Ooooh… me, too! I don’t know if it’s the lyrics or Emmy Rossum’s voice that does it to me. I also like (from the movie soundtrack) the bonus by Minnie Driver “Learn to be Lonely”.“Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again” from Phantom tears me up.
Daeve–don’t worry, I don’t think I’ve EVER called “The Pina Colada Song” by it’s real name (no one knows it as “Escape” anyway… everyone calls it “The Pina Colada Song”!)
I seem to have missed the OP’s final line–“What do you belt out when you’re alone in the car?” There’s a lot of them, but the one I go to first is Trisha Yearwood’s “The Song Remembers When”
But that’s just a lot of water underneath a bridge I’ve burned,
And there’s no use in backtracking around corners I have turned,
Still I guess some things we bury are just bound to rise again,
For even if the whole world has forgotton the song remembers when.