When You're Honest With Yourself:

  • Thread starter Thread starter Voice_of_Reason_1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The bible says that fasting and prayer and a devout and contrite heart will bring you closer to God, but it hasn’t happened.
Have you tried it? Have you tried praying for a contrite heart? Have you tried praying for humilit? Have you tried praying for belief?

It must be remembered however, that He is God and therefore will give this to you in His time.

I will relate here a personal experience to sort of explain this:

My niece was born with a lump on her cheek, which the doctors said needed to be removed while she is still an infant or else there will be terrible scarring left.

So before she was one, they operated on her. When she was strapped in the straigth jacket, she cried so hard and looked towards her father for help, to be freed of this straight jacket. But her father of course did no such thing. After the operation when she came to, when her father would try to comrfort her she turned away from him. All she knew was that she was in pain and he did not help.

Now she is a grown woman, minus the lump and no trace of scars at all.

I think we need to be humble. But in order to be humble, sometimes we need to be humbled. Only then will we know that God is inded God, and that He is indeed Love.
When I adopted a belief in God, I was going through a rough time. But I feel like comfort doesn’t come from God, but from the idea that there is this cosmic, celestial, timeless being carrying you on its crest.
Then what you have adopted is not Christian belief but somewhat pantheistic belief. It is good then that you no longer believe this.

Then God can lead you to really knowing Him… personally.
What I’ve “heard” from God sounds very much like my own thoughts and things I’ve read in the bible.
What makes you think that God does not speak to you thorugh your own thoughts? He created you. He can communicate with you in ways you have not even imagined. What you have read in the Bible is God’s own revelation.
I’ve never experienced miracles, nor have I seen one, nor even heard good evidence for them. I just don’t have any reason to believe. I want to, sorely, but I can’t - I just cannot.
I watched a film on the Human Body and cried. I was just amazed at how ownderfully God has created us. We are all miracles.

It is a matter of traning the eye to see. 🙂
 
In any event, far less is my argument that Christianity prohibits reason specifically, and far more is my argument that natural reason (of which the greatest benefactor is our senses) fails to concord well with biblical or religious teachings.
No, not in Catholic teachings. “Natural Reason”, as you put it, is quite well accepted and embraced.

In any case, I hope you don’t give up. It seems to me, and I don’t presume to be a mind or heart reader, that if you’ve truly given up you wouldn’t waste posting here in the CAF. 😉
 
Both benedictus2 and Spiritualunity mention how they feel something else is what brought this issue up here( and with yourself) more then your saying. I agree. No one is judging your heart,that would be play God, but as a Christian we can judge actions. None of us know anything about you except what you show.
I just do not understand why you would bring up such an important and personal yet universal thing as, faith, here in caf.What do you want?
Do holidays such as Christmas stir up things in you perhaps?
Frankly, I think spiritualunity is on the right track and also that we all should pray for you.
I will definitely pray for you. Wavering in your faith must be a horrible thing to go though

I just sense that something else under all this, is causing you to be prideful and this is not the way to find God. It appears to me that most people on this thread have been telling you this in their own way of expressing it. Humiliy comes first. One absolutely must have humility to findz God.
 
I’m glad to see my problem framed by other contributers to this thread. Thank you. I think, however, that free will is the leap for me which makes accepting God difficult. Most every rational person would agree that we are profoundly affected by our environment and biology (I go a little further, and say that we are only affected by those factors). Whatever the case - even adding bronze-age metaphores (a contrite heart, a soul or spirit or whathaveyou) doesn’t give us dominion over our own actions (in such a way that would lead to salvation or damnation), because God is the alleged author of those things as well. It is a difficult thing to perceive - that we can not act beyond the nature which is imputed to us (for one, because we like to think of our life as self-directed and autonomous; for two, because we perceive that we could have done something other). We are as determined as vines that grow, and animals that hunt (albeit, our intellects and consciousness make for many more complicated interactions).
Frame it how you wish: God created a world in which people have the potential to perish. Us finite beings, with our limited knowledge, must bear an eternal punishment for not hedging our metaphysical bets and believing on Him. This is a problem.
You framed the problem yourself in the post I responded to. While environment and biology certainly effect us, they do not control us. Why do you believe your actions are fully controlled by others. Do you not realize that you have self control as well. Sure, you can’t control everything, but you do make choices that effect you every minute of every day. You complain about a lack of autonomy, yet you also complain about being held responsible for your actions, which is what is required for true autonomy.

