When does the soul enter the body?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jay29
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So, if I take a morning-after pill 10 hours after intercourse, and the zygote has yet to evolve, what are the ramifications here?

A while back I also asked if anyone had a definition of Death, as in the ending of a biological life. For I do believe an understanding of when Death occurs has connections to our discussion here.

Davidv, the question still remains when does the fussion of gametes occur, not at egg penetration.
From the standpoint of Catholic moral teaching, contraception is a grave evil. In this instance, given the 12-24 hour timeline for the zygote to form, one may also be involved in the destruction of a new human being.

(By the way, my personal viewpoint on ‘ensoulment’ is that it occurs at sperm penetration. At that moment, the ovum undergoes a profound transformation, no other sperm can penetrate, and the process of embryogenesis begins.)
 
From the standpoint of Catholic moral teaching, contraception is a grave evil. In this instance, given the 12-24 hour timeline for the zygote to form, one may also be involved in the destruction of a new human being.

(By the way, my personal viewpoint on ‘ensoulment’ is that it occurs at sperm penetration. At that moment, the ovum undergoes a profound transformation, no other sperm can penetrate, and the process of embryogenesis begins.)
Actually more than one sperm may enter an egg.
 
That would be a mortal sin (murder), because your intent was to kill a person if a person exists where you are applying “killing intent”.

The actual fact that a person might not actually be there is irrelevant. Your intent and actual actions were to kill a person.
This is faulty logic. Of course it’s relevant, it’s why the Catholic Church even discusses the issue!!! To take a morning after pill before conception takes place, that is, to take action so that a human being is NOT formed is hardly an intent to kill a human being, because no human being is yet present. I took action to assure that no human being is formed. To say that any action which does not lead to a human being being formed is a mortal sin, is to say that sitting at home on a Friday night is a sin because that means that I’m not out actively seeking the future mother of my children: i.e. an action that I’m taking is not leading to the creation of a new human being. According to your argument, I should have no emotions, likes or dislikes when it comes to meeting a possible mate, I should simply say “I do,” get married and produce children, because according to your argument it’s a mortal sin to act, or have opinions and personal feelings about anything that might lead to a human not being created.
 
This is faulty logic. Of course it’s relevant, it’s why the Catholic Church even discusses the issue!!! To take a morning after pill before conception takes place, that is, to take action so that a human being is NOT formed is hardly an intent to kill a human being, because no human being is yet present.
Just as using a condom is a moral evil, because it’s intended use is to prevent the possibility of a person being created while allowing the sexual act to happen, to use the “morning after” pill is precisely the same case.

Please read up a bit on why contraception, as well as abortion, are both intrinsic evils. 🙂
I took action to assure that no human being is formed. To say that any action which does not lead to a human being being formed is a mortal sin, is to say that sitting at home on a Friday night is a sin because that means that I’m not out actively seeking the future mother of my children: i.e. an action that I’m taking is not leading to the creation of a new human being.
If the sex act is involved in the “activity being done” then the possibility of the creation of a new person MUST be allowed.

Staying home on friday has nothing to do with the sex act.
According to your argument, I should have no emotions, likes or dislikes when it comes to meeting a possible mate, I should simply say “I do,” get married and produce children, because according to your argument it’s a mortal sin to act, or have opinions and personal feelings about anything that might lead to a human not being created.
You are rather ill informed, aren’t you?

If the sex act is done, it must be done chastely, which means within the bounds of marriage to a person of the opposite sex.

We are specifically commanded NOT to be procreative if we’re not wed to a person of the opposite sex.

If your vocation is to be married, then finding a person of the opposite sex and having sex after marriage with that person is your job.

If your vocation is to be unmarried, then you are to be chaste, meaning in this case celibate.

Do you understand now why “staying home on friday” has nothing to do with this argument?
 
If your vocation is to be married, then finding a person of the opposite sex and having sex after marriage with that person is your job.

