What would you do if DD's friend reveals she has a crush on DD?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is something you could try, but I don’t know if it would work. In most cases the answer will always be no, even if the answer is actually yes.
Agreed. It’s a possibility, but I’m not sure how you would determine it. It could be that the OP’s daughter simply has a very close relationship with her, and she os reasonably certain that her daughter would be open about it. However, we cannot be sure.

Odds are the daughter doesn’t reciprocate, but we can’t know that 100%.
 
I don’t think anyone has suggested the possibility of a heterosexual same-sex crush. It seems to happen at that age and it’s usually on someone older that they want to be emulate. Unfortunately everything seems sexulized so admiration and fondness (which can be overwhelming when it’s a new relationship) is turned into something it’s not.

This young girl probably doesn’t know how to say (or wouldn’t want to say), “I really, really like you and want to be just like you” especially at that age. It doesn’t sound cool.
Indeed. I think there is in fact a trend to be edgy. And what could be more edgy than claiming to be bi-sexual in an all-girls Catholic high school.
It’s edgy, there is language for it, and there is that “lesbian chic” going on. I thought that was over but I guess it’s moved from college into the high-school (almost middle school) crowd.
 
I guess what I am wondering is how all this came to the attention of the parents.
Because she told me she received a text from this girl.

We had been talking about this girl for a while because this girl had revealed earlier in the year that she struggled with depression.

This is another page in the story.
 
Because she told me she received a text from this girl.

We had been talking about this girl for a while because this girl had revealed earlier in the year that she struggled with depression.

This is another page in the story.
So we have another piece to this puzzle. She could be depressed because she does have legitimate same-sex attraction, or she could be depressed and is therefore acting out in socially unacceptable ways to get attention. It really boils down to why she is depressed. What is the cause? Bad family life? Something happen to her when she was a child/early teen?

To be clear, I know you likely don’t know why. These are just good questions to ask.
 
Because she told me she received a text from this girl.

We had been talking about this girl for a while because this girl had revealed earlier in the year that she struggled with depression.

This is another page in the story.
I should say to my DD that her friend is a very troubled person and she should be careful with her.

I strongly believe that a girl from a decent family would never text something like this to anyone, even if she had strong homossexual inclinations. If she did that, this is probably a sign that the family where she comes from is also troubled to some degree.

Also, a decent girl with some sense of moral would at least try to be discrete about her inclinations with other people. But a 14 yo. girl who texts other girls about her sexual preferences like that probably doesn’s think it is wrong to be a homossexual anymore.

We should love sinners and try to bring them back to God as much as we can, but I would say that sinner who does not see sin as a problem is also a very dangerous person in potential.

So I would make sure that my DD understands that before insisting even one day more in a friendship like that.
 
I should say to my DD that her friend is a very troubled person and she should be careful with her.

I strongly believe that a girl from a decent family would never text something like this to anyone, even if she had strong homossexual inclinations. If she did that, this is probably a sign that the family where she comes from is also troubled to some degree.

Also, a decent girl with some sense of moral would at least try to be discrete about her inclinations with other people. But a 14 yo. girl who texts other girls about her sexual preferences like that probably doesn’s think it is wrong to be a homossexual anymore.

We should love sinners and try to bring them back to God as much as we can, but I would say that sinner who does not see sin as a problem is also a very dangerous person in potential.

So I would make sure that my DD understands that before insisting even one day more in a friendship like that.
The friend texted the daughter that she has a crush on her. Telling people you like them is pretty normal these days. Look at the bright side, it was a text not a sext.
 
I should say to my DD that her friend is a very troubled person and she should be careful with her.

I strongly believe that a girl from a decent family would never text something like this to anyone, even if she had strong homossexual inclinations. If she did that, this is probably a sign that the family where she comes from is also troubled to some degree.

Also, a decent girl with some sense of moral would at least try to be discrete about her inclinations with other people. But a 14 yo. girl who texts other girls about her sexual preferences like that probably doesn’s think it is wrong to be a homossexual anymore.

We should love sinners and try to bring them back to God as much as we can, but I would say that sinner who does not see sin as a problem is also a very dangerous person in potential.

So I would make sure that my DD understands that before insisting even one day more in a friendship like that.
Meh, I really don’t think it reflects too badly on her family. They’re in high school. High school students do stupid things. It’s not like she’s harrassing the OP’s daughter (unless she is and this information hasn’t been posted). She’s simply informing the daughter how she feels.