And to complain that you have limited knowledge on which to make decisions is to me, absolutely wrong. You have all the information you need to gain eternal life. Just follow Jesus’ example. Love God and your neighbor. Avoid hate and selfishness. Partake of the sacraments where you recieve God’s graces simply by asking for them.
 
Yeah, I understand that the Church needs to get caught up to the new age we’re in, and so reason has been permitted sparingly, but the Bible is decidedly against worldly knowledge: humanismbyjoe.com/Bible_Opposes_Knowledge.htm (for you’re reading pleasure)
The Bible is against worldly knowledge but you need to know what is meant by worldly knowlege.

And no the church does not need to get caught up to the new age we’re in. The Church needs to stand her ground and evangelize the world. The Church is here precisely for that reason, to evangelize the world and not for the world to evangelize the Church.

The world at the moment is caught up in materialism, in the I/Me/Myself mentality. The church needs to go out there and fight that death oriented mentality.
In any event, far less is my argument that Christianity prohibits reason specifically, and far more is my argument that natural reason (of which the greatest benefactor is our senses) fails to concord well with biblical or religious teachings.
Perhaps, you will find that fundamentalist and evangelical do not exercise reason when it comes to their faith. That is why we get so many illogical and irrational posts from a fair few protestants in this thread.

But Catholic theology is robust. The Catholic Church has nurtured great thinkers. Pope Benedict himself is a towering intellect. You should read G K Chesterton. He is a brilliant thinker and truly Catholic.

And for the merely generic Christianity, try CS Lewis. He is also a brilliant thinker and he converted from atheism so you can probably relate to him more.

It is absurd to say that faith and religion is against reason. Quite the contrary in fact, especially when it comes to the Catholic Church.

This is Peter Kreeft’s website who is a convert from Protestantism. It is the force of reason and rigorous study of the faith that made him convert. His website if full of intelligient articles and talks.
http://www.peterkreeft.com/home.htm
 
Benedictus2

Pray to have faith. Something like the centurion’s prayer. “Help my unbelief”.


I’ve done this; it was to no avail.

In everything you have written here, you have remained vague.
What precise belief do you have an issue with?


God is elusive to the senses – the means by which we understand the world.

But all biology gives you are inclinations. You may have sinful inclinatios but you do not have to act out these inclinations. That is where your will comes in. You are free to choose either evil or good.

You are assuming you have free will because you perceive that you could have acted alternatively (read my other posts). But let me give you the benefit of the doubt: even if you are not fully bound by biology and environment, you will agree (as any rational person will) that we are at very least, profoundly affected by those things. The fact that we are in the least affected by environment and biology makes our decisions not fully free (because there are other agents acting upon us). Even calling it the devil – our actions are not free because there is some external agency directing us.

He gives us just enough grace to say yes.
God knows our weaknesses and knows how much grace we are given to battle these weaknesses. Our salvation and damnation depends on those two.
But even then, God gives us the grace to return, to be forgiven and thus be reconciled once more to Him.
He is God and therefore will give this to you in His time.
What makes you think that God does not speak to you through your own thoughts? He created you.


The speculated traits of a being give me no richer knowledge as to the speculated existence of said being. I wish I could take these adages to mean something more, but they just sound like relgious schtick.

That is because you read some parts of the Bible in isolation

Is there any context which pacifies the terror and unjust sovereignty depicted in those verses (Romans 9:20-22 on the potter and the vessels)? Please provide it, if you have it.

No we are not required to believe against everything else we know about the world. That is a total lie.

How do you figure? Being contrary without giving me apt reasons as to why you are so isn’t making a convincing case. It tells me that you don’t have any good reason to believe otherwise, but you do so anyway out of tenacity.

You may not see any good reason in it but a whole lot of people do. Are they all wrong and you alone are right?

Are we really appealing to the masses here? Shall we then say, “are the Muslims right?” because there are so many of them? And I think “you alone” is a bit of a misnomer: it seems there are other people who hold my view (you’re not ignorant of this fact, I’m sure).

I would hazard a guess that your problems stem from other things you have not written here.

It doesn’t matter from what my problems stem (if indeed you could be so perspicuous as to discern from what). The problems have stemmed on an intellectual platform and there seems to be nearly-incontrovertible evidence against the logical concerns they pose. I would be well pleased if someone could address my concerns logically without trying to analyze me.

God can lead you to really knowing Him… personally.

I must be sceptical. I’ve yet to meet a Christian who does know God personally. But perhaps we have different definitions. How does one (even the most thorough-going Christian) know God personally? In what way is knowing God personally made apparent?