QUOTE]
  1. So, you are saying that after marriage the only thing a person should do is work (to procure money for food), eat (to gain energy for intercourse), and perform intercourse? Because any other action (such as watching TV, reading, talking, jogging, etc) is a deliberate decision to not allow a human being to be created.
Not to hammer the point but I don’t think you addressed my previous inquiry:

“According to your argument, I should have no emotions, likes or dislikes when it comes to meeting a possible mate, I should simply say ‘I do,’ get married and produce children, because according to your argument it’s a mortal sin to act, or have opinions and personal feelings about anything that might lead to a human not being created.”

Should I marry the first member of the opposite sex I meet upon turning 18?

If I don’t marry the first person I meet upon turning 18, then I am making a deliberate decision that is preventing a human being from being created, and this is construed as a moral sin, is that correct?
  1. I would also ask as to the Church’s definition of the “sexual act.” Is there any Church document that precisely defines this concept?
 
CatsAndDogs;4295427:
If your vocation is to be married, then finding a person of the opposite sex and having sex after marriage with that person is your job.
  1. So, you are saying that after marriage the only thing a person should do is work (to procure money for food), eat (to gain energy for intercourse), and perform intercourse? Because any other action (such as watching TV, reading, talking, jogging, etc) is a deliberate decision to not allow a human being to be created.
Uh, no. 🙂

After marriage, if sex happens it is not to be interfered with such that the possibility of appropriate procreation is eliminated.

(( Catholic NFP is acceptable, as it allows for timing of procreation but not cessation of procreation. ))
Not to hammer the point but I don’t think you addressed my previous inquiry:
“According to your argument, I should have no emotions, likes or dislikes when it comes to meeting a possible mate, I should simply say ‘I do,’ get married and produce children, because according to your argument it’s a mortal sin to act, or have opinions and personal feelings about anything that might lead to a human not being created.”
Should I marry the first member of the opposite sex I meet upon turning 18?
No. You should discern what your vocation is (married or unmarried) and, always being chaste, decide when and to whom you wish to get married.

The timing of this is entirely up to you. 🙂
If I don’t marry the first person I meet upon turning 18, then I am making a deliberate decision that is preventing a human being from being created, and this is construed as a moral sin, is that correct?
No. Being chaste is not a sin. Being unchaste IS a sin, so be chaste.
  1. I would also ask as to the Church’s definition of the “sexual act.” Is there any Church document that precisely defines this concept?
Theology of the Body

…happy reading! 🙂 :shamrock2:
 
To open up another point of consideration:

We have seen :
  1. That in 1974 the Church states, and prepares contingency arguments for, the understanding that the fusion of soul into matter may not occur at “conception.” That no one is absolutely sure, and to be moral from a Catholic perspective, it is the safest approach to assume the soul melds with matter at “conception.”
  2. “Conception” is a layman’s term for a 24 hour process of exchanges and creations of various chemicals which MAY (it does not necessarily mean it biologically MUST) develop into a zygote, embryo, fetus, and post-birth organism. There is no “instant of conception” biologically.
I now add to this debate a definition offered by the Vatican as to when biological matter possess human life and when biological matter does not possess human life. In 2006 the Vatican along with The Pontifical Academy of Sciences specifically defined what Life is, and when a body possesses life: the Catholic Church’s definition of Life is any human body that has “organized neurological activity throughout the entire brain, including the cerebrum, cerebellum, and brain stem.” If this “organized activity” is not present then Life (the presence of a soul and body) is not present according to the Vatican.

The acquisition of organized neurological activity (the definition of Life according to the Vatican) does not occur until approximately 24- 27 weeks after the “conception” of the fetus.
 
Uh, no. 🙂

After marriage, if sex happens it is not to be interfered with such that the possibility of appropriate procreation is eliminated.

…

The timing of this is entirely up to you.
With the understanding that human matter is finite, that is we will biologically die one day, thus there is only a finite amount of time to create human life, isn’t leaving the “timing entirely up to me” limiting the time I have to create human life. If any action that is taken that stops a human life being created is a mortal sin, then leaving the timing up to me is a mortal sin, it is me taking action to not create as many human lives as I biologically can. And if I don’t create as many humans as I can, then I am not allowing a human being that was to be born to me to not be born.

