This week I played (guitar) Blest Be the Lord, Christ Be Our Light, The Cry of the Poor, and City of God. I considered For All the Saints, but eventually went with my other selections. Why? The songs seemed to fit liturgically and they are some of the 100+ songs in my repetoire. In addition, the congregation knows these songs.
I and a young piano player are the only musicians my parish has. He plays the late Sunday morning Mass, I play the early Sunday Mass and, when I can, the vigil Mass. I play that OCP stuff because that is what I know (my repetoire is approximately 125 hymns). Please think about this and your musicians before you complain about the music selections. If you don’t like them, find a way to suggest what you would like to hear. If it’s within your musician’s ability he/she will likely try to oblige you. If not, then sing the songs that are selected as well as you can to the glory and praise of our Lord.