It is a matter of traning the eye to see.

I’m glad you acknowledged this. This is part of my concern. I may be training myself to believe things that aren’t true (the way you would consider a Muslim, or Buddhist, or Atheist to be training themselves to see in a certain light). The only difference is, I can depend on the natural world being consistent and observable. The supernatural world is forever obscure and ever-changing in the formulations put forward by people.
 
I just sense that something else under all this, is causing you to be prideful and this is not the way to find God. It appears to me that most people on this thread have been telling you this in their own way of expressing it. Humiliy comes first. One absolutely must have humility to findz God.
I don’t think I’ve given anyone reason to believe that I’m prideful (except if you define prideful as being disagreeable, which no person should). I don’t claim to know all the answers, but that doesn’t mean I don’t hold a high standard of what kinds of answers are satisfactory.

The way to get right with God, if there is a way to get right with God, isn’t in me acknowledging some deeply rooted problem in myself, because someone in cyberspace has suggested there is one. As I’ve said a number of times, my concerns are purely intellectual. The road to recovery (if there exists one) remains in clearing up perceptions, not redirecting emotions. Surely there is a reasonable person who can sympathize with this.
 
I’ve done this; it was to no avail.
Because you expect everything in your time. I think your god is yourself. To pray to God means to wait for His time. He will give it you in His time. He is God not you.
God is elusive to the senses – the means by which we understand the world.
Of course He is because He is God. The God that you fully comprehend is no God at all. Think about having a pet worm. Do you think that worm can comprehend you? Yet you expect to fully comprehend God?

I think your problem is not so much faith but pride. You want God on your terms.

But don’t worry, when we get to the other side of eternity and we see Him face to face and are no longer limited by this natural world which you highly esteem, then you will know that which you want to know now.
You are assuming you have free will because you perceive that you could have acted alternatively (read my other posts). But let me give you the benefit of the doubt: even if you are not fully bound by biology and environment, you will agree (as any rational person will) that we are at very
least, profoundly affected by those things. The fact that we are in the least affected by environment and biology makes our decisions not fully free (because there are other agents acting upon us). Even calling it the devil – our actions are not free because there is some external agency directing us.
You have a very Calvinistic take on this. So I take it you are Protestant. Yes we are affected by environment that is true so when we sin, God takes into consideration our weaknesses. You remember that story of the labourers in the vineyard who all got given the same wage even though some of them got there late. God is merciful and just.

But yes, we do have free will. We can always so no to sin and say yes to God. And the greater the difficulty the greater the reward. Think of the martyrs. There are also things that you can put in place to train yourself to act in in “yes to God” manner in all your choices.

It is like anything. The muscle that you train is that muscle that grows big and strong. With every yes to virtue, your “virtue muscle” grows bigger so practicing virtue becomes a little bit easier. Now if it is the “vice muscle” that you keep exercising then it is no wonder that you will find it hard to exercise virtue.

It is said that for a murderer, the first kill is hard but it gets easier with the next and the next.
The speculated traits of a being give me no richer knowledge as to the speculated existence of said being. I wish I could take these adages to mean something more, but they just sound like relgious schtick.
But they are not speculated traits. They are real. And many people have found them to be real and these are extremely intelligient people so you cannot say that the stupid are the only ones who succumb to this notion.

I think what you need to pray for most of all is humility. You have this arrogant perception that God must somwhow bow to you and make His attributes known to you in your way and your time. The one who does that is not God who is supreme but your lackey, your slave.
Is there any context which pacifies the terror and unjust sovereignty depicted in those verses (Romans
9:20-22 on the potter and the vessels)? Please provide it, if you have it.
Read the Gospels. John in particular. Immerse yourself in it. Mediate on it. Don’t do a cursory reading of it. Soak yourself in this Gospel.
How do you figure? Being contrary without giving me apt reasons as to why you are so isn’t making a convincing case. It tells me that you don’t have any good reason to believe otherwise, but you do so anyway out of tenacity.
No, I believe because I know what I believe. I have feeling that you are throwing something away which don’t even have a full grasp of. Jesus said this is revealed to little children. Perhaps you need to pray for childlike humility.
Are we really appealing to the masses here? Shall we then say, “are the Muslims right?” because there are so many of them? And I think “you alone” is a bit of a misnomer: it seems there are other people who hold my view (you’re not ignorant of this fact, I’m sure).
Actually not the masses. Since you claim to be an intellectual, read the works of G K Chesterton, von Hildebrand, CS Lewis, Edith Stein, Pope Benedict. Pope John Paul II is a brilliant philosopher so read his works. They are very far from being the masses.
 
