"We Believe Scripture, Except When It Supports Catholic Dogma"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Teflon93
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Just one comment/question…

Why is the term “Roman Catholic” that offensive anyway?

In my small community there is a road sign “St. Anthony’s Roman Catholic Church” with a left arrow pointer (it might be abbreviated RC I forgot) to a small Roman Catholic church.

It would seem to me that if St. Anthony’s Roman Catholic Church can call themselves Roman Catholic that y’all shouldn’t get all hot under the collar if an anonymous internet poster calls you that.
The problem is that they say “The Roman Catholic Church believes/teaches…” as if the Maronite, Ruthenian, Byzantine, Alexandrian, Syriac, Armenian, Chaldean, etc. Catholic Churches do not. Giving them the benefit of the doubt, I’d say that probably they are not aware of the 22 other Rites that are just as Catholic as the Roman (Latin) Rite.

The Catechism is called the Catechism of the Catholic Church, not the Catechism of the Roman Catholic Church. The Church is much bigger than the Latin Rite. Nothing wrong with a parish identifying which Rite it is, but when statements are made about Church teaching, it’s important to know that these teachings are not exclusively “Roman” teachings.
 
The problem is that they say “The Roman Catholic Church believes/teaches…” as if the Maronite, Ruthenian, Byzantine, Alexandrian, Syriac, Armenian, Chaldean, etc. Catholic Churches do not. Giving them the benefit of the doubt, I’d say that probably they are not aware of the 22 other Rites that are just as Catholic as the Roman (Latin) Rite.

The Catechism is called the Catechism of the Catholic Church, not the Catechism of the Roman Catholic Church. The Church is much bigger than the Latin Rite. Nothing wrong with a parish identifying which Rite it is, but when statements are made about Church teaching, it’s important to know that these teachings are not exclusively “Roman” teachings.
OK.

I can understand that from a Catholic perspective the term Roman Catholic is imprecise and confusing.

However, the statement was made that the term “Roman Catholic” was insulting. There is a difference between “imprecise and confusing” and “insulting”.

I have a hard time believing that St. Anthony’s would use an “insulting” and “offensive” phrase (albeit in other contexts) in its road sign.
 
OK.

I can understand that from a Catholic perspective the term Roman Catholic is imprecise and confusing.

However, the statement was made that the term “Roman Catholic” was insulting. There is a difference between “imprecise and confusing” and “insulting”.
Normally, Roman Catholic doesn’t bother me personally, as much as “Romish” or “Roman” (though I admit “Papist” just makes me giggle) without the “Catholic.” There is a world of difference between a Roman and a Roman Catholic, kwim?
I have a hard time believing that St. Anthony’s would use an “insulting” phrase in its road sign.
In that context it is not insulting, just identifying the Rite.
 
The problem is that they say “The Roman Catholic Church believes/teaches…” as if the Maronite, Ruthenian, Byzantine, Alexandrian, Syriac, Armenian, Chaldean, etc. Catholic Churches do not. Giving them the benefit of the doubt, I’d say that probably they are not aware of the 22 other Rites that are just as Catholic as the Roman (Latin) Rite.

The Catechism is called the Catechism of the Catholic Church, not the Catechism of the Roman Catholic Church. The Church is much bigger than the Latin Rite. Nothing wrong with a parish identifying which Rite it is, but when statements are made about Church teaching, it’s important to know that these teachings are not exclusively “Roman” teachings.
👍
 
Normally, Roman Catholic doesn’t bother me personally, as much as “Romish” or “Roman” (though I admit “Papist” just makes me giggle) without the “Catholic.” There is a world of difference between a Roman and a Roman Catholic, kwim?

In that context it is not insulting, just identifying the Rite.
Try being an Eastern Catholic and being called “Uniate”!:mad:
 
Try being an Eastern Catholic and being called “Uniate”!:mad:
OK, had to look that up.

n. a member of an Eastern church that is in union with the Roman Catholic Church, acknowledges the Roman pope as supreme in matters of faith, but maintains its own liturgy, discipline, and rite.

:confused: Isn’t that right? Does it depend on the tone of voice used that determines whether it’s meant as an adjective or an insult?
 
No, the term reflects what the writings are in his belief system. Why should he use your language.

Let me flip this around.

Say you are having the same discussion on Baptist Boards or something like that. If you referred to the writings as the Deuterocanonicals instead of the apocrypha, would it be fair for them to consider that an insult.

Calling this an insult reeks of hypersensitivity.
This is a Catholic forum. To refer to the Deuterocanonicals as uninspired literature such as Apocrypha is wrong and continued use of the term is offensive. It degrades the status of the Deuterocanonicals.

