Why are you so anxious to try and clearly define what nobody knows? Why not err on the side of life? Or are you trying to justify a particular act?
I am trying to deal with the original question of “when does the soul” enter the body. I’m trying to critically understand the texts of men that explain the concepts, will and methods of God. To turn the question around, I’ll ask, Why do you seem to be implying you know exactly the will and methods of God?
Our discussion of contraception branched off of the issue of when “conception” takes place. Someone offered the solution that once the zygote is formed “conception” has taken place. I offered the scientific fact that it takes 12-24 hours after intercourse for the zygote to form, and that in that time a morning-after pill may be taken before a human being is formed.
“Sexual activity,” which doesn’t seem to be defined in the Theology of the Body, is the Motivation of Behavior combined with the Action of Behavior, of what is known as intercourse. Without all components of sexual activity, sexual activity does not take place. Desire is the first and most sustaining component of sexual activity, again, let me be clear:
Desire is PART of any sexual act that may or may not end in emission.
This cannot be denied. Whether it fits with my opinion or your opinion it cannot be denied.
To frustrate Desire is to frustrate a specific sexual act that will possibly end in the creation of human life. Does that make us all mortal sinners, I don’t know, maybe. You are uncomfortable with this, but maybe it is the case. And I agree maybe it is ludicrous to think that. Personally I don’t think that is the case, but if the Church says contraceptions are a mortal sin, and any frustration of the sex act (the frustration of Desire) is a contraception, then for the Church it is what it is. This concept of contraception does not oppose your understanding of contraception. It is in agreement with it.
I use the Death/Life/BrainDead concept because it is the clearest textual and bio-spiritual definition of the presence of Soul the Catholic Church has given to date. The definition of when a Soul is present, and when a Soul is not present doesn’t change because of a situation. Whether the human matter is 100years old, 50years old, 10years old, 1years old, or earlier, the definition stands: “Life is Absent when the Brain exhibits no Organized Neurological Pattern.” The Church said this!!! Are you attempting to say that the Church does not define Life in this way? You may want to argue that what I’m saying is not what they meant, but again all we have are the “texts of men” to investigate.
"You’re de-contextualizing the info you got from the Church (a normal enough occurrence for a non-to-anti-Catholic) and applying it where it is inappropriate to make an illegitimate point.
I’m not "de-contextualizing it at all. I’m doing the exact opposite, I’m contextualizing the text, I’m interpreting. To suggest that texts stand within their own context is to say that texts are stagnant. It is to say that interpretation, whether it’s Catholic interpretation, or non-Catholic interpretation is not possible nor allowed. And that is not the case, for obviously the Catholic Church must interpret, for example, how Jesus would react to violent video games, since violent video games are not mentioned in the New Testament. The Church must interpret the New Testament to give it’s advice on video games. Texts are not stagnant!! No text stands alone, isolated from meaning! Meaning is interpretation, it is figuring out what something means.
Now, you’re welcome to your understandings of things, but you’re out of line telling Catholics what their own beliefs should be based on your non-Catholic perspective.
And, continuing this extension, Jesus was either lying or wrong when he promised to protect his Church, and be with us until the end of time. Is that the conclusion that you are trying to reach?
I do not think I am out of line for proposing ideas that cause people to critically think, and critically face the texts of the Church that form their beliefs?
I’m trying to demonstrate that the “texts of men” (as both spoken and written) that attempt to explain the will of God are inappropriate, interpreted (yes, the Catholic Church interprets), and implied vehicles of understanding. Further, that if one is to investigate the “texts of men,” the “texts of the Church” one finds that the answers offered in this forum as to the question of when the soul enters the body are incorrect, at one end of the spectrum, and simplistic, on the other end.
I have presented evidence of biology and theology that deal with Life, Soul, Death, and Brain, evidence that I myself am still critically thinking about, evidence that the Catholic Church is still thinking about. Thus, this was and is my answer to the question of when does the soul enter the body:
The Catholic Church is unsure.
It may not be the right answer for you. But it is not wrong.