Your posts and my posts seem to be saying the same thing, only I’m admitting that having choices about when I want to procreate is limiting the amount of humans I can produce, thus denying human life…just what a contraception-device does…

…in a way my “timing entirely up to me” is a mental contraception rather than a physical one.
 
the Catholic Church’s definition of Life is any human body that has “organized neurological activity throughout the entire brain, including the cerebrum, cerebellum, and brain stem.” If this “organized activity” is not present then Life (the presence of a soul and body) is not present according to the Vatican.
We’ll be needing a link to this information. Thanks!
 
With the understanding that human matter is finite, that is we will biologically die one day, thus there is only a finite amount of time to create human life, isn’t leaving the “timing entirely up to me” limiting the time I have to create human life.
(( I’ll assume that’s a question. You might try using that squiggly “?” thing at the end of questions. ))

Yes, there is no problem with anyone limiting the time one person has to create human life.

Now if EVERYONE chose to be permanently celibate (and chaste) we might have a problem! 🙂
If any action that is taken that stops a human life being created is a mortal sin, then leaving the timing up to me is a mortal sin, it is me taking action to not create as many human lives as I biologically can.
Your error is in your imagined commandment to create AS MANY HUMAN LIVES AS POSSIBLE.

That is not a commandment. We are to be fruitful, not rabbits.
And if I don’t create as many humans as I can, then I am not allowing a human being that was to be born to me to not be born.
Persons are created when they are created, and not before they are created at the time of conception.

There is no “big box 'o souls” which needs to be used up.
Your posts and my posts seem to be saying the same thing, only I’m admitting that having choices about when I want to procreate is limiting the amount of humans I can produce, thus denying human life…just what a contraception-device does…
No. Contraception is the willful negating of the possibility of creating new persons WHILE still “having sex”, whereas following a the chaste vocation of celibacy has nothing to do with sex whatsoever.
…in a way my “timing entirely up to me” is a mental contraception rather than a physical one.
The intent of contraception is to have sex without the possibility of procreation. That is a mortal sin.

The intent of “not having sex” is to be chastely celibate, which is not a sin.

It all boils down to your error of thinking that it’s a commandment that we are to produce as many persons as possible. That is not a commandment.
 
Let’s not pull grammatical nit-picking into the discussion. I forgot to use a question mark, but you don’t include antecedents in some of your sentences, as well as entering indefinite articles that are not needed. Let’s let it slide.

According to the Church, the “vocation of marriage” is to produce children is that correct? The vocation of the priesthood is a whole other can o’worms. But marriage = children. According to the Church to deny a child the right to be born is a mortal sin. Is this correct?

A “contraceptive device” is any concept or physical object that purposefully delays impregnation.

Thus, condemns, as well as mental decisions that purposefully delay impregnation are mortal sins. A contraceptive does not have to be an object, because withdrawing the male member at the moment of ejaculation is a contraceptive action -sorry, that’s about as G-rated as I could write the sentence 🙂 But I think we can both agree that a contraceptive device does not have to be a physical object…?

Thus, the Church would believe that any device or decision (such as the decision of pulling the male member out at the time of ejaculation, etc) that denies a child the right to be born is a mortal sin, correct?

Also, I would still like to see how “sexual activity” is officially defined by the Catholic church. I know today psychologists have a pretty broad, though I think appropriate, understanding of “sexual activity.” Due to the fact that the Church is involved with “what is in the heart,” that is, Motivation of Behavior, as well as Action of Behavior, the mere physical feat of…trying to think of a G-rated way to say this…penetration is only the Action of Behavior, what does the Church have to say on the Motivation of Behavior, and how that links to “sexual activity”?

What is implied by the Life/Death discussion and link, is that according to the Catholic Church, Human Life (by definition the union of Soul and Matter) is no longer present at the time of “brain death.” Obviously the matter is still present, would you agree? I mean the matter is sitting there in the coffin. So that means it is the soul that has left the matter, thus no Life is present. That was what I was stating.
 