It doesn’t matter from what my problems stem (if indeed you could be so perspicuous as to discern from what). The problems have stemmed on an intellectual platform and there seems to be nearly-incontrovertible evidence against the logical concerns they pose. I would be well pleased if someone could address my concerns logically without trying to analyze me.
But It does matter because the platform is hardly intellectual and the evidence hardly incontrovertible.
This is just my long shot guess based on what you posted regarding being bound by biology and the like: Are you struggling with homosexuality and you feel that that somehow puts you out of God’s love so it is easier to believe in no god at all?
I must be sceptical. I’ve yet to meet a Christian who does know God personally. But perhaps we have different definitions. How does one (even the most thorough-going Christian) know God personally? In what way is knowing God personally made apparent?
We are are beings with souls. You know it in your soul. That is a much deeper knowing than sensient knowing.
I’m glad you acknowledged this. This is part of my concern. I may be training myself to believe things that aren’t true (the way you would consider a Muslim, or Buddhist, or Atheist to be training themselves to see in a certain light). The only difference is, I can depend on the natural world being consistent and observable. The supernatural world is forever obscure and ever-changing in the formulations put forward by people.
The whole problem is that you keep limiting yourself to the natural world. We are much more than just natural beings. We have supernatural souls.
 
I’ve always been taken by the argument:

You cannot name one, not even one, good thing done in the name of faith that couldn’t have been done by someone with no faith at all. However, you can name all kinds of wicked, evil, terrible things done in the name of the faith that would have never entered the mind of someone with no faith.
At least the person with faith DID the good deeds, while the person without faith did nothing. Sure, people with faith have done some terrible things…but terrible, wicked, evil things are done as much by people with no faith as it has been done by people with faith…
CC
 
I don’t think I’ve given anyone reason to believe that I’m prideful (except if you define prideful as being disagreeable, which no person should). I don’t claim to know all the answers, but that doesn’t mean I don’t hold a high standard of what kinds of answers are satisfactory.

The way to get right with God, if there is a way to get right with God, isn’t in me acknowledging some deeply rooted problem in myself, because someone in cyberspace has suggested there is one. As I’ve said a number of times, my concerns are purely intellectual. The road to recovery (if there exists one) remains in clearing up perceptions, not redirecting emotions. Surely there is a reasonable person who can sympathize with this.
Hi VoR,
I hope you will click on this link and listen attentively to Fr Barron.

It goes to the heart of your question.

 
I’ve always been taken by the argument:

You cannot name one, not even one, good thing done in the name of faith that couldn’t have been done by someone with no faith at all. However, you can name all kinds of wicked, evil, terrible things done in the name of the faith that would have never entered the mind of someone with no faith.
Wow and you call yourself Christian? I was right about you after all. You’re mental framework is clearly not Christian in the least.

The greatest evil that no faith has foisted upon the world is the evils wrought by communism. Perhaps you should read up on that.
 
The way to get right with God, if there is a way to get right with God, isn’t in me acknowledging some deeply rooted problem in myself, because someone in cyberspace has suggested there is one. As I’ve said a number of times, my concerns are purely intellectual. The road to recovery (if there exists one) remains in clearing up perceptions, not redirecting emotions. Surely there is a reasonable person who can sympathize with this.
You’re almost tempting me to answer you from the standpoint of Vulcan metaphysics.
 
Thank you for your post! I am being as honest with myself as I possibly can. The thing is, I have tried earnestly to be devout, my relationship with my family is very good, my life is extremely satisfying in all its domains, and I’ve tried in futility to get closer to God but I don’t feel anything or think anything. The bible says that fasting and prayer and a devout and contrite heart will bring you closer to God, but it hasn’t happened. When I adopted a belief in God, I was going through a rough time. But I feel like comfort doesn’t come from God, but from the idea that there is this cosmic, celestial, timeless being carrying you on its crest. What I’ve “heard” from God sounds very much like my own thoughts and things I’ve read in the bible. I’ve never experienced miracles, nor have I seen one, nor even heard good evidence for them. I just don’t have any reason to believe. I want to, sorely, but I can’t - I just cannot.
How long were you praying to God for? Mystical awareness of God does not pop up overnight, nor even usually in a short period of time (say, a couple of years). It’s a long term process of becoming intimate with God by becoming pure and holy. If you want to come closer to God, it means determining, once and for all, that you will-- no matter what-- become holy. Do yourself a favor and read a popular book on the mystical teaching of Sts. John and Teresa called “Fire Within” by Fr. Thomas Dubay. Oh yeah, you can meet Him. But it will cost you everything.

