What are the reasons I should (or shouldn't) become Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Simple_Theist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why do u think that there is a lot of fundamentalism mainly in the religions that consider a book as the ultimate authority?. just as muslims and fundamentalist protestants do.
because for many people the surest way of knowing the will of god is through recorded revelations.

you must realize that in Islam fundamentalism is mainstream. and yet they are far less fragmented. why do you think that is?
the concept of sola scripture does do harm.
because people can say whatever they want about the book.
and yet there are far more more details, beliefs & rituals in Catholicism than the average Bible Christian.
The book has no authority by itself.
Realistically, Authorities lie in people, not in non-living objects.
 
There are so many beautiful reasons for me to be a Catholic; however, at each step of this journey I first had to pray for faith so that the riches that are rendered to us in our practice as Catholics are absorbed as what they are - real, genuine blessings, tools to reach and be with Christ. Pray for faith. God Bless you.
 
because for many people the surest way of knowing the will of god is through recorded revelations.

you must realize that in Islam fundamentalism is mainstream. and yet they are far less fragmented. why do you think that is?
I would say that it is becuase they have a book as an ultimate authority and that cause fragmantation. there r radical fundamentalist muslims and there are also peaceful muslims, that believe that non muslims also have rights. although they believe the 5 pillars they yet have huge diferences in other believes.

there is a diference among the institutions that have hierachies they all believe the same doctrines plus there is someone that is a guide that say what is good and wrong in order to guide the faithfull.
 
because for many people the surest way of knowing the will of god is through recorded revelations.
But they must be reliable and authentic, how would you determine that?
you must realize that in Islam fundamentalism is mainstream. and yet they are far less fragmented. why do you think that is?
Because you will be stoned to death if you are anything else in those countries
and yet there are far more more details, beliefs & rituals in Catholicism than the average Bible Christian.
Not the same thing as lots of religions and doctrines
Realistically, Authorities lie in people, not in non-living objects.
The CC represents Jesus on Earth.

Agnos, what happened to you over the week-end? Your usually biting sarcasm has become watered-down, weak
 
But they must be reliable and authentic, how would you determine that?
you will have to ask them that. 😃
The CC represents Jesus on Earth.
thats what they all say.
Agnos, what happened to you over the week-end? Your usually biting sarcasm has become watered-down, weak
ive been sick this weekend. cough, cold & not much sleep because of coughs & cold. right now i feel a little weak. thats why i started late in posting here…that i posted at all. 😦
 
ive been sick this weekend. cough, cold & not much sleep because of coughs & cold. right now i feel a little weak. thats why i started late in posting here…that i posted at all. 😦
I noticed you started late. Hmm…sounds like you’re fighting a battle here…:rolleyes:
 
History.
Either the history of the Christian religion (and I include in this the 1500 years before Luther!!!) demonstrates that the theology of the Catholics is the theology of the original Apostles in the Bible, or, it doesn’t.
I say history also.
Read The Lambs Supper by Scott Hahn and Surprised by Truth

That would be a start.
 
Scott Hahn is a typical convert, a radical. He scares the daylights out of me!
A man who has a deep love for God scares you? He isn’t your typical radical. I have read most of his books and they are inspiring and full of life. Scott Hahn is also a devout member of Opus Dei, a lay Catholic organization founded by Josemaria Escriva. Both my sisters are members of Opus Dei.
 
There are so many beautiful reasons for me to be a Catholic; however, at each step of this journey I first had to pray for faith so that the riches that are rendered to us in our practice as Catholics are absorbed as what they are - real, genuine blessings, tools to reach and be with Christ. Pray for faith. God Bless you.
Calls to mind that old Protestant proverb: “Some things, you just have to take on proof” 🙂
 
Scott Hahn is a typical convert, a radical. He scares the daylights out of me!
Scott Hahn was a Protestant Theologian. He accidentally discovered the truth in the Eucharist and was teaching it to a theology class. A former catholic student spoke up and explained he was teaching something the Catholics believe which ended up transubstantiation. He then converted.

Get the dvd. It is very good.
 
Scott Hahn was a Protestant Theologian. He accidentally discovered the truth in the Eucharist and was teaching it to a theology class. A former catholic student spoke up and explained he was teaching something the Catholics believe which ended up transubstantiation. He then converted.

Get the dvd. It is very good.
Scott Hahn was a Presbyterian, correct?
 
Scott Hahn was a Presbyterian, correct?
He was a minister in some form of small offshoot of the Presbyterian Church - his theology was somewhat different than mainstream Presbyterianism, though.

He got his start in Campus Crusade for Christ, which is an Evangelical organization, and the form of Presbyterianism that he practiced had quite a bit in common with the Evangelical movement.
 
Scott Hahn also believe in a concept of covenant family. This beliefs was very Catholic, and many of his Presbyterian accused that he will eventually become Catholic because of the concept of a covenant family that God establish first with Adam, then Noah, then Abraham, then Moses, and now with the New Covenant, which Jesus Christ Himself establish.
 
He got his start in Campus Crusade for Christ, which is an Evangelical organization, and the form of Presbyterianism that he practiced had quite a bit in common with the Evangelical movement.
Lots of Presbyterians are evangelical and always have been.

Edwin
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top