Let’s not pull grammatical nit-picking into the discussion. I forgot to use a question mark, but you don’t include antecedents in some of your sentences, as well as entering indefinite articles that are not needed. Let’s let it slide.
Yeah, I do get a bit “creative” with my blithering, don’t I? 🙂
According to the Church, the “vocation of marriage” is to produce children is that correct? The vocation of the priesthood is a whole other can o’worms. But marriage = children. According to the Church to deny a child the right to be born is a mortal sin. Is this correct?
Read the “Theology of the Body” material. It will answer your questions better than I can, though I will give you my probably lame attemps.

A child should only result from a chaste and proper “coupling”. If a child “occurs” otherwise some sin (nearly always mortal) occurred in the process.

Marriage does not equal children. Marriage equals the correct environment to produce children, and that “production” mustn’t be ultimately frustrated.
A “contraceptive device” is any concept or physical object that purposefully delays impregnation.
No. A contraceptive device doesn’t “delay”, but rather “prohibits” (in theory and intent) an occasion which would otherwise result in impregnation.
Thus, condemns (condoms), as well as mental decisions that purposefully delay impregnation are mortal sins.
Once again, it’s not “purposefully delay” but rather “purposefully prohibit in specific occurrence”.

Condoms prohibit the possible production of a child while allowing the sex act.

A particular “mental decision” which eliminates the possibility of producing a child is not connected with the performance of the sex act.

Condoms are evil because they allow sex without consequence.
“Not having sex” is not evil because it allows NO SEX with the consequences of “no sex” (which is no child production).
A contraceptive does not have to be an object, because withdrawing the male member at the moment of ejaculation is a contraceptive action -sorry, that’s about as G-rated as I could write the sentence 🙂 But I think we can both agree that a contraceptive device does not have to be a physical object…?
The “withdrawing” scenario is an example of contraception because it allows the sex act while prohibiting the possibility of child production.

But if the sex act is not “present” in the scenario, there is no CONTRACEPTION!
Thus, the Church would believe that any device or decision (such as the decision of pulling the male member out at the time of ejaculation, etc) that denies a child the right to be born is a mortal sin, correct?
It is a mortal sin to combine the sex act with anything which would prohibit child production.

But simply abstaining from the sex act, by being celibate, is not contraception because there is no “-ception” happening!
Also, I would still like to see how “sexual activity” is officially defined by the Catholic church. I know today… what does the Church have to say on the Motivation of Behavior, and how that links to “sexual activity”?
Once again, read the Theology of the Body material. 🙂
What is implied by the Life/Death discussion and link, is that according to the Catholic Church, Human Life (by definition the union of Soul and Matter) is no longer present at the time of “brain death.” Obviously the matter is still present, would you agree?
I agree to whatever the Church says on the subject.
I mean the matter is sitting there in the coffin. So that means it is the soul that has left the matter, thus no Life is present. That was what I was stating.
What you were implying was that since there is no “brain activity” in the VERY pre-born person, that that person was not truly alive as a human being.

That is an incorrect interpretation of what was presented in the article that you presented.
 
Marriage does not equal children. Marriage equals the correct environment to produce children, and that “production” mustn’t be ultimately frustrated.
I agree. Let me give an example: My wife wants to be “romantic” I don’t want to because I’m stressed, tired, etc. Which is to say I have made a personal decision. I have frustrated the sexual, procreative act, which will produce a child, or the possibility of producing a child. My decision acts as a contraceptive. There was a “-ception,” because there is Desire. Desire is a part of the sexual act, without the component of desire the sexual act cannot progress, thus desire is part of the sexual act, part of “sexual activity” between a man and a wife. By my saying no, the procreative sexual act, in process, for desire is part of the process, the act of procreation is frustrated.

