When was hell created?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Abba
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So is it a good analogy that Jesus fed 5000, walked on water, opened the eyes of the blind man? What about Jesus rising from the dead…please don’t spread error here that will influence the poorly informed.
Everyone is entitled to an opinion, as you are to yours. Or do you believe in censorship? If you do, please start with the atheists. Expressing an opinion is not spreading error. It is expressing an opinion. Simple enough!

Read my post again. I said MANY, not ALL passages, If one is so easily influenced by a post by an anonymous person, they have a problem. 🙂
 
Everyone is entitled to an opinion, as you are to yours. Or do you believe in censorship? If you do, please start with the atheists. Expressing an opinion is not spreading error. It is expressing an opinion. Simple enough!

Read my post again. I said MANY, not ALL passages, If one is so easily influenced by a post by an anonymous person, they have a problem. 🙂
I don’t believe in censorship…it just bothers me that the Words of Jesus in the Bible, which we used to take an oath on, are not taken literally.

Jesus was never afraid to call a spade a spade…He didn’t mince words…“Your sins are forgiven”…only God can forgive sins!..Jesus says, is it easier to say your sins are forgiven, or arise take up your palate & walk!" The miracle ends the controversy. 👍
 
When was hell created? Was it after Jesus resurrected?
If the angels are pure spirits, how could hell be a place? So would it not be safe to say that hell is not a place originally. Hell is a word to describe sufferings. So the angels, when they “fell”, describes their sufferings…their departure from all that is happiness and goodness.
 
It was thought by St. Augustine that hell was created in the beginning (in Genesis 1). He reasoned that when God said ‘let there be light’ it was talking about the creation of the angels, because God later creates the sun and the stars after he created the “light”. And, so when he separates the light from the darkness that this was when Satan and the bad angels (representing the darkness) rebelled, and this was when hell was created for the angels. As the Scripture says that hell was created for the bad angels.
 
I don’t believe in censorship…it just bothers me that the Words of Jesus in the Bible, which we used to take an oath on, are not taken literally.
Jesus told many parables. Do you take them literally?

(And, if not, aren’t they still Truth, whether literal or not?)
Jesus was never afraid to call a spade a spade
He was also never afraid to tell a story, if that was the best way to get His point across. 😉
 
Jesus told many parables. Do you take them literally?

(And, if not, aren’t they still Truth, whether literal or not?)

He was also never afraid to tell a story, if that was the best way to get His point across. 😉
The story of the rich man & Lazarus could have been a parable…although Jesus names the beggar, which could mean it was factual.

Nevertheless, the point of the story is the beggar was happy in heaven ( a place) & the stingy rich guy was in hell, where he wanted a drop of water to cool his tongue, “because I am in agony in this fire.” Luke16 : 19 - 32. The reading also says there is a great chasm between heaven & hell which cannot be crossed.

Jesus gave a lot of useless information for a parable that’s not literal…🤷 :dts:
 
The story of the rich man & Lazarus could have been a parable…although Jesus names the beggar, which could mean it was factual.
So, pick another parable: do you take the sower and the seed literally? The prodigal son? The Good Samaritan?
Nevertheless, the point of the story is the beggar was happy in heaven ( a place) & the stingy rich guy was in hell, where he wanted a drop of water to cool his tongue, “because I am in agony in this fire.” Luke16 : 19 - 32. The reading also says there is a great chasm between heaven & hell which cannot be crossed.
Jesus gave a lot of useless information for a parable that’s not literal…🤷 :dts:
If not literal, then nevertheless still an illustration of the truth.

Also, the depiction couldn’t have been heaven, since the gates of heaven hadn’t yet been opened. 😉

Finally, the ‘place’ argument doesn’t work, for the reasons already outlined: it’s a story, not a theological/philosophical treatise; as a story, it relies on images and narrative (rather than dry theological assertion); it describes people who have died and who no longer have bodies (with which to ‘be’ in a place). 🤷
 
=Abba;13192716]When was hell created? Was it after Jesus resurrected?
when Satan fought God for control of Heaven and LOST!:o

And its need is further evidenced by the Original sin of Adam and Eve

{I’m NOT saying that THEY went to hell; they MAY have sought and received God Forgiveness? This we DO NOT KNOW

God Bless you,

Pat Miron
 
when Satan fought God for control of Heaven and LOST!:o

And its need is further evidenced by the Original sin of Adam and Eve

{I’m NOT saying that THEY went to hell; they MAY have sought and received God Forgiveness? This we DO NOT KNOW

God Bless you,

Pat Miron
Yes we do. For one thing, Genesis clearly tells us that they acknowledged the Lord such as when Seth was born, indicating that they had a restored relationship with God.

Further the Church has held that Christ released Adam (and by extension, Eve) and the rest of the just from Sheol the day he died.
 
So, pick another parable: do you take the sower and the seed literally? The prodigal son? The Good Samaritan?

If not literal, then nevertheless still an illustration of the truth.

Also, the depiction couldn’t have been heaven, since the gates of heaven hadn’t yet been opened. 😉

Finally, the ‘place’ argument doesn’t work, for the reasons already outlined: it’s a story, not a theological/philosophical treatise; as a story, it relies on images and narrative (rather than dry theological assertion); it describes people who have died and who no longer have bodies (with which to ‘be’ in a place). 🤷
I think, Mr. Gorgias, you just like to disagree! :rolleyes:

So the chasm Jesus refers to… is the distance between the suffering in the rich guy’s mind & the joy in Lazarus’ mind which the people were too dumb to understand?