Now that we know the girl has a history of depression, I think it makes even less sense to mark her as a “bad kid”. Starting a close friendship might be unwise, but why on earth is it neccessary to break off their friendship altogther?

This assumes that the girl has been respectful, of course. As long as the daughter’s wishes are respected and she does not express any romantic interest in the friend, I don’t think there’s much a parent could or should do.

It might be nice to know what the daughter’s attitude is, though. That’s a big part of it- especially whether the situation makes her uncomfortable and whether she wants to continue the friendship.
 
I should say to my DD that her friend is a very troubled person and she should be careful with her.

I strongly believe that a girl from a decent family would never text something like this to anyone, even if she had strong homossexual inclinations. If she did that, this is probably a sign that the family where she comes from is also troubled to some degree.

Also, a decent girl with some sense of moral would at least try to be discrete about her inclinations with other people. But a 14 yo. girl who texts other girls about her sexual preferences like that probably doesn’s think it is wrong to be a homossexual anymore.

We should love sinners and try to bring them back to God as much as we can, but I would say that sinner who does not see sin as a problem is also a very dangerous person in potential.

So I would make sure that my DD understands that before insisting even one day more in a friendship like that.
Teenagers text EVERYTHING under the sun. Doesn’t matter if they come from a decent family, a broken family, a single parent family, foster care…teens text and text and text. A teen would absolutely text that she had a crush…on a girl or a guy, wouldn’t matter. But just because she would text such a thing, doesn’t automatically mean she is actually homosexual or doesn’t think its wrong. Girls get girl crushes on each other at this age, most of the time its not even sexual in any manner. It has more to do with finding their way, identifying with someone they admire or would like to be and because our culture is so sexually saturated, they listen to those messages and automatically think they must be homosexual to be enamored with or find themselves identifying with one of their classmates.
 
So we have another piece to this puzzle. She could be depressed because she does have legitimate same-sex attraction, or she could be depressed and is therefore acting out in socially unacceptable ways to get attention. It really boils down to why she is depressed. What is the cause? Bad family life? Something happen to her when she was a child/early teen?

To be clear, I know you likely don’t know why. These are just good questions to ask.
Just to be clear, teenage depression can happen to the best of kids from the best of families as well as those that come from a troubled background. And there doesn’t necessarily have to be a “cause” or a significant event that triggered the depression. Teenage depression is a very complicated illness. And some kids that say they are depressed, say it to get attention, you are right on that. But some kids will never tell anyone either. I think we need to be careful we don’t start to analyze this girl since we don’t know her or her background.
 
Teenagers text EVERYTHING under the sun. Doesn’t matter if they come from a decent family, a broken family, a single parent family, foster care…teens text and text and text. A teen would absolutely text that she had a crush…on a girl or a guy, wouldn’t matter. But just because she would text such a thing, doesn’t automatically mean she is actually homosexual or doesn’t think its wrong. Girls get girl crushes on each other at this age, most of the time its not even sexual in any manner. It has more to do with finding their way, identifying with someone they admire or would like to be and because our culture is so sexually saturated, they listen to those messages and automatically think they must be homosexual to be enamored with or find themselves identifying with one of their classmates.
This. The more I think about it, the more I realize that what people text doesn’t really allow you to determine whether they come from a decent family or even if they are a decent person. I hate to think what my classmates would be considered if we scrutinized all their texts. We all message weird stuff to our friends. Doesn’t mean we’re unstable. It mostly means we’re teenagers and we’re still figuring out what “appropriate” means. :o

Unless the girl acts on it or makes the daughter uncomfortable, I don’t really think she’s done anything wrong.
 
Nothing. My daughters know homosexual behavior is wrong, so they’d be able to handle the situation themselves.
 
Nothing. My daughters know homosexual behavior is wrong, so they’d be able to handle the situation themselves.
Really? So if you knew there was, say, heroin, in your daughter’s school, or friend group, even if you knew they were well grounded, you would do nothing?
 
Really? So if you knew there was, say, heroin, in your daughter’s school, or friend group, even if you knew they were well grounded, you would do nothing?
That’s a little different because heroin is illegal and life threatening. She would have to tell the school and get the authorities involved.
 
Nothing. My daughters know homosexual behavior is wrong, so they’d be able to handle the situation themselves.
This is the attitude my own parents had when I was a teenager. I was left to my own devices many times when I was actually exposed to a situation that was beyond what I had experienced before in my life. My parents took the same line of thinking that I had been taught between right and wrong and I’d know what to do when confronted with troubling decisions. Its dangerous to think you teach your children firm values and morals and then just let them go on their own. I might have known what was right, but that didn’t mean I actually had the skill set to handle the emotions or psychological effects of the situations many teenagers may encounter. To do nothing is dangerous, at the very least a parent should be there to continue to help guide and discuss decisions and situations. If a teenager finds themselves in over their head, a parent may need to step in and intervene.