I’ll be honest with you. I went through a time of disbelief in my high school years. I wanted desperately to believe but just couldn’t bring myself to. It was awful, and quite frankly, I completely sympathize with you. What’s necessary is building a good foundation which makes accepting supernatural faith possible (if you are a strict materialist/physicalist about the universe, and you think that we can’t know anything about God or immaterial realities by reason, well… you’re going to have a tough time ‘just having faith.’ Reasonable beliefs precede supernatural faith.) I’d be happy to discuss anything with you, if you want to send me a message.

As to miracles-- probably the best attested of modern miracles are (1) Fatima, (2) Lourdes, and (3) the Eucharistic miracle of Lanciano. You might find these helpful. But remember that the virtue of faith does not proportion its firmness of assent to the level of evidence.
 
Voice of reason,

Reading through this, it occurs to me that you are really struggling with this. You want to believe but its just not happening for you. That can be frustrating. Know this, very few people have true visions of God. God is too great for us to perceive him directly. That is why he had to come to us in the form of Jesus, the son, because otherwise we couldn’t relate to him. But what we all can see is the results of his work, if we are open to it. The daily sun rises and sunsets. the majesty of mountain ranges and of roaring seas, the love between a mother and her child, the orderliness of the universe, the voice of our conscience within. These are all signs of God’s presence. Try to stay open to God. You will percieve him when you are ready.
 
Voice of reason,

Reading through this, it occurs to me that you are really struggling with this. You want to believe but its just not happening for you. That can be frustrating. Know this, very few people have true visions of God. God is too great for us to perceive him directly. That is why he had to come to us in the form of Jesus, the son, because otherwise we couldn’t relate to him. But what we all can see is the results of his work, if we are open to it. The daily sun rises and sunsets. the majesty of mountain ranges and of roaring seas, the love between a mother and her child, the orderliness of the universe, the voice of our conscience within. These are all signs of God’s presence. Try to stay open to God. You will percieve him when you are ready.
Great post. :clapping::clapping::clapping:
 
Benedictus2

Of course He is [elusive] because He is God. The God that you fully comprehend is no God at all. Think about having a pet worm. Do you think that worm can comprehend you? Yet you expect to fully comprehend God?


Why would God attempt to communicate with people who couldn’t comprehend Him by even a mere shadow of his being? It’s more likely the case that we simply can’t comprehend what simply isn’t there.

God takes into consideration our weaknesses.

It follows, then, God being truly just, that he allows a full concession to our weakness (in which case, no one could possibly be damned – they, being evidently too weak to save themselves)

But yes, we do have free will. We can always [say] no to sin and say yes to God.

This is precisely what I’m saying is not the case (from the arguments I’ve made above). You can choose to oppose me with or without explanation, but I can’t be persuaded to believe anything without at least a reason.

But they are not speculated traits. They are real. And many people have found them to be real and these are extremely intelligent people so you cannot say that the stupid are the only ones who succumb to this notion.

If they could be affirmed beyond mere speculation, then there would be not only less division between views on God, but the beliefs in God would be completely ubiquitous (which they’re not). They’re falling out of favour as quickly as the gods of antiquity. And I’m certainly not saying that only stupid people believe in God; not by any stretch. I just think that belief in God, like the gods of antiquity were, or like stereotypes, or like urban legends, are made extremely palatable for embracing. But whether or not people embrace the idea of God is of no relevance; it’s reason that should bring us to those conclusions.

You have this arrogant perception that God must somehow bow to you and make His attributes known to you in your way and your time.

I don’t have any arrogant perceptions about God. It just seems odd to me that we are forced to believe in God (whom we’ve never seen, cannot hear, or feel with any of our ordinary senses) who is alleged to have come to earth and preformed miracles (which no one has ever seen replicated; e.g., water into wine, walking on water, raising people from the dead). All of these things, you’ll agree, confound our ordinary understanding of the world, and God wants us to reject the reason which he apparently is the author of so that we may feel it in our souls, his presence in all-abundance. It seems less like God wants to make his attributes known to me in His time, and more like he simply doesn’t want anyone to know his attributes.