And you’re correct, the contraceptive acts prohibits a “specific occurrence” in which a pregnancy is possible. The above example I think discusses a specific occurrence.
What you were implying was that since there is no “brain activity” in the VERY pre-born person, that that person was not truly alive as a human being.
That is an incorrect interpretation of what was presented in the article that you presented.
I’m not implying anything that is not able to be implied by definitions, perhaps contradictory definitions given by the Church, but definitions of when Life and Soul are present and when Life and Soul not present. The church states that the presence of Life, and Life is the union of soul and matter, the church states that the soul (Life) is not present when the brain does not have “organized neurological activity.” I’m only stating what the church states.

I would also counter that my interpretation is not incorrect, but rather different than your interpretation of these texts.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CatsAndDogs View Post

Marriage does not equal children. Marriage equals the correct environment to produce children, and that “production” mustn’t be ultimately frustrated.

I agree. Let me give an example: My wife wants to be “romantic” I don’t want to because I’m stressed, tired, etc. Which is to say I have made a personal decision. I have frustrated the sexual, procreative act, which will produce a child, or the possibility of producing a child. My decision acts as a contraceptive.
No. Your decision does NOT act as a contraceptive. It acts as a contra-sex-tive.

The term “contraceptive” is applicable ONLY in combination with a potentially successful (intended) “emission”.
There was a “-ception,” because there is Desire. Desire is a part of the sexual act, without the component of desire the sexual act cannot progress, thus desire is part of the sexual act, part of “sexual activity” between a man and a wife.
There must be an actual “act” for there to be contraception.

You may disagree with that, but you do that only to justify your opinion.
By my saying no, the procreative sexual act, in process, for desire is part of the process, the act of procreation is frustrated.
Under your definitions as regards this issue every celibate man, or woman, is de facto contracepting and in mortal sin.

That is a ludicrous position, which invalidates, for the reasons I’ve given (and probably many more as I’m not that versed in the Theology of the Body), your definitions and conclusions based on those conclusions.

Now, you’re welcome to your understandings of things, but you’re out of line telling Catholics what their own beliefs should be based on your non-Catholic perspective.
And you’re correct, the contraceptive acts prohibits a “specific occurrence” in which a pregnancy is possible. The above example I think discusses a specific occurrence.
If no (specific instance of an) “act” takes place, no contraception happens.
 
Quote:

What you were implying was that since there is no “brain activity” in the VERY pre-born person, that that person was not truly alive as a human being.

That is an incorrect interpretation of what was presented in the article that you presented.

I’m not implying anything that is not able to be implied by definitions, perhaps contradictory definitions given by the Church, but definitions of when Life and Soul are present and when Life and Soul not present.

The church states that the presence of Life, and Life is the union of soul and matter,…

…the church states that the soul (Life) is not present when the brain does not have "organized neurological activity."
The “no life if no neurological activity” argument is applicable ONLY with life “on the way out” and not “on the way in”.
I’m only stating what the church states.
You’re de-contextualizing the info you got from the Church (a normal enough occurrence for a non-to-anti-Catholic) and applying it where it is inappropriate to make an illegitimate point.
I would also counter that my interpretation is not incorrect, but rather different than your interpretation of these texts.
Your interpretation is incorrect for the reasons given.
 
So, if I take a morning-after pill 10 hours after intercourse, and the zygote has yet to evolve, what are the ramifications here?

A while back I also asked if anyone had a definition of Death, as in the ending of a biological life. For I do believe an understanding of when Death occurs has connections to our discussion here.

Davidv, the question still remains when does the fussion of gametes occur, not at egg penetration.
Why are you so anxious to try and clearly define what nobody knows? Why not err on the side of life? Or are you trying to justify a particular act?
If one responds to this fact with any other Catholic Church documentation that counters this footnote, then there exists contradictions in Church theology, and thus the Church, as an extension of the infallible Pope, is in fact fallible and Church theology breaks down.
And, continuing this extension, Jesus was either lying or wrong when he promised to protect his Church, and be with us until the end of time. Is that the conclusion that you are trying to reach?
 