I know the teenager landscape has changed drastically since I was a teenager. My daughter has to face so much more than I ever did. I’ve done my best to teach her right and wrong, but I’d be a fool to think my job is over and I can sit back and do nothing from here on out.
 
This is the attitude my own parents had when I was a teenager. I was left to my own devices many times when I was actually exposed to a situation that was beyond what I had experienced before in my life. My parents took the same line of thinking that I had been taught between right and wrong and I’d know what to do when confronted with troubling decisions. Its dangerous to think you teach your children firm values and morals and then just let them go on their own. I might have known what was right, but that didn’t mean I actually had the skill set to handle the emotions or psychological effects of the situations many teenagers may encounter. To do nothing is dangerous, at the very least a parent should be there to continue to help guide and discuss decisions and situations. If a teenager finds themselves in over their head, a parent may need to step in and intervene.

I know the teenager landscape has changed drastically since I was a teenager. My daughter has to face so much more than I ever did. I’ve done my best to teach her right and wrong, but I’d be a fool to think my job is over and I can sit back and do nothing from here on out.
I don’t think the poster was trying to say she would always do nothing in any situation. I think she was specifically addressing only this particular situation. Quite frankly, I know where she’s coming from. I guess not everyone is the same, but when I was a teenager, it would have been a no brainer to me if I was in this situation - a girl has a crush on me, I don’t have the same feelings back, end of story. It isn’t any different from a boy having a crush on me and me not having the same feelings for him back. The fact that it’s a girl doesn’t really make a difference.
 
I don’t think the poster was trying to say she would always do nothing in any situation. I think she was specifically addressing only this particular situation. Quite frankly, I know where she’s coming from. I guess not everyone is the same, but when I was a teenager, it would have been a no brainer to me if I was in this situation - a girl has a crush on me, I don’t have the same feelings back, end of story. It isn’t any different from a boy having a crush on me and me not having the same feelings for him back. The fact that it’s a girl doesn’t really make a difference.
Actually she said she’d do nothing, and I take her word that’s what she meant until she says different.

It doesn’t matter if its this situation, a situation with drugs, a situation with cheating at school, a boy crush, a girl crush…doesn’t matter. You still stay active in your teenager’s life, more or less depending upon their needs, their skill set and their maturity at the time. And yes, not every teenager is the same, even within the same family. That’s why you keep those lines of communication open, you check in with them on their lives and relationships and hopefully you’ve developed trust with them so they can say “Mom, I’m in over my head and I need your help”. You don’t hover, you don’t necessarily intervene the first time they seem to be in trouble, but you don’t teach them right from wrong and then let them to their own devices. Perhaps you could have handled a girl crush, but not every teenager will be able to even after you think you’ve given them a firm foundation in faith and values.
 
It doesn’t matter if its this situation, a situation with drugs, a situation with cheating at school, a boy crush, a girl crush…doesn’t matter. You still stay active in your teenager’s life, more or less depending upon their needs, their skill set and their maturity at the time.
Indeed.

But the parenting question for me is this: if you find out that your DD’s friend/associate/classmate is cheating, involved with drugs, or has a disordered attraction, do you discourage the friendship? I certainly have the ability to do that. (I wouldn’t invite the girl over, nor allow my daughter to go to her home.)

I want my children to be surrounded by goodness, not by dysfunction and poor character. (I get that we may be judging incorrectly whether someone who cheats or uses drugs as having poor character, rather than being guilty of just poor choices, but with my children I err on the side of caution, and if someone cheats or uses drugs, it says a lot about her, no?)

As far as if this were a boy crush, well, that’s not disordered so I think I’d handle that situation a bit differently.
 
I’ve come to this thread late:

But I always thought girls having crushes on other girls in their teens was normal and is something they grow out of.

We’ve over-sexualized everything now. Now someone doesn’t have a crush, nowadays they are bisexual - when they very probably aren’t.

And it doesn’t stop there: crushes aren’t just over-sexualized they are also politicized. So not just bi-sexual, but “queer.”

And I address this comment to the “queer” agenda: It’s just a crush - a temporary rush of hormones and affectionate feelings for crying out loud!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top