C
CatsAndDogs
Guest
“Sexual activity” is not the issue.“Sexual activity,” which doesn’t seem to be defined in the Theology of the Body,…
The sex act, which is the (or an) act which would produce a child in a “natural way” (as per the Church), is the issue.
Why are you so obsessed with “desire”?…is the Motivation of Behavior combined with the Action of Behavior, of what is known as intercourse. Without all components of sexual activity, sexual activity does not take place.
Is it because that way you can define ANY abstinence from the sex act as “contraceptive” and make a mockery of abstinence in principle, according to YOUR errant definitions of Catholic morality? Of course that’s it!
Desire is the first and most sustaining component of sexual activity, again, let me be clear:
Desire is PART of any sexual act that may or may not end in emission.
This cannot be denied. Whether it fits with my opinion or your opinion it cannot be denied.
Thus, to you, “frustrating desire” (ie not being perpetually “aroused”) is to be "acting contraceptively!To frustrate Desire is to frustrate a specific sexual act that will possibly end in the creation of human life.
If your ludicrous definitions weren’t so ludicrously errant you’d be right. Fortunately, you’re NOT right definitionally or in conclusion.Does that make us all mortal sinners, I don’t know, maybe.
It’s NOT the case. Why? Because we Catholics know what “contraception” means.You are uncomfortable with this, but maybe it is the case.
Once again, you’re basic error is in your definition of “contraception”.And I agree maybe it is ludicrous to think that. Personally I don’t think that is the case, but if the Church says contraceptions are a mortal sin, and any frustration of the sex act (the frustration of Desire) is a contraception, then for the Church it is what it is.
You’re incorrect for the above reasons.This concept of contraception does not oppose your understanding of contraception. It is in agreement with it.