Why are you so anxious to try and clearly define what nobody knows? Why not err on the side of life? Or are you trying to justify a particular act?
I am trying to deal with the original question of “when does the soul” enter the body. I’m trying to critically understand the texts of men that explain the concepts, will and methods of God. To turn the question around, I’ll ask, Why do you seem to be implying you know exactly the will and methods of God?

Our discussion of contraception branched off of the issue of when “conception” takes place. Someone offered the solution that once the zygote is formed “conception” has taken place. I offered the scientific fact that it takes 12-24 hours after intercourse for the zygote to form, and that in that time a morning-after pill may be taken before a human being is formed.

“Sexual activity,” which doesn’t seem to be defined in the Theology of the Body, is the Motivation of Behavior combined with the Action of Behavior, of what is known as intercourse. Without all components of sexual activity, sexual activity does not take place. Desire is the first and most sustaining component of sexual activity, again, let me be clear:

Desire is PART of any sexual act that may or may not end in emission.

This cannot be denied. Whether it fits with my opinion or your opinion it cannot be denied.

To frustrate Desire is to frustrate a specific sexual act that will possibly end in the creation of human life. Does that make us all mortal sinners, I don’t know, maybe. You are uncomfortable with this, but maybe it is the case. And I agree maybe it is ludicrous to think that. Personally I don’t think that is the case, but if the Church says contraceptions are a mortal sin, and any frustration of the sex act (the frustration of Desire) is a contraception, then for the Church it is what it is. This concept of contraception does not oppose your understanding of contraception. It is in agreement with it.

I use the Death/Life/BrainDead concept because it is the clearest textual and bio-spiritual definition of the presence of Soul the Catholic Church has given to date. The definition of when a Soul is present, and when a Soul is not present doesn’t change because of a situation. Whether the human matter is 100years old, 50years old, 10years old, 1years old, or earlier, the definition stands: “Life is Absent when the Brain exhibits no Organized Neurological Pattern.” The Church said this!!! Are you attempting to say that the Church does not define Life in this way? You may want to argue that what I’m saying is not what they meant, but again all we have are the “texts of men” to investigate.
"You’re de-contextualizing the info you got from the Church (a normal enough occurrence for a non-to-anti-Catholic) and applying it where it is inappropriate to make an illegitimate point.
I’m not "de-contextualizing it at all. I’m doing the exact opposite, I’m contextualizing the text, I’m interpreting. To suggest that texts stand within their own context is to say that texts are stagnant. It is to say that interpretation, whether it’s Catholic interpretation, or non-Catholic interpretation is not possible nor allowed. And that is not the case, for obviously the Catholic Church must interpret, for example, how Jesus would react to violent video games, since violent video games are not mentioned in the New Testament. The Church must interpret the New Testament to give it’s advice on video games. Texts are not stagnant!! No text stands alone, isolated from meaning! Meaning is interpretation, it is figuring out what something means.
Now, you’re welcome to your understandings of things, but you’re out of line telling Catholics what their own beliefs should be based on your non-Catholic perspective.

And, continuing this extension, Jesus was either lying or wrong when he promised to protect his Church, and be with us until the end of time. Is that the conclusion that you are trying to reach?
I do not think I am out of line for proposing ideas that cause people to critically think, and critically face the texts of the Church that form their beliefs?

I’m trying to demonstrate that the “texts of men” (as both spoken and written) that attempt to explain the will of God are inappropriate, interpreted (yes, the Catholic Church interprets), and implied vehicles of understanding. Further, that if one is to investigate the “texts of men,” the “texts of the Church” one finds that the answers offered in this forum as to the question of when the soul enters the body are incorrect, at one end of the spectrum, and simplistic, on the other end.

I have presented evidence of biology and theology that deal with Life, Soul, Death, and Brain, evidence that I myself am still critically thinking about, evidence that the Catholic Church is still thinking about. Thus, this was and is my answer to the question of when does the soul enter the body:

The Catholic Church is unsure.

It may not be the right answer for you. But it is not wrong.
 
I am only a critically thinking person placed on the earth by God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top