If I were on a Baptist Board, I would use their terminology, but in parenthesis explain my position.

I’ll change my opinion when the attacks on my Church stop. As for forgiving - you can’t forgive when people don’t apologize and continue to insult. You want to call that hypersensitivity - fine. I’ll continue to call it as I see it.
 
40.png
sodak:
I’ll change my opinion when the attacks on my Church stop. As for forgiving - you can’t forgive when people don’t apologize and continue to insult. You want to call that hypersensitivity - fine. I’ll continue to call it as I see it.
Here I go again telling you what you must do, sodak.

If you are a Christian, and you say you are, then you must forgive others, and your church teaches that protestants are Christians, albeit “separated” ones; therefore, you are commanded by God to forgive a perceived wrong/insult against you (cf Mt 6:14-15; 18:21-35; Eph 4:31-32). 🙂
 
And while we meander along, drbible1611 remains elusive.

I’ll keep track.

Day Three.
 
k, so we’re just bumping the thread till the other principal of the debate returns, right? Then we’ll get back on topic? 😉 😛 😉
 
k, so we’re just bumping the thread till the other principal of the debate returns, right? Then we’ll get back on topic? 😉 😛 😉
That’s the plan. I certainly don’t mind the OT meandering in the meantime.

I certainly hope drbible1611 isn’t merely running out the clock.
 
Here I go again telling you what you must do, sodak.

If you are a Christian, and you say you are, then you must forgive others, and your church teaches that protestants are Christians, albeit “separated” ones; therefore, you are commanded by God to forgive a perceived wrong/insult against you (cf Mt 6:14-15; 18:21-35; Eph 4:31-32). 🙂
Who says I haven’t? That doesn’t mean I can’t object to a new insult.

My Church doesn’t teach that I only forgive Christians. I’m glad that I take direction from my Church.

As for DrBible, I’m surprised that nobody has noticed - he’s been suspended. For how long, I don’t know.
 
As for DrBible, I’m surprised that nobody has noticed - he’s been suspended. For how long, I don’t know.
I just checked yesterday; he was posting in another thread.

Guess we’ll be waiting awhile.
 
Here I go again telling you what you must do, sodak.

If you are a Christian, and you say you are, then you must forgive others, and your church teaches that protestants are Christians, albeit “separated” ones; therefore, you are commanded by God to forgive a perceived wrong/insult against you (cf Mt 6:14-15; 18:21-35; Eph 4:31-32). 🙂
Sandusky is correct here, Sodak. When in doubt forgive, as you wish to be forgiven.

Here are the words you used.
40.png
sodak:
As for forgiving - you can’t forgive when people don’t apologize and continue to insult. You want to call that hypersensitivity - fine. I’ll continue to call it as I see it
I think Jesus managed to forgive the taunters while on the Cross. It’s a great example of what we are supposed to do. And before any “pot and kettle” comments come flying back at me, I’ll admit that I’m not always as forgiving as I should be.

Edited: Let me note that although I disagree with Sandy’s interpretation of the Scripture, I heartily agree with his plea for forgiving one another.
 
Here I go again telling you what you must do, sodak.

If you are a Christian, and you say you are, then you must forgive others, and your church teaches that protestants are Christians, albeit “separated” ones; therefore, you are commanded by God to forgive a perceived wrong/insult against you (cf Mt 6:14-15; 18:21-35; Eph 4:31-32). 🙂
As Protestants are our brothers and sisters, we are called upon to correct them:
Matthew 18 -
15: Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.
16: But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established.
17: And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican.
Misapplying Scripture is one of the things we need to correct you on, sandusky. We Catholics are Christians, after all, are we not?
 
drbible is a no show. So I PMd him. If he didn’t want to post he could simply say he didn’t see the thread. But I sent him the link for this thread & now there is no excuse. I look forward to reading his posts.
 
drbible is a no show. So I PMd him. If he didn’t want to post he could simply say he didn’t see the thread. But I sent him the link for this thread & now there is no excuse. I look forward to reading his posts.
Well, no excuse, except maybe the banning?
 
Sandusky is correct here, Sodak. When in doubt forgive, as you wish to be forgiven.
I ask you again, who says I haven’t? You seem to be quick in judging me.

Defending the faith and forgiving the apostate are 2 different things.
 
drbible is a no show. So I PMd him. If he didn’t want to post he could simply say he didn’t see the thread. But I sent him the link for this thread & now there is no excuse. I look forward to reading his posts.
Thanks, Sandy—hopefully he’ll drop in soon. It should be interesting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top