This is just my long shot guess based on what you posted regarding being bound by biology and the like: Are you struggling with homosexuality and you feel that that somehow puts you out of God’s love so it is easier to believe in no god at all?

No; see, you keep looking for things wrong with me instead of addressing the arguments in a coherent, logical manner. You make contradictions to my claims but don’t give me any good reason as to the merits of those opposing beliefs.

The whole problem is that you keep limiting yourself to the natural world. We are much more than just natural beings. We have supernatural souls.
We are beings with souls. You know it in your soul. That is a much deeper knowing than sensient knowing.


You`re explaining an incomprehensible thing with yet another incomprehensible thing. How do souls know things? How do I know if my soul knows things? It’s totally obscure to our reason.

I appreciate the proverbs, but I can’t base any kind of belief, natural or supernatural, on anecdotes. You said that it’s hardly an intellectual concern: all I mean by ‘intellectual’ is that they are problems in logic and reason. Objectively speaking, no matter where my heart stands, those logical incongruities will still exist. Do you understand my difficulty?
 
Hi VoR,
I hope you will click on this link and listen attentively to Fr Barron.

It goes to the heart of your question.

Thank you for the link. I recall reading about these things in Aquinas’ Summa. Concerning Fr.'s address:

“If there is an apparent conflict between a clearly known scientific truth and a religious truth, either we’re dealing with bad science or bad religion.”

Agreed.

“Contingent things – things that don’t contain within themselves the reason for their existence – exist, and that’s a puzzle… the fact that they exist needs to be explained [other things will never serve as an adequate explanation]”

I agree with the first part, especially that it is a puzzle and a mystery. The second part is a matter of the beholder (the fact that we must invent an explanation, because it needs to be explained)

**“Scientists don’t address the question as to whether there is something rather than nothing” **

I agree, to an extent.

**`` is no claim made from ancient times to modern times that is more extravagant and more extraordinary than the Christian Claim” **

Agreed.

As I have said already though, there is a huge epistemic gap between there being something rather than nothing, and the existence of God.
 
How long were you praying to God for? Mystical awareness of God does not pop up overnight, nor even usually in a short period of time (say, a couple of years). It’s a long term process of becoming intimate with God by becoming pure and holy. If you want to come closer to God, it means determining, once and for all, that you will-- no matter what-- become holy. Do yourself a favor and read a popular book on the mystical teaching of Sts. John and Teresa called “Fire Within” by Fr. Thomas Dubay. Oh yeah, you can meet Him. But it will cost you everything.

I’ll be honest with you. I went through a time of disbelief in my high school years. I wanted desperately to believe but just couldn’t bring myself to. It was awful, and quite frankly, I completely sympathize with you. What’s necessary is building a good foundation which makes accepting supernatural faith possible (if you are a strict materialist/physicalist about the universe, and you think that we can’t know anything about God or immaterial realities by reason, well… you’re going to have a tough time ‘just having faith.’ Reasonable beliefs precede supernatural faith.) I’d be happy to discuss anything with you, if you want to send me a message.

As to miracles-- probably the best attested of modern miracles are (1) Fatima, (2) Lourdes, and (3) the Eucharistic miracle of Lanciano. You might find these helpful. But remember that the virtue of faith does not proportion its firmness of assent to the level of evidence.
Hi, thank you for posting! I’m glad that you can relate. I am somewhat of a strict materialist / phsyicalist, which does make having faith hard. I understand that faith doesn’t happen overnight, but you seem firm in your beliefs at this point in your life. How is it that you know God? (I do not mean, ‘how is it that you come to know God?’). I mean, quite literally, what makes God real to you, and not imagined or false (as one might say of other religions and philosophies)?
 
Voice of reason,

Reading through this, it occurs to me that you are really struggling with this. You want to believe but its just not happening for you. That can be frustrating. Know this, very few people have true visions of God. God is too great for us to perceive him directly. That is why he had to come to us in the form of Jesus, the son, because otherwise we couldn’t relate to him. But what we all can see is the results of his work, if we are open to it. The daily sun rises and sunsets. the majesty of mountain ranges and of roaring seas, the love between a mother and her child, the orderliness of the universe, the voice of our conscience within. These are all signs of God’s presence. Try to stay open to God. You will percieve him when you are ready.
Don’t you find those signs to be fairly subjective though? A love between a mother and a child is no more explained by God than it is unicorns. Shall we say that “God has distributed his love upon the human population and we are the vessels through which that love is continuously shown?” Because then I would wonder, “why should I believe that it was God? Why can’t it all just be part of the natural world?”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top