Where were the Protestants before the 1500's?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nanotwerp
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The bible was compiled by the early Catholic Church. They made the call on what should be published. In those writings, Acts, Hebrews, John etc. we see no apostle leading people to Mary. If it happened and wasn’t recorded, that’s not a problem to me. My position is the same. The apostles in the New Testament writings didn’t preach a message that included Mary. They weren’t ignoring her. They weren’t being disrespectful. They were following the orders of Jesus. Go into all the world and preach the gospel.
Just out of curiosity, who gave Luke all the details about Mary in Luke 1 & 2?

Mary did.

And what did the Holy Spirit inspire Luke to write?

Luke 1:48-49
From now on all generations will call me blessed, 49 for the Mighty One has done great things for me—holy is his name.

How would all generations know to do this if they were not told? 🤷

It seems to me that the gospel has included quite a bit about Mary right from the beginning. 👍
 
The bible was compiled by the early Catholic Church. They made the call on what should be published. In those writings, Acts, Hebrews, John etc. we see no apostle leading people to Mary. If it happened and wasn’t recorded, that’s not a problem to me. My position is the same. The apostles in the New Testament writings didn’t preach a message that included Mary. They weren’t ignoring her. They weren’t being disrespectful. They were following the orders of Jesus. Go into all the world and preach the gospel.
Read Revelation 11:19-12:6. There is the Queen of Heaven who bore a male child who was destined to rule all the nations.
 
If we point people to Jesus and say “Do whatever He tells you.” we are doing exactly what Mary did.
The above is very Catholic! 👍

From the Vatican website:

Mary’s request: “Do whatever he tells you”, keeps its ever timely value for Christians of every age and is destined to renew its marvellous effect in everyone’s life. It is an exhortation to trust without hesitation, especially when one does not understand the meaning or benefit of what Christ asks.

vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/audiences/1997/documents/hf_jp-ii_aud_26021997_en.html

And

This Wisdom is Jesus Christ himself, the Eternal Word of God, who perfectly reveals and accomplishes the will of the Father (cf.Heb 10:5-10). Mary invites everyone to accept this Wisdom. To us too she addresses the command she gave to the servants at Cana in Galilee during the marriage feast: “Do whatever he tells you” (Jn 2:5).
vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_06081993_veritatis-splendor_en.html
 
The bible was compiled by the early Catholic Church. They made the call on what should be published. In those writings, Acts, Hebrews, John etc. we see no apostle leading people to Mary.

How do you know they did not? Are you sure all the apostles taught was written down?
If it happened and wasn’t recorded, that’s not a problem to me. My position is the same. The apostles in the New Testament writings didn’t preach a message that included Mary.
 
Just out of curiosity, who gave Luke all the details about Mary in Luke 1 & 2?
Mary did.
And what did the Holy Spirit inspire Luke to write?

Luke 1:48-49
From now on all generations will call me blessed, 49 for the Mighty One has done great things for me—holy is his name.

How would all generations know to do this if they were not told? 🤷

It seems to me that the gospel has included quite a bit about Mary right from the beginning. 👍
All that’s true but what I said is also true. No mention of Mary in any of the recorded gospel messages.
Acts 10 - Peter preaches to the gentiles,
Acts - Paul preaches to the jailers, Paul preaches to the Greeks
John 3 - Jesus preaches the gospel,
Hebrews 12 - “fixing our eyes on Jesus, the author and finisher…”
Read Revelation 11:19-12:6. There is the Queen of Heaven who bore a male child who was destined to rule all the nations.
Yes, also not in the accounts I mention above.
How do you know they did not? Are you sure all the apostles taught was written down?
I already said two times it’s possible. How do you know they didn’t get around on skateboards? How do you know they didn’t smoke cigars?
Have you read all the other early Christian writings that did not make it into the Bible?
No. I’m sure they do but I’m not commenting on those writings. I’m commenting on the biblical accounts. The recorded preaching in the bible does not include Mary.
Did Jesus tell them to ignore Mary, His mother? Can you point out a chapter and verse that says Jesus directed them to ignore His mother?
Well using the present logic, I could say how do you know He didn’t say to ignore Mary. Everything Jesus said has not been recorded?
 
All that’s true but what I said is also true. No mention of Mary in any of the recorded gospel messages.
Acts 10 - Peter preaches to the gentiles,
Acts - Paul preaches to the jailers, Paul preaches to the Greeks
John 3 - Jesus preaches the gospel,
Hebrews 12 - “fixing our eyes on Jesus, the author and finisher…”
Oh, yes. I see your point.

When giving a short sermon, focus on Jesus.

When writing out the complete gospel, backfill with some of the details about Mary.
 
Great!

Now, scripture reveals that the kings typically had both royal stewards and queens, correct?
"In place of the queen in the royal court of Judah stood the
gevira , best translated as “royal-lady,” though “queen-mother” is the best functional
equivalent in English.The official religion of ancient Israel viewed Yahweh alone as the ruler of the universe, with no attendant deities and, most importantly, no consort.that the elevation of the mother of the king to “royal-lady” in ancient Israel was intended to
dispel any suggestion that the king had a consort"
, jewishstudies.rutgers.edu/component/docman/doc_view/122-no-stelae-no-queens-two-issues-concerning-the-kings-of-israel-and-judah?Itemid=158 interesting article. It should be noted that other Jewish scholars think the title is to suggest a “mother of god(s)”… I have no problem in seeing Mary possibly having this title for as has been suggested we are all “royal” thru Jesus. My main problem with it however might be some of the fruits of marionism ( ruling authority, influence based on position and not merit of “(name removed by moderator)ut” that all may put forth) and that early fathers did not ascribe this title to her, despite Revelations.
 
As for this saved business, I have to say there are those who come to my door and the first question they ask me is are toy saved? I tell that no one saved till they are in heaven. They try to tell me that they are already saved so then I ask them if there are already in heaven? they say no, and I say then till you are in heaven you are not saved. They just walk away with a funny look on their face. What this tells me is that among the many protestants out there are those who somehow think or believe that all they have to do is believe in Jesus and they are automatically saved and so do not have do anything else to be saved. It seems to me that they do not understand that there is more to it than that.

One of the very reasons we believe in what the CC teaches is that it has and is teaching the very same things it taught for nearly 2000 years being passed on by the Apostles themselves having learned it from Jesus Himself and guided by the Holy Spirit to remember all that Jesus taught them.
Actually other churches have same reaction. For JW’s are very miffed at Christians who seem to do nothing (esp.on Saturday mornings) for the Kingdom. There are others who are happy to do anything if shown it is required or pleasing to the Father…I would not assume anything from your interaction with them. To them “saved” is being born of the Spirit, being born again, entering life from death. To them, they were previously and unknowingly destined for hell. Now all things are in the light and new. Of course they are pilgrim’s, with a possible long journey ahead, to which you allude to, and put that way, they would concur.
 
To them “saved” is being born of the Spirit, being born again, entering life from death.
Is there a Bible verse that actually uses the word “saved” that says that being saved is being born of the Spirit?
 
That angel and the holy spirit were with me from the womb. They know everything about me. If they thought I was rude they would have told me by now. If an angel comes to me in a dream or an awake state I will talk to him.
So you truly believe that angels speak to anyone who is rude to them or God? Really??

I would think it better manners to just say a quick prayer of thank you to them for praying for you and for taking care of you. Why you need a sign to talk to them, I don’t understand.
The angels and saints take our prayers to God period. There are no conditions attached to it. Pray to God, pray to the angels - whatever. I pray to God.
Yes, they take our prayers to God, and pray on our behalf. Thank you for agreeing with the Christian belief on this issue. And I think you should pray to God, but why not ask others, especially the holy ones in Heaven to pray for you as well? They don’t sleep, and they have plenty of limitless time in Heaven to pray for you.
 
And I think you should pray to God, but why not ask others, especially the holy ones in Heaven to pray for you as well? They don’t sleep, and they have plenty of limitless time in Heaven to pray for you.
Egg-zactly.

I would be very, very surprised if Dalphon has never asked another person here on earth to pray for him.

(Question posed to Dalphon): Do you think that this person should have told you, “I can’t. You need to talk to God only. Never to any other Christians.”
 
Is there a Bible verse that actually uses the word “saved” that says that being saved is being born of the Spirit?
Not sure. But i think CC teaches a past, present and future “saving”. Don’t think there are any scriptures that say the lost or unsaved have been born in the spirit…It is like this . Your are in muddy waters and drowning. The Mother ship comes and hauls you in . Do you later sit on deck with a cup of cocoa and say , “Thank God I have been saved.” ? After all you are on the Mother Ship. Or do you say , " I am saved from those muddy waters but I am not sure the ship won’t sink, or maybe i will jump off the ship. I hope I’ll reach safe harbor" . Either way, the present is all we have and the person is on deck saved from an imminent death. …Maybe you prefer this one (true story) .A man falls one hundred feet on a construction site accident. He lands safely on dirt, missing concrete etc with only a bruise. As they carry him off in a stretcher to get checked out he says , " Don’t drop me".
 
Egg-zactly.

I would be very, very surprised if Dalphon has never asked another person here on earth to pray for him.

(Question posed to Dalphon): Do you think that this person should have told you, “I can’t. You need to talk to God only. Never to any other Christians.”
Come on you can do better than that. That we can all pray, and that we can all pray for one another is a given. That the departed living have same hearing and seeing qualities of the Paraclete affording them specific intercession is some folks issue.
 
Actually other churches have same reaction. For JW’s are very miffed at Christians who seem to do nothing (esp.on Saturday mornings) for the Kingdom. There are others who are happy to do anything if shown it is required or pleasing to the Father…I would not assume anything from your interaction with them. To them “saved” is being born of the Spirit, being born again, entering life from death. To them, they were previously and unknowingly destined for hell. Now all things are in the light and new. Of course they are pilgrim’s, with a possible long journey ahead, to which you allude to, and put that way, they would concur.
Hi benhur: I understand what you are saying. There was JW who lived next to me. They were once Catholic’s and I learned much about their ways and beliefs, yet while I did not agree with them I did get along with them. The way those who came to my door asking if I was saved told me that they themselves were assured of being saved because they believed in Jesus Christ as their personal savior, and so were saved automatically and did not have to worry about going to hell because they already knew they were going to heaven because of their believing in Jesus the Christ. I also told them that the devil also believed in Jesus the Christ and in God the Father and the Holy Spirit but that did not mean that he was going to be saved since he obviously rejected God. So it takes more than just a belief in God and or Jesus the Christ to be saved and anyway it’s up to God to decide who is saved and who is not, not us.
 
So you truly believe that angels speak to anyone who is rude to them or God? Really??
I would think it better manners to just say a quick prayer of thank you to them for praying for you and for taking care of you. Why you need a sign to talk to them, I don’t understand.

Yes, they take our prayers to God, and pray on our behalf. Thank you for agreeing with the Christian belief on this issue. And I think you should pray to God, but why not ask others, especially the holy ones in Heaven to pray for you as well? They don’t sleep, and they have plenty of limitless time in Heaven to pray for you.
Will you pray for me?
Egg-zactly.

I would be very, very surprised if Dalphon has never asked another person here on earth to pray for him.
Since you know I don’t pray to angels or anyone else, have you prayed for me?
 
Come on you can do better than that. That we can all pray, and that we can all pray for one another is a given. That the departed living have same hearing and seeing qualities of the Paraclete affording them specific intercession is some folks issue.
What kind of Heaven would that be, where everyone is apparently bound hand and foot, gagged at the mouth, and with cotton stuffed in their ears? If the people in Heaven can’t hear us or help us, then what would be the point of becoming a Saint? 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top