Look, I don’t have time to waste on foolish arguments like the Bible tells us so, this is my final comment! Bye!
 
when Satan fought God for control of Heaven and LOST!:o

And its need is further evidenced by the Original sin of Adam and Eve

{I’m NOT saying that THEY went to hell; they MAY have sought and received God Forgiveness? This we DO NOT KNOW

God Bless you,

Pat Miron
If you listen to a lot of the people on CAF…there is no such place as hell…I feel like I’m in hell when I’m on the CAF website.

I need a break! 😦
 
Read the Bible & most of these questions will be answered …Luke 16:22-30 ; Rev. 20: 14& 15.

There are other references…get a Concordance.
“Read the Bible.” Good one! I doubt we’ll know that before the Rapture. But, God probably had had something in mind, soon as Michael kicked Lucis out of heaven. Remember, he was waiting in Eden, to work on Eve/ Adam. Here are some further verses I found, ( Strong’s conc.), on ‘angels/ Hell’. Isai.14:12-17, Matt. 25:41, 2Pet. 2:4, Jude6, Revel. 12: 7-11. Hope they are useful to someone. Cyril. (P.S. Get ready! Don’t go there!)
 
“Read the Bible.” Good one! I doubt we’ll know that before the Rapture. But, God probably had had something in mind, soon as Michael kicked Lucis out of heaven. Remember, he was waiting in Eden, to work on Eve/ Adam. Here are some further verses I found, ( Strong’s conc.), on ‘angels/ Hell’. Isai.14:12-17, Matt. 25:41, 2Pet. 2:4, Jude6, Revel. 12: 7-11. Hope they are useful to someone. Cyril. (P.S. Get ready! Don’t go there!)
Matt. 25: 41 really shows hell as a place with fire…yes the answers are in God’s Word.
 
I think, Mr. Gorgias, you just like to disagree! :rolleyes:
LOL! Remember, TTF… you’re engaging in this dialogue, too! 😉

Interestingly, though, you continue to avoid answering the questions I’ve put to you. Most significantly, if Lazarus and the rich man were dead, are you saying that they nevertheless had bodies?

We know that we shall receive our glorified bodies only in the eschaton, so… we know that they did not. That’s critical, because…
So the chasm Jesus refers to… is the distance between the suffering in the rich guy’s mind & the joy in Lazarus’ mind which the people were too dumb to understand?
Tell me: would a literal, physical chasm keep a spirit contained and boxed in? Of course not! So, there’s your answer right there: a literal, physical ‘chasm’ would have no effects on souls in Abraham’s Bosom. But hey – if you want to continue to assert (in the face of all logical discussion to the contrary) that it’s a literal, physical description… well, have at it! :whacky:
Look, I don’t have time to waste on foolish arguments
Hmm. Sure seems like you do… 😉
 
LOL! Remember, TTF… you’re engaging in this dialogue, too! 😉

Interestingly, though, you continue to avoid answering the questions I’ve put to you. Most significantly, if Lazarus and the rich man were dead, are you saying that they nevertheless had bodies?

We know that we shall receive our glorified bodies only in the eschaton, so… we know that they did not. That’s critical, because…

Tell me: would a literal, physical chasm keep a spirit contained and boxed in? Of course not! So, there’s your answer right there: a literal, physical ‘chasm’ would have no effects on souls in Abraham’s Bosom. But hey – if you want to continue to assert (in the face of all logical discussion to the contrary) that it’s a literal, physical description… well, have at it! :whacky:

Hmm. Sure seems like you do… 😉
No …I quit!
 
=porthos11;13196580]Yes we do. For one thing, Genesis clearly tells us that they acknowledged the Lord such as when Seth was born, indicating that they had a restored relationship with God.
Further the Church has held that Christ released Adam (and by extension, Eve) and the rest of the just from Sheol the day he died.
Thank YOU!

God Bless you

Patrick
 
=patmiron;13196569]when Satan fought God for control of Heaven and LOST!:o
And its need is further evidenced by the Original sin of Adam and Eve
{I’m NOT saying that THEY went to hell; they MAY have sought and received God Forgiveness? This we DO NOT KNOW
God Bless you,
Pat Miron
Lucifer disobeyed God and then God created hell which is a separation from God.

Response by AL [Pat Miron’s mentor]
 
fred conty,

I just found a nice article right here on CA:
Cyril of Jerusalem
“We shall be raised therefore, all with our bodies eternal, but not all with bodies alike: for if a man is righteous, he will receive a heavenly body, that he may be able worthily to hold converse with angels; but if a man is a sinner, he shall receive an eternal body, fitted to endure the penalties of sins, that he may burn eternally in fire, nor ever be consumed. And righteously will God assign this portion to either company; for we do nothing without the body. We b.aspheme with the mouth, and with the mouth we pray. With the body we commit fornication, and with the body we keep chastity. With the hand we rob, and by the hand we bestow alms; and the rest in like manner. Since then the body has been our minister in all things, it shall also share with us in the future the fruits of the past” (Catechetical Lectures 18:19 [A.D. 350]).
catholic.com/tracts/the-hell-there-is
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top