When does the soul enter the body?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jay29
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“Sexual activity,” which doesn’t seem to be defined in the Theology of the Body,…
“Sexual activity” is not the issue.

The sex act, which is the (or an) act which would produce a child in a “natural way” (as per the Church), is the issue.
…is the Motivation of Behavior combined with the Action of Behavior, of what is known as intercourse. Without all components of sexual activity, sexual activity does not take place.
Why are you so obsessed with “desire”?

Is it because that way you can define ANY abstinence from the sex act as “contraceptive” and make a mockery of abstinence in principle, according to YOUR errant definitions of Catholic morality? Of course that’s it!
Desire is the first and most sustaining component of sexual activity, again, let me be clear:
Desire is PART of any sexual act that may or may not end in emission.
This cannot be denied. Whether it fits with my opinion or your opinion it cannot be denied.
To frustrate Desire is to frustrate a specific sexual act that will possibly end in the creation of human life.
Thus, to you, “frustrating desire” (ie not being perpetually “aroused”) is to be "acting contraceptively!
Does that make us all mortal sinners, I don’t know, maybe.
If your ludicrous definitions weren’t so ludicrously errant you’d be right. Fortunately, you’re NOT right definitionally or in conclusion.
You are uncomfortable with this, but maybe it is the case.
It’s NOT the case. Why? Because we Catholics know what “contraception” means.
And I agree maybe it is ludicrous to think that. Personally I don’t think that is the case, but if the Church says contraceptions are a mortal sin, and any frustration of the sex act (the frustration of Desire) is a contraception, then for the Church it is what it is.
Once again, you’re basic error is in your definition of “contraception”.
This concept of contraception does not oppose your understanding of contraception. It is in agreement with it.
You’re incorrect for the above reasons.
 
I use the Death/Life/BrainDead concept because it is the clearest textual and bio-spiritual definition of the presence of Soul the Catholic Church has given to date.
The context of that definition is the end of life, and not the beginning of life.

To excerpt the “neurological activity” argument from the “end of life” scenario and use it in the “beginning of life” scenario where no neural differentiation has yet occurred is an inappropriate and inapplicable use of that information.
The definition of when a Soul is present, and when a Soul is not present doesn’t change because of a situation.
That is true! But a human person at the beginning of life does not NEED nor CAN have neurological activity present to have a soul.

Your attempted “sleight of hand” by replacing this with that quickly and out of sight is proof of nothing other than that you don’t know what you’re talking about.
Whether the human matter is 100years old, 50years old, 10years old, 1years old, or earlier, the definition stands:
“Life is Absent when the Brain exhibits no Organized Neurological Pattern.”
Wrong. End of story. What is your next argument?
The Church said this!!!
It says this in the end of life scenario, and nowhere else. Check your facts!
Are you attempting to say that the Church does not define Life in this way? You may want to argue that what I’m saying is not what they meant, but again all we have are the “texts of men” to investigate.
Would you please edit your profile so that we can know what your religious affiliation is, please?

What is your preoccupation with the “texts of men”? Why is that important to you?
 
This will/not clear things up:

Jeremiah 1:5
“Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, before you were born I set you apart; I appointed you as a prophet to the nations.”
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by sodak View Post
"You’re de-contextualizing the info you got from the Church (a normal enough occurrence for a non-to-anti-Catholic) and applying it where it is inappropriate to make an illegitimate point.
Firstly, who is “Sodak”. Those quotations are from CatsAndDogs (me), and I’d like to get credit for them, thank you very much! 🙂
I’m not "de-contextualizing it at all. I’m doing the exact opposite, I’m contextualizing the text, I’m interpreting. To suggest that texts stand within their own context is to say that texts are stagnant. It is to say that interpretation, whether it’s Catholic interpretation, or non-Catholic interpretation is not possible nor allowed.
Did you notice that you took an article explaining the Church’s understanding of when life is OVER, and you’re applying it to when life BEGINS?

Not too “kosher”, do you think?
And that is not the case, for obviously the Catholic Church must interpret, for example, how Jesus would react to violent video games, since violent video games are not mentioned in the New Testament. The Church must interpret the New Testament to give it’s advice on video games. Texts are not stagnant!! No text stands alone, isolated from meaning! Meaning is interpretation, it is figuring out what something means.
I’m quite happy indeed that I don’t rely on you for ANY sort of “analysis” or interpretation of anything whatsoever.

