T
The_Prodigal
Guest
Souls in heaven are disunited from the body. The resurrection will reunite body and soul.
Yes you’re right. But you made it sound like a soul is messed up or something. The soul away from the body is still alive. But the body without the soul is a corpse, dead. The soul is what animates us, gives us life because God breathed it into us.Souls in heaven are disunited from the body. The resurrection will reunite body and soul.
As you can see from the above footnote, it does recognize a human life from the first moments. The question is, rather, when a spiritual, immortal soul is infused. There is no question that some sort of soul is present. If the child is alive, then there is soul. And if it is alive, then it has human life. There are no other options since a)a dead thing doesn’t become a living thing. And b) a non-human doesn’t become a human.Actually the Catholic Church doesn’t really know when the soul enters the physical tissue that will become a human life.
That is right, because a soul is the animating principle of all life. But a human life could exist without a spiritual soul.Footnote 19 of the Declaration on Procurement of Abortion released by the Vatican on November 18th 1974, states that the moment of the soul fussing with matter is unknown. And remember, according to the Catholic church a human life is the union of soul and body…
Untrue. If the fetus is alive, it has a soul. And it is human. Read over that footnote again.thus, the Catholic Church admits that they are not sure when a fetus actually becomes a human, that is, a body with a soul.
I don’t see how you come to that conclusion. The footnote expressly contradicts what you are saying, since it says “there is still nothing lass than a human life.”Footnote 19 also states that there exists a length of time when the fetus dwells within the womb but is not yet human: “…supposing a belated animation, there is still nothing less than a human life, preparing for and calling for a soul in which the nature received from parents is completed.” This sentence from Footnote 19 admits first the fact that the fetus is not yet a human,
Thanks for the reply, can you provide links to offical Church documents that speak about two souls in a human being.zachforn,
Welcome to the forums.
You seem to be misunderstanding some points in the footnote that you referred to. Here is note 19 in its entirety:This declaration expressly leaves aside the question of the moment when the spiritual soul is infused. There is not a unanimous tradition on this point and authors are as yet in disagreement. For some it dates from the first instant; for others it could not at least precede nidation. It is not within the competence of science to decide between these views, because the existence of an immortal soul is not a question in its field. It is a philosophical problem from which our moral affirmation remains independent for two reasons: (1) supposing a belated animation, t****here is still nothing less than a human life, preparing for and calling for a *(spiritual - my addition, VC) *soul in which the nature received from parents is completed, (2) on the other hand, it suffices that this presence of the soul be probable (and one can never prove the contrary) in order that the taking of life involve accepting the risk of killing a man, not only waiting for, but already in possession of his soul.
It is important to note in the footnote that it is referring to a spiritual soul. There are two types of souls (animating principles of life): spiritual and material. All living things have souls.
As you can see from the above footnote, it does recognize a human life from the first moments. The question is, rather, when a spiritual, immortal soul is infused. There is no question that some sort of soul is present. If the child is alive, then there is soul. And if it is alive, then it has human life. There are no other options since a)a dead thing doesn’t become a living thing. And b) a non-human doesn’t become a human.
That is right, because a soul is the animating principle of all life. But a human life could exist without a spiritual soul.
Untrue. If the fetus is alive, it has a soul. And it is human. Read over that footnote again.
I don’t see how you come to that conclusion. The footnote expressly contradicts what you are saying, since it says “there is still nothing lass than a human life.”
zach,I have to think that if the church were talking about different varities of souls they would have had to mention it, rather than relying on others to insert “Spiritual” before soul.
So a human life is not present until the immortal soul of that future person (I say “future” because a human person is man and soul) is infused in the matter? Is that correct?zach,
I added the word spiritual only to the *third *mention of soul in the footnote. The first mention is “spiritual soul”, the second is “immortal soul” and the third is “soul” but spiritual and immortal are implied, and I was just clearing that up for you and other readers.
