bible on your door step.
 
These killers might have found another excuse, or maybe not. You’re jumping to conclusions. This doesn’t excuse the pastor for giving them one.
These people don’t need one.
 
So because the cultural significance to you is minimal, you’re going to hold the middle east to that standard? Personally, I think you might feel differently if I left a burning bible on your door step.
No, not really. Wanna come over. We can have a beer or two and enjoy the flames. Well, Imight get a little miffed if I got in trouble with my HAO for that little stunt.
 
It’s a terrible thing that there are people in this world so depraved as to kill innocent people over this.

The pastor shouldn’t lose a single liberty over some nutjob’s demented insane reactions.
 
It’s a terrible thing that there are people in this world so depraved as to kill innocent people over this.

The pastor shouldn’t lose a single liberty over some nutjob’s demented insane reactions.
Religious book burning should probably be as protected as flag burning. It’s through this pastor’s actions 8 people are dead. Why are you promoting this man’s right to incite hatred against readers of the Koran?
 
You’re making assumptions again. It won’t change the fact that 8 people are dead over a pastor burning the Koran.
No, there are 8 people dead because of some insane, delusional people.
 
No, not really. Wanna come over. We can have a beer or two and enjoy the flames. Well, Imight get a little miffed if I got in trouble with my HAO for that little stunt.
Where you live? I’m out in CA, it might make it a little difficult. Maybe we can skype about it 😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top