C
cmudd
Guest
cmudd;2842793:
Is there any way to demand a better bishop from Rome?
We do not have a right to demand anything from Rome. That is presumptuous. Benedict XVI is the pope- not any of us. He is in charge- not any of us. Respect the wisdom and guidance of the Holy Father, and trust in his fidelity to the Chair of St. Peter- which God has ordained he should fill.
QUOTE]
Please don’t misunderstand me. I have great faith that God will not let his Church go astray. I also have great faith in BXVI. But that does not mean that he is above making poor appointments nor does it mean that we cannot demand things from Rome. We can and should demand that we are given orthodox leadership. We must demand that we are given access to licit sacraments. I am not writing about being hostile. These are things that are guaranteed us by the Church itself, outlined in cannon law and in Church history. We do ourselves and the Church a great justice by demanding these things.
If a pope was creating scandal by having a live-in girlfreind, would we not be allowed to demand that he behave?
Great saints have demanded from the papacy, too (Teresa of Avila). Again, I’m not writing about challenging, being presumtuous or being hostile, but we have the obligation to demand orthodoxy from our leaders.
That being said, I belive that BXVI has the Church’s best interests in mind, but neither he nor JPII or any other pope is amune from appointing bad bishops. I don’t think that AB Neiderauer is living up to our hopes and prayer over there in SF nor is Cardinal Mahony really the posterchild for orthodoxy in the Church.
Should we sit back and thank His Holiness for giving us desasterous men as leaders or should we humbly and persistently inform him that we need better?