The distinction of a spiritual soul is in the document that you are referring to. The soul is the principle of life in a body (soul, Latin: anima), that which animates a body. It is a basic principle that if a body is alive it has a soul.
When does “conception” take place? Biologists know that a sperm entering an egg is not “conception,” that is, it is not guaranteed that a fertilized egg (thus a possible human) will emerge. Discrete marking points such as conception, fertilization, zygote embryo are entirely artificial constructions of biologists and doctors in order to better categorize development for academic and medical purposes. As stated in an earlier message one of this artificial construction, “conception,” is a 12-24 hour process, so does "conception’ take placed after this period is completed?Since the human soul is defined as the animating principle of the body, it must exist as soon as the body exists. Biologically, a distinct new body of a new human individual begins at conception. Aquinas didn’t know that because he didn’t know biology. (He condemned abortion just the same, as do the authors of the above document.) Now we do. And putting the biology together with Catholic philosophy of the soul, it is apparent that the soul is infused at conception.
God knew us before we were born in His eternity, because in His eternity all of our time is seen (by Him) as a whole simultaneously, but there is a period of time in our time when we do not yet exist.Of course our soul existed before we were conceived and before we were born. God knew us before we were born.
When it is possible that a new and unique person (in DNA, time and place) can develop more fully, then “conception” has taken place.When does “conception” take place? Biologists know that a sperm entering an egg is not “conception,” that is, it is not guaranteed that a fertilized egg (thus a possible human) will emerge. Discrete marking points such as conception, fertilization, zygote embryo are entirely artificial constructions of biologists and doctors in order to better categorize development for academic and medical purposes. As stated in an earlier message one of this artificial construction, “conception,” is a 12-24 hour process, so does "conception’ take placed after this period is completed?
From a secular source, wikipedia:When does “conception” take place? Biologists know that a sperm entering an egg is not “conception,” that is, it is not guaranteed that a fertilized egg (thus a possible human) will emerge. Discrete marking points such as conception, fertilization, zygote embryo are entirely artificial constructions of biologists and doctors in order to better categorize development for academic and medical purposes. As stated in an earlier message one of this artificial construction, “conception,” is a 12-24 hour process, so does "conception’ take placed after this period is completed?
Based on this it seems that there can be no confusion as to when conception occurs, even if we are unable to observe it.Fertilisation[1] (also known as conception, fecundation and syngamy), is the fusion of gametes to produce a new organism of the same species.
It’s true that “conception” is not a precise term, biologically. There is sperm penetration, mitosis, merging of the DNA, and formation of the zygote. Shall we say that the uncertainty has been reduced to a 24 hour period? At least we know that by the time the zygote is formed a new and genetically distinct individual of the human species is present.When does “conception” take place? Biologists know that a sperm entering an egg is not “conception,” that is, it is not guaranteed that a fertilized egg (thus a possible human) will emerge. Discrete marking points such as conception, fertilization, zygote embryo are entirely artificial constructions of biologists and doctors in order to better categorize development for academic and medical purposes. As stated in an earlier message one of this artificial construction, “conception,” is a 12-24 hour process, so does "conception’ take placed after this period is completed?
So, if I take a morning-after pill 10 hours after intercourse, and the zygote has yet to evolve, what are the ramifications here?It’s true that “conception” is not a precise term, biologically. There is sperm penetration, mitosis, merging of the DNA, and formation of the zygote. Shall we say that the uncertainty has been reduced to a 24 hour period? At least we know that by the time the zygote is formed a new and genetically distinct individual of the human species is present.
Sometimes I think that the usual take about heaven, or pergatory, or hell as a “place” is disleading. Do these man anything except that the saints are “with” God, the suffering souls are “approaching” Him, and the damned are “away from” Him.Souls in heaven are disunited from the body. The resurrection will reunite body and soul.
That would be a mortal sin (murder), because your intent was to kill a person if a person exists where you are applying “killing intent”.So, if I take a morning-after pill 10 hours after intercourse, and the zygote has yet to evolve, what are the ramifications here?