But, you are quite amusing. Do continue sharing your wealth of “insight”! 🙂
 
I’m trying to demonstrate that the “texts of men” (as both spoken and written) that attempt to explain the will of God are inappropriate, interpreted (yes, the Catholic Church interprets), and implied vehicles of understanding.
Well, I’ll take it you’re not Catholic, then? 🙂
Further, that if one is to investigate the “texts of men,” the “texts of the Church” one finds that the answers offered in this forum as to the question of when the soul enters the body are incorrect, at one end of the spectrum, and simplistic, on the other end.
So, you’re definitely not Catholic, then? <chuckle, chuckle, chuckle, chuckle>
 
I am only a critically thinking person placed on the earth by God.
So, you are some sort of Christian, then?

(( The “critically thinking” part we can leave for conjecture at some future time. ))
 
Firstly, who is “Sodak”. Those quotations are from CatsAndDogs (me), and I’d like to get credit for them, thank you very much! 🙂
You beat me to it. OP, I’ll assume this was a mistake. Misquote me again, and you’ll be speaking with the moderators.
 
  1. “Conception” is a layman’s term for a 24 hour process of exchanges and creations of various chemicals which MAY (it does not necessarily mean it biologically MUST) develop into a zygote, embryo, fetus, and post-birth organism. There is no “instant of conception” biologically.
Ah, but you are not judged by biology.

Conception is like the end of life: No conception, no conception, no conception, CONCEPTION. It begins in an instant. Of course, it develops, or you and I would not be typing. But, to put a time frame on it, to describe it as a process is the evil one’s wiggle words. “Surely, it’s not a life yet…”
I now add to this debate a definition offered by the Vatican as to when biological matter possess human life and when biological matter does not possess human life. In 2006 the Vatican along with The Pontifical Academy of Sciences specifically defined what Life is, and when a body possesses life: the Catholic Church’s definition of Life is any human body that has “organized neurological activity throughout the entire brain, including the cerebrum, cerebellum, and brain stem.” If this “organized activity” is not present then Life (the presence of a soul and body) is not present according to the Vatican.
No link? Sorry, I do not believe this.
The acquisition of organized neurological activity (the definition of Life according to the Vatican) does not occur until approximately 24- 27 weeks after the “conception” of the fetus.
I am calling BS (Blessed Scripture) on this!!!
 
Ah, but you are not judged by biology.

Conception is like the end of life: No conception, no conception, no conception, CONCEPTION. It begins in an instant. Of course, it develops, or you and I would not be typing. But, to put a time frame on it, to describe it as a process is the evil one’s wiggle words. “Surely, it’s not a life yet…”

No link? Sorry, I do not believe this.
8e.devbio.com/article.php?id=162

I also wonder about twins, late stage twining. What does the church say about twinning?
 
Would you please edit your profile so that we can know what your religious affiliation is, please?
my religious affilitation…hmm.

Here’s what I know: Life is… beautiful.
Code:
      and
             it's
                 that 
                        simple

   I think that is all affiliations.
 
This is a radical, foaming at the mouth progressive site. I do not believe one word they say. How about a link to the Vatican site, or the affected chapter from the Catechism? That would have some pull here.
When you say you don’t believe a word of it, I trust you Prayer Warrior. And I would agree; please post a Vatican link that biologically discusses the creation of a zygote. I would hope this link would provide a discussion of the Vatican’s view on the biological phenomena of twinning as well.
 
When you say you don’t believe a word of it, I trust you Prayer Warrior. And I would agree; please post a Vatican link that biologically discusses the creation of a zygote. I would hope this link would provide a discussion of the Vatican’s view on the biological phenomena of twinning as well.
I will search it out. The basic point is, that conception begins at a precise moment in time. Development occurs afterward, but the egg is either fertilized or it is not. Further analysis only muddies the water and opens the door to relativism. The product of relativism is Princeton Professor Peter Singer, who believes that parents should be able to kill their newborn within 30 days if they don’t like it.

See section 366:

vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p1s2c1p6.htm

This indicates that the soul is created instantly. The clear moment of creation is conception. Any other point in time is a man-made distinction, and is pure opinion.
 
It is that the fetus has life that it grows at all. Life is what makes it grow.

Did Jesus enter Mary’s womb after the fetus achieved brain activity?
 
It is that the fetus has life that it grows at all. Life is what makes it grow.

Did Jesus enter Mary’s womb after the fetus achieved brain activity?
He was created, in His human nature by the power of the Holy Spirit. Bam! There his human nature was, growing in Mary’s womb.
 
Since souls are immortal, we imagine that they return to God, who will expect an accounting, as He did with Cain, whose brother’s (Abel) blood cried out to God from the ground.
Here is the dilema, the soul is stained with original sin and isn’t baptised. Does it go to heaven?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top