What would you do if DD's friend reveals she has a crush on DD?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is, frankly, ridiculous.

Feelings can indeed be sinful. Is not lust a feeling? What about jealousy? And pride?

In fact, how many of the 7 deadly sins are feelings?
It is not ridiculous at all… he is 100% correct.

And no, the sins of lust, jealousy, and pride are not merely “feelings” that cannot be controlled. They are a deliberate decision to take spur of the moment negative emotions into the next level by dwelling on them and feeding them.
 
It is not ridiculous at all… he is 100% correct.

And no, the sins of lust, jealousy, and pride are not merely “feelings” that cannot be controlled. They are a deliberate decision to take spur of the moment negative emotions into the next level by dwelling on them and feeding them.
And that makes them not feelings how?
 
14?? :confused:

14 is NOT too young to have a crush on somebody. :nope:
I don’t know about you, but my first major crush was when I was ten. She was the prettiest girl at camp and even asked for my phone once and sneakily put her phone number in my list of contacts. I was standing pretty tall after that. 😃
 
I know you probably think I’m stupid and don’t know what I’m talking about, but if you’re going to disagree with me, have the respect to do so in an appropriate response … rather than just dismissing my post with a silly video, like I’m not worth the discussion or something.

But anyhow…

It is not my opinion at all, it is the truth, and it is how the Church sees it. Having a homosexual orientation/attraction (ie - having “feelings” of attraction for persons of the same sex) is not freely chosen, and is therefore not a sin unless it is acted upon.
And that makes them not feelings how?
I already explained it to you. The sins of lust, jealousy, etc etc are deliberate decisions to act (act being a key word here) on those feelings by dwelling on them or feeding them. (A decision is an action, not a feeling you can’t control.) That is why lust, for example, isn’t merely arousal or sexual attraction (both being feelings)… but a deliberate decision to objectify someone, even if only in your heart. That is beyond merely a feeling. The decision to do so is an action.
 
I don’t know about you, but my first major crush was when I was ten. She was the prettiest girl at camp and even asked for my phone once and sneakily put her phone number in my list of contacts. I was standing pretty tall after that. 😃
I remember having crushes on boys when I was as young as 4 years old. My first really REALLY big crush was at age 11.

I’m not sure what I would’ve said if my mom had been like “I forbid you to have a crush on that boy… you are far too young to feel that way!” … Ummm, well guess what, I do? 🤷
 
I remember having crushes on boys when I was as young as 4 years old. My first really REALLY big crush was at age 11.

I’m not sure what I would’ve said if my mom had been like “I forbid you to have a crush on that boy… you are far too young to feel that way!” … Ummm, well guess what, I do? 🤷
Haha. Exactly. And thank goodness your mother can’t do things like that, because that wouldn’t be healthy. Having crushes is a healthy and normal thing, and just because someone has same-sex attraction it doesn’t mean they will be devoid of this normal thing. There’s nothing you can do about it. If it moves past a crush in the situation the mother is in and turns into love, that may cause problems. But for right now, harmless crushes usually go away, especially if the person senses the other does not feel mutual.
 
So if this situation occurred, and your 14yr old DD’s friend revealed that she’s bi-sexual and had feelings for your DD, what would be your response?
Ah, teenage years - an explosion of hormones, crushes, emotions and sometimes confused thoughts and feelings.

My advice would simply be to tell your daughter to continue to be a good friend, though if necessary to make the boundaries of that friendship clear.
 
Not to downplay any concerns here, but I wonder if perhaps her friend is just trying to act a certain way, according to the latest trends?

I’m sure I’m wrong in some cases, but the first thought that usually pops into my head when I hear about a female teenage bisexual is to first put the word “bisexual” in quotes. Not because I think bisexual attraction doesn’t exist, but because it seems to be more of a fad these days than any sort of true attraction. As in, probably 95% of the young women who claim to be bi really aren’t at all; they’re just trying to act in a way that they think is sexy, because society in the past 15 years at least has been promoting lesbian action among heterosexual women as something that turns men on. And since the age of the sexualization of children is getting lower and lower, it’s not likely that 14 year-old girls will be immune to it.

I guess my point is, maybe this will blow over quickly. Hopefully this friend is just acting out, and a firm “knock it off” will set her straight. If her friend respects it, there’s no reason they can’t continue the friendship.
This is pretty accurate. It could be that you know she’s serious, due to circumstances, but if you don’t, she may just be pretending or even joking. Many of my friends (I’m a teenage girl) consistently refer to each other as “wives” or pretend to be lesbians in pure jest. Occasionally, they bring me into this and insist that I, too, am married to one of them, or the child in one of their play “families”.

It honestly doesn’t bother me. As far as I can tell, it’s simply a way of saying to everyone else “I don’t care what you think. Your opinion of me doesn’t matter.” The girls in question are unusual, but I’m certain that few, if any, are actually bisexual.

On the other hand, I suppose there are circumstances where it would be pretty obvious the girl wasn’t joking. In that case, it’s unwise to forbid the friendship and unwise to tell your daughter that she is “too young for this nonsense”. If you really feel she should focus on school, say that. I would simply remind her of church teaching on the matter and tell her not to lead her friend to sin. It’s perfectly possible to have a friendship with this girl, provided the friend is respectful and does not press the issue.

If the friend is disrespectful and does not respect your daughter’s feelings, distance is probably the best thing. However, we can’t make that judgement based on a few sentences of typed information. A lot of it will come down to the level of respect for your daughter, regardless of whether she is serious.
 
I would simply remind her of church teaching on the matter and tell her not to lead her friend to sin.
Yes. My DD is solidly grounded in her faith.
It’s perfectly possible to have a friendship with this girl, provided the friend is respectful and does not press the issue.
Right. I just wonder how much investment DD should have in entertaining this drama. They’ve just started this friendship and are navigating their way through the transition to high school.

DD is not that close to her…but the situation does bring up parenting questions for me.
 
Why the need for such petulant behaviour? Deborah seemed perfectly civil in her post.
That’s just how she’s always talked to me. Very disrespectful and immature. It gives off the message that she doesn’t take what I say seriously because she thinks what I say has absolutely 0 value.
 
Not to downplay any concerns here, but I wonder if perhaps her friend is just trying to act a certain way, according to the latest trends?
Indeed. I think there is in fact a trend to be edgy. And what could be more edgy than claiming to be bi-sexual in an all-girls Catholic high school.
 
Right. I just wonder how much investment DD should have in entertaining this drama. They’ve just started this friendship and are navigating their way through the transition to high school.

DD is not that close to her…but the situation does bring up parenting questions for me.
That is a hectic time, but there will be more of this to come. I think dealing with these things is also part of the transition process- high school is a place where lots of young people come together, and I have encountered many new things there. Many of them were things that helped me grow, and many were things I just had to learn to endure.

If they’re not close and the girl isn’t being disrespectful, I’m not sure if there’s anything else to do. Avoiding all drama is nearly impossible in a school setting. The best you can aim for is not letting it affect schoolwork, faith, or close friendships. If your daughter is well grounded in her faith, as you say, she should be fine. 🙂
 
That is a hectic time, but there will be more of this to come. I think dealing with these things is also part of the transition process- high school is a place where lots of young people come together, and I have encountered many new things there. Many of them were things that helped me grow, and many were things I just had to learn to endure.

If they’re not close and the girl isn’t being disrespectful, I’m not sure if there’s anything else to do. Avoiding all drama is nearly impossible in a school setting. The best you can aim for is not letting it affect schoolwork, faith, or close friendships. If your daughter is well grounded in her faith, as you say, she should be fine. 🙂
👍
 
I can’t see that this has been addressed already but I sort of did with my first post…I don’t think anyone has mentioned asking the daughter if she, herself, has the same feelings toward her friend as the friend does. That is something I would definitely ask her if I was her parent and would like to know.
This is something you could try, but I don’t know if it would work. In most cases the answer will always be no, even if the answer is actually yes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top