F
Fauken
Guest
But it’s Allah who rebuked us for our supposed polytheism, right? He doesn’t bother to call us monotheistic. He who should know our beliefs given who he’s supposed to be. So how did he not know?
Last edited:
- Status
S
Sean
Guest
I think the Christology was taught to him by a gnostic
T
Thom18
Guest
That was probably it. Gnostic or Arian, they’re all heretics to me.
S
Sean
Guest
Oh and what about the kabba many non Mohammedans would look at all the mosques being built to face the little rock that can from “heaven” to be idolatry.
S
Sean
Guest
Gnostism even worse
F
Fauken
Guest
It doesn’t answer my point. That Muslims were insisting that I worship three gods was a side point. My main point is that the Quran claims Christianity is polytheistic, which is not true. For something that is supposed to be the word of God, it gets Trinitarianism very wrong.
I’m not trying to bait you to get suspended, and I don’t care if you fear me or how many times you’ve been suspended.
S
SalamKhan
Guest
Jacob venerated a rock & called it ‘House of God’ in the book of Genesis. No Muslim considers the Kaaba to be God, nor worships the Kaaba. You actually do consider three persons to be God, and worship the three persons.
S
Sean
Guest
We aren’t trying to be scary stop victimising yourself what do you expect from a catholic forum everybody to agree with you.
S
SalamKhan
Guest
What’s Trinitarianism?
It’s not modalism, not partialism, nor polytheism, etc.
Ah, it’s a mystery! For someone who claims others get Trinitarianism wrong, you don’t even know what’s right.
T
Thom18
Guest
You’re not answering the question of “why didn’t Allah know what Christians believe?”Fauken:
What’s Trinitarianism?
It’s not modalism, not partialism, nor polytheism, etc.
Ah, it’s a mystery! For someone who claims others get Trinitarianism wrong, you don’t even know what’s right.
S
Sean
Guest
Really I did not know Jacob went out into the said I Arabian desert in some rinky sink old town called mecca and built the house of God there quite a odd place or maybe it was placed in the Koran to give mecca some significance.
C
confusedcatholic1
Guest
To be fair, Catholics on here were seemingly claiming that by him criticizing the Church, he was trying to attack us, and this forum apparently has a dumb rule where you can’t discuss and debate the Truth
S
Sean
Guest
Ah its a mystery like how parts of your holy book is unintelligible
S
Sean
Guest
What is the truth?
T
Thom18
Guest
False. This forum has reasonable rules about not proselytizing people into non-Catholic religions, and not to be condescending, belittling, mocking or being unreasonably argumentative. These don’t equate to “you can’t debate the Truth”. We’re Catholics; we have the fullness of Truth.
S
SalamKhan
Guest
You agreed I wasn’t insulting the church, but he immediately gave me a warning not to insult the church or proselytise to my religion; neither of which I was doing. Then he gave an irrelevant (because I said only Christians call the Trinity monotheism) response about Allah not considering Christians to be monotheists, which reeked of bait. He’s obviously trying to push his weight.
S
Sean
Guest
I like this it is always intresting When somebody else from a different viewpoint comes along
S
SalamKhan
Guest
Okay, I’ll take the bait.
Allah knew what Christians believed, the Trinity isn’t monotheism. I answered your question, are you happy now? Can I get suspended please?
C
confusedcatholic1
Guest
Are you serious or sarcastic
V
Vico
Guest
Then you will have to resolve the major difference that Islam does not accept the Christian scriptures (they are said to be corrupt) nor original sin, nor by most, that Jesus Christ was crucified, died, and resurrected, and Islam rejects that Jesus has both divine and human natures.
